VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Gangs Of New York - SCREENER - TcS (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=13090)

If the rest of the movie is the same as the sample I give it an 8/8 great job

__________________
Hay

quote:

---

Originally posted by likwid8


Ya, thats why it was pointless to make it 3 CD's when extracting the first CD led out to 394 MEGS!!!!

It boggles my mind why they couldnt fill up the rest of the space.... let alone 3 cds? errrrrr

---

looks damn good...keep up the good work http://us.f1.yahoofs.com/users/ec18d59d/bc/Yahoo!+Photo+Album/roach1.jpg?pfCvOG.AAQvSickP

quote:

---

Originally posted by DJD4566
just letting you guys know the two towers has been nominated for shit for the academy aways crap so theres a dvd screener made

---

just burned this nice rls! i plan on watching it tomorrow. although i think the svcd sample was far superior, i'm very gracious for the great rls from TcS! thanks guys! the svcd sample had MUCH less macro/micro blocks, it looked very clean.

the vcd rip has a shitload of micro blocks all over the movie, and HEAVY macro blocks in dark scenes. in the future it'd be nice to have svcd, but it's free so thanks for taking the time/energy/risk in puttin this flic out!!

__________________
retired from the scene, but still leechin!

Nice rip for a vhs screener to vcd, thanks tcs.

For the cry babies out there this movie could have been done on 2 cd's but then it would have been out of standard and then lots of others would have cried "you didn't do it right". It's one of those damd if you do and damd if you don't things. Also I can tell you it takes more effort to do such a long movie that way when your gonna have to split it dead in the middle to make it work.

Keep up the good work

Video could have been better, audio is typical for a screener, good movie but not great.

I was gonna reencode the audio as 192k (for myself) so I could just put it on 2 cd's, and when I was looking at the length of the movie I noticed the only reason this doesn't fit on 2 cd's is the 3 minutes of credits. So cut the credits off, and you can get it down to 2 cd's and keep it vcd-compliant.

I saw a few jerky moments on my standalone, but nice quality overall. Audio (treble mainly) seemed distorted at certain points.

Good release overall.

8/7/9

personally i thought this movie did not live up to its potential .. or how should i say could have been a lot fuckin better

it could be just me i was really eager to watch this looking forward to it since late 2001

at least it did not 'blow goats' but not so great

this is an awesome scr esp considerin theatre release date was waht 2 weeks prior?

im a lil puzzled why it was not done svcd as well

8/8/7.5 is my rating based off vcd scr

Great release but I had some wierd problems with this release which were also apparent in their Adaptation rip, some parts seemed jerky not really a ghosting effect like those in VideoCD TC's but like bad ivtc style jerks but I don't know if that's possible on vcd's. Otherwise, nice quality.