VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Cinderella Man *SVCD* - TELESYNC - Centropy (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=63668)

too dark of course,horizonal lines through the movie,looks like sh^t-great movie but wait for something better

the darkness problem is far less extreme as most posters are claiming, still a very watchable copy... after viewing entire movie:

6/7/8 (very good movie)

I couldn't take the darkness after the first disc. I don't know what kind of TV people have who are rating the video 7 or higher, but I wish I had one.

4/8/8 (Based on 1st Disc)

quote:

---

Originally posted by /^/-Flikz-\^\
the darkness problem is far less extreme as most posters are claiming, still a very watchable copy... after viewing entire movie:

6/7/8 (very good movie)

---

v/6 a/7 m/5

everyone seems to be a "loyal centropy follower" are people afraid of saying anything but nice rls?

way too dark

__________________
"but i choose to die, on a steady diet of booze and lies"

quote:

---

Originally posted by tallguy425
WTF is up with this guy...every thread is the samething!

he should be banned

---

It's not CTP's best, and it might be that i have a slightly better tv-set than others, but i really cant say that its as bad as some people portray.

For me the movie (so yes.. the video too) was very decent, and easy too follow.. very few scenes were THAT dark that u could barely see what was happening, and they were always indoor and meant to be dark coz that's just how it was back then without electricity.

It's a good movie too.. bit much leaning towards an oscar tho.. could be me but the director is trying too hard for that imo.

As far as ratings go :

V - 6.5 (could have been better.. most groups would have made it worse i'm sure, since there's no proper or any other copy out that is this watchable)
A - 8 (since DTS is dead i'm rating it as far as direct audio could go - this is no let down for sure)
M - 7.5 (good movie, but as i said before.. they're trying to hard for the oscar but that could just as well be me )

Video 4 Way to dark

Audio 6

Movie 9

ok... I've deleted every stupid/pointless post from this thread, next I start deleting accounts.

For anybody who cares, here is my take on this release:

The bright scenes are very crisp, clear and the colour is good.

The dark scenes are like they're from a different rip. Reddish, WAAAAAAAY dark and basically the scenes are reduced to "floating" red heads on a black background. We attempted to correct it using various filters on WinDVD (outputting to a 42" 1080i Plasma) and we couldn't affect the dark scenes enough to make them watchable. We also attempted to correct it by burning to a CD then playing back in the DVD player (and correcting on the TV itself) - still no joy.

Basically, you *can* improve the dark scenes a bit but they're still too dark to watch comfortably and as such, we turned the movie off after about 20 minutes.

On a side note, after skimming though the movie, there's a helluva lot of dark scenes

V - 6 (shame, cos the bright scenes are pretty damn nice)
A - 6 (slightly quiet and muffled but reasonable enough)
M - Dunno, but the 'tards on iMDB think it's better than sex

__________________
Statistically... 9 out of 10 people actually enjoy gang rape.

Sorry CTP, NOT up to your usual standard. Yes it is watchable. But the pic is Darker than Batman Begins FFS. Thanks but i will wait for a TC or better.


6.5/8/?

House of Cinderella????

Haven't got around to watching it on set top yet, but from sample and cue-mount, here's my verdict:

Video: 6.2 (Really dark guys, reminds me of House of Wax, not too bad in the fight scenes but even then it's a little washy)
Audio: 8 (Crisp enough for my liking)
Movie: N/A (Haven't watched full movie, will edit after watching)

Definitely not up to par for Centropy's usual TS quality, looks watchable if I set my settings on my DVD Player and TV just right, will hope for the best...

__________________

Great release! Couldnt complain.. its the best thats out!

i guess it all depends on the person

I couldnt stand it, watched 20, maybe 25 minutes into the film and enough was enough

too damn dark!

maybe 4?/6/?

bah, im spoiled now, i didnt used to be

__________________
ehhhhh

cheers centropy for trying.,, not following trends but my opinion dark but watchable if you want to see this and dont want to spend your $$ or wait for it to be released in uk its passable.

Based on Full Release

V:6 - Very dark during some scenes
S:9
M:9 - His best flick since Mystery Alaska

__________________

I seen it at the theaters

the movie IS dark

so, untill a screener or rip this is pretty darn good

v-6.5 (consedering how dark the movie really is)
a-7
m-8

although it looks like a good movie, im not too desperate to watch it so i will wait for a retail rip.

usual centropy quality, just too dark

soz guys its a bit hard to watch

6.5/8/waiting till retail

I enjoyed this film a lot and to be totaly honest this isn't the worst
release i've sat all the way through, but if your not in that much of
a hurry to see the film. i'd wait til a screener or a dvd rip appears.
In all not a half bad movie.

V : 6.5
A : 6.5
M : 7.5

__________________