VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Fantastic Four *SVCD* - CAM - BaPH (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=64590)

For a cam:
V-7
A-6
M-6

The twat factor is very high in this. Seems like the camera had to be hidden for a while in the beginning, a few bathroom breaks, and the usher must have checked in because half the screen is covered for a few seconds about half way through. Actual video quality is pretty good for a cam. Audio is just ok, you can understand what is being said. Lot of coughing and mic-rubbing. Grab this if you can't wait, it gets the job done.

__________________
[ECHELON]

decent cam, picture a bit blurry and it does seem interlaced (but heh it's svcd it will probably look fine on my tv.) audio is typical. I've only watched the first disc but so far there hasn't really been any audience participation, although there is sound a couple times from the cammer moving around.

7/6/? - hopefully the second half is better then the first, but I'm not keeping my hopes up.

__________________
There is nothing to be afraid of.....except super aids

Just a follow-up: Movie was great! If i wasnt unemployed and broke with 2.00 left in my account, i would gladly go pay to see it.

from the sample...

picture: 7 ; kinda blury, but pretty good for a cam
audio: 6.5; coughing is kinda annoying, but decent

this had minimal theater sound and wasn't that bad...for cam audio it was real nice and clear..less hollow...

all the cam guys does is cough everyone once in a while and some f..king female keeps getting her dumb ass up a few times...overall its a great cam...

Video 7
audio 7 rated as cam its great audio..
Film 8 it was good and bad. Not enough action but enough story to build the characters up for the sequel.

__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...

grabbed sample (grabbing full movie) it took a while for a established viewer like blu-neo to post, i was d/ling b4 that but now i am assured its an OK rls at worst the sample (i no longer think thats ample enuff for sound) is good a great cam good color a slight bit saturated and blurry... but great none the less, the sound is good also, cam/ts is difficult nowadays, WOTW cam had better sound in some areas than the TS, i hope this is sorted out soon, if not i have a volume button

:ops cam rated as 7/8/??? to be edited soon enuff::

From full release:
Video - 6
I would've given it a 7 on just the picture aspect, but the fact that there's a few points where someone blocks some part of the picture made me go with 6 for video as an experience, as opposed to an aspect.

Audio - 4
Don't let the 4 mislead you, in the world of 'just cams', audio is very good, but I rate in an overall(or 'I want to convert this to DVD) aspect. Sound is a bit hollow, but not so bad that you must strain your ears. You can also hear some audience sounds in the parts I did listen to. It also seems to slip in/out of sync, but it could just be WMP, so when I see it converted, it may play just fine. I'll let you know if it IS an issue (unless someone else does first).

Movie - ???
Going to watch it in 2 more hours. If it's HALF as good as what everyone has hyped it up to be, it'll be the year's best.

outa curiosity what would u guys consider to be a 10 for a cam cuz I havent seen a seen a quality cam ever. Havent downloaded many of em, but i guess its all about the persons opinion. So what release in the past would u consider a 10 for a cam.

due to being a cam i would give this

6-v
6-a
?-m

can hear the guy clearing his throat in the sample, going to burn and watch on the tv tonight and see if it clears up the pixelation.

quote:

---

outa curiosity what would u guys consider to be a 10 for a cam cuz I havent seen a seen a quality cam ever. Havent downloaded many of em, but i guess its all about the persons opinion. So what release in the past would u consider a 10 for a cam

---

10 rated cams---- VideoCD after the re-encoding of DTS, only a few out there, napoleon dynamite is one... but me i dont care if TS and CAM... ppl say TS and cam video are the same... essentialy it is, but TS is mostly if not always above cam video... Video can reach 10, but sound... well this rls is dam good and for a cam.... but since the crackdown, ive noticed quite a few good cams, and the dts rendering being different, a quiet no laughing/coughing cam can sound better than the input jack for TS... sorry but alot of ts's recently just dont sound right

for the first release of this, nicely done. it is a cam and there are a few points when the screen is covered. all in all the audio isnt that bad. nice work.
video 6.0 for a cam
audio 5.0
movie 5.0 nice, but not up to the hype that is out there for this film.

5/5/5+

I give the movie a 5+ because jessica alba in a tight litle suit deserves a 5+.

bitrate is a mess for svcd 1hr 1st cd 37 mins second cd the ending is missing from it also, (the bit where u see d*****SPOILER REMOVED(muppet!)*****) shame really this silver was decent but wtf happened when these guys re-encoded it?

4/7/7

got this for my 4yr old son isn`t released here till the 22nd and he`s already collecting the toys from burger king (i love those double whoppers) i just didn`t enjoy the film i think i`m starting to get old, not bad for a cam , pity about the guy having to cover up the camera lens when ppl get up.

v/6
a/6
m/4

i give BaPH a 10 for stepping up and releasig this movie but i give this release a 6/6/5 would have been higher had it not been for the idiot and the girl constantly moving

Poor cam, don't know how on earth it's getting all these high ratings. Very washed out, not too sharp, audio is awful. It's watchable but I wouldn't call it enjoyable. On the plus side it doesn't seem overly cropped.

And will people please stop using the term "twat factor"... it's both annoying and idiotic.

This is the best CAM I've seen in a very long time. Blocking the camera under their bag for a few seconds a few times doesn't bother me at all, and the toilet visits isn't so disturbing either, overall very good cam.

Video: 7.5
Audio: 6
Movie: 8

Video = 5
Audio = 4
Movie = 6


Coughing and you can here the audience. There is a Spanish version with damn good video but the audio is Spanish.

__________________

nice for a cam

6/6/7