VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Fantastic Four *SVCD* - TELECINE - SVCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=64921)

audio is clearly out of sync in at least 3 parts of film for around 30-60 secs apiece ...picture quality is fine..movie has stretched AR but very watchable..not a bad movie but could have been better with better actors and actresses..
7/6/6

I personally give this:

v: 9 (very, very nice picture, a little dark in parts... but DAMN it's nice)
a: 6 (tinny as hell and completely mono. Very easy to hear the voices and whats going on though)
m: 8 (I don't see what all the fuss is about? This was a good movie if you watch it for what it is)

Pretty Nice Release except for the sound. I didn't have overburn issues on CD1 because I put it on 1 DVD :P The movie was ok for what it was (marvel comics), the climax just didn't quite do it for me (if you know what I mean).

7.5/5.5/6.5

v/10
a/7
m/7

i waited for the telecine and it was better than expected

8/6/7

Decent movie, Jessica Alba was hot in her uniform and that's worth an extra point. Video was pretty good but the audio was lacking. I got used to it after a bit but it sounded like it could've come through a nice telephone.

Video: 9
Audio: 7
Film: 7

Overall good quality, the synch error is minor, only for 1 minute, bad thing is CD1 you have to overburn, and my dvd writer does not support overburn, so I had to cut out parts of the film, i.e. the begining 1st minute.

video: 8.5 (very nice, bit dark in places)
audio: 7 (not very good for a TC)
movie: 6 (pretty shit)

xTFCx

audio sync issues on this one are quite annoying. at least 5 pts in the movie the audio goes out of sync for 30-60 seconds.

8.0/6.0/7.0

Not bad Video for TC.... The audio is a little weak
Fight with Doom was a let down ...
Movie was not what i was expecting...

Out of sync issues on cd2 a couple times..

7/6/6

__________________
Carpe Diem !

Thank you for the release.
After watching full movie on standalone.

V - 9 nice and sharp
A - 6 to much treble not enough bass, only noticed a sync issue at the planetarium.
M - 8 very entertaining, should have done more on the fight with Doom.

finally got around to watching this the other night on the TV..

for whatever reason I couldn't overburn disc 1... so i ended up
using tmpgenc mpeg tools to trim off the first minute of the
movie.

otherwise -- the video is superb. great colors and sharp. Audio
is great - less the few sections it goes out of sync, but that
only lasts like a total of 30 seconds.

movie was ok.. they should have picked a bigger actor to play
the thing. looked like he was 5'7...

v: 8.5
a: 7
m: 6.5

Okay, saw this in theaters first... Video was a little choppy at times and had a few instances of pixelation. Audio was out of sync a couple of time, most priminately in cd3 for about 30 seconds. Movie itself isn't that bad considerin it's an origin movie. CAN'T WAIT till part two (GALACTUS w/SILVER SURFER).

Video: 8
Audio: 7
Movie: 7

__________________
"he took my stapler and he never brought it back "

Milton Waddams (Office Space)

Video was decent for a telecine release. Color vibrance was a touch off but we can't expect miracles here.

Audio was clear. I heard a popping sound in the beginning of the film. The scene taking place in the planetarium goes out of sync. This occurs for a total duration of approximately 40 seconds. At the end of the film audio cut from a stereo level to a mono when the credits began and there was reading of the credits in russian (i believe). These changes in audio lead me to believe that audio for this release was patched together using multiple sources.

The movie was a good blockbuster flick. The storyline was nothing extraordinary. Makes me beleive that Marvel is trying to capitalize on the comic book franchise/movie craze. Hopefully they'll put more thought into a better script next time around. Overall though, the film is a great escape but nothing that will amaze.

Video- 8
Audio-6.5
Film- 7

In hopes of finding an excellent reproduction of what I saw in the theater, I downloaded this version. I wasn't really happy with the results. Video is jerky in some parts. Audio is out of sync in several scenes. A good try, but nothing has outdone the XviD version that ADYWAN put out. I downloaded it after this one (making my total FF downloads to 6). If your looking for quality, go with that..... not this one.

Movie 6.5/4.5/8.0

LT

v-8.5 a-6 m- 6

__________________
"but i choose to die, on a steady diet of booze and lies"