VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Constantine *SVCD* - TELESYNC - Centropy (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=55783)

very good release 8/8/7

Its close, but not quite the best....

The SAOSIN rls is cropped, no big deal. i can get over it. and it has a tilt to it (that u only notice the first 2 mins of the film) otherwise its best imo.

Centropy is a fine group but the picture on this just aint got the luster of SAOSIN's rls.and im a stickler for quality picture/color myself.

i wonder where Chankra is on this one.....

After downloading and skimming through CD1 , i cant see a huge difference to make me want to burn Centropy. You got a little more of the top and straighter for more blurry and washed colors. If you have SAOSiN release , you wont need this copy .

There are flaws in all 5 releases so far but we all have to remember they are TELESYNC's which are all cropped , or have issues to some degree.

I picked up SAOSiN's release saturday morning and it will do me for 4/5 weeks till a nice TELECiNE DVDR gets released.

One thing i dont understand here is the ratings ...

Centropy - 8.6/9.3/8.5
SG18 - 4.0/5.8/7.9
POT - 2.2/4.9/7.7
COBRA - 4.7/6.4/7.9
SAOSiN - 7.4/7.7/8.3

I can understand the picture quality rating but sound ?? , From what i read so far SAOSiN has 3 spots where it echo's (havent seen them as i cant make it through the movie) , but besides that their ALL DTS Disk Audio. How does POT get a 4.9 yet Centropy gets a 9.3 or SAOSiN a 7.7 ?

Point being , im sure if SAOSiN said Centropy or COBRA said VideoCD it woulda got higher ratings as not all but lots vote on the grp and not the actual quality.

Very nice rls! Watch this rls on TV (DVD PLAYER, XBOX or PS2)

8/7/9

SAOSIN GOTS SPEED

:: I CAN TYPE IN CAPS TOO AND TALK SHIT. -cC.

__________________
Where is maVen - SAOSIN - VideoCD and CenTroPy.

no no ,just because its centropy rules dont apply ,you are all way overrating this release , its a dupe , pic not great ,sound ok ,movie worth a watch , but if u have the other release i'd stick with that.

Very nice rl.

I give it 7/9/8

al=d: I cant understand why you have to write everything in capital letters....

:: We don't have a cheering section. -K::

8 - washed
8 - good
? - dunno

__________________
I Just Want to Be like Radiohead, And do something ingenious.

sooooo...

what should i do stick with my saosin? or get the centropy?

sample looks ok

has anyone watched it the whole way through is there any people walking across screen?

if not i will d/load

__________________
HAIL HAIL

CTP rls is good but for me SAOSIN was good enuff for me yeah it was cropped but good colours etc... This for me is not STP's best and well we should not go weak at the knees cos they managed to get to rls a copy of this... rol on *Valiant* looks a good flick!!

V:6, A:8, M:8.

7/8/?...not the best TS ive ever seen, but it'll do

yay for centropy.

8/8/7.8

...

8
8
5 MOVIE SUCKS

:: Don't flame. -K::

ok ok got centropy release
yes its alittle faded but i can enhance the color so it looks perfect now

Vid:9
Audio:8
Movie:9.9 heheh

Keep it up boys

nice rls although as noted previously on this thread colours are washed, sound is excellent though. Not watched the whole movie yet so cant comment on that but have been looking forward to this one for a while so hope I'm not disappointed.

7/9/?

bah decent, but a dupe. The other rls was fine. This actualy is worst in my opnion. Other was more crisp, and did nto have washed like fuck colors.
video 7- bleh
audio-what ya expect? 9
movie- pretty entertaining

quote:

---

Originally posted by IRC_Moviefan
After downloading and skimming through CD1 , i cant see a huge difference to make me want to burn Centropy. You got a little more of the top and straighter for more blurry and washed colors. If you have SAOSiN release , you wont need this copy .

There are flaws in all 5 releases so far but we all have to remember they are TELESYNC's which are all cropped , or have issues to some degree.

I picked up SAOSiN's release saturday morning and it will do me for 4/5 weeks till a nice TELECiNE DVDR gets released.

One thing i dont understand here is the ratings ...

Centropy - 8.6/9.3/8.5
SG18 - 4.0/5.8/7.9
POT - 2.2/4.9/7.7
COBRA - 4.7/6.4/7.9
SAOSiN - 7.4/7.7/8.3

I can understand the picture quality rating but sound ?? , From what i read so far SAOSiN has 3 spots where it echo's (havent seen them as i cant make it through the movie) , but besides that their ALL DTS Disk Audio. How does POT get a 4.9 yet Centropy gets a 9.3 or SAOSiN a 7.7 ?

Point being , im sure if SAOSiN said Centropy or COBRA said VideoCD it woulda got higher ratings as not all but lots vote on the grp and not the actual quality.

---

video is a little over-brightened (reminiscent of ctp's rls of I Robot but not as severe) but it's centered well with no angle or noticable cropping, and good aspect ratio. V=8

audio is what we've come to expect from TS's these days.... very very nice!! A=9

the film itself was actually much better than i expected. M=7

Comparing the ctp and saosin rls's of this is tough. Saosin's has more vibrant colors but ctp's doesn't have the top cropping or the dissonant echo in the audio.
Personally I prefer the ctp version, the weird sound of saosin's bothered me more than the slightly faded pic of this one.
It's just a matter of preference though... damn it's nice to be able to compare two TS's of such nice quality!