VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- DVDR (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=24)
-- Spiderman 2 *NTSC* - TELECINE - XPD (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=44788)

quote:

---

Originally posted by Skynet
It IS 5.1 sound! How about you actually HAVE the release before you start talking shit.

---

__________________
563-773-1880

<Dwaggy> i caught you a delicious Bass
<The404> This is because you are an idiot

Yes it has a menu, scene select and even a cute little XPD intro screen.

Audio: 10+ (Dolby Digital 5.1, whoever complained should get stuffed...According to this, its 384 Kbps which is good)
Video: 9 (Average of 4.5 Mbps, so says Powerdvd..Video is a bit blurry too, but still great for a dvdr.)
Movie: 10 (Loved it better than the first one)

quote:

---

Originally posted by Moloko_Plus
Yes it has a menu, scene select and even a cute little XPD intro screen.

---

Just watched the movie.. sorry folks but no way is that 5.1, the speech is coming out of all speakers, no positional sound effects, dont get me wrong it is nice quality sound but dont get excited its not dolby digital, even if it has been encoded as such.

Not too bad a release, But coulda been better. About the same picture quality as Harry Potter 3. Audio is nice & clear & yes, it is stereo, but not full 5.1

If you've got no other release, then this is worth getting to save you having to encode it into dvd yourself.

Meneu is pretty plain, just a jpeg with Play Movie & Scene Selection on it & with background music from the movie itself.

7/7/9

Really enjoyable movie. Looked amazing at the theatre, so go see it there first people! It's definately worth it

JustMe

quote:

---

Originally posted by Moloko_Plus
Yes it has a menu, scene select and even a cute little XPD intro screen.

Audio: 10+ (Dolby Digital 5.1, whoever complained should get stuffed...According to this, its 384 Kbps which is good)
Video: 9 (Average of 4.5 Mbps, so says Powerdvd..Video is a bit blurry too, but still great for a dvdr.)
Movie: 10 (Loved it better than the first one)

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by vip3r
Stick with the VideoCD 3 disc release/TELECINE (if you have them, if not grab this) - but otherwise i wouldn't waste the time and bandwith. As this release doesn't even have 5.1 and isn't the greatest.

8/8/9

---

__________________
mmm...muffins

It's not my fault that they fucked their nfo up is it? No. And considering i have no interest in this release, i wasn't able to clarify/check to see if it actually was 5.1

Yeah I know, I was just pointing out that the people that were declaring 2 channel sound were getting their info from......well the nfo. Not your fault, just being as clear as possible. ;-)

__________________
mmm...muffins

just watched, this is really nice, reminds me of the tc of terminator 3 !


video - 9 "very nice"

sound 9 "little low in some spots, sounds like 5.1 to me !"

movie 10 "loved the first one loved this one"

http://img19.photobucket.com/albums.../spideyrate.jpg

mayby this will shut everyone up about what it is and what it isnt. its obvious that some here didnt bother to even get the sample, yet they somehow feel they can pull an opinion out of the air and try to tell the people who DO have it, whats up with it.

some people...

__________________

quote:

---

Originally posted by pHo
ok, well in future when you join a community that is very anti-sellers, you really should choose a username that isn't going to cause confusion and annoyance. its like joinin an arabic forum with the name BUSHRULES because you like the australian outback.

---

I dont post often but i have to say i watched the release and there is DD 5.1 those of you rating off the nfo and flaming based on the nfo should pull your head out of your ass and stop mongering in the forums. XPD put out a quality release its excellent high quality and well worth the DL. This far from retail a release like this is a keeper in and out. Cheers to XPD

quote:

---

Originally posted by spotfek
Just watched the movie.. sorry folks but no way is that 5.1, the speech is coming out of all speakers, no positional sound effects, dont get me wrong it is nice quality sound but dont get excited its not dolby digital, even if it has been encoded as such.

---

Im still not sure if i should get this or not, can anyone who has watched the whole release on a proper 5.1 setup and knows what to listen for, verify this is a proper 5.1 encode and not just stereo to 5.1 which is what any cheap amp can do.

I put the sample on a CDRW and it doesn't sound like it to me, i hear very little seperation between the speakers, more of an ambient sound.

Cheers

My download of this just finished downloading, and i burnt it to DVDR, slipped it in my DVD Player and was amazed of the qaulity, its brilliant, at first i was a little wary about it as the preview clip on my pc didnt look good qaulity, but i took into account that i generally find my movies to look much better on a proper tv and not my monitor. Anyway i was correct as it was awesome qaulity. Only thing is im not convinced that there is 5.1 in this, as i dont have a 5.1 system, but its just the fact that at the start of the movie, on the title screen, the audio does exactly the same thing as on the alliance release, it like freezes for a couple of seconds and then carries on as normal, it also does go a little stuttery in places, but appart from that its great.

10/7/10!!

Hi there. Long term reader 1st time poster.

I've got the release and burnt it with nero from the image. It appears to work perfectly but wont play beyond chapter 7 on the various dvd players that i've tried it on. I dont usually have any problems with burning/watching releases.

I was wondering if anybody had any suggestions as to why this might be happening and what could be done to reslove it.

Many Thanks

Still nobody can comment on this as havig proper 5.1 sound.

Guess i'll just have to get it then to find out, i want to anyway now, saw this at the cinema last night, amazing film, and i hope this does have good 5.1 as the sound in the cinema was awesome, great panning and brilliant use of the Sub channel.

quote:

---

I've got the release and burnt it with nero from the image. It appears to work perfectly but wont play beyond chapter 7 on the various dvd players that i've tried it on. I dont usually have any problems with burning/watching releases.

---

7 coasters in...i'm gonna throw in the towel :-D

Tried dvd dcrypter etc, extracted the files using iso buster and chapter 7 onwards just dont work, not even through the pc :-(.

I wish I only had to worry about 5.1 or not hehehe.

Me and my mate just watched this film on a proper audio system, but it isnt a DTS 5.1, its just dolby pro logic or Dolby Surround system. It was playing in a high pitched background sound all the way through almost, it got a little annoying, but nethermind, brilliant qaulity overall though, just the sound is a little dissapointing in my opinion, but not the worst

I stated way back that there is no way this is 5.1 and that statement still stands, for anyone who is still wondering, yes I have watched the whole thing all the way through on a standalone dvd player hooked up to dolby digital decoder. yes the little light comes on saying it is dolby, yes it says 5.1 384k when u watch it on a software dvd player but NO it is not 5.1 in any form whatsoever.