VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Charlie And The Chocolate Factory *SVCD* - TELESYNC - (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=64788)

this is one bbaaaaaaadddddddd flick.not to mention the quality. it may b closer to the book,but most peeps will compare it to the last film,an compared to that.........its naff!
v-3
a-7
m-0!

6/7/6

Decent release ..

The cropping makes this unwatchable.

Video: 3
Audio: 6 (passable)
Movie: 6 (you'll either love it or hate it)

Video good
audio more like a cam auio not a TS
movie still watching

so whose release is this ?



::EDIT:: Yo Mommas! - NS::

Ah good shot whoever done it I managed to sit and watch it!

and i find it hard to believe people are whinging after everything that has happened lately.

dont like it? to cropped go to the THEATRE and watch it then these guys are just giving you an alternative.

6/7/8?

__________________

Props to the unknown releasers for having the balls to release this right now, or maybe stupidity.

but...................

5/5/?

umm, don't bother with this, it seems to be the same source as the cam but, amazingly, lower quality.

I'd almost say it's a re-encode of the cam that was encoded to maybe xvid then to SVCD or something.

Picture does get clearer on a standalone, but I'd stick with the cam for now.

Cropping aside, can anyone clarify if there are scenes actually missing? I haven't made it thru all or either copy, and won't even bother.

If you are desperate, and can't find the BaPH release this one is watchable.

__________________
And it appears Burt Reynolds has changed his name to Turd Furgeson.

That's right, it's a funny name

v-6 cropped/washed a-7 m-4

__________________
"but i choose to die, on a steady diet of booze and lies"

Eh.

5/5/7

Video - 5 -- Cropped to all hell, most of the people's faces are cut off in any semblance of a closeup. Colors are slightly washed out, motion is a tiny bit blurred (on my TV -- was VERY blurred on my PC), a little grainy.

Audio - 5 -- Poor audio source. Anything remotely loud is unintelligable, ie the Oompa Loompa songs. Anything really quiet is also unintelligable.

Movie - 7 -- Much truer to the book, but I'm pissed about Tim Burton's craptastic tunnel scene and I'm not so sure about Johnny Depp.

IMHO, wait for another release -- this one ain't worth the bandwidth.

__________________
... n1ckn4m3

vid/6
aud/7
mov/8.5

if it wasnt for the cropping id give the video a 8 but this does have some serious cropping to the lower half and sides.
a good way to explain how cropped is if the frame is of a adult standing next to a child you will only see the childs forehead and nothing below that.
if your a serious J.D fan or burton fan save your bandwidth for a better release