VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Star Wars Episode 2 *PROPER* - TELESYNC - SEVcD (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=2843)

Do you really think Lucas will release a DVD screener ??
I highly doubt it.

Your just gunna have to settle for the CAM bootlegs for now till the Official DVD is released.

what i think about the rls'

video I audio
_____________________________
#1 SeVCD I #1 SeVCD
#2 VCD World I #2 FTF
#3 HafVCD I #3 tie between
#4 FTF I #4 hafvcd and vcdworld
_____________________________

thats my story and i'm sticking to it!


i currently use the SeVCD version for dubbing to tape or just to watch on my own

needed some work - but not that bad at all

Pic quality is pretty good for a TS.

Audio was good, but right channel was out and there was no intro.

Ended up demuxing & fixing audio by copying left channel to the right (and applied the same audio fix to CD 2).

Took the intro from FTF's rls & replaced their broken intro audio w/ the intro music from episode 4 (it's the same track).

Spliced the re-worked intro onto the the beginning of CD 1.

Demuxed it again & smoothed audio transition between the intro & the feature in CoolEdit.

Now I'd give it an 8+ rather than the six I gave it to start with.

BTW, mpg encoding was wacked too - both discs were about 800MB each out of the bin, but when remuxed after repair they came in at around 700 each, which i would have expected in the first place based upon the playing time (~132 minutes)

Considering the amount of work involved, I gotta ask, where do these boys get off calling this "Proper"?

If they had just spent another three or four more hours on their compilation & encode, this release coulda gotten an 8.5 rating here, not the 6.7 it's holding at now...

BR

}:-o ==()

hey Bong Ripper..maybe you should release YOUR version..hehe..sounds better than the ones I got

I agree, you should release your version, I have a version made up out of the different releases, the main film is the SeVCD version but it has the start and is in stereo, well mono through both speakers.
I am trying to add the start and end music from my episode 2 soundtrack to the film but getting it to sync isnt easy.

When episode 1 was released, I had a vcd which was taken from a screener tape, the only thing wrong with it was that it had subtitles along the bottom, apart from that it was great, the sound was clear and the picture was clear, not very sharp but nice.
I say give it 3-6 weeks and there will be a copy out just as good.

anyway ,this rls is good

SEVcD is not PROPER

This SEVcD version says PROPER but PROPERs release has 3 cds.

SEVcD

Err whoops I was looking at a different release.

BongRipper Release

You should release your version. I am sure everyone would greatly appreciate your efforts.

Star Wars

Movie was along time waiting. The Quality was so-so but the audio was shit
Centropy where are you?

Rumours say SEVcD is the Centropy version ... it was their first release and released thru same channels as Centrophys.

Remember the last sentence from New Guy nfo?

I personally don't give a crap weather it is or not..

A72

bongripper

hey bongripper...how did you copy the audio to the 2nd channel? did you use cooledit for that also?

quote:

---

Originally posted by Mathesar
This release skips horribly in my dvd player (Samsung M301) ,not sure why everything else runs fine that ive tried (have tons of svcd/vcd),I even tried burning it twice and used differant media ,both burns work fine in my PC tho (?) I havent seen the other releases but the video quality is pretty crappy overall and the audio is a bit distorted.

---

quote:

---

outkast2g
hey bongripper...how did you copy the audio to the 2nd channel? did you use cooledit for that also?

---

hey bongripper!

how do you put the audio track form episode 4 over the one in the mpeg?