VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- I Robot *SVCD* *PROPER* - TELECINE - SKF (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=45990)

less top and bottom cropping, but fuck it. not worth the bw wasteage. lookd the same as tuns and thats all im saying

7/9/9

Pic is still stretched a little, same with the other TC releases. I'll stick with the TS. Just say no to Bad AR.

i have metor's dvdr cos i couldnt be arsed with changing cd's for the tun release. it looks about the same, and theres no need for all the group bashing that goes on, i think people should just leave tun alone or do better themselfs, this is about the same.

7/8/8

I'd say this is an invalid proper. The only mistake TUN did, was making it 3 cd's. This XViD .ru p2p crap, well about that i couldn't care less, becasue the TUN video quality beats this crap anyday.

__________________
ProVoKaTioN

quote:

---

enough for this terrible terrible sci fi movie, if you didnt figure out it was the girl robot the first 30 mins in, i feel sorry for you

---

A nice rls, but I actually prefer the 5.1 treatment and aspect ratio of the new group METEOR DVDR rls...Very Clean pic a tad washed out and much cleaner audio..This PROPER would have been great if I hadn't already watched the CTP and METEOR rls's...Enjoy!!

quote:

---

A nice rls, but I actually prefer the 5.1 treatment and aspect ratio of the new group METEOR DVDR rls

---

8/8/8

but if u hav the videocd rls.....id stick with it until retail dvd

__________________
HOLLA AT YO BOY!

sorry i meant Centropy

__________________
HOLLA AT YO BOY!

Looks worse than the TUN release and has the exact same aspect ratio error AND the bars on the left and right. Okay release but should be nuked just for trying to call it a proper.

Video:7
Audio: 8
Movie: good enough I guess.

i dont really care for telecines anymore, but wth..

8/9/8

and pimpzta e-gangster whatever, there IS an edit button

__________________
I AM USING THE INTRANET!

first posting on vcdquality.com

awesome site btw

anyways, yeah this release wasnt needed but as it was mentioned earlier at least there is groups willing to put forth the effort to put releases out for us, so i guess its ok in the long run

as for me i have the centropy release, and it was great, watched the movie and i liked it, i didnt LOVE it but it was a good summer movie.

i give it 7/8/8

Now i am just waiting for a dvd rip or screener and lock it away in my vault of releases lately lol

This is uneeded really, i mean the the screener will probably be here soon. Stick with te TUN release.

7/7/9

quote:

---

This is uneeded really, i mean the the screener will probably be here soon. Stick with te TUN release.

---

*sample judge*
good effort, picture looks a little pinched.
late as hell, but appreciated.
for tc: 6.5/8/8

__________________
fuckinggoogleit.com
"The power of accurate observation is commonly called cynicism by those who have not got it."
-George Bernard Shaw
I like proof!

First off, Hi to everyone on the board, this is my first post.

secondly...Just near the end of getting this release now, ill edit my post shortly when i playback this on my standalone DVD player. To anyone who doesnt have any copy of the film yet i feel this might be the best SVCD copy to get, but we'll see.

EDIT:

Ok, well after watching this lastnite on the standalone, i'll comment on the quality...

Sound was fine, no problems whatsoever.

Picture was a little steched, nothng major and becomes almost unnoticable.

The colours seemed a little washed out but again, great picture Q for a telecine.

This rls includes all of the credits.

There a slight colour flicker i noticed once during the elevator scene.

overall good rls. 8/8/7

I like this movie, just a treat for the eye nothng more!

Don't think it should be nuked

This release is not useless. Ignoring the groups wars for a minute I don't think there is anything wrong with this release. Yes the quality is about the same as the TUN release but the fact is, this is a 2 cd release unlike the 2.5 cd TUN release. Whatever your opinions of TUN and SKF, if you don't have a decent I Robot, clearly the SKF is the best SVCD choice at the moment......