VCDQuality Forums
Show all 115 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- DIVX (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=23)
-- 300 *XviD* - DVD SCR - NEPTUNE (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=75393)


Posted by X69 on 03-21-2007 04:37 PM:


IMPORTANT, PLEASE READ

1 NO REQUESTING MOVIES OR SAMPLES (THIS INCLUDES REQUESTS FOR OTHER GROUPS TO RELEASE THIS MOVIE!)

2 DO NOT DISCUSS WHERE TO DOWNLOAD MOVIES OR SAMPLES

3 DO NOT ASK FOR "RAR PASSWORDS" COS WE DON'T KNOW THEM. CHECK WITH YOUR SOURCE

4 NO FLAMING

5 NO "SPOILERS"

6 NO SCENE-RELATED DISCUSSION/RUMORS (ESPECIALLY REGARDING BUSTS)

7 COMMENT ON THIS RELEASE ONLY (AND ONLY IF YOU'VE SEEN AT LEAST THE SAMPLE). THIS IS THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE THREAD!

8 NO "NOOB" QUESTIONS SUCH AS "HOW DO I WATCH THIS?" ASK IN THE APPROPRIATE PART OF THE FORUM

9 NO DISCUSSING TRADING/SELLING. IF YOU SELL COPIES, GO AWAY YOU'RE NOT WELCOME HERE

* Newbie questions? Want some weird term clarifying? Read our FAQ

* General questions unrelated to this release? Internet LOL's? Right here dudes

* Haven't read the forum rules? Want to play Russian roulette with your forum account?
READ THIS TO AVOID BEING BANNED



*** PEOPLE IGNORING THE RULES WILL BE BANNED ***


Posted by DapperDan on 03-21-2007 04:39 PM:

From the sample, this is quality.
V - 9
A - 8
M - ? (I'm the only person on the planet who hasn't seen it yet..)


Posted by vinigreti on 03-21-2007 04:48 PM:

This is a proper DVD SCR, great job with this release. Very impressed.

V - 9
A - 8
M - 7

Kick ass movie.


Posted by Lucio on 03-21-2007 04:53 PM:

kickass movie and you gave it a 7???
anyway great release...finally
v-7 a bit blurry
a-9
m-10 thanks neptune


Posted by NibbleMe on 03-21-2007 04:56 PM:

Yer looks like the one to get.

Sample:-

V : 8
A : 8 (looks to be right in-sync too)
M : ? Will watch soon now!

Ta NEPTUNE


Posted by Mailman on 03-21-2007 05:05 PM:

I am so glad I've only watched half so far and now I can watch the whole thing in better quality. This is excellant timing and quality, thanks guys.

V-9
A-9
M-8


Posted by Ergen on 03-21-2007 05:06 PM:

A very soon dvdscreener, have only seen the sample and it looks perfect !!
don't know if there are any text include haven't seen the full version yet.

9/9/10


Posted by maccydad on 03-21-2007 05:08 PM:

a very good release skimmed through cant find fault will watch properly tonight
V8
A6 was a 8 but a fair bit of feed back every now an then
m 9

__________________


Posted by barabbas on 03-21-2007 05:12 PM:

Very fast release. Average picture quality for a DVDScr, washed out and blocky. It's the source, but anyway, I rate the picture I see.

V - 7 (again, for a DVDScr)
A - 8 (it's direct from the source and stereo, so no surprises there)
M - ? Will wait for a DVDRip / DVDR with 5.1 audio.


Posted by iGotLaid_off on 03-21-2007 05:30 PM:

V - 8 (picture has dark slighly washed colors, probably the source)
A - 8 (Great!)
M- probably still go see this one in theaters.

wasn't expecting this one for awhile, hope the studios aren't too angry! thx NEPTUNE


Posted by jicjak on 03-21-2007 05:38 PM:

Can't see anything wrong with it at all. Great video and audio. Will watch movie again and with this quality it may be better then first time around.



9/8.5/?


Posted by Bullet on 03-21-2007 05:43 PM:

it's a TC and not a dvdscr. RAted as tc:

9/9/?

rated as dvdscr:

7/7/?

__________________


Posted by JB99 on 03-21-2007 05:47 PM:

V - 9 (great quality)
A - 8 (I will wait for 5.1 audio)
M - 9 (I've seen this once at theater and i'm gonna see it again)

Many thanks to the Group.


Posted by DapperDan on 03-21-2007 06:17 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by barabbas
Very fast release. Average picture quality for a DVDScr, washed out and blocky. It's the source, but anyway, I rate the picture I see.

V - 7 (again, for a DVDScr)
A - 8 (it's direct from the source and stereo, so no surprises there)
M - ? Will wait for a DVDRip / DVDR with 5.1 audio.



You're obviously commenting on something else. This is clear with very little "blockiness". Sound and colours are as intended and the source is definetly a SCR.
You and the other guy(Bullet) have got your 300's mixed up . Not difficult as there are so many versions out there.


Posted by BenO169 on 03-21-2007 06:24 PM:

Excellent release and excellent timing!

V - 10 (I dunno why people are saying blocky it's excellent for a DVDSCR)
A - 7 most of audio is good, but decreases quality once in a while
M - 10 Most badass movie. sex, war, rebellion, its got it all.


Posted by piet007 on 03-21-2007 06:55 PM:

wow, very good quality. Props for Neptune!

v: 9

a: 8.5

m: 9

looks awesome on my plasma screen!!


Posted by XIII on 03-21-2007 06:58 PM:

Any BB scenes or scrolling text property of etc ?


Posted by CATBOX on 03-21-2007 07:00 PM:

Finally after 47 releases of the Workprint there is a real screener! Quality is great. Video is a very wide aspect ratio, but looks like a genuine DVD Screener source. Audio is superb. Movie was good.

Best of all, the Watermarks are gone! Good bye MOJO. Thanks Neptune. Couldn't wait for the DVDR, so i've made my own.

CATBOX


Posted by Tork on 03-21-2007 07:00 PM:

9/9/8.5


Posted by Arthur Daily on 03-21-2007 07:33 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Bullet
it's a TC and not a dvdscr. RAted as tc:

9/9/?

rated as dvdscr:

7/7/?



i'm afraid hes right guys,

As you can see from this line (faint line) that is visible throughout the sample.avi (still leeching the rest)

Not for one second taking away the fact that this is the BEST TC I've seen for a LONG TIME.
better than all them 'so called' R5 releases of late.
So don't think I'm crapping on the release or quality for one second.
Its MINT, however it is also mislabeled and sadly should
be nuked as such, allowing for a real DVDscr in the future and not a PROPPER

Neptune, This is the best TC for months you should be proud.
the quality alone makes me overlook the mislabel
keep up the good work, (but watch the labels)


My shitty screen grab dose the picture quality no justice at all.
Its just to illustrate the line, i know there's a proper name for it...
but either way, its not an artifact you associate with DVDscr's
http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h102/Arthur_Daily/grab.jpg



9 for video, top notch TC
8 for audio, only because its 384 kbit/s 2ch AC3

__________________
*Meet the rest of the VCDQ Crew, HERE *


Posted by STRICTLY_CRIM on 03-21-2007 07:41 PM:

:: Plz STFU, not everyone uses the same sources :: -L


Posted by Bullet on 03-21-2007 07:48 PM:

quote:
do you know wtf you are talking about?


think i do




arthur daily:

Chuck norris doesnt own a bbq, oven or microwave. Cause revenge is a dish best served cold

__________________


Posted by Posessor on 03-21-2007 07:58 PM:

quote:
i'm afraid hes right guys,

As you can see from this line (faint line) that is visible throughout the sample.avi (still leeching the rest)

Not for one second taking away the fact that this is the BEST TC I've seen for a LONG TIME.
better than all them 'so called' R5 releases of late.
So don't think I'm crapping on the release or quality for one second.
Its MINT, however it is also mislabeled and sadly should
be nuked as such, allowing for a real DVDscr in the future and not a PROPPER

Neptune, This is the best TC for months you should be proud.
the quality alone makes me overlook the mislabel
keep up the good work, (but watch the labels)


My shitty screen grab dose the picture quality no justice at all.
Its just to illustrate the line, i know there's a proper name for it...
but either way, its not an artifact you associate with DVDscr's
http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h..._Daily/grab.jpg


Are you kidding me? I don't see a friggin line! It's quality is sublime on my tv so I don't see a problem with it!


Posted by infinityfsp20 on 03-21-2007 08:12 PM:

Arthur... maybe it would be a good release if it wasnt just a re-encode of the DVDR on p2p.

Still though, decent quality of course. 9/8/*

__________________
iNFiNiTY


Posted by Arthur Daily on 03-21-2007 08:33 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by infinityfsp2002
Arthur... maybe it would be a good release if it wasnt just a re-encode of the DVDR on p2p.9/8/*



LOL

a re-encode, doesnt create that sort of artifact.
*Vertical line or 'scratch' (i swear there's a proper name for it)
static over moving image*

Its a Telecine and a dam fine one at that.

__________________
*Meet the rest of the VCDQ Crew, HERE *


Posted by sandvic on 03-21-2007 08:37 PM:

Looks like a p2p reencode, np idea if dvdr was 'R5' or TC but it's good quality

7/8/8


Posted by DapperDan on 03-21-2007 08:47 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Arthur Daily
LOL

a re-encode, doesnt create that sort of artifact.
*Vertical line or 'scratch' (i swear there's a proper name for it)
static over moving image*

Its a Telecine and a dam fine one at that.



What artifact ? There is nothing in your pic or in the sample. I suggest you invest in new gear, Arfur. Get Tel to drop off some stuff at the lock up


Posted by nullvoiid on 03-21-2007 08:50 PM:

rating as a dvdscr

v = 8
a = 9
m = 7 dont know expected to much maybe

i've looked for the artifact that arthur daily mention but i cannot see it, the untrained eye and all that, but if its a tc then its the best i've ever seen!


Posted by fireman911 on 03-21-2007 08:50 PM:

jeps TC, a very nice one , but still a tc
why the hell you tag this as a dvdscreener, you must be proud on this TC !

for tc:
V:9 (very nice!)
A:6 (its direct but to lowly recorded)
M:9

__________________
i shall burn it...(onto a dvd :P )


Posted by EViL-EWoK on 03-21-2007 08:53 PM:

yeah I goota believe its a TC. but still jerkoff'able

8/8/looks like another LOTR, ill still watch it

__________________
I Just Want to Be like Radiohead, And do something ingenious.


Posted by DapperDan on 03-21-2007 09:06 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by EViL-EWoK
yeah I goota believe its a TC. but still jerkoff'able

8/8/looks like another LOTR, ill still watch it



Do you see artifacts too ? What makes you "goota" believe this is a TC ?


Posted by VonRashniek on 03-21-2007 09:07 PM:

Arthur, I'm not disagree'n with ya, cause generally you know ur sh*t.
But I'll be dammed if I can see the line(artifact) your talking about. Heh I must be gettin old,,,lol.
I've seen the line which you refer to on other movies. Like I said I'm not scumming you down, I just don't see it.
I believe the line you are referring to is usually corrected by DNR when they go from film to digital, although I may be wrong. DNR is usually used to correct film grain, electronic noise of the telecine, comb filter artifacts in composite video sources, film speckles, dirt, scratches etc... So we don't see them.
So if your seeing the line, then you probably are correct in saying it's a pretty damned sweet TC.
In rating this as a TC you gotta give it high 9's
Either way this is most watchable copy out there, and I doubt there will be better for awhile.
2cents

__________________
Opinions are like azzholes, everyones got one, and yours stinks.


Posted by Arthur Daily on 03-21-2007 09:28 PM:

I could have said nothing, just not posted THIS post here,

But i think its worth a laugh, and also i think i owe it to Neptune.

Ready guys.......



The Vertical line i speak of...........
























is on my fuckin LCD, not the movie.



Please, allow me to post the 1st Arthurs a retard pic

http://skp36.tripod.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/.pond/retard.jpg.w300h341.jpg

__________________
*Meet the rest of the VCDQ Crew, HERE *


Posted by Stonington on 03-21-2007 09:44 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Arthur Daily
I could have said nothing, just not posted THIS post here,

But i think its worth a laugh, and also i think i owe it to Neptune.

Ready guys.......



The Vertical line i speak of...........
























is on my fuckin LCD, not the movie.



Please, allow me to post the 1st Arthurs a retard pic

http://skp36.tripod.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/.pond/retard.jpg.w300h341.jpg



LOL **it happens. Now to the movie:

v/9
a/9
m/9

About as good as it gets 'til R1 gets here.


Posted by cenox on 03-21-2007 09:44 PM:

LOL! that was so funny.


Cool u have the guts to admit it Arthur Daily

As for the movie:

V = 9
A = 8
M = Haven't seen yet..


Posted by dakiller on 03-21-2007 10:21 PM:

I spent ages squinting and looking for that artifact..lmao

c'est la vie

as far as this release goes....
HOLY FUCK!!!

Vid:9
Aud:8
Mov:9

__________________
"Sure, Kill Bill's a violent movie. But it's a Tarantino movie. You don't go to see Metallica and ask the fuckers to turn the music down."


Posted by OSH on 03-21-2007 10:30 PM:

I was content with the Workprint and then this comes along. Both releases are keepers, Workprint for the obvious reasons and this also for the obvious reasons ha. Pic is excellent but could be sharper and looks too dark. As for the sound, nice and loud.

V-8
A-9
M-?

__________________


I'm gay. <3 <3 <3


Posted by Beaver40 on 03-21-2007 11:58 PM:

Is it me??

Video is perfect...

Audio is to loud...anything happening and it crackles...

Great movie


Posted by Stealth-X23x on 03-21-2007 11:59 PM:

From the sample it looks great.

8/9/?

Gonna watch soon.


Posted by acdcfanbill on 03-22-2007 01:13 AM:

v:9
a:8
m:7

pretty good movie, certainly a visual experience, short on story and such, but a fun time. video is great, audio is nearly as good, touch of loud parts for me and a bit of static but quite nice.


Posted by X400 on 03-22-2007 01:23 AM:

8/8/6

movie was ok think everyones just feeding off of the hype
^^ just based on action its a 8 the story brings it down


Posted by CiC on 03-22-2007 01:42 AM:

Impressive release Neptune

V: 8
A: 8
M: 6.5


Posted by kelnar on 03-22-2007 01:48 AM:

ok so arthur admitted he made a mistake lol, what's bullets excuse for accusing this of being a tc therefore mislabled.
there is no way in hell this is a tc.... if it is then it's an R5, but still, i think it is a 100% dvdscr.


Posted by tyronepiggomz on 03-22-2007 01:56 AM:

UNNUKED: verified.dvdscr.source

v-8
a-8
m-watching tonight


Posted by SultrySalesma on 03-22-2007 02:13 AM:

Wow, such a quick release!

V:9 -Beautiful
A:6 -My audio cuts out during the credits...Anyone else?
M:6 -Lots of hype. Kind of figured it'd be that way. Real nice to look at, but the message was heavy handed and not as great as it could have been.


Posted by chevyls7 on 03-22-2007 02:49 AM:

awesome job thankz

V - 9
A - 8
M - 10


Posted by vanzan on 03-22-2007 02:55 AM:

Audio cuts out for credits here too. Its an improvement on the 20th release I already have but not a huge one.

Its still very dark. I still cant see that spear that is thrown when the persian tells them to lay down their weapons (cd1 45:40).

Audio is a little better

V:8
A:8
M:6


Posted by Forsaken on 03-22-2007 03:17 AM:

ive skimmed thru the sample and cd1.

video is very clear but a bit dark.
i dont believe this is a dvdscr

dvdscr should be dvd quality in terms of brightness and lighting in the movie.

when there is a loud scene the sound crackles and distorts a lot.
maybe its the pc speakers that im using here at work...will try it out on a proper system later on.


Posted by Spidey1790 on 03-22-2007 03:59 AM:

V - 9 Very Little Blockyness.
A - 8 Little "Glitches" Here and There, Some Crackling.
M - 10 Awesome Damn Movie!


Thanks For The Great Release!

__________________
Hmm...


Posted by BONE on 03-22-2007 04:01 AM:

9/6/8

vid is great

audio is just OK .. the music cuts in and out (especially when the women's voice is heard). I guess it is clipping, hard to tell because it doesn't happen all the time. The main soundtrack seems cool. Not sure what is going on, but it's definitely not great. Plus there is no sound during the end credits.

Overall .. kick ass release!


Posted by pedantics on 03-22-2007 04:08 AM:

if one were to consider how early this release is when rating, it'd be 10s all round for this bad boy.

9/7.5/8

probably an r5 given the inconsistent sound quality. still all good though!


Posted by thecritik on 03-22-2007 06:31 AM:

V = 9
A = 8
M = 10

Best release i've seen in a while. Doesn't get much better than this.

SPARTA!!!!!!

__________________
If it goes beep, I can fix it!!


Posted by ukextremist on 03-22-2007 07:04 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by vanzan
Audio cuts out for credits here too. Its an improvement on the 20th release I already have but not a huge one.

Its still very dark. I still cant see that spear that is thrown when the persian tells them to lay down their weapons (cd1 45:40).

Audio is a little better

V:8
A:8
M:6




Turn your brightness up abit mate.

This is one of the quickest screeners of all time and of a big film like this neptune is now my new hero.

Considering where still waiting for decent releases of white noise 2 and epic movie (coz the others where shit)
How anyone can have bad things to say about this release is beyond me.

V-9
A-8 Sound cut's out in the end credits but does anyone care???
M-9 Great movie dident let me down one bit great story great action and some RIGHT big nipples all's good in the world.

Some people are going on about a crackle i cant hear it i think you might all need to update your pc or turn you base down abit.


Posted by arvlight& on 03-22-2007 08:10 AM:

video is great.

i don't know how in the hell everyone is rating this release so high on audio. the sound clips whenever it gets loud, which is a lot in this movie. so unless you like loud cracks throughout the entire movie... it made it unwatchable for me until i fixed it. maybe i'm just picky since i'm a sound engineer.

i ran the sound thru a clip distortion filter to get rid of the crackle and then normalized it in soundtrack pro. the sound gets a 9 from me after the distortion is removed.

V10/A4/M9


Posted by GuidoVelvito on 03-22-2007 08:46 AM:

From the sample and from skimming through the movie, it looks damn good and is the best out there right now. You'll notice colors a bit washed and video is dark but then again that's how the original movie was shot. This copy just has colors a bit more washed and video a bit darker but overall the video is still sharp and audio is great. I give it 8.5/9/? (Haven't watched full movie yet to comment on it.)


Posted by frak on 03-22-2007 09:11 AM:

Watched this on the TV tonight...

Had previously watched the last TS from 20th, which was pretty good.... this is just better.

video is excellent and sharp.. slightly dull colors but nothing to complain about.

audio is spot on.

best release to date and the movie as most know by now is one of the most entertaining action flicks I've seen in a while.

v: 9
a: 9
m: 10


Posted by 404notfound on 03-22-2007 10:10 AM:

Hold on... Would a DVDSCR have 'FINISHED' as the very last frame? isn't that an end of reel thing. i only caught a quick glimse last night but its defo there.

Still.. Its a nice release

V: 9
A: 7 (Some of the queen stuff was really low)
M: 5.5 (My second time watching. Still think its overrated)

__________________


Posted by 1892spinthemi on 03-22-2007 10:28 AM:

based on good skimm thru n rated as scr
v-9 a-7 m-?(may wait for retail b4 watch this)
video is ok clear enough and as good as it gets when uk rls 22nd march !
but the audio has serious crackle on loud scenes !!! too overpowering quiet scenes quiet and loud too loud !!!
shame really maybe the audio guy had ear muffs on !
but all round if u really want a copy ? get this 1 !!
complete , watchable , audible(just enough)
they didnt win the race for 1st rls but won it for the best all rounder !(which to me is better)

__________________
keep the scene alive please !


Posted by Z-Man on 03-22-2007 11:32 AM:

I cannot believe that no one is addressing this awful crackling every time the sound gets loud....
V=9
A=5
M=10


Posted by asnsky on 03-22-2007 12:13 PM:

V = 9
A = 8
M = 10


great release ....


Posted by joepasser on 03-22-2007 01:12 PM:

vid 8
aud 4
mov ?

audio is too annoying

no prob hearing speaking parts.
however its those other more graphical parts of the film that get ruined by clouds of toxic and white noise.


Posted by danteshors on 03-22-2007 01:50 PM:

I cannot believe that no one is addressing this awful crackling every time the sound gets loud....

For real.

V=8
A=4
M=8


Posted by 1892spinthemi on 03-22-2007 02:06 PM:

"" but the audio has serious crackle on loud scenes !!! too overpowering quiet scenes quiet and loud too loud !!!
shame really maybe the audio guy had ear muffs on ! ""

Z-MAN i just did .... dont think it makes it unwatchable tho
i will wait but i am patient...

__________________
keep the scene alive please !


Posted by Neversoft on 03-22-2007 02:25 PM:

You've done some amazingly retarded stuff on here in the past Arthur but that is comedy gold, thanks

I haven't watched the movie yet but I'm not sure what some of you folks are watching but I'm damned certain this is a TC not a DVDSCR. Sure, it's a fantastic TC, one of the best... but it's a TC, not a DVDSCR

Some of you seem really defensive just because somebody points out that you're mistaken and the group has mislabelled it. It doesn't prevent it from being an excellent copy of the movie and in all fairness I'd respect Neptune more for "Calling a spade a spade" instead of tagging it incorrectly. Does it pass as a DVDSCR? Not really, the definition isn't good enough, if it was an actual DVDSCR it would be a poor one but as it stands it's an awesome TC... Live with it!

Oh and for a DVD screener the audio would be a bit gash as well.

V - 6/10 (if DVDSCR) or 9/10 (for TC)
A - 5/10 (if DVDSCR) or 7/10 (for TC)
M - Dunno

__________________
Statistically... 9 out of 10 people actually enjoy gang rape.


Posted by signum on 03-22-2007 02:49 PM:

v 9
a 10 becouse me 6.1 receiver coming good sound
m 10
this is sparta and death
nice movie cheers neptun fine release

__________________
la dolce vita


Posted by bateman666 on 03-22-2007 03:33 PM:

video is excellent and the film was very enjoyable.

as for the audio. it was loud and crackling on my pc, but when i put it onto a dvd and played it on my tv is was fine.

a top quality copy.


Posted by tallguy425 on 03-22-2007 03:46 PM:

this is a TC

V - 9
A - 9
m - 10


Posted by 1892spinthemi on 03-22-2007 05:05 PM:

decided to dvd-r this
and the audio comes out perfect !!!
poor on pc mint on the telly !!
out today and really good pic and audio for speed
so i change my review to v-9 a-8.75 m-10 for the action

awesome fight scenes ! quailty to match when put to dvd-r !!!
happy happy happy

__________________
keep the scene alive please !


Posted by Plasmah on 03-22-2007 05:48 PM:

Finally

V-8
A-7
M-8


Posted by Arthur Daily on 03-22-2007 06:38 PM:

ITS A TC !!!!!!!!

For Feck sake, ok so i had a mark on my screen
and a moment of Retardedness but the Fact remains

ITS A TC aka Telecine,
Not and i repeat not a DVDscr.

Basically you call a TC a TC if its a TC
or a Cam a Cam, When? When its a cam.

You don't call the dude in the post office Bob because he looks like you uncle bob.
If his name is Fred, then call him Fred.

OK, back on my meds now.....

Here's the Definitive proof that this is a TC
anyone still in any denial or don't know what a Telecine is and to embarrassed to ask..
Google it.


Here's the Last frame, Don't believe? check it yourself...

Screen grab of last frame
(opens a .bmp picture i uploaded to Photo bucket)

__________________
*Meet the rest of the VCDQ Crew, HERE *


Posted by cashmoney on 03-22-2007 06:55 PM:

Video: 9 nice and clear
Audio: 7 hard to hear speaking but still good
Movie: Was killed by the hype so-so except the fighting which owned so a 7.5


Posted by marion on 03-22-2007 07:39 PM:

I have just watched this one and I would give it at the very least a 9/10 on all points, not sure if any of those that are flaming it have actually watched the movie, but the sound is great, the picture is great and the movie, brilliant!!!
I have read a few various remarks and I am sure you must all be watching a different version as for any lines on it, couldn't see anything that distracted me from the film. I convered with DivxtoDVD and no probs at all

__________________
aka sunfreek


Posted by nwoidaho on 03-22-2007 09:18 PM:

V: 9.5 A:8.5 M:10 <<---Watched it TWICE!

This is a High Quality TC. The machine this was captured on was of the highest quality.

With that said, the audio codec used is a little funky causing people to have clipping and popping problems when the audio peaks about -6Db.

Go install the most recent AC3filter and set the down mix settings to stereo and turn the audio down manually.

After that I encoded this to a DVD and it looks wonderful.

__________________
Check Out The BJ Shea Morning Experience on KISW/Seattle 5-10am PDT at www.kisw.com


Posted by SlySy on 03-22-2007 09:20 PM:

I watched this movie and I could care less who released it or if it's a TC or DVD screener. Most of you are picky little shit's. 10's all around.



::MOD EDIT:: You miss the point we're making... The quality IS excellent but mislabelling the release prevents any groups from releasing a DVDSCR as it would be nuked as a dupe - although they can "proper" this release. Why not release this as a TC in the first place cos it's a damned impressive one!? - Neversoft::


Posted by matt159 on 03-23-2007 12:09 AM:

goto videohelp.com and get ac3filter and follow these steps to sort out the sound
NOW to configure.
1 Go into ac3filters configure (click start menu tards and find ac3filter, under there is something called ac3filter config DUH!!)
2 slide the master and gain sliders under the main, and mixer tabs to about 3/4 full
3 goto to the mixer tab and tick ALL THE CHECK BOXES under where it says options EXCEPT FOR THE BASS REDIR one, UNTICK THAT ONE
4 next to the options selection is a output selection, from those drop down boxes choose 2/0 Stereo and below that choose PCM 16bit
5 under the system tab check ALL the boxes under use ac3filter for, and all the boxes under SPDIF passthrough, LEAVE the check boxes under the SPDIF OPTIONS set to there defaults
6 Where it says filter merit select prefer AC3filter
7 Where it says Default audio render choose Use direct sound as default audio render
8 return to the main tab and where it says output select 2/0 stereo and in the other pulldown box choose PCM 16bit...


Posted by Jayhab on 03-23-2007 12:19 AM:

Convert it to a DVD!!!

Audio is sketchy as hell until you convert it to a DVD!
I didn't need to install any new codecs, and play with the volume or anything - just joined the two parts and converted it using DivxtoDvd.

The audio is then absolutely fine - really crisp and clear with absolutely no drop-outs/clips/pops
V=10
A=10
M= will watch later!


Posted by RealJB on 03-23-2007 02:53 AM:

Still waiting for a good enough release...

Picture has a slight blur, contrast is out of whack - so it has a washed-out look. Much closer to the true "golden-hued" cinema release. If this *was* a screener (which I doubt) it would have to be lifted off a VHS. Artifacts are visible in the dark areas of the screen - probably the encoding that's done that.

Audio is screwed. It should be nuked for its audio - seriously.

If you want to compare the quality, watch the trailer. Maybe ok for small screen if you don't have a problem with the audio but this is not one for big screens.

V = 8

A = 4

M = 9

The real DVD will be around soon enough and it'll be worth the wait.

__________________
Let's get one thing straight - you don't know me, you don't know what I contribute to the scene, you don't know how long I've been on the scene... in short, you don't know, ok? So don't give me any of that whining crap about not criticising groups' releases. If you want to waste your time, bandwidth and media on the latest POS why bother reading this forum? As a discerning consumer I like to avoid crap, so thanks to those with the honesty to tell it like it is.


Posted by BIOHazard87 on 03-23-2007 06:47 AM:

V: 8
A: 1 (Highly distorted while watching on TV? I will try a re-burn)
M: N/A


Posted by blobbyrob on 03-23-2007 09:39 AM:

Couldn't get any sound at all on WMP 11 so I downloaded & installed an ac3 codec (sorry can't remember which 1) which sorted it. Converted to Dvd using ConvertXtoDvd & came out almost perfect. Looks & sounds superb on my 32" Samsung LCD

V 9
A 9
M 9


Posted by Son_of_Thunde on 03-23-2007 10:27 AM:

Very high quality, especially since it came out so quickly.

V: 8.5 Great except for when fading to and from black, at those points it gets a little artifacted, nothing too bad though. I watched it with three other people and I was the only one to notice.
A: 8 It would be perfect but it was only stereo.
M: 8 Better than I thought it would be. I'm glad I waited for a quality release.


Posted by videotape74 on 03-23-2007 11:04 AM:

if you want to improve the audio of this release before converting it to dvd to watch on your home theatre setup, here's what i did and it turned out great...

convert the .ac3 audio to .wav using BeSweet/BeLight or something along those lines. Then use Sony Soundforge with the following:
process > normalize > normalize using peak level @ -1.93db

hit ok, let it process and then save the new file. then convert it back to ac3 with the tool of your choice. i only used 192kb ac3 on my final dvd because 384 is pretty much pointless for a 2.0 mix especially in the case of this audio that has alot of cutoffs and clipping.


Posted by transferman on 03-23-2007 04:16 PM:

This is a Great TC screener, yeah the audio sucks and is very annoying when played on the PC, but i as some other people in here converted onto a DVD and when i play it back on my DVD players, the audio is just great, no carckling at all.

Props to Neptune for a fine realease


Posted by BigBadBart on 03-23-2007 05:05 PM:

300 Scr-Neptune

Actaully You're all WRONG

Did you not notice artifacts as in 'Rocky Balboa' and many others lately or how they get subs direct onto movies

The simply anser is :

There all TV-Rip type captures. NOT direct Digital Rips.

So any artifacts or colour degradation is due to the CUPTURE MACHINE

Now you can all go out to play, you silly children

TIM-The Invisible Man

__________________
BigBadBart


Posted by XIII on 03-23-2007 05:48 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by videotape74
if you want to improve the audio of this release before converting it to dvd to watch on your home theatre setup, here's what i did and it turned out great...

convert the .ac3 audio to .wav using BeSweet/BeLight or something along those lines. Then use Sony Soundforge with the following:
process > normalize > normalize using peak level @ -1.93db

hit ok, let it process and then save the new file. then convert it back to ac3 with the tool of your choice. i only used 192kb ac3 on my final dvd because 384 is pretty much pointless for a 2.0 mix especially in the case of this audio that has alot of cutoffs and clipping.



Dude you could have done the whole process in Besweet ac3 > ac3


XIII


Posted by Forsaken on 03-23-2007 06:48 PM:

i watched this tonight at a mates place on a large HD tv with a kick ass sound system.

the picture quality was fantastic...seemed like it was a proper xvid
you could see in certain scenes where it was just a tad to dark, but otherwise you could hardly notice it once you got into the movie.

the sound was very good and didnt crackle at all.

awesome movie well worth watching


Posted by impaler on 03-23-2007 06:54 PM:

i really don't understand how anyone can think this is a 9v quality dvdscr.
it really is a nice TC.

here's a comparison i made with vlc:
the large (not HD) trailer from the apple site, and the sample of this release.

you will see how incredibly blurry this release is, with washed out colours and bad details in high and low brightness areas.


http://img405.imageshack.us/my.php?image=01vlcsnapfromlargetrailga5.png


Posted by impaler on 03-23-2007 07:09 PM:

here's the trailer
http://img405.imageshack.us/my.php?image=01vlcsnapfromlargetrailga5.png

here's the release
http://img158.imageshack.us/my.php?image=02vlcsnapfromsocalleddved5.png

again:
trailer:
http://img116.imageshack.us/my.php?image=03vlcsnapfromlargetrailao4.png

release:
http://img47.imageshack.us/my.php?image=04vlcsnapfromsocalleddvfc8.png


Posted by BigBadBart on 03-23-2007 10:37 PM:

300 Xvid-neptune

NOTE:

The colours on this Xvid are fine just like the original, because it was done by the 'Sin City' film crew, and how weird the colur process was on that. Catch the current TV trailer for this then you'll see how close this is.

As for converting audio (or warping as it's known), make sure the audio software being used does'nt try to fix the 'PITCH' (or 'pitch control), allow the pitch to go up or down for the correct ntsc-pal warp otherwise a warbled effect will be heard especially on long sustained sounds (violins etc.)

Goldwave has an exellent warp feature in it's software.


TIM

__________________
BigBadBart


Posted by ashes on 03-23-2007 11:13 PM:

IGotLaid_off>

Its supposed to look like that, as you explain it 'washed out colors'

Nice screener!

8/8/9

__________________
Imagination is more important than knowledge. - A. Einstein


Posted by koby66 on 03-23-2007 11:18 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by DapperDan
You're obviously commenting on something else. This is clear with very little "blockiness". Sound and colours are as intended and the source is definetly a SCR.
You and the other guy(Bullet) have got your 300's mixed up . Not difficult as there are so many versions out there.



same here DapperDan...
this is the way the movie is supposed to
look...I've seen it in the theaters and
the movie looks the same!!!!

v-9
a-8
m-9


Posted by mrdj on 03-24-2007 02:03 AM:

absolute quality props for this film fukkin brilliant film


v 8

a 9

m 10


Posted by pomh on 03-24-2007 05:16 AM:

great screener I must say, but even the TELESYNC, which had a little credits, had music to go with it. This version doesn't seem to have the music with the credits. Maybe this is just me saying this because I liked the music in the credits, oh well. Movie is still # 1 at box office and to have a DVDSCR of it already, that's just, WOW!


Posted by pomh on 03-24-2007 11:00 AM:

I have experienced trouble authoring and burning this file to DVD. I got past the wait of the fil transfer, but the authoring tool only put out an hour and 28 minutes of movie, noticably not the whole thing. where is the mVs release, or the SWiNE release? I still want this DVDSCR/DVDR...


Posted by NorQue on 03-24-2007 11:10 AM:

Re: 300 Xvid-neptune

quote:
Originally posted by BigBadBart
NOTE:

The colours on this Xvid are fine just like the original, because it was done by the 'Sin City' film crew, and how weird the colur process was on that. Catch the current TV trailer for this then you'll see how close this is.


The colors are fine... because this movie was done by "the 'Sin City' film crew"? You have any idea how stupid this argument sounds? Just FYI, Sin City looks fine as a DVDRip, this one doesn't. It's quite good, considering the time this got released, but it's far from perfect, especially in the color and sharpness department.

5/3/7

This is compared to other DVDSCRs, since this is supposed to be one. I think the picture quality is mediocre at best, doesn't deserve a more than average rating - which 5 is supposed to be, IMHO. Audio crackles, this can't be above average anymore. Possible that this is fixable, but I'm not rating any distant possibilities, I'm rating this release. And audio for this release is seriously lacking - compared to other DVDSCRs, again.


Posted by yukichigai on 03-24-2007 01:49 PM:

Given the quality of the release I suspect that we may ALL be right.. and wrong.

If you remember back when R5s were announced they were specifically mentioned as "doing the same things a teleciner does, but with studio equipment," e.g. taking the movie and capturing digitals of all the reels, then turning that into a release. It isn't the only way R5s come out, but the only exceptions are leaked sources, pre-release "for your consideration" stuff, etc. Anyway, given the insanely high quality of the TC work, the various DVD->XviD artefacts you can vaguely pick up on, and the release source being called a DVD SCR I'm going to have to say that it is actually a Telecine-sourced *R5* and that Neptune must be one of the groups that doesn't support the designation.


That's my two cents.

quote:
Originally posted by Arthur Daily
ITS A TC !!!!!!!!

For Feck sake, ok so i had a mark on my screen
and a moment of Retardedness but the Fact remains

ITS A TC aka Telecine,
Not and i repeat not a DVDscr.

Basically you call a TC a TC if its a TC
or a Cam a Cam, When? When its a cam.

You don't call the dude in the post office Bob because he looks like you uncle bob.
If his name is Fred, then call him Fred.

OK, back on my meds now.....

Here's the Definitive proof that this is a TC
anyone still in any denial or don't know what a Telecine is and to embarrassed to ask..
Google it.


Here's the Last frame, Don't believe? check it yourself...

Screen grab of last frame
(opens a .bmp picture i uploaded to Photo bucket)


Posted by dariusgw on 03-24-2007 02:31 PM:

Great video 9
Crisp Audio 9
Movie Overall 9.5


Posted by sara20 on 03-24-2007 03:51 PM:

V-9
A-9
M-8

__________________
Sara


Posted by sar on 03-24-2007 04:49 PM:

The sound is indeed, pretty much terrible. I don't know how people can rate it an 8.

Can anyone tell me how to fix it in BeSweet ?

7/6/8

(rated as dvdscr - pretty sure it's a tc/r5)


Posted by Jayhab on 03-24-2007 10:16 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by sar
The sound is indeed, pretty much terrible. I don't know how people can rate it an 8.

Can anyone tell me how to fix it in BeSweet ?

7/6/-

(rated as dvdscr - pretty sure it's a tc/r5)



> As mentioned earlier by myself and several others - convert it to a DVD and there are no probs with the sound or you can play around with codecs and stuff>?>


Posted by ramsfanattic on 03-25-2007 03:38 AM:

Talking

Hats off to Neptune....This is one of the absolute best SCr I have seen in awhile. Outstanding job.......

V: 9
A: 9
M: 8 (Guys will love it)

Great Job NEPTUNE!!!!!!!


Posted by pomh on 03-25-2007 04:56 AM:

burned without authoring and it turner out ike crap. The 2.35:1 is maintained but that's all that is maintained in this screener when combinded. About 10 minutes in, goes badly out of sync, then 30 minutes later, audio is barely able to hear, then disc 2 there is no audio. If this file is not totally fucked up, could someone please, and I do mean pretty please tell me what to convert and what to author this with? I liked their Blood Diamond release way better... This one is a shame for NEPTUNE, sorry...


Posted by Lester_Diamon on 03-26-2007 07:18 AM:

The video is top quality, couldn't ask for much better. However, the sound is fucked up. I had to keep turning the volume up and down throughout the entire movie, not sure if this is normal or not but fucked up none the less. I'd give the movie itself a 7, why not, heterosexual women need something to masturbate to

LD


Posted by pjfan0281 on 03-27-2007 07:42 AM:

i did what someone else suggested. i extracted the audio (virtualdub), converted to wav(besweet), normalize to -1.93db(soundforge). then instead of converting back i left as wav and encoded video and audio to dvd format with TMPGENC. came out awesome. finest i have ever seen


Posted by qwerty666 on 03-28-2007 06:25 PM:

8.5/8/7. Nice quick release. Audio crackles the odd time during loud music scenes but other then dat no problems.


Posted by Rei on 03-29-2007 10:47 AM:

I had the audio crackling problems too, but downloading the newest ac3filter codec (1.30b) seemed to fix it. I'm not sure what version I had previously.

Now time to watch

v9/a9/m?


Posted by Spetz on 03-29-2007 03:26 PM:

Watched this ages ago .

V - 9ish for a TeleCine , 8 for dvdscr (totally watchable)

A - 9 (good clear AC3)

M - 9 (great action sequences ,awesome storyline ,one of Frank Miller's finest)


Posted by mrblonduk on 03-29-2007 07:44 PM:

excellent release! and a bloody god film too, wasnt sure what t expect aving seen trailors ect.
i didnt burn this film i stuck it straight on a USB stick and played it on the DVD player -32" LCD in my bedroom and it looks and sounds a LOT better than on a PC

As far as the video goes its pretty much spot on, colours look great, no blurring etc, if anything it looks VERY slightly cropped...9

Audio when i watched the first 5 mins on the PC sounded shit.. generally muffled and a bit crackly, like someone had turned the volume up full then put a pillow over the speakers
but when i watched it on the TV the sound was fine.. a litle low in parts but completely understandable! 8


Posted by karchambault on 04-02-2007 01:47 AM:

First post in a while.

Watched this on my PC first. Video was great, but audio was crappy (lot of static). Watched this on my stand-alone and... no static. PHENOMENAL MOVIE.

V-9
A-9 on Stand-alone, 6 on PC
M-10

__________________
"he took my stapler and he never brought it back "

Milton Waddams (Office Space)


Posted by razorbladex90 on 04-02-2007 06:45 PM:

not going to get into any bitching about whether its a tc or a dvdscr... All I care about is that I got a film like this, the week it was released in suberb quality to watch in to comfort of my own living room with a nice cool beer...

Burned o dvd, watched on a 32" widescreen tv and results are as follows...

V - Absoloutly brilliant. Near DVD quality. can't complain at all - 9

A - Didn't notice any problems with crackling whatsoever, at worst it soulnds a little distorted..a LITTLE - 8

M - Brilliant! shut your brain off and enjoy the highly stylised violence - 9

__________________
Yo, She-Bitch..... Let's Go!


Posted by pomh on 04-03-2007 06:35 AM:

There is a reencode of the original two files. 300 (2007)DVDSCR.XviD-NEPTUNE (reencoded). I guess I am not the only one who could not burn this file either. Worked great until I converter it, and it was out of sync. I was able to save this file using DVD Santa and delaying the audio sync by 350 milliseconds. Sure as hell saved this movie from becoming a disaster before I could even watch it. Stil have not burned though. Great rls, although did seem kind of blury for what the video was worth. Maybe it is just the monitor, but the file was only half the size of what the two files were alone...


Posted by unholy_jesus on 04-08-2007 01:35 AM:

no way in hell this is a TC. for surely DVDSCR...got the neptune release of it and all u guys surely too...but most of u mention 2.0...my reciever is gettin' a 5.1 DD out of it...and it's not virtual surround sound

V - 10 (dvd scr wise)
A - 10 - ain't nothing' wrong with it
M - 10 - Blood, gore and violence is all i need to get off


Posted by bobofrut on 04-08-2007 03:45 PM:

V - 9
A - 8
M - 10


Posted by djb1203 on 04-10-2007 07:38 PM:

i had the same crackling problem on the audio.... i downloaded the AC3filter 1.30b codec as previously mentioned...and it seems to of done the job


Posted by enigmatics on 04-16-2007 07:59 AM:

I burned it to DVD using VSO ConvertoDIVX and ran into a slight problem. The video wraps around at the edges. Has anyone else had this problem? If so, how do I solve it?

Overally, I thought it was decent.

V - 8.5 (A bit dark and missing some definition)
A - 8.5 (There's some bass and cracking issues)
O - 8.5 (Overall a good copy, wondering if it's really a Screener)


Posted by GloCK|40 on 05-12-2007 07:24 AM:

Wink Wow!!

V-8
A-8
M-8.5

This one gets 8's across the board b/c it is just a plain good release. And not to mention a great movie also. The Video is very clean and crisp. I didnt notice not a single macroblock throughout the entire movie. And the Audio was very clean and clear also. Great Job on this one NETUNE!!! Keep em coming

__________________
LoCKeD aNd LoaDeD


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:11 AM.
Show all 115 posts from this thread on one page

Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.3.0
Copyright © Jelsoft Enterprises Limited 2000 - 2002.