VCDQuality Forums
Show all 103 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Team America World Police *SVCD* - TELESYNC - Centropy (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=47976)


Posted by Mystic Slippers on 10-24-2004 07:42 PM:

Team America World Police *SVCD* - TELESYNC - Centropy

Technically this should be nuked for 'dupe'.

But CTP doesn't care coz no other theatre groups exist.

Nice rls though.

::edit:: we'll nuke it on this website though. after all, you should be informed.


Posted by vip3r on 10-24-2004 07:42 PM:

Dupe of FRA ... Team.America.World.Police.SVCD.TELESYNC-FRA

I seriously hope this one gets nuked, but it probably wont because everyone is so obsessed with this group.

Quality is good .. i must admit it, looks a little bright (but that just may be because the SAMPLE takes place in the desert .. ). Sound is good quality as per usual..movie was just lame, they tried too hard to make it funny imo, very disappointing..

8.5/9/4


Posted by Saner on 10-24-2004 07:46 PM:

7/8/?


Posted by Air1 on 10-24-2004 07:46 PM:

by sample:

video: 8.5+
audio: 9
movie: 10


video good but a little dark. other than that not many complaints. the darkness causes faded colors but it's a good, good TS.

audio is great.

movie rocks. saw it opening night. never had such a fun time in the theater since South Park The Movie.


Posted by teo4all on 10-24-2004 07:47 PM:

Seems like CTP is back to theyr usual..."not careing about other grp's work"routine...

now for the release quality..
Video is nice,WS but a bit bright...not as blurry as fra, audio tops
movie dunno

7/9/? - but still dupe...

__________________
I am what i am and much more


Posted by Pebosjan on 10-24-2004 07:48 PM:

Damn, then I wont be seeing this one around. Looks great from sample. But no grade from me from stuff like that.


Posted by snutte on 10-24-2004 07:54 PM:

Nice work. Is it really a dupe? Cause Team.America.World.Police.SVCD.TELESYNC-FRA got nuked on some sites. For what i dont really remeber. Think it was out.of.sync?

7/9/10


Posted by Movieman420 on 10-24-2004 07:58 PM:

Dupe or not, it's a better TS period...

Not a big fan of 'dupe' nuking, keeps better releases from being out out...but I don't make the rules.
VERY glad to see this release!

8/8/7

__________________


Posted by Mongoloid on 10-24-2004 07:58 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by vip3r
Dupe of FRA ... Team.America.World.Police.SVCD.TELESYNC-FRA

I seriously hope this one gets nuked, but it probably wont because everyone is so obsessed with this group.



It's not obsession.. it's recognition and respect for the best movie-release group of the past years (!!). Respect should be given where respect is due.

BTW.. the -FRA release is nuked on almost all sites that do care about quality.. therefor it wont be considered a dupe on most sites, as much as it will be considered a proper.

That CTP doesnt tag as proper, is their own choice ofcoz.

And teo4all :
Why should CTP care or respect crap quality ? I wouldnt. By not taking a piss on FRA in their nfo they kinda showed more respect that deserved for that crappy release (qualitywise!!)

my 2 cts

8.5/9.5/8


Posted by Debo on 10-24-2004 08:05 PM:

good pic
great sound
ima grab this
8/9

__________________


Posted by JonBlaze87 on 10-24-2004 08:14 PM:

What do u guys mean by "dupe"? Does that mean they used the same source as fra but re-encoded it?
anyway been waiting for good release for this movie. thx centropy


Posted by Miller on 10-24-2004 08:15 PM:

its a shame they diden't release this earlyer. Video is Nice looks alot brighter, sound is great,much better release then FRA's but its still a dupe.

8/8/?

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!


Posted by Miller on 10-24-2004 08:16 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by JonBlaze87
What do u guys mean by "dupe"? Does that mean they used the same source as fra but re-encoded it?

\

dupe - not needed, it means their was already a release in this format and it was not nuked

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!


Posted by snozzler29 on 10-24-2004 08:18 PM:

as long as its better quality to watch who gives a shit if its a dupe or not

7/8/?


Posted by Redemption1980 on 10-24-2004 08:21 PM:

I personally dont care if its a dupe or not.

Its better than the FRA release, not enough to re-download it though, i still have that one, not watched it yet though, but i'll think i'll stick with it.

8/9/? dont know if i want to watch it, i hated South Park, so im not sure id like this


Posted by crapper on 10-24-2004 08:24 PM:

ctp did an other really nice one

picture bright but ok 8

sound nice 9

movie i donno

i guesse it'll be duped , nuked or whatever.. then again.. its a damm nice release and as far as i care.. CTP great job.. and keep em comin those ts's


Posted by Schmiggy JK23 on 10-24-2004 08:24 PM:

7.5/8/ not sure yet.

A dupe it may be, so they should have labled it correctly. Its still is the best copy out so far.

cant wait to watch it

__________________
"much to learn you still have..."


Posted by Ch1c0 on 10-24-2004 08:26 PM:

Thumbs up

yeah.. for real..
who really cares about dupe... it's better quality

glad i never watched the FRA one...


Posted by Jassll on 10-24-2004 08:27 PM:

Video - 7/10 - top of the line, just a tad bright but its not as bad as the I Robot copy was
Audio - 8/10 - good and clear
Movie - ?

Who cares that its nuked for being duped. This release was needed FRA's release was crap, this should be labled as Proper Thanks Centropy


Posted by yyiryyib on 10-24-2004 08:30 PM:

just watched the sample and downloading in a min, looks much better than FRA's the scene dupe floating around needs to go

8/8/10


Posted by Miller on 10-24-2004 08:30 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Jassll
Video - 7/10 - top of the line, just a tad bright but its not as bad as the I Robot copy was
Audio - 8/10 - good and clear
Movie - ?

Who cares that its nuked for being duped. This release was needed FRA's release was crap, this should be labled as Proper Thanks Centropy



u can only proper if their is a issue with the release, not for video quality!

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!


Posted by proto on 10-24-2004 08:36 PM:

yeh its a dupe...i dont care its the best release so far..

from sample: colours look a bit faded, audio is fine.

8/8/-

__________________
proto


Posted by a1catraz on 10-24-2004 08:46 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Miller
u can only proper if their is a issue with the release, not for video quality!


their cocky, but they've got a reason to be cocky.


Posted by stormswe on 10-24-2004 08:52 PM:

yeah yeah..

..another nozone silver from ctp.

nice one tho

7/8/7


Posted by Korps on 10-24-2004 08:56 PM:

YAY...

Beeen Waiting For A Decent TS...

Thank.You.Centropy.

__________________
- Korps^


Posted by uRMoM.=P on 10-24-2004 08:58 PM:

Talking NICE

Good to see a quality release of TS. I know people always hate on this guys, and dont like the fact they never proper... but its not their fault they are on a class of their own. I think we have all lower our standards with maven svcd.ts and hopefully its about time someone raises that bar again, and who better than the grp that started the svcd.ts
good job guys keep it up!

__________________
Bangin your mom since '98


Posted by Mongoloid on 10-24-2004 08:59 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Miller
u can only proper if their is a issue with the release, not for video quality!


Most ppl call shitty video an issue with movies. And with most i mean all people, except the blind

Not that i nor all the ppl chosing quality over outdated scenerules really care that it's nuked I guess.. One can still leech a nuked release


Posted by Sco0t on 10-24-2004 09:03 PM:

Good rls CTP, 7/8/8. All these people wondering if it was a dupe, on some sites the FRA rls was duped because it was a mislabled cam. But overall this is a better rls than FRA. Good work.


Posted by StanTek on 10-24-2004 09:12 PM:

Team America World Police *SVCD* - TELESYNC - Centropy

Who cares if this is a Dupe! It is better then what is out there now! Quit complaining and start releasing your own. Anyway the video is pretty good and the audio was fine.

Video= 7
Audio=8
Movie=6


Posted by Miller on 10-24-2004 09:18 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Mongoloid
Most ppl call shitty video an issue with movies. And with most i mean all people, except the blind

Not that i nor all the ppl chosing quality over outdated scenerules really care that it's nuked I guess.. One can still leech a nuked release



/me shakes his head


outdated scene rules wtf!

im not ganna argue with you, about the quality for the release, becuase i know ctp is much better, but still its a dupe and thats that

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!


Posted by vanzan on 10-24-2004 09:28 PM:

From the sample: Video 8 / Audio 8

Very nice indeed.


Posted by Dodgy Del on 10-24-2004 09:43 PM:

Thumbs up

FINALLY!!

Nice to see you back Centropy.

Been waiting ages for this one.

Grabbing it now

__________________
Lets praise all the groups out there who make this scene for what it's worth because if we didn't then we'd all be spending a fortune at the pics.Remember to practice SAFE SEX (as illistrated in the pic).


Posted by fizzyk on 10-24-2004 09:45 PM:

VCD/[NUKED]-Team.America.World.Police.SVCD.TS-Centropy/

REASON-Dupe.FRA


thats a reason on one of my sites

so i am not sure


Posted by mintie on 10-24-2004 09:47 PM:

7/8/8

Rate the Movie less ass kissing.


Posted by joey_75051 on 10-24-2004 09:51 PM:

POST WAS ERASED


Posted by SaabZ on 10-24-2004 10:00 PM:

Quality realease of this flick
Bit bright in parts but puts Fra'a copy in the shade

As for the dupe rule it sucks ass big stlyle when a release is nuked which is far better quality because some other group posted it first

8/8/7


Posted by StYlEz_P on 10-24-2004 10:02 PM:

Just a personal opinon here but damn peeps need to get off centropys dick , yeah they were ONCE a great ts group but where the fuck have they been recently ? they have been mostly dealing with dvdr and svcd dvdrips ... and this is a dupe and theres no need to shit on fra with the PROPER tag even tho its a better release imo .... anyways just got through cd1 and judging by taht 7/8/4 a bit bright but most def very watchable and the audio is pretty decent all the way through and as for the movie i guess its a matter of taste i personally didnt fancy it that much ..... ty and have a nice day


Posted by Haman on 10-25-2004 01:09 AM:

nice one, good ctp quality, not shit like FRA

7/8/8


Posted by BurntHostage on 10-25-2004 01:20 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by Miller
u can only proper if their is a issue with the release, not for video quality!


Isn't poor video quality an issue? Semantics...



btw,

your sig always cracks me up!
..................................
8/8/9 from sample


Posted by K-FurY on 10-25-2004 01:27 AM:

never picked up the FRA or NOX copies so i grabbed this. video is nice, kinda washed out, but much better than the FRA release. audio sounds crystal clear most likely dts, so no problems, didnt notice any sync problems either. going to watch the full movie later tonight, cool intro too btw.

8/9/x


Posted by Beelzebud on 10-25-2004 01:32 AM:

This is the best release out there, yet.

Nuke it for being a dupe, if you want to. Personally I'd stick with this, since it's the better copy.

7.5/8.5/8


Posted by Enzomatrx on 10-25-2004 01:40 AM:

FRA's was fully watchable with great sound once you turned the volume up.

This, yes, is better to watch and all but seriously shoulda have been at least an *Internal* release.

But since when does CTP follow any rules.

Now that the technical "rule following" jibber jabber is out of the way I must say I really don't care about nuking/duping/blah blah since basically I don't run any site, don't have to bother with any credit thing or whatnot so really it doesn't make me lose any sleep at night if 30 copies of a movie come out without tagging them as propers or internals.

still a little washed-outty but -- yes -- better than the FRA release.
8/9/10


Posted by joey_75051 on 10-25-2004 01:40 AM:

POST WAS ERASED


Posted by homesickalien on 10-25-2004 01:42 AM:

you guys whine so much about groups...

this release is different than the other and it's better. end of story.


Posted by Justin_Case on 10-25-2004 01:44 AM:

dupety dupe dupe fa shizzle

Any1 know what's up with the dirt pack on Nsane ??? Y was it there?

__________________
SUCK IT SLOW


Posted by misfits138 on 10-25-2004 02:03 AM:

Dupe or not I've been waiting for a good quality TS of this so I'm happy.


Posted by dwayne on 10-25-2004 02:51 AM:

a dupe? they should be rewarded for that not shuned

movie was funny at points

7/6/ROFL

__________________
"Imagination is more important than knowledge.
Knowledge is limited. Imagination encircles the world."
-Albert Einstein (1879-1955)


Posted by therookie on 10-25-2004 03:17 AM:

if they had just put a (Proper) in it all would be we'll.

if any one knows anything about the mv scene, some vidz will get a proper for 1 interlaced frame in a 4 min vid...

this is no nuke as the other releases were crappy


Posted by MR.FLIX-IT on 10-25-2004 04:39 AM:

Yes, A good release of a funny as hell movie
Joey This in no way is a FRA release or reencode.
video is much better as well as audio..
Video-7.5
Audio-7.5
Movie Overal-Funny AsS SHIt

Good to see Centropy again
keep 'em comin


Posted by The5Venomz on 10-25-2004 05:21 AM:

I don't understand how it can be nuked since the last release was poo...This is just what I've been waiting for. I'm about to watch it now, so far, it looks much better!!


Posted by misfits138 on 10-25-2004 06:14 AM:

Just got done watching it, video was a little dark but all and all it was an above average TS. The movie is the funniest shit I've seen since South Park Bigger, Longer, Uncut. "America Fuck Yeah. Comin' again to save
the motherfucking day, yeah."

8/9/10 10 10


Posted by PsychoPostalWor on 10-25-2004 06:32 AM:

always nuking for stupid reasons here anyways...why should this be any different??

Thanks CTP for a nice release of a crappy movie

7/8/3


Posted by bcool2k on 10-25-2004 06:53 AM:

a well deserved NUKED.dupe of FRA. Pic is a tad cleaner and brighter sound is the same. this movie had its moments, but not something i care to watch over and over again. Thanx CTP, but i already saw this flick.


7.5/8/7


Posted by valentine on 10-25-2004 06:56 AM:

FRA version should be nuked for not being a VCD. The quality wasn't there to support an SVCD. This version is justifiably SVCD, and therefore shouldn't be nuked.

7/8/7

__________________


Posted by frak on 10-25-2004 08:55 AM:

Watched this on the big screen tonight:

Movie was hilarious.

Quality was excellent - much better than the previous two
releases. Video quality was sharp and bright with good color.
audio was excellent. If it is a dupe - who cares, centropy
cleaned it up nicely - at least they know how to use video
tools.

Video: 8
Audio: 8.5
movie: 9


Posted by tr1pp1n on 10-25-2004 10:55 AM:

calm down kids

this argument has been going on since the spiderman ts a few years back, calm down they arent going to change their stance over night on this, and you arent going to be the savior who nukes em, most people in the scene like them and their releases and thats how it will be as long as they exist, so for shit sake stop it with this pointless argument...

as for the movie it was the funniest shit ive seen in a while....

7.5/8/9/5

__________________

The wise man does not play leap frog with unicorns...


Posted by bratt31999 on 10-25-2004 12:12 PM:

As stated previously the video is a little grainy and colors are a little washed out. The audio is great and movie is better than I anticipated. Defiantly a keeper, I would also like to add that this movie is defiantly not a kid’s movie. All in all another great release by a great group. Keep up the good work, you guys rock.


Posted by theinitialj on 10-25-2004 01:03 PM:

This is a great release definately the best one out. Just finished cd1. Video 8.5, Audio 8.5. If you havent seen this yet this is definately the version to get.


Posted by Movie_Insider on 10-25-2004 01:18 PM:

been awhile since I last posted , pic is pretty good, and sound is real nice I loved this movie! Then again I love south park!
7.5/8/8


Posted by AcclaimedCritic on 10-25-2004 01:20 PM:

Cool

the masters return once again
rules or not, when you're this good you dont really need to give a fuck do you! lets get off the reasons for it being nuked and just stick to the quality!
8/9/7
not their best release ever but better by a mile than the other 2 shit releases of this

__________________
Just telling it like I see it.You don't like it ? Why should I care!


Posted by angelfly on 10-25-2004 02:01 PM:

good quality release

8/7/10

as for the nuke..

it sucks since this is better quality but rules are rules


Posted by Truth on 10-25-2004 02:18 PM:

Better than FRA's rls but it's a dupe...rules have to be in place and adhered to otherwise you would get 50 rls of a movie by credit whores claiming their video was a smidge (technical word look it up) clearer than the last release....Sometimes like in this case the difference is clear BUT if ya open the floodgates then it would be abused....NUKED for DUPE

Video 8
Sound 9
Movie ? rarely see a movie all the way thru lol this ones no different...

p.s. Justin_Case your cables are a mess sort it ya lazy mofo...


Posted by CTP_Groupie on 10-25-2004 02:56 PM:

Centropy Is back

The masters have returned What a shitty movie though.

V:9.0
A:9.0
M:5.0


Posted by punzada on 10-25-2004 03:34 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by DethStar
You can't proper for quality.

Now shut the fuck up, you cock sucking tool.



He is correct (although quite vulgar) that you cannot proper on quality alone. However, if ctp would of stuck to scene standards they probably should of just of made it an "internal" which would of rose as the best TS availible anyway. Like everyone is saying, decent TS, slightly faded colors & a lil dark, nice audio, great movie saw this one in the theaters and it was definitely worth the money.


Posted by vcdking24 on 10-25-2004 03:57 PM:

this is not a dupe. the picture is clearly different than fra pic. no outside edge darkness....best copy out there.....stop with all the nuking...shits getting out of hand..


Posted by timeless on 10-25-2004 04:56 PM:

who cares about the childish politics of the scene. if people hear that this release is far better quality than the earlier one, but then hear its nuked for being a dupe, are they really gonna say noooo i can't download the better one because it was nuked! be realistic... fuck the "rules", they're the same rules that got Brutus' Bourne Supremacy nuked for being 2CD (or was it 3?), when it was like 2 minutes under the "agreed" length for 2CD. they gave a reason in their NFO (action, needed good quality for fast movements) but noooo, fuck the quality, if it doesn't fit the rules it has to be nuked

props to centropy for giving us a top quality TS, far better than the previous rls's
8/8/x


Posted by Redemption1980 on 10-25-2004 06:10 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by DethStar
You can't proper for quality.

Now shut the fuck up, you cock sucking tool.



The first line was true, though a wrong rule in my opinion, as this is better than the last and is still needed.

The second was totally uncalled for, and shows theres still a fair wack of kiddies on here.


Posted by [pr] on 10-25-2004 06:34 PM:

fuck yeah!

funny movie, great rip - 7/8/8


Posted by corvex on 10-25-2004 06:38 PM:

Ok well first of all, this was nuked on this site for a couple of hours then they lifted it...and put it back on...come on

Plz dont sheep nuke, it is technicaly a Dupe, but quality is litteraly 2 times better so fuck the scene rules in these types of cases

Thank you Centropy for the best rls of this movie TS wise


TS Rating:

video : 8
audio : 8
movie : 10 (if you like south park you will love this one)

America FUCK YEAH, has taken a whole new meaning hahaha

__________________
eat, live , breathe : VCD


Posted by pHo on 10-25-2004 06:47 PM:

i removed the nuke (multiple times) because its lame to watch kiddies crying over the fact that this release is clearly better than the previous ones. wanna nuke it on your shitty site? go ahead, it really is your loss if you wan't to see and actually HEAR the movie eh.

altho tbh, after 30mins watching it last night i was highly disappointed. it better get better.

__________________
563-773-1880

<Dwaggy> i caught you a delicious Bass
<The404> This is because you are an idiot


Posted by BLUE-NEO on 10-25-2004 07:52 PM:

just viewed full release...good job...about as good as a puppet movie could be..
picture and sound are great.

8/8/9 movie was good, stupid, and just plain funny.

__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...


Posted by Miller on 10-25-2004 07:53 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by vcdking24
this is not a dupe. the picture is clearly different than fra pic. no outside edge darkness....best copy out there.....stop with all the nuking...shits getting out of hand..


ok this is the last time im going to say somthing in this thread and then im never going to look at it again, becuase some people just don't get it, dupe becuase their is already a release of this movie, a dupe doesn't mean same source like you are saying, that would be stolen source, just becuase its nuked for dupe does not mean this is not a great release, its just it should have been internal.

/me walks away from this thread shaking his head

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!


Posted by fizzyk on 10-25-2004 09:12 PM:

wat is the fuss about

its better quality then the fra rel

so it doesnt matter
just watch it

fuck the politics

leave that for bush and kerry


Posted by drfutzz on 10-26-2004 12:15 AM:

been waiting for a descent version. Loved it! I am a die hard southpark fan. It was basically southpark with puppets, and sex.(lol) video is way better than the previous two.


f-jacky




8/8/10


Posted by FunkyFlyChicken on 10-26-2004 12:16 AM:

FRA release had better video

Ok, I was shocked when I saw this.

FRA's release was perfectly fine, if you aren't too lazy to turn the volume up. In fact, FRA's release had better colors, and was a bit brighter than Centropy's.

Centropy gives no reason for this release in their nfo. Why? Because even they knew their release wasn't necessary, but they put it out there anyhow.

PErsonally, I could care less about that... but would be nice if people actually rated this release based on the quality, and not based on the fact that it's Centropy.

Sure, CTP released a lot of good stuff years back. Who cares? Lots of groups release stuff. Don't mean 2 shits to me who it is, as long as I'm getting a movie.

After viewing both releases, entire movie, the scores are:

CTP Release:
6.5/8/8
(faded look, dark, but good audio without having to turn volume up)

FRA Release:
7.5/7/8
(clear, bright, nice colors, audio is PERFECTLY fine if you turn it up a notch)

__________________
--FunkyFlyChicken
"It's time to ruffle some feathers"


Posted by McBagpipe on 10-26-2004 12:22 AM:

team america centropy svcd

apparantly a dupe of the FRA release - how ever i would say slightly better in the sense not as dark or blurry and decided upon
this version. How ever thx to both groups for a good effort and sharing. 7.5/7.5/7


Posted by SkullWolf on 10-26-2004 02:16 AM:

Re: FRA release had better video

quote:
Originally posted by FunkyFlyChicken
After viewing both releases, entire movie, the scores are:

CTP Release:
6.5/8/8
(faded look, dark, but good audio without having to turn volume up)

FRA Release:
7.5/7/8
(clear, bright, nice colors, audio is PERFECTLY fine if you turn it up a notch)



Are you retarded? I downloaded the sampe of the FRA release and I figured that either A) I was over the legal BAL B) It was an oversized/re-encd VCD C) Four layers of saran wrap were placed in front of the lens while filming. It also had that stupid issue of being too quiet (Which just shows that FRA has no clue how to decode DTS), and the weaker the signal the poorer the quality (especially with a lossy sound codec such as MPEG).

Why Centropy didn't make this an Internal release I'll never know, as it would have saved us from reading these 70+ comments on OMG NO NUKE ITS TEH BETTRE!!!!1. Does anyone have a link to the scene rules anywhere--I've seen copy/paste references to them all the time so I don't think it's against the rules to ask--, because I think you can nuke for something like "SVCD.not.needed". (Though I'm probably wrong there). Either way, yes, this should be nuked.

To the "OMG NO N00K!!!" kiddies out there, these rules are the only reason that you can figure out which releases to download in the first place. They are for your benefit. Shut up.


So as for MY review of the CTP release:
7.5/9/6.5


Now please, can we stop arguing about "outdated scene rules" and "sheep nukers" and just get along?


Posted by bobey on 10-26-2004 04:09 AM:

nice release, video better than FRA's release so i grabbed it... audio is pretty much the same, just turn the volume up on FRA's one...

8/8/9.5

south park rulz


Posted by evilsailor on 10-26-2004 04:27 AM:

Man you'd think people who are smart enough to get broadband internet, find this website, and get the right codecs to watch movies could take five minutes of their time and LEARN ABOUT THE SCENE. Yeah, sure, it doesn't matter if you know it or not when you were leeching off of Kazaa, but now it does, so if you're gonna be blabbering on "th1s 1z n0 dup3, u guyz sux0r!!" you're fucking stupid. And I don't mean, "oh, you disagree with me, therefore you are stupid," I mean a "does your mommy tie your shoes for you" kind of stupid. There is no question of whether or not this is a dupe, it is a dupe. The question isn't even the greater one, of whether it's okay to proper for quality, as this isn't even a proper. The question is why CTP just pretty much said fuck everyone else in the scene, and the answer to that is probably that they thought, "everyone's so used to slobbing our knobs, nobody will care." And as it goes for the patrons of this forum, they were correct. It's pretty sad actually. I suppose too many Kazaa kiddies have read XDCC and IRC tutorials off the int4rw3b.

Now the review:
Slightly better video than FRA
Sound the same as FRA (just louder)
Movie is funny as fuck.


Posted by lostaznguy on 10-26-2004 09:48 AM:

yea... =P nice try CTP


Posted by Q B on 10-26-2004 11:45 AM:

Nice release

8/8/8


Posted by CTP_Groupie on 10-26-2004 01:43 PM:

Re: FRA release had better video

quote:
Originally posted by FunkyFlyChicken
Ok, I was shocked when I saw this.

FRA's release was perfectly fine, if you aren't too lazy to turn the volume up. In fact, FRA's release had better colors, and was a bit brighter than Centropy's.




Sure, CTP released a lot of good stuff years back. Who cares? .

After viewing both releases, entire movie, the scores are:

CTP Release:
6.5/8/8
(faded look, dark, but good audio without having to turn volume up)

FRA Release:
7.5/7/8
(clear, bright, nice colors, audio is PERFECTLY fine if you turn it up a notch)



You got to be fucking kidding me! I think this guy must be frickin blind.
FRA's release is unbearable imo.

With Centropy you cannot go wrong


Posted by FDNY on 10-26-2004 04:25 PM:

This is a much better release than FRA.
Clearer, less flicker, and better cropping. Thank you CTP.

__________________
Da' EyE oF BeDsTuY


Posted by Diggler on 10-26-2004 04:41 PM:

I don't really give two hoots about whether it's a dupe. It looks good and sounds good, which is all I wanted.

8/8/8


Posted by Furius on 10-26-2004 04:53 PM:

To nuke or not to nuke, that is the question....

nice release anyway.
8/9/7

Pretty funny film too.


Posted by stevensly on 10-26-2004 05:09 PM:

Thumbs up

If you haven't got a copy, this is the one to get.
The video is a little bright, slightly, but otherwise very good and audio is mint.

V 7
A 8
M ?(havent finished it)


Posted by dekehead on 10-26-2004 11:11 PM:

Never understood the scene rule of not being able to release a better quality product for clarity reasons...

Either way, CTP's version is truly the better of the two and im thankful they released this.

For a TS:

8/10(dts?)/xx

(Your choice, depending on how much you like puppet pr0n.)


Posted by BongRipper on 10-27-2004 02:47 AM:

scene rules aside, this is the best release of this movie to date; worth the download for sure...

Video a little washed out, sound a little up & down, but hey it IS a TS

8/7/6

__________________
Anything worth doing, is worth doing high!


Posted by KnowTheToe on 10-27-2004 04:06 AM:

v=7 ( a little washed out)
a=8
m=f'in off the wall. The puppet sex scene is funny as hell.

__________________
Do you know the toe?


Posted by vission on 10-27-2004 08:47 AM:

Still A Rookie To The Vcdquality Forums, But I've Been A Viewer, Since I Can't Remember. At Any Rate, I Don't Ride On Groups For Being Popular,Etc Because I'm A Man Of Higher Standards & Quality. This Release Is Above Par Compared To The Other Current Releases Of This Movie. I've Watched Most of This Copy So Far, And All Is Good. Picture Quality & Sound Aren't Bad, Not The Greatest, Picture Is A Little Bright (Could Always Be My TV), Sound A Little Low. Other Than That, If The Running Time Is Off/Missing Scenes, Which I'm Not Sure. It's The Best Rls Yet. Thx Much Centropy.


-]-Drunk While Writing-[-


Posted by TwilageR on 10-27-2004 04:50 PM:

7.5/9/4

Well this movie was just a joke, I knew Matt and Trey made some lame shows and movies what were great but they struck out this time.

7.5/9/4


Posted by EclipseGSX on 10-28-2004 12:56 AM:

Anyone else notice that the picture isn't centered? It's a pain in the ass on a widescreen TV, because when changing the viewing mode you end up with a black bar on the top, and some of the picture cut off on the bottom. Other than that... it's ok -- average telesync. This isn't the same Centropy quality you'd expect (their Finding Nemo was amazing). Oh well.

V: 6.5 (Not centered vertically, bit dark and grainy)
A: 8.0 (Direct... clear)
M: 8.5 (A little slow in parts, but overall pretty damn funny)


Posted by nullvoiid on 10-28-2004 03:24 AM:

7/8/in my opinion 9

picture a little washed but but still looks great when played on the tv, sounds as good as it get's when you have 2 speakers
This could be called a dupe but how can you call a centropy a dupe!! (rules gone mad)


Posted by BiggD23 on 10-28-2004 06:27 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by nullvoiid
This could be called a dupe but how can you call a centropy a dupe!! (rules gone mad)


Ugh...it seems pretty simple to me...there was already an SVCD TS of this movie out, therefore it is a DUPE. Who cares what group put it out, it's still a dupe. All CTP had to do was INTERNAL (just like FRA did with Surviving Xmas) and everything would have been fine.

/rant

V: 7 (slightly washed out and not centered)
A: 9 (nothing wrong here)
M: 8 (I usually like Matt & Trey's stuff alot)


Posted by DaveMode on 10-28-2004 10:24 PM:

I enjoyed this movie and was happy to see a nice quality release like this one.

As far as I'm concerned: good quality movies > scene rules


Posted by KillX3 on 10-29-2004 03:58 AM:

funny movie especially the south korean dictator

7/8/8

__________________
GTA Pimps --> Wanna Play?
www.gtapimps.com


Posted by infinityfsp2002 on 10-29-2004 08:07 PM:

Ehh, Quality cannot be reason for proper (even though CTP didnt even do that, which i think shows a bit of disrespect to FRA there...) since then it can be opinon if a copy is better quality than another, and we will get a load of lame releases which are just re-encodes or other TS's.

8 / 8 / - btw.

__________________
iNFiNiTY


Posted by commiewhore on 10-30-2004 08:19 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by vip3r
Dupe of FRA ... Team.America.World.Police.SVCD.TELESYNC-FRA

I seriously hope this one gets nuked, but it probably wont because everyone is so obsessed with this group.

Quality is good .. i must admit it, looks a little bright (but that just may be because the SAMPLE takes place in the desert .. ). Sound is good quality as per usual..movie was just lame, they tried too hard to make it funny imo, very disappointing..

8.5/9/4





look at what you voted here for quality, then look at quality on what you voted for FRA ...


pathetic

video = 8 ...its almost VHS copy minus the crop

audio = 9 .... dts


movie = 6 ...no replay value really, but was funny and had its truth sometimes...the nox cam and fra actually have less scenes than this, the bar scene is cut more in their copy , while he is puking ...that or you just cant see whats going on so it looks like a full min is gone...but whatver


never here to suck ctp's dick but yea they did good <clap>one hand</clap>


Posted by MarkMathers on 10-30-2004 05:53 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by BiggD23
Ugh...it seems pretty simple to me...there was already an SVCD TS of this movie out, therefore it is a DUPE. Who cares what group put it out, it's still a dupe. All CTP had to do was INTERNAL (just like FRA did with Surviving Xmas) and everything would have been fine.

/rant

V: 7 (slightly washed out and not centered)
A: 9 (nothing wrong here)
M: 8 (I usually like Matt & Trey's stuff alot)




Woah! Slow down there partner. Yous Said "who cares what group put it out, its still a dupe" well sure i agree but not when the quality is like 10X better.


Posted by CTP_Groupie on 10-30-2004 11:48 PM:

CTP ENOUGH SAID

Enough of this bullshit! It's Centropy fellas enough said who in the scene can top them in quality movie releases throughout the years? NOBODY! The rules are horse shit, the only complainers are morons who dont want people to think they're on the CTP bandwagon. In secret, I believe everyone looks foward to everyone of their releases. Cmon Admit it


Posted by subfusc on 10-31-2004 12:06 AM:

Very nice for a telesync imo,
movie was... okay

8/8/5


Posted by weedchemist on 10-31-2004 04:11 AM:

didnt read all 101 posts but...

but.... im amazed at the such high scores on this, i have seen better quality cams... this is grainy... i had to turn down contrast all the way and darken it a bit so it wasnt so grainy, after that i turner color up alot and tint up a lil and it looked pretty nice, this woulda been really good with a better encode, but the audio was good! 8video? no way when other svcd groups are getting that too with better video, as a svcd with direct i rate this at 6/9/5 i definately thought this would be pretty good, and i barely got a chuckle out, a movie kids will laugh at, but not a movie for the kids... kinda sad...

::It's Centropy fellas enough said who in the scene can top them in quality movie releases throughout the years?::
the 2 (1in the same) groups that have ruled the SVCD TS scene recently that we arent supposed to mention, u know who im talkin about


Posted by iGZo on 10-31-2004 07:47 PM:

7/8/7

I am glad they made fun of everyone in that movie. Classic.

Anyways, dig the intro, and quality was pretty good for a TS.

__________________


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:02 PM.
Show all 103 posts from this thread on one page

Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.3.0
Copyright © Jelsoft Enterprises Limited 2000 - 2002.