VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- The Island *SVCD* *PROPER* - TELECINE - ItsNotMe (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=65643)

I know Im only suppose to be commenting on this release but I fee like I have to say something in response to several comments that have been made. THE ORIGINAL RELEASE. This Pre'd as an xvid. The ROYAL DVD-R was created using that xvid. The ASTROiDS release used direct stream copy for video. The video was untouched ( therefore the least altered and therefore the best in this case.by default) and was simply redubbed in English. The NBP release was ripped and encoded poorly from the the ROYAL DVD-R. Thats why the low - res - lol. Anyhow, what Im trying to get at is.WHY THE FU***** FAN FAIR. Every group who has recieved any attention from releasing this movie didnt have anything to do with the original film to video transfer anyhow.Its one GIANT CHAIN of LEECH ( asside from one dedicated grp taking the time to capture English audio ). I have my bets on ROYAL but I really dont know how far the leech latter goes. Anyhow, the base of my statement is this. Its been what so many people have been saying just in many more word s ( possibly redundent ) ..... THIS HAS BEEN DONE! ItsNotMe, it been done several times now and your PROPER is BS. ITS A WASTE OF TIME.

As far as the quality of rip. Looks Great. Sounds Great. But perhaps there should be an additional catogory added for legitimicy. If there was I would rate this release at - 10.

nicely said..i aplaued you!! finaly someone with some sence. instead if kids crappy comments.

like i said before..if you got a early rls then stick with it..this is all about the same quality.

This is a nice full screen copy.

I watched it on my 32 inch TV and played it from my older Pioneer Standalone DVD player.

This picture quality looked great and the sound was nice & clear.
If it was dubbed, then I couldn't tell....In fact I didn't notice any problems with this release.

No, I dont' have a plasma TV, and I may not have the greatest home theater set up, but on my very average set up this looked great. I have no complaints about this release.

I'll take a release with this type of quality everytime.

9/9/8

looks good but im gonna go with the xvid after comparing the two samples

9/9