VCDQuality Forums - Star Wars Episode III Revenge of the Sith INTERNAL NTSC DVDR - DVDRIP

Pages (4): « 1 [2] 3 4 »
Show all 64 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- DVDR (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=24)
-- Star Wars Episode III Revenge of the Sith INTERNAL NTSC DVDR - DVDRIP - aAF (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=63369)

Posted by Wanderer22 on 06-09-2005 07:05 PM:

Re: STARWARS

quote:
Originally posted by manchester
IVE HAD A COPY OF THIS FOR A DAY OR SO NOW AND MINE HAS GOT THE
ENDING ON IT HAS A MENU ASWELL CAN ANYONE CONFIRM WETHER THIS RLS HAS A MENU ON IT

VIDEO 9.5
AUDIO 9.5

First off, WHY ARE YOU YELLING?

Secondly... if you have the thing, why are you asking if it has menus? Shouldn't you already know if it has menus?

Posted by chuxterofdoom on 06-09-2005 07:21 PM:

Mine has menus as well. and the ending is not cut off. Just the credits.

Posted by manchester on 06-09-2005 07:23 PM:

Re: Re: STARWARS

quote:
Originally posted by Wanderer22
First off, WHY ARE YOU YELLING?

Secondly... if you have the thing, why are you asking if it has menus? Shouldn't you already know if it has menus?

FIRST IAM NOT YELLING

SECOND I WAS ASKING WETHER THE IND RLS HAD A MENU

THIRD MINE HAS A MENU AND ITS THE [DVDR-KKi] RLS
SO IT WAS A SIMPLE QUESTION SO WHY SPIT YOUR DUMMY OUT

Posted by Wanderer22 on 06-09-2005 07:31 PM:

Re: Re: Re: STARWARS

quote:
Originally posted by manchester
FIRST IAM NOT YELLING

SECOND I WAS ASKING WETHER THE IND RLS HAD A MENU

THIRD MINE HAS A MENU AND ITS THE [DVDR-KKi] RLS
SO IT WAS A SIMPLE QUESTION SO WHY SPIT YOUR DUMMY OUT

Obviously, you missed your Internet 101 class.

All capital letters, LIKE THIS, equals yelling. It's the typing equivelant of SCREAMING EVERYTHING. And it's highly annoying.

Second, you specifically stated "I have this release and it has a menu, does this release have a menu?" Which is a bit contradictory. If you had a different release, then you should have said so. As I understand it, the KKi release is a re-encode of the XviD.. if you're happy with that, be my guest.

Also, if you had actually read this thread, you would have seen the following comment by JKozzy:

"And it's got the menus and all that jazz".

Which would answer your question with a rather resounding "yes", without you even having to ask it in the first place.

Posted by MrMayhem on 06-09-2005 07:54 PM:

How can anybody moan about this rls what more can you ask for it has a menu and the full film quality was quite good and you will never get a retail quality copy so soon for such a big film. Thanks to all who go above and beyond to get us rls so quickly

let the Mayhem begin

Posted by xiaNaix on 06-09-2005 08:02 PM:

I grabbed this. I'm pretty sure it's just another re-encode of the XviD release that someone slapped a basic menu on (just one "play" button).

As a final death blow to this crap release, it is missing the ending. This is not an authoring issue. Loading the final VOB file into an editor such as MPEGVCR reveals that the last couple of minutes are completely missing.

My best guess is that someone fed the XviD release into a standalone DVD recorder to create this. They probably used the 2-hour record mode and that's why it is cut off.

The KKi release has equal picture quality, audio in the proper channels, better menu (chapters, etc.), and English subtitles. I'll stick to that until the real source is released.

And, for the record, iND is not a group. That means it's an "independent" release. And I'm not suprised no one wants to claim it.

Posted by ATS on 06-09-2005 08:23 PM:

STAR WARS Episode III DVD-R

The DVD-R that I downloaded is complete except for the credits.
The Main Menu has a picture of a portion (1/2) of Darth Vader on the left and is titled (of course) STAR WARS ESPISODE III REVENGE OF THE SITH. It has four chapter screens.

Great looking release!

Posted by dwayne on 06-09-2005 09:20 PM:

this was a not needed release i think i anyone who knows their ass from a hole in the ground can convert the xvid to dvdr no need

also its bright and not as colorful as the xvid ..should of used CCE

7/8/10 movie rocked

__________________
"Imagination is more important than knowledge.
Knowledge is limited. Imagination encircles the world."
-Albert Einstein (1879-1955)

Posted by pargoff on 06-10-2005 01:32 AM:

i think some people may be confusing the releases here. this forum is for the ind release as far as i can tell and it is missing the end of the movie after the darth NOOOOOOO scene. this IS NOT a discussion for the KKI release that is floating around and which is complete. as for this particular release...

9
9
10

Posted by asssack on 06-10-2005 01:50 AM:

yo its a alright release, hopefully they release the real source, or get a better quality version..

Posted by hoozdapimp on 06-10-2005 02:01 AM:

my best guess is that whoever encoded this release probably used DVD2SVCD (using DVD 2 DVD mode), used 1 pass VBR and it got slightly oversized....results in 1 big 4gb+ mpg file and another smaller mpg file that they didn't see and just authored with the big mpg file....of course that's a stretch :P

Posted by Ripper on 06-10-2005 02:24 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by xiaNaix
And, for the record, iND is not a group. That means it's an "independent" release. And I'm not suprised no one wants to claim it.

IND is a courier group mate and they occasionally "find" releases that no one has bothered to release as well as a few fixes for dvdr retails now and again.
I'm happy with the kki release till the retail comes out

__________________
I was never caught!

Posted by graham23s on 06-10-2005 02:32 AM:

when was the kki version released?i can't seem to fing the .nfo anywhere

Graham

Posted by Wanderer22 on 06-10-2005 02:35 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by graham23s
when was the kki version released?i can't seem to fing the .nfo anywhere

Graham

Isn't the KKI just a re-encode of the XviD? That would disqualify it from being listed here, as I understand VCDQ's general rules.

Posted by jrw on 06-10-2005 04:51 AM:

Re: STAR WARS Episode III DVD-R

quote:
Originally posted by ATS
The DVD-R that I downloaded is complete except for the credits.
The Main Menu has a picture of a portion (1/2) of Darth Vader on the left and is titled (of course) STAR WARS ESPISODE III REVENGE OF THE SITH. It has four chapter screens.

Great looking release!

This release is no good period,Its missing 5 minutes of the ending BEFORE the credits. If you have the whole ending then you didnt download this particular release, it also doesnt have any chapter screens...I think you're reffering to the KKi release.

Posted by Wanderer22 on 06-10-2005 05:29 AM:

Finally finished downloading.. that was a waste of bandwidth. The copy itself is wonderful, this isn't a re-encode of the XviD (certain compression artifacts I noticed in the XviD are missing here).. but it is missing the end of the movie... that seems somewhat asenine to me.

EDIT:

This is a re-encode... I just can't tell what it's a re-encode OF..

It's not a re-encode of the XviD, although I think this may have been the Source of the XviD. It has the same flickering here and there, but not the compression artifacts and bleedover that the XviD had.

I picked this version up so as to have a higher resolution source to make my own SVCDs out of. Although it was worthless because of the missing footage, I took a gander at it in TMPEGEnc anyway, in IVTC, to see if I could determine where the flickering was coming from. Looks like it had been de-interlaced at some point (badly), then re-interlaced for the DVD.

So now that we have that out of the way, does anyone know where the ACTUAL source is? What's this KKI release? Another re-encode? Same flickering?

Posted by dragonballz on 06-10-2005 05:46 AM:

great work another classic

Posted by FozzieWak on 06-10-2005 06:19 AM:

I got this release a few days ago, the jpg really does a bad job at showing the quality.

video 9 - some glitches, i think to keep in sync.

audio 6.8 - alot of the louder parts would not sound clean and crisp but raspy and muffled.

Movie 9.5 - blockbuster

Posted by thedevilman on 06-10-2005 06:31 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by Wanderer22
So now that we have that out of the way, does anyone know where the ACTUAL source is? What's this KKI release? Another re-encode? Same flickering?

KKi iz a conversion to DVDR of the iND XviD with the reversed audio fixed, english subtitlez and retail style menuz. still a bit of the audio clipping th0 from the XviD, but not horrible.

too bad about this iND DVDR. just seemz like everyone iz in a hurry to get the best copy of this out and their hurry keeps producing mistakes.

__________________
When all were deemed broken and torn, fallen in time... he stood in the shadows creeping, pushing fire with quiet breaths of darkness and mischief.
-thedevilman

Posted by xiaNaix on 06-10-2005 07:51 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by Wanderer22
This is a re-encode... I just can't tell what it's a re-encode OF..

It's not a re-encode of the XviD, although I think this may have been the Source of the XviD. It has the same flickering here and there, but not the compression artifacts and bleedover that the XviD had.

Those could have been cleaned up by the filtering in a good set-top DVD recorder, which is how I suspect this release was created. I have a JVC unit that I use to transer VCD and SVCD to NTSC DVD-R. It cleans up alot of the artifacting and color issues. I did that with both the workprint and the Russian telecine. Yes, I've wasted way too much bandwith on this movie.

Also, if I were to record this in SP (2-hour) mode, it would cut off right around the same spot this one does. I truly believe this was a re-encode of the XviD done with a standalone DVD recorder.

And, yes, the KKi release is a re-encode. It's much better than this crap, though.

All times are GMT. The time now is 04:05 AM.

Pages (4): « 1 [2] 3 4 »
Show all 64 posts from this thread on one page