VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Kill Bill: Volume 2 *SVCD* *NUKED* - TELESYNC - TCR (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=39813)

quote:

---

Originally posted by djj
What on earth are talking about? There are no french subs in this release?! Or are you talking about VideoCD proper?

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by dalton4life
(I think) there is a glitch at 41.44 of CD2 that causes it to lock up for about 8 minutes if you try to re enocde with with TMPGenc which often do.

---

__________________
All the excitement of a trip to hell with none of the negitive side affects!

I thought this release was bloody damn good. Granted the B&W scenes are sometimes

blue and the colours go iffy now and then. Its still a nice release and I a fricken

good movie aswell

7/7/8

nuked why? this is a verry good relese.. black and white a little bright but the rest is great

8 video
8 audio
7 movie

Release is alright ,blue at begining for abit but fixes after that ,colour don't go bad that much ,think it went bad only a few times in the whole film and not for long.

Screen split is not that bad don't last for to long.

Also about the video cd release ,how can that be a proper for this ,haveing french or german subs in a large chunk of the film when the film is english audio is worse than having the screen split for a while.

i had the same lockup problem with TMPGenc
i reencoded it with mainconcepts mpeg encoder - without any problems - and pretty fast (2pass - mpeg2 - 480x576 - around 4 hours and the movie fits on 2 cd´s)

TCR Copy = *Nuked*: See list of reasons why in previous posts - lots of errors.
VideoCD's PROPER = *Nuked* Out of Sync and 20 minutes of Subtitles are French.

Wait for REAL.PROPER or Screener my suggestion.

Or go with the CAM that hasnt been nuked yet

__________________
All the excitement of a trip to hell with none of the negitive side affects!

pshhhhhh the TCR was just fine lol even if it was nuked it looked just peachie :P

Just watched whole movie..Top Quality TS...

Video 8
Audio 8
Movie 8

looks good perfect timing for the uncut vol1 to come out
7.5/8/?

and HERO is one of the worst movies ive ever seen almost worse then crouching tiger, almost

no errors on my copy all looked good only thing was the 3 cds.. even put this on dvd for a friend encoded just fine and yes ive watched the whole movie it didnt have any errors

sucks that the videocd version has french subs. otherwise it looked amazing in quality. and the sound was damn near perfect.

but the tcr version should be nuked. I'm ashamed to even send my parents their copy. I told them just go to the movies and keep it deep in thought, because this is not a keeper...too many flaws.
The guy walking through the picture and too much color. But when I got to disc 2 and the screen flipped I said f..k it. Couldn't enjoy it.

5/7/10 TCR version

8/9/10 Videocd version... Video gets an eight because of the french subs. would have been a 9, because it looks that good.

__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...

Very Nice Release Def The One To Get... Unless you speak french & if so you proably already surrendered

Little bluish during the beginning B&W scene and seems to have a brightness & color saturation. CD2 has a short time with the bottom of the scene wrap'd to the top. Direct Audio is very nice. Props to TCR

7/9/7.5

Thats the only problem with the VideoCD releases. The Video and sound on them are perfect, some of the best TS work I have seen, but if a movie has subtitles in it, then you are fcuked if you don't understand french.

Just got this TCR release, the saturation I can fix, just turn it down with avisynth before encoding to DVDmpeg2, the blue and white instead of black and white I am not really bothered about, as long as the picture is watchable then thats all that matters.

quote:

---

Originally posted by keebler
no errors on my copy all looked good only thing was the 3 cds.. even put this on dvd for a friend encoded just fine and yes ive watched the whole movie it didnt have any errors

---

Just finished whole rls.

Nuked or not...

Quality not bad, just the glitches become annoying, which really is just color issues and the 3min screen split... what can you do about the giant walking accross the screen for two seconds at the beginning?

Regardless, I'd rather have this version where I can read the subs, really needed during "The Bride's" training. Quality is good enough to hold me until a screener comes out. No real motion blur during the action, no sound issues. Nuked = BS. I seen FTF get away with non-nuked crap 10x worse than this.

Not to say that this is up to par with what TCR was releasing when they debuted . . . however, take away the screen split on CD2 and fix the color, and it pretty much looks like the old TCR.

6 (because of short screen split and colors)
8 (No issues with it)
9 (Just wanted a longer fight with Bill, rating is based on vol1 & 2 together, neither is better than the other, it's a continuation of the same damn story.)

A lot of things wrong with this release which have already been mentioned and debated. I would like to know why the VideoCD proper release isn't on this site yet.

7/7/?


this is from the SAMPLE, im downloading now. from the sample it looks very good in quality. i always take other revies with a grain of salt. there is no inbetween on this board, you either got release purist where basically nothing is good enough for them or you have the exact opposite, people flaming the boards with outragous ratings. sometimes without even watching the movie! in any event. we should all be greatful for the hard work people put into this for our enjoyment. dont take ANY release for granted...

quote:

---

Originally posted by CTP Fan
I would like to know why the VideoCD proper release isn't on this site yet.

---

__________________
All the excitement of a trip to hell with none of the negitive side affects!

quote:

---

Originally posted by I am X
First, Iwill report all glitches that I observed:

1. First few minutes of movie, some guy walks across the screen....

---

__________________
"with great power comes great responsibility."