VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King - SCREENER - RiNG (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=33726)

I've only seen most of the first disk but so far I thought it was a very good (vcd) vhs screener. A bit of pixilation is going to be expected on a vcd...but it was an excellent rip in my opinion. As far as a some people out there wishing it was a svcd....

quote:

---

Originally posted by pjfan281
sure, a 7cd svcd =P

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by pezley
not the best of the trilogy, but whether you enjoy the films or not you have to respect everything peter jackson has done

---

decent. better than a TS. CVD would rock

this is a good encode from VHS I love it.
4CDs ist ok for the movie, the good thing its i can make a multi
language *fg*
I love the movie in engl. but german is a bit better for me.
so props to RiNG
(only saw the sample)

__________________
happy day

cartoon master
***************
sorry my English is bad ^-^

quote:

---

Originally posted by cofferscuffs
id prefer a cvd so i can burn onto dvdr

anyways nice ws scr, i still hate the farcical ending of the movie though
6/5/7

---

As new poster just like to say I think this site is great!!
just downloaded the sample and it looks not bad

go see it in the movies its far better on the big screen

keep up the good work guys

A WORTHY RELEASE.

This is a great screener, I don't see why anyone is grading it low. And the little white line at the bottom of the screen. My God is like a grain long..How nick picky. And please stop dissing and disrespecting the writers and directors, when you can do no better. This was a great film. Long as hell. But great! And the trilogy is one of the best of all times. For some of us, who can appreciate and comprehend the story and concept. For all the kiddies stick with disney. Great release by this group.

8/9/10 will definitely do until a dvdrip is available.
Better than all the telesync's and small promotion display about 3 times in the film. Nice overall looks great on the television.

__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...

VEry nice rls good video and sound. very watchable...but it doesn't feel right watching this on non-dvd quality movie is just too good. anyways still a great rls good work ring. can't wait to buy this over the summer
7/8/10

well, this release is a little better than the logistic copy that has been available for over a month now. the sound is great, but the pic is only slightly better. i will wait for dvd or dvd-scr b4 i watch this flik again. thanks Ring. better late than never

7.5/8.5/9

__________________
puFF, puFF, pass mutha fukka!

Well looks really good on a dvd player, hard to notice artifacts.. yes you see some but still pretty plained out from it.. good sound and color... even cd 3... and as for a dvd.. It wont be out til around august.. All the LOTR's have come out about august 26th.. so you got 7-8 months to wait man on that dvd...grab this now.. as dvdscreener or rip wont be any time soom.

Been waiting for this one thanks a lot the RING or who ever you are. This looks like a fearly respectable release will sute me just fine until a dvd leaks. The other thing is people forget that this little line and some of the picture can be clean up with some basic video editing.

Thanks RING a fine vhs release

Very good job 'RiNG' :P

8/8/10 (a little generous).

This is probably the best quality you are gonna get from a VCD. I would say any other VCD releases of this would be a complete waste of time. SVCD/CVD/DVD might be an idea, but please no more VCD's!!!

Cheers for the hard work you put into this one 'RiNG' :P.

I have my doubts as to whether or not there will even be a DVD Screener for this one, but it shouldn't be too long before the factories start churning out the Pre-Retails since they will need so many to stock the shelves they'll have to start soon!

Hehe.

My thoughts

well looking at the sample its a pretty solid screener. the onyl thing that got my eye was in the bottom of the picture the flash line

quote:

---

Originally posted by ta2
Very good job 'RiNG' :P



This is probably the best quality you are gonna get from a VCD. I would say any other VCD releases of this would be a complete waste of time. SVCD/CVD/DVD might be an idea, but please no more VCD's!!!

---

im torn on this one. its just not that much better than the logistic version, not for the 4 cd's. considering i know ill end up buying the first dvd set, then the extended set (im such a whore), then the obvious box set of all the movies, i think ill pass on this one. great job non the less.

__________________

quote:

---

Originally posted by pHo
ok, well in future when you join a community that is very anti-sellers, you really should choose a username that isn't going to cause confusion and annoyance. its like joinin an arabic forum with the name BUSHRULES because you like the australian outback.

---

good job on the screener

Good quality, will hold every off until the DVDR comes out ... which I'm sure what everyone's waiting on. Clear video, good audio, not too pixally, what more can you ask of a vhs screener ...

Looks ok for being WS, most of the time that's not the case, good job RiNG, mad props for this one

video = 8
audio = 8
movie = 10

thanks again

Very nice release. Video is very clear and better than half of the screeners released this season. Audio is near flawless.

Video - 8
Audio - 8
Movie - 10

pixelation of fast scenes was hardly noticeable on my standalone =) so im happy w/ this copy till the retail comes out which wont be till later LOL

8/8/10

__________________
Dark Evolution is here.....

slightly blurry and pixelated but nothing major and was better on standalone, flashing light at bottom didn't show on my tv, good job and will watch tonight

Video - 7
Audio - 9
Movie - ?

quote:

---

Originally posted by luckyluke80
i agree. why are vhs scr always vcd wouldn't svcd get better quality out of the rls. just wondering

---

__________________
cC.

Nice release RiNG.

Not bad for a VCD/VHS SCREENER.
Yeah as it's been said a CVD would be much better (SVCD would be a waste).

CVD gets almost no play in scene,... too bad it's great for VHS.

CD2 de-sync's half way through, but the film is still watchable.

__________________
- C0G0N3