VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- DIVX (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=23)
-- Fantastic 4 Rise Of The Silver Surfer R5 LINE *Xvid* - R5 - PUKKA (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=77434)

quote:

---

Originally posted by AndrewBud
whatever moderator thinks hes funny with his blue shit can go fuck themselves.

and yes ban me please this site used to be cool but now its full of lame ass fucking retards that think they own the world because they run some low end MOVIE only website.

www.theisonews.com is my new friend so fuck yourself.

---

Just finished watching the movie.... well here we go;


Video 9.5
Audio 7 (NO AUDIO Synch Problems - just pitchy sometimes)
Movie 7

Super fast release and download!!!! For those (like me) who havent watched the movie DO GRAB IT!!!!!!)

From sample very clear and another good release and fast from Pukka.

V 9
A 9
M Gonna watch later

Pls let me know how this rating system goes. Judging by rating of earlier releases that also have this mono sound I'm really confused. Throwing out 9's and 10's on this sorta audio, imho, is just wrong and dissillusional.

Good thing that StephenR brought his comment:

quote:

---

It's the same as with Spiderman - good video let down by mono sound.

---

V: 9 - Always tops for R5 release.
A: 7- Not flawless but still good
M: 6 - A definite improvement on the original which i thought was a bit crap.

Great video, flat and hollow mono sound, one of the worst movies of this year (any year, really) so far.

8/5/2

9/5/8

Video: 9 -- Gorgeous R5, crisp, clean, good AR... Damn near perfect.

Audio: 5 -- Since it's R5.LINE, the audio was taken from an alternate source to replace the original russian, and it shows. The audio clips and pops sometimes, it's fuzzy around the highs and lows, very hollow, somewhat muddy, and there's very poor channel separation (if any at all, I couldn't really tell). Don't get me wrong, it's still quite watchable, it's just that the imperfect audio seems very out of place with such good video at first, and took me a few minutes to accustom to.

Movie: 8 -- Pretty good, Silver Surfer was one of my faves from the comics and he was done fairly well. A+ for Galactus, he looks great! Overall, the movie was nowhere near as cheesy or dim as the first one, definitely better than the original.

Watched from start to finish with XBMC on 51" HD, audio was in sync entirely, no video flaws or noticable artifacts. All in all, very, very watchable.

__________________
... n1ckn4m3

quote:

---

Originally posted by vat0r
V-10 (As an R5)
A- 10 ("")
M-7

Good flick but honestly a little to cheesy for me to give a higher rating then 7.

---

__________________
Why pay?

I watched it yesterday.

V: 9.5 - Pretty impressive. Sharp, good color balance, good brightness and contrast balance. Looked nice on my HDTV with
Oppo upconvert Divx player.

A: 8 - I agree with the others who say the audio is adequate but sounds like a mono mix. Of course it would be better to have a 5.1 surround track but I have to rate it as an R5.

M: C+. OK movie but does not rate summer blockbuster status.

A: 7 ( hollow, out of sync on standalone )
V: 8.5 ( nice! )
M: 4 ( watch for the effects, don't expect much. crap. )

Spot on! IMO, This is a Great RLS. No worries with sound.

V: 9
A: 8
M: 7

Some people seem to complain when they should be glad to get such good releases. Yes, the sound is a bit rough and mono, so what when we are lucky to have such fine releases. The video is great quality for a long movie and 700MB's!

V-9, A-7 (considering it's problems), M-8

looks pretty good

v 8.5
a 7
m 5

V- 9.5 Can't fault it on the system I watched it on.

A- 8 Perfectly clear through tv speakers

M- 8 Really enjoyed it, although I am a big Marvel fan.

v: 9
a: 8
m: 8.5