VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Spiderman 2 *SVCD* - TELECINE - ALLiANCE (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=44723)

quote:

---

Originally posted by ou812
I've seen all 3 releases and this is my comparison:

SpiderMan.2.SVCD.TELESYNC-VideoCD
good first release, tilted, washed colors, PAL, and excellent audio

Spider.Man.2.TC.Line.Dubbed.German.SVCD-EMPiRE
german cam audio, rendered 16:9, PAL, and has an encoder screen at the beginning of the movie (dunno exactly what that was)

Spiderman.2.TELECINE.SVCD-ALLiANCE
great colors, good audio, NTSC, and definatly the best release out. No flaws in the video I see. Glad it wasn't internal.

---

im def sticking with videocd's copy as this, imo, dont look good

7/8/7

quote:

---

Originally posted by pjfan281
well now you forgot the 3cd version by VideoCD which corrected many of the problems of the 2cd

---

dunno what your on about with boxes coming up on the 2cd version of videoCD???? mine was bang on - in fact alot of ppl i know got sold a dodgy copy on dvd and they thought my version on cd was miles better than the one they had

quote:

---

Originally posted by Movie_Insider
nice job 8/8/9 but a little late

---

7/8/9

Not bad video and audio, but I prefer the VideoCD 3cd INTERNAL release to be honest.

__________________
Hullo Hullo, We Are The Rangers Boys!

Clearly better than the ts when compared side by side, sharper and more accurate colours. Audio is about the same.

only a dvdr release will justify whether or not alliance stole the german source and mux'ed it with videocd's audio, they've done it in the past with other groups' dvd releases so it wouldn't shock me but hey... I could be wrong quality is good but at the same time does have a re-encode feel to it. 7/8/5

The samples are a good idea, but i kinda prefer the TS.

Yes this does have better colour, and its sharper up close, but the TS looks better on distance shots.

7/8/9

This isnt bad, but if you already have one of the pervious rls's, especially the VideoCD one, stick with them. The quality is better, but not enough for most people to justify the download.

Not the best TC either, I'd say it's average for a TC so...

7/10/9.5

too bad i already seen it
7/8/9

__________________

It is a good movie, but the quality isn´t it.
My Voting for this:

8/8/7

quote:

---

Originally posted by ch0pp3r
I waited a bit better...

But anyway 7/9/3

Gonna keep VideCD's rel and wait the DVDr.

---

__________________
My sig worked, It's back.

nice job alliance good tc picture was good and audio as well hope maybe to see tc for i robot and anchorman since videocd aint doing ts"s it seems

its good for a tc but not the best 8/9/9

saw the sample, looks real good. If you burn it and watch on your tv it looks even better than it looks on the pc and therefore this is the one to get over the video cd version hands down. The sound is the same, this can even pass as a vhs screener. Very nice.

__________________
hello

4 samples was well worth it
nice job , who cares 60mb its great!

__________________
I Just Want to Be like Radiohead, And do something ingenious.

finally my brown eyes got laid. .. .twice

9/9/8

__________________
I Just Want to Be like Radiohead, And do something ingenious.

well this was a good rls, most likely empire's source...with dts audio laid on it.....


damn good rls, pretty worthless though if you have the VideoCD rls....a screener rls would be just as worthless

wait for dvd or dvdscreener


8/7/8 .......the audio looks to be .05 seconds off..if you wanna get technical....later

nice release, better IMO that 3 discs VideoCD internal

waiting DVD

9/8/9