VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- I Robot *PROPER* - TELESYNC - POT (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=44634)

[QUOTE]Originally posted by outside_ag
[B]LOL. That is hillarious.

lol m8 if u watch the first 5 mins its all over the place... and also through the movie (he must b trying 2 dodge the idiots that are poping up now and again)

watched the movie now.. pritty good
just wait 4 a better rls ....

i know it wont be long

Average rls imo.

6/6/7

btw you guys shouldn't talk about scene bs on here

I agree its average, picture is pretty poor, watchable though, but its too shaky and grainy at times

Sound isn't as great as everyone is making either, (and i wish people wouldn't refer to it as DTS sound, its mp2 from DTS source)
Theres a buzzing at times and it doesn't do my DPL2 system any favours.

6/7/?

Movie was decent...

7/7/7

__________________
My sig worked, It's back.

great job pot now you should take a bow.

8/8/8/

thanks keep it up

well i say

What’s the deal with the shaking I just watched it and is it me or did the screen shake the whole time???.... and the pixilation made the movie on the boarder line of not watch able I would stick with the FRA release its much darker but its very clear for a cam and the hiss in the audio goes away if you mess with the treble level

This is decent for a VCD release. The audio is quite, needed to crank the volume, but the quality is great. Audio does go out of sync for about 5 minutes or so, in the middle of CD1, then comes back in. Saw this on the big screen, it lacked a little detail there too.

Heads and people, in a theatre imagine that. There aren't many releases that don't have a person's head in it. But anything is better than Cold Creek Manor, where you can hear the camera dude munching on pop corn.

To my eyes, and on my TV, I perfered this release compared to the FRA release. They are both VCDs, and the quality fits accordingly, just the FRA has nasty audio.

6/8/8 Good movie.

alright just watched this... great movie ... must kill the ROBOTS!

picture was so-so... but ok

7/8/9.5

One of the Top Movies i've saw this summer ... Going to see this in Threatres when i get back from a trip next week

quote:

---

Originally posted by fkngrvn
To my eyes, and on my TV, I perfered this release compared to the FRA release.

---

just got done watching this....

video is grainey and zoomed in - but watchable by all means

audio is perfect

movie was really good!


7/10/9


some guy with a cap on gets up and goes somewhere twice in this movie..... bit of a pain but that whats you get Just made the experience a little more authentic and like being in a cinema

__________________
[3:57am] <@mystic-s> every person in the usa is gay and loves men. they also like putting bicycles up their bottom <--- hehehehe

6/8/7

The video is definitely watchably, but certainly not terrific even for a TS.

The audio is excellent, I hope this kind of quality continues.

I just finished watching the movie. For a summer blockbuster popcorn flick it can't be beat. I wish it had stopped to be a little more contemplative at times, there were hints, but not enough to create real depth.

Anyway, it was an enjoyable experience all around.

p.s. Get down in front!

__________________

2 Headshots (1 during the ending)
3 walk-bys, from the same guy with the ballcap and mustache

Other then that, its a decent watch. I liked the movie.

Ummm... am I the only one that noticed this????

BOTH RELEASES ARE FROM THE SAME SOURCE!!

If you compare the fra and pot releases.. they are the same video source.... just that pot used something like tmpenc to either zoom in or stretch the top and bottom ... if you look at both.. in the scene where he tackles the robot about 7:55 into the movie you will notice someones head.. with curly hair on the right (your right) side of the screen.... it's there in both releases.. and I am 100% positive they are from the same silver source.. just pot got hold of the dts discs.. to resync the audio....... the picture on fra is 10 times better than pot... probably because they trashed the video quality by stretching it out.. either trying to cut out some of the heads.. or trying to make people think they had their own video source as well............

But aren't they the ones bitching in their nfo that some "elite" group was gonna strip their dts audio and use it for their own release???????? hmmm..........

After watching both releases.. i'm revising my rating........

POT=
6 video
9 Audio (sync issues stopped it from a 10)
10 movie.... it kicked ass..... one of my fav's for the year.

FRA =
8 video (much better than pot)
7 audio (released as a cam.. but the audio is direct so it
should be a telesync.. but to shut up the whiners
they only claimed it as a cam, yes it's direct.. you can hear the cammer fool with the audio jack a few times.. background hiss because it's not a great connection... but a few years ago this would have been top notch and received much higher ratings)
10 movie

quote:

---

Originally posted by lickmyzack
Ummm... am I the only one that noticed this????

BOTH RELEASES ARE FROM THE SAME SOURCE!!

If you compare the fra and pot releases.. they are the same video source.... just that pot used something like tmpenc to either zoom in or stretch the top and bottom ... if you look at both.. in the scene where he tackles the robot about 7:55 into the movie you will notice someones head.. with curly hair on the right (your right) side of the screen.... it's there in both releases.. and I am 100% positive they are from the same silver source.. just pot got hold of the dts discs.. to resync the audio....... the picture on fra is 10 times better than pot... probably because they trashed the video quality by stretching it out.. either trying to cut out some of the heads.. or trying to make people think they had their own video source as well............

But aren't they the ones bitching in their nfo that some "elite" group was gonna strip their dts audio and use it for their own release???????? hmmm..........

---

__________________
All the excitement of a trip to hell with none of the negitive side affects!

quote:

---

Originally posted by lickmyzack
Ummm... am I the only one that noticed this????

BOTH RELEASES ARE FROM THE SAME SOURCE!!

If you compare the fra and pot releases.. they are the same video source.... just that pot used something like tmpenc to either zoom in or stretch the top and bottom ... if you look at both.. in the scene where he tackles the robot about 7:55 into the movie you will notice someones head.. with curly hair on the right (your right) side of the screen.... it's there in both releases.. and I am 100% positive they are from the same silver source.. just pot got hold of the dts discs.. to resync the audio....... the picture on fra is 10 times better than pot... probably because they trashed the video quality by stretching it out.. either trying to cut out some of the heads.. or trying to make people think they had their own video source as well............

But aren't they the ones bitching in their nfo that some "elite" group was gonna strip their dts audio and use it for their own release???????? hmmm..........

After watching both releases.. i'm revising my rating........

POT=
6 video
9 Audio (sync issues stopped it from a 10)
10 movie.... it kicked ass..... one of my fav's for the year.

FRA =
8 video (much better than pot)
7 audio (released as a cam.. but the audio is direct so it
should be a telesync.. but to shut up the whiners
they only claimed it as a cam, yes it's direct.. you can hear the cammer fool with the audio jack a few times.. background hiss because it's not a great connection... but a few years ago this would have been top notch and received much higher ratings)
10 movie

---

just checked this out definately not the blockbuster I'd thought it'd be but its good nonetheless.


Video-6.5
Theres a few dark scenes where you cannot see exactly what your seeing but you make it out.
Audio-7 volume's a little low, dont hear any hiss or anything so good
Movie-8.5 - few twists but still pretty solid sci-fi storyline.

my first review...of many hopefully.

Watched this one last night. Very watchable on my TV. Picture was a little grainy but I think this is a great release so early on. Video was grainy but very watchable....sound was excellent once you turned it up a bit. Good summer action movie also. 6/8/8 ...nice job POT keep up the good work. Thank you.

I just watched this via the XBox, streamed to TV and must say it was highly watchable. I did not miss a line due to the audio being really great, and while the picture was a little blurry (only slightly) and the part used for the sample shows the most camera movement of the whole movie (weird choice for the sample with that fact), I did not miss one detail, even in all of the action scenes (and the tunnel sequence with a bad copy could easily be enough of a scene to judge the release on).

Considering the roadshow for myself in Japan doesn't happen until Sept. 18 (http://www.foxjapan.com/movies/irobot/), this was a great way to spend a Sunday night.

Thanks POT for a great, highly watchable release that I can eventually ask a nice, cute Japanese person to in two months

For TS: 7.5/9/9 (I really enjoyed the movie... maybe because I love the genre of 'dammit I'm right and everyone else is a fucking idiot', and Will Smith did pull it off nicely)

Also, as a movie, the CG was perfectly melded. The robots could have been stand-ins, you wouldn't know. Nothing overdone (except maybe near the end final battle with the climbing... no spoilers there)... and I never read the book so I can't do that kind of argument.

quote:

---

Originally posted by AddNtoX
so pls stfu and stop trying to talk like u know what ur talking about

---

Bitchin....

Great pic, decent audio, tho i found myself with the remote in hand, cranking it for conversations and turning it down for action.. Other than that... bitchin.


8/6/7

__________________
-zak
Is that skeet on ur pants?