VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- DIVX (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=23)
-- Star Wars Episode III Revenge of the Sith INTERNAL DVDRip XviD - DVDRIP - aAF (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=63272)

I can not get sound for some reason, but apart from that picture looks dvd source to me, way to good for a telecine.

9/x/9

quote:

---

Originally posted by EViL-EWoK
obv not a dvdrip. its a TC. close enough to a dvdrip to be labeled DVDRip.
Since it is internal the rules are bent

9/9/8

still holy shit nice work

---

__________________
I like big butts and I cannot lie.

source is obviously not a telecine, you're just talking out of your ass. very nice looking - 9/9/7

I am not going to argue with everyone because that is not the point of these posts. All i am gonna say is it looks and sounds so perfect that if it is not a DVDRIP they sure fooled me. I already watched CD1. WOW!! Great Job!

Video - 9.5
Audio - 9.5
Movie - 9.5

I do not exist therefore i am above all

__________________
I Do Not Exist Therefore I Am Above All!!

9.8/9/10 watched first few minutes and very nice much better then wp never saw tc u can kinda see a little pixelation but not much very nice

Well i saw all 3 versions and i can say

WP- was ridiculously pixalted and the aspect ratio... well .. im sure everyone knows already!!

TC- I thought Tun did a good job ... my only complaint was that it was a tad too dark.. and that the sides were a little cropped off ... other than that flawless.. very minor pixles ...

DVD-Rip- Must admit it looks very nice when the movie isnt very dark .. sound rocks but theres still a few pixles .. so i can go either way with the TC and this one

V-9
S-10
M-6.5 <--- dont get me started!!

WOW!!!!! Grab this one QUICK!!!

This is the one to get as its FLAWLESS.

George will be glad he's hanging up his hat after he see's this release.

Well done boys on an EXCELLENT release and so damm quick too.

__________________
Lets praise all the groups out there who make this scene for what it's worth because if we didn't then we'd all be spending a fortune at the pics.Remember to practice SAFE SEX (as illistrated in the pic).

8/9/9

I think that this one is R0 dvdrip
like the "BoB" rls of Around the Wold in 80 days last year.
it's allmost DVD quality.
maybe some academic screener (dvd) but i think that's too soon for that.
who knows

No Sound For Me... at first
9
8
8


quality is great........

Judging from sample I can't see how anyone can agree this comes from a dvd - the pic is "okay" but the sound is hideously bad! Scratchy, tinny, flat - what have we.

Pic is the best yet but bad AR for me.

Sound isn't hugely great either - not even as good as the workprint.

Will do until retail but there's certainly room for improvement. Hope they release the DVD source

8/7/9

AR is fine for me, but the picture isn't perfect. You can see lots of distortion thruout the film (easiest point is on the intro "Far Far Away" screen, look at the text closely) which to me says its been on an analogue source at some point in its life. Sound is better, but I'm still concerned the master is screwed, because the lava fight still doesn't sound great.

7/8/10

I'm not sucking cock and saying the video is perfect when it clearly isn't.. it might've been ripped from a DVD, but it didn't start its life there I'm sure of that. Best release out tho without a doubt.

__________________
563-773-1880

<Dwaggy> i caught you a delicious Bass
<The404> This is because you are an idiot

Just thought i would point out that iND stands for iNDependant, meaning this was a -NoGroup release, iND isnt really a release group, anyone can release under the name.

:: Shut up. -K::

Gave it a 9/9/10

It's most def. the best thing out, but to me it looks like it has not been ripped by professionals.

i grabbed the first cd of this yesterday from a newsgroup, had no really nfo like this one and no group name, stil its the best quality out now, its not a TC and its not a re encode of TUN's release, its near perfect, i just wonder how this go out so soon, lucas will be fuming

ntsc
2 chan ac3

only thing i see missing is the end credits other than that perfect

9/9/8

Not had a problem playing it on the Yamada 6700 DVD/Divx player.

Quality is just tiny bit short of DVD quality, but I am not complaining! It is definitely not from a camera. The only gripe is that in the beginning, the sound levels appear a bit too high and some of the explosions sounded distorted. Apart from that, an excellent release and totally unexpected and out of the blue!

This is no TC for sure. The sound isn't tinny at all...in fact it is the best sound yet. the AR is spot on. Don't be fooled by that other internal floating around out there by CDRS it's only a re-encode of the TUN SVCD w/fake 5.1 AC3, now THAT ONE sounded tinny. The video is a little pixelated but if you can watch the workprint you should have ne problems with this.

V=8
A= 9
M= 10

9/9/8 Can't fault this, job well done.