VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- DIVX (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=23)
-- Minority Report - DVDRIP - RFtA (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=11038)

the rip is quite ok, i don't know what you all bitch about except for the cropping!
the colors ARE THAT WAY, have a look at some trailer!

nice rip, tho i could imagine to download a proper if there will be one some day

//spoo

I dont honestly see why you people bitch, this is a nice rip. The colours that you say are not correct are! the film is like this, great audio also and the picture is nice and clear.

Keep up the good work RFTA

Before you bitch remember no one is perfect and if you dont like it, rip it yourself or dont download it, its simple. Other than that stfu.

kthx

Why bitch about who's better, everything's free. Good rip, watched it last night and nothing was wrong with it. Good job RFTA, as for scene groups hating on each other on public forums...take it out on efnet and not this board.

__________________
<Hitman47 > aight, im going to bed, but i leave you with this, remember, everytime you masturbate, your dead relatives are watching

I don't see anything wrong w/ the cropping. The movie was filmed anamorphic (2:35:1) I have the Fight Club Special Edition DVD. It's 2:35:1. The size looks the same unless you people are getting really technical and looking at pixels. I don't think RFTa didn't mess with its AR.

there are no cropping problems
it's like that
http://us.imdb.com/Technical?0181689
2:35:1 ratio

the only problem with the cropping, if you can call it that way, is that there are still black margins in the video at all 4 sides, so it could be cropped a little more (thus increasing the resolution of the final view area), but it is a very minor thing.

the AR is completely correct, yes.

//spoo

bugger all wrong with this...

dunno what u lot r on about - this is a quality release - perhaps comments are relating to the VCD?

so is this actually worth downloadin or should i wait for a proper??

__________________
mellow like a cello

it IS worth downloading and i don't see any real reason why there should be a proper!

as i said above, the colors are ok, the AR is, too... only the cropping could be made better, but it's not noticeable when you zoom into the picture a little bit (using bsplayer for instance)

//spoo

Yes you should get it. The colors are supposed to be weird looking. I saw it in theatres and it is like that. This is a nice release. If you are going to get it, get this one. All the SVCD ones have problems such as too high bitrate and then bad quality and all this shit. If you get this one you can encode it to SVCD quite easily in TMPGEnc. Just go to www.vcdhelp.com and there are guides to SVCD ripping from DivX. This release isnt the greatest DVDrip ever, but it is much better than screeners and ts's and shit like that. If you want the DVDrip then get this one. There are no problems with it. I thought this was a kickass movie so just get it. I give it 7/8 for video and audio. If you dont like the cropping you can recrop it in TMPGEnc by using clip frame and typing in how much you want off on the sides and top. All this stuff can easily be done in TMPGEnc.

** Also if it was so bad it would be nuked from all the sites, but all the XDCC bots have this and all the newsgroups also