VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Thunderbirds - CAM - FTF (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=44808)

[QUOTE]Originally posted by punzada
twice, for like, 3 seconds, get over yourself with every other lil cunt bitching about it, quality otherwise is fine for a TS, good job to centropy.

have to agree with you their , 3 seconds of a movie nothing to complain about!. some people just need somthing to bitch about!!!

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!

At what point to the people stand up, ive not been able to find it, and i dont wanna spoil any of the movie.

A time would be nice.

Cheers

quote:

---

Originally posted by Redemption1980
At what point to the people stand up, ive not been able to find it, and i dont wanna spoil any of the movie.

A time would be nice.

Cheers

---

I Robot comments since this thread is messed up big time.

Picture has the usual Centropy problem where the glare from anything white renders any bright scenes almost unwatchable. I actually found the POT CAM more watchable with about the same number of people moving in front of the Camcorder, though the slight blur and cam shake with POT is a pain.
The picture quality and sound quality here is higher, by a good bit, but I'd rather see the details hidden in the bright glare.

7/8/8

The best available just now but it can be improved a LOT.

*edit* for info
There is a guy who sits down at the beginning and a woman? who moves around twice and a head that appears a couple of times.
This doesnt bother me in the slightest but the point of this forum i thought is to give feedback on the quality of the releases, to let people know what to expect. The groups have made it clear they dont care whatever we think.
It all good as far as I'm concerned.

I, Robot IMHO is the best release yet. nothing like the recent VideoCD releases.

but ignoring videocd's releases (Spiderman2 and whatever else) I give this a 9. 7 if you count videoCD's releases. still a shitload better then any other group's release

still worthy download. I doubt i'll bother with anything else until a dvd copy is released.

dunno about thunderbirds..

i have a question though (at least im asking?). but why do people comment that video for a cam is good? i thought TS and Cams video was the same.. TS patched into the theatre's audio directly and a cam just used the camera's microphone. TC does the same as a TS except it does it for video also..

can someone tell me if im wrong and why i'm wrong?

I, Robot-CTP

Agreed with comments on the white-balance of the video, audio good though seems to be v. quiet in quiet segments and overloud in action sequences. Movie: enjoyable, but some of Smith's lines are weak... 7/7/6

__________________
Google owns...

Thunderthighs !!!!!!!

This film should be called thunderthighs - because like a girl with them , it should be avoided by all costs !!!!

The release itself is aload of c*$p - how it manages to get above a 4 in the video rating is above me - i think people must be judging off jpegs or the sample which is surprisingly the best quality in the whole film .

No disrespect to ftf because it is a pre release copy and i admire their work but i'm sure they can do better than this !!!!

Just watched the full movie, for those who need to know.......

Someone walks in front of the camera and sits down close to the start.

Someone else gets up in the middle some where, twice.

Nothing major, Quality is well watchable but the first post rating it as a 10 is way off the mark!!

Bright in places, similar to the same thing in Troy. But doesn't waste the movie.

Some strange horizontal lines appear and go, they can be seen on the right at the start of the film and then on the left during the film in some places (hairline, nothing to worry about)

Full film, right to the credits. Worth getting a hold of, no need for a proper.

Video:7.5
Audio:8
Movie: 9 (I thought it was a great flick)

...This is for I Robot, not Thunderbirds which seems to be in the same thread!

__________________
"The lesson here is you can't expect users to learn. There's too much fun going on out there on the Internet."

i robot

people need to start giving better info quality is good apart from the 5 or 6 bed wetters who walk past the screen in the first 45 minites

Re: i robot

quote:

---

Originally posted by tyson24
people need to start giving better info quality is good apart from the 5 or 6 bed wetters who walk past the screen in the first 45 minites

---

__________________
"The lesson here is you can't expect users to learn. There's too much fun going on out there on the Internet."

The white balance everyone is bashing is NOTHING compared to that of TROY, which made that film totally unwatchable! So don't compare this to TROY, you meathead!!

You want an honest and accurate opinion. Here ya go.
Picture was very good with a slight line(hairlinethin) that seemed to roll up the picture a few time. It didn't really affect the movie. There were three "heads" that i saw in the picture that didn't really affect it either(one may have stood out a little though). The picture was bright, but it was not at the "Troy" level(couldn't enjoy that movie). Also this movie didn't have the usual centropy overcrop.

The sound was very clean, but a little too dynamic in that the dialog would be at a very low volume then the action would seem to be ten times louder(was a little irritating). All in all a good release. This is the one to get.

<< I Robot >>

I watched the full movie last night...

I rate the release:

7.5 / 9.0 / 9.0

As discussed, the white balance was the biggest problem for me... the interior scenes are fine, but when the action moves outside, things get a little washed out. The movie does suffer from a blur within fast paced scenes... which seems the norm for a cam release... use a fast shutter speed on camcorder..??

Sound was fine, it was clear on a standard Dolby surround setup.

As for the movie, I really enjoyed it. I'm not a fan of Will Smith though... his dialogue in the movie is poor. The star of the show is predictably the robot
I thought the 30 year look into the future was very well done... no flying cars or spaceships.. check out the Audi car.

Overall the best release so far... yes there are 3 times the screen is obstructed by some gimp "dropping the kids off @ the pool", yes the cap has an intermittent green hairline on vertically scrolling parts... who cares.. I enjoyed the movie, and I will pay good money to see it properly in the cinema, based on this "preview".

Thanks for your efforts Centropy.

Ok. I've had enough of this. Lets set some rules.

1 NO REQUESTING (This is obvious. Ask and get banned)

2 NO SLAGGING OFF OTHER USERS. I am fucking sick to death of people slagging each other off. Stick to rating the quality and note any problems you feel with the release. SLAG OFF OTHER USERS AND I WILL BAN YOU!

3 I do not want to hear any shit about "Ooooh. Where's Centropy/Video CD" or "I'll wait for Centropy/VIDEO CD"

4 If you cant abide by the above rules. GET THE FUCK OUT. Nobody wants you here!

__________________

quote:

---

Ok. I've had enough of this. Lets set some rules.

---

Thunderbirds - CAM - FTF

Video is very pixelated at times throughout the movie,so bad sometimes could not make out what was on screen,at other times pic is watchable but not the best cam I have seen

Audio sound like someone is speaking into a tin bucket

Video 4
Audio 4
Movie ?

bad movie

i will have to say that the movie SLEEPOVER was easily a more entertaining movie, i never saw this as i heard that it has been done before, a tv series or sumthing, but this is the worst movie ive ween in months upon months, the quality umm ehhh no, but it is pre, and it was watchable the audio isnt that incredibly bad, the new catowoman is worse, no audience noise, slightly muffled/hollow, shoulda been svcd, but oh well... 4/7/3

regarding I, Robot

Haven't watched the whole thing yet, but so far it looks damn good to me. Will Smith in the shower....mmm...mmm....mmm!

I haven't read all the posts since it's so mixed up with Thunderbirds, but I saw some complaining about I, Robot. What is there to complain about? I can never figure out why some of you people whine and pout, use fowl language (no doubt due to a limited vocabulary and limited intelligence), rant and rage over FREEBIES!!!! Catch a clue, people. As they say, "You get what you pay for." If you're paying nothing and you get crap, so what? At worst, maybe you have a couple of coasters. But this release is great, especially compared to nothing, which is what you would get at the theater if you didn't pay them. Have a little appreciation for these groups. If you think it can be done better, then you go out and do it yourself. I doubt there will be very many takers on that challenge.

__________________

quote:

---

Originally posted by Redemption1980
At what point to the people stand up, ive not been able to find it, and i dont wanna spoil any of the movie.

A time would be nice.

Cheers

---

__________________
One Day The Dead Shall Walk The Earth.

thunderbirds

All I Can Say Is Wait 6/10 very poor