VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Fantasic 4 *SVCD* *PROPER* - TELECINE - FUCK (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=64928)

IMPORTANT, PLEASE READ

1 NO REQUESTING MOVIES OR SAMPLES (THIS INCLUDES REQUESTS FOR OTHER GROUPS TO RELEASE THIS FILM!)

2 DO NOT DISCUSS WHERE TO DOWNLOAD MOVIES OR SAMPLES

3 NO FLAMING

4 NO "SPOILERS"

5 COMMENT ON THIS RELEASE ONLY (AND ONLY IF YOU'VE SEEN IT). THIS IS THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE THREAD!

6 NO "NOOB" QUESTIONS SUCH AS "HOW DO I WATCH THIS?" ASK IN THE APPROPRIATE PART OF THE FORUM

7 NO DISCUSSING TRADING/SELLING. IF YOU SELL COPIES, GO AWAY YOU'RE NOT WELCOME HERE


*** PEOPLE IGNORING THE RULES WILL BE BANNED ***

GREAT

this is a must get 9/10/10

__________________
dsa

Great

awsome quality very birght and audio is clear

__________________
dsa

AR is a lil better but I'd stick with the SVCD rls, better encoding, clearer pic. Audio has some flaws like popping in both.

V- 7

A- 7

M- ??

-SP

Fantastic 4

yeah big improvement here video is same as FCR which is quite decent but the audio is much better nice and crisp not that awful hiss at certain parts .


Video 9
Audio 8 maybe 8.5
Movie 7


Movie starts too quick , big boring middle , then ends couldnt get into it still good special effects tho.


bigsluyky

Where is the thread for the original Telecine?

I feel like I've had the Jedi Mind Trick done to me. 10 comments, but noboy can read them? They certainly have an impact on this release, as it's a "Proper" of that one.

FUCKing cool.


8/10/0 based on jpeg sample only.





::EDIT:: Just because you're a regular you don't have an automatic right to turn your fucking brain off!! Firstly, since when was it ok to rate based on the jpeg sample and how the cunt could you rate the audio from a jpeg? Well done, Poindexter - NS::

The video quality of this release is fantastic, but the audio is worse than the cam versions. I give this release a 9/4/8

the audio gets out of syn for a lil bit at the 67 mark. video clarity however is great. i give this a 9/5/7

quote:

---

Originally posted by T-H-E-W-H-O
based on jpeg sample only. [/B]

---

can't see why a proper the first TC was fine for me, and the AR was barely noticable.

not needed proper

this is an not needed proper since u cant notice the AR change w/o tools and the cropping of -svcd is perfect
also the video and audio of this release is WAY lesser than the -svcd release, so no reason at all to grab this proper, grab the -svcd

video OK, just a little dark
8/10

audio poor, if its not CAM audio, I'm a monkeys uncle
4/10

just watched it, and was passable, kinda like X-Men, first one was just to set up the sequel really
6/10

tN

I liked the other version better

I redid the sound in fuck's release, stole audio from svcd's second cd.. CHECK YOUR RLS BFR U RLS.. dumbass' when are they ever gonna learn.. I give this a 8/5/6
5 for audio cuz its fucked, 6 for movie cuz it wasnt all that great.. need a rpk should be here soon.. hopefully they arnt lazy..
http://perso.wanadoo.fr/world.of.sigma/snes-megaman%20x3-gold%20megaman%20slashing%20sword.gif

__________________
/me farts

This release reportedly goes out of sync @ 6:25 - not sure about that, but it might be true.

well this has been nuked due to sync issues....... i didnt bother to get this, so cant comment..... but if its been nuked why is everyone saying how great it is???

__________________
One Day The Dead Shall Walk The Earth.

quote:

---

Originally posted by T-H-E-W-H-O
FUCKing cool.


8/10/0 based on jpeg sample only.





::EDIT:: Just because you're a regular you don't have an automatic right to turn your fucking brain off!! Firstly, since when was it ok to rate based on the jpeg sample and how the cunt could you rate the audio from a jpeg? Well done, Poindexter - NS::

---

__________________
One Day The Dead Shall Walk The Earth.

Watched it through audio goes out of sync for 15 seconds at the most this is well worth the dl.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Hairyhamster
well this has been nuked due to sync issues....... i didnt bother to get this, so cant comment..... but if its been nuked why is everyone saying how great it is???

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Hairyhamster
LMAO........ 10/10 FOR AUDIO FROM A JPEG...

THATS MADE MY DAY........ TIME FOR A BEER ME THINKS!

OH P.S... SOMEONE ELSE HAS RATED AUDIO AS A 10..... WAS THAT FROM THE JPEG AS WELL????.... MUST HAVE BEEN COS IF YOU GIVE THAT 10 FOR AUDIO YOU NEED A HEARING AID ME OLD PAL

---

video' s the best I' ve seen this far from all f4 releases. Shame about the audio problems.

9/5/6

V - 9
A - 7.5
M - 6

Video was good and bright, audio improved but still has some hissing and pops....

video on this one is better and nice..audio is straight cam..or maybe only mono...but its jacked..and sounded like shit in my surround sound even with EQ adjustments just wouldn't work...guess I'll hope for a proper proper...or something.

9/4/8 movie was ok...and nice release...good telecine.

__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...

9/7/7




hint:darkness

__________________
dsa

lol NS, i was kidding.

whats with these Fantastic 4 releases, they have like the same crappy audio source. isn't getting decent audio the easy part? This audio is worse then the worst audio i can remember in a real telesync let alone a telecine. What kinda crap is that, they can get direct video and no good direct audio. Headphone jack broken? hehe

__________________
In the land of the blind, the one eyed man is King.

BLAH BLAH BLAH

Whats with all the negetivity??? This is a great RLS. Audio isn't the greatest but I'm sure they tried. Most of us here only DL and its fucked up the only thing I see people contributing is bitching!! Maybe we should be a little more appreciative because beggers cant be choosers. TO who ever released it, just brush da haters off and keep those great rls comming

V8.5/A7.5/M7.5

A/V out of sync for 15-30 sec but recovers

Here's a simple clarification. The silver that was bought was an Asian TC. You can tell when the credits kick in, and the names are read aloud. The reason this release desyncs is because there is a scene in it that is not the same as the US theatrical version. This scene occurs when Sue Storm coerces Reed Richards to take a break from his research. Instead of taking him down to the dock where he first asked her out (or vice-versa), the movie cuts to a planetarium scene. There is no English audio for this scene available (the audio used in this TC release was used from the TS released a few days earlier). However, the movie goes back in sync after this scene.

8/5/crap

slightly lesser quality as the svcd, can't imagine how this is a "proper"

Audio is GAWD AWFUL!!!! and out of freaking sync!!!

but the audio on the jpeg deservs a 10!

Now, I'm a network tech, and fairly pc savy, but how the FUCK to you attatch sound to a jpeg?

.

quote:

---

Whats with all the negetivity??? This is a great RLS. Audio isn't the greatest but I'm sure they tried. Most of us here only DL and its fucked up the only thing I see people contributing is bitching!!

---

__________________
And it appears Burt Reynolds has changed his name to Turd Furgeson.

That's right, it's a funny name

I don't know what movie you guys are watching but what I'm viewing right now isn't what you're talking about...

Video - an easy 10...amazing...

Audio - hard to rate because of the asian source...but I'd give it a 7

Movie - 9 fun as fuck

This release is sweet though because the asian version is in fact different from the US version, so we get to see extra scenes, diffferent camera shots, all that good shit...but at the expense of the audio not syncing...

Still, the video quality is as close to DVD as you'll probably get.

__________________
"Girls kick ass...it says so on the T-Shirt."
-Max

"There are those who said this day would never come...what are they to say now?"