VCDQuality Forums - The Lord Of The Rings *VCD* - SCREENER

Show all 35 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- The Lord Of The Rings *VCD* - SCREENER - WVF (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=288)

Posted by X69 on 01-20-2002 09:47 PM:

In order to post on the new comments syste you will have to register.. You only have to register once.. so ya might as well do it now.. all new comments will be this way.. i know.. alot of you dont like it.. but it's gonna be better in the long run..
-X69

Posted by nsj00001 on 01-20-2002 09:55 PM:

VCD Is good but not as good as SVCD

Hi Hi

Posted by NeWcS on 01-20-2002 10:37 PM:

hhhhmmmmm, Guess its a good idea.

I'll stick to the DVD eeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrr SVCD

Posted by Crispy23 on 01-20-2002 10:46 PM:

SVCDs and VCDs

some people may or may not have the ability to play SVCDS... i
personally am glad that this was released... and im glad it was reencoded to Mpeg-1..

thanks WVF!!

looks like the nfo is dated wrong.. this just came out today right?

Posted by Josep on 01-20-2002 11:20 PM:

you can convert svcd's to vcd's anyway numb nuts! then combine the files and put them on to 2 cds, that is for the dvd svcd rip that you are talking about, your just too lazy if your not going to reencode a hella good quality movie from tcf

Posted by MovieLord on 01-20-2002 11:36 PM:

Re: SVCDs and VCDs

quote:
Originally posted by Crispy23
some people may or may not have the ability to play SVCDS... i
personally am glad that this was released... and im glad it was reencoded to Mpeg-1..

Please don't steer people wrong it's very annoying

ANYBODY who has a computer and a decent video card can watch SVCD'S!

JUST DOWNLOAD WINDVD and then, get the crack from Astalavista!

And enjoy!

BTW, Josep, converting a SVCD to VCD is like changing water to vinegar!

We don't want that now do we?

Posted by NeRo on 01-20-2002 11:58 PM:

WTF is going On??

You guys aren't even making sense with what you're sayin damn, just comment on how fuckin good the movie is or not. Lord Of the Rings looks absolutely OUTSTANDING - fuck everything else you hear. I burned this movie, played it on my dvd player and it blew everyone that saw it over my house away. The shit looks as good as a real dvd. I mean GO DL THIS SHIT NOW if you haven't done it already. I don's why I see ppl talking about they don't want to get a svcd and how a dvd version is what they are waiting for, then you got a guy that doesn't even know when it got released, then you got ppl that don't even know a svcd is. WOW these must be the ppl that have no clue about the scene, and no clue about anything. You rookies need to do sum more research or somethin cause you're embarassing yourselves. This is a great svcd and I mean GREAT. Don't judge pics, don't judge what somebody else said, you gotta get this, burn this, and play it on your dvd player and damn, your mouth will be open and that's the truth.

Posted by X69 on 01-21-2002 12:02 AM:

Re: WTF is going On??

quote:
Originally posted by NeRo
You guys aren't even making sense with what you're sayin damn, just comment on how fuckin good the movie is or not. Lord Of the Rings looks absolutely OUTSTANDING - fuck everything else you hear. I burned this movie, played it on my dvd player and it blew everyone that saw it over my house away. The shit looks as good as a real dvd. I mean GO DL THIS SHIT NOW if you haven't done it already. I don's why I see ppl talking about they don't want to get a svcd and how a dvd version is what they are waiting for, then you got a guy that doesn't even know when it got released, then you got ppl that don't even know a svcd is. WOW these must be the ppl that have no clue about the scene, and no clue about anything. You rookies need to do sum more research or somethin cause you're embarassing yourselves. This is a great svcd and I mean GREAT. Don't judge pics, don't judge what somebody else said, you gotta get this, burn this, and play it on your dvd player and damn, your mouth will be open and that's the truth.

lol.. you says this is a great svcd? welp.. your commenting on the VCD release..
-X69

Posted by NeRo on 01-21-2002 12:02 AM:

OOPS

It seems that a new group has released a nasty lookin version of LOTR. I didn't even see that. The version I was talking about was The Lord Of The Rings *DVD* *SVCD* by the great group TCF. Sorry about that but most of what I said still stands. heh

Posted by dumwaldo on 01-21-2002 12:07 AM:

i just had to register and add my $0.02

this release hits new levels of lameness. this is pathetic. anybody with a half of a brain has the ability to find www.vcdhelp.com and convert the SVCD themself. thats all this is is A RE-ENCODING OF THE SVCD!!!

in their annoying nfo the feebly claim that it was encoded from the same source as the SVCD but the disc count seems to be to high for some reason. could it be because all the did was run the SVCD through TMPGEnc? if this were encoded from the same source it would have been 3 CD's like the SVCD should have been.

message to the 3 pathetic lamers that call themself WVF...
in your nfo it says "We arent really a group that releases VCDs" well keep it that way.

incidentally if you arent a group that releases VCDs why are you called World Vcd Federation?

__________________
what the hell do i know, i watch my movies on a 2.2" screen.

"pho est wonderful!" "pho est wonderful!" really, he is

Posted by NeRo on 01-21-2002 12:10 AM:

dumwaldo....

hey dumwaldo, you had me laughin man, I completely agree man. I saw this release like what tha fuck?

Posted by numbnutz on 01-21-2002 12:14 AM:

joke?

sounds like a bad joke. the first release is the only release, if you dont have a clue how to play a svcd to bad.

Posted by eST0r on 01-21-2002 12:15 AM:

You get the fuckin point?

I do also think it was pointless, but still they're out there helping people that don't have dvd players/capibility to use it, even if it's BS, who fucking cares a rip a damn rip... besides, If one of you got the right to do it, I bet you would

Posted by ArchdemoN on 01-21-2002 01:23 AM:

The VCD was not at all pointless, it was converted quite well with minimal loss of quality, i saw both versions, they looked very similar.

The TCF version was dvd quality.
The WWV version is above VHS quality, and sound is perfect.
there is loss of quality, bcz the SVCD was 2100Bitrate, this one was 1500, if i remember correctly...

also, playing on your pc, holding 4CD is a real pain, gr8 work on the conversion.

also:
download a sample, don't rate this on a jpg image.

Posted by Josep on 01-21-2002 02:53 AM:

who really cares, either way its not like wvf is violating any laws against tcf, they can do whatever they want, and if they get recognition for it then fine, they are a group, and the whole mixing water and vinager thingy from svcd to vcd, its not that bad of a change, i have 8 cds of it, one set in svcd, and one set in vcd, haven't tried the svcd out yet though...

Posted by Vyrrus on 01-21-2002 03:26 AM:

When I got LOTR SVCD first thing I did was reencode it to VCD (my panasonic 5 disc wont read SVCD and I'm too lazy to get up and change cd's) and it still looks great...guess I shoulda called myself a release group and dropped it to distro and got my 15 mins of IRC fame....least i did combine mine and split them into 3 CDs (for anyone contempulating this..the [S]VCD combines seamlessly TCF did a great job all around on it...even the editing)

Posted by rodney on 01-21-2002 03:36 AM:

release isnt bad, should get the svcd release though.

Posted by Hitman47 on 01-21-2002 04:06 AM:

umm

the only way i woulda thot this was a TAD better, if it was at least 1 cd less... but its not.. pointless... newbies only

Posted by bret on 01-21-2002 06:57 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by Vyrrus
When I got LOTR SVCD first thing I did was reencode it to VCD (my panasonic 5 disc wont read SVCD and I'm too lazy to get up and change cd's) and it still looks great...guess I shoulda called myself a release group and dropped it to distro and got my 15 mins of IRC fame....least i did combine mine and split them into 3 CDs (for anyone contempulating this..the [S]VCD combines seamlessly TCF did a great job all around on it...even the editing)

How did you reencode it? My set top won't play the SVCD either. . .

Posted by RenAndStimpy on 01-21-2002 03:05 PM:

WHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"some people don't know how to play a svcd"
WHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!

if you don't know how to play a svcd you should kill yourself. And this version SUCKS LIKE HELL. The fucked up the great svcd!!

""Still rolling on the floor""""

Posted by AZiZ on 01-21-2002 09:50 PM:

not the best though, but ok

well the SVCD is MUCH MUCH Better

Posted by vorfeed on 01-22-2002 05:01 AM:

omfg, haha, svcd->vcd conversion, still 4 cd's, so very gay, hahahahaha

TCF svcd 0wned my standalone, the SVCD scene is big enough that VCD dupes are no longer needed

what's next ? i gonna start seeing DALnet vcd->divx conversions on here ?

Posted by Outrage_Display on 01-22-2002 05:05 AM:

Props to you for the conversion, for those who are not as fortunate as others. Could have merged and recut the movie into 3 cds

Posted by 31337-d00d on 01-22-2002 07:19 AM:

th1$ i$ 14M3 $h17 !

Posted by dumwaldo on 01-22-2002 12:37 PM:

i just looked over the forum at isonews and i would like to recind my previous statements. apparently they were right when they said "Due to the fact that all you noobies and leeches have no idea how to view a SVCD properly.".

i am sorry for casting aspursions on your fine group as i can now see that a pound of ignorance is easier to find than an ounce of knowledge. keep on hand holding for the masses, its a much better option that expecting people to be able to do things for themself.

but still shame on you for trying to claim it was from the same source when it obviously is just a re-encode of the SVCD.

Vyrrus
apparently yes all you have to do is re-encode SVCD's and you are a group. maybe we should both grab the new tupak SVCD and re-encode it so we can have a race to see who's "group" is better... ROTFLOL

__________________
what the hell do i know, i watch my movies on a 2.2" screen.

"pho est wonderful!" "pho est wonderful!" really, he is

Posted by Memnock on 01-22-2002 12:43 PM:

VCD release is good

There are some stand alone DVD players that will play VCD but not SVCD, my friend has a Sony model that is like that. I tried playing a SVCD on it and it would not play it so I had to convert it to regular VCD for him and then it played it perfectly.

So please don't say that there's no need for this release. Some people don't know how to convert SVCD to regular VCD that might need to. It's a lengthy process (expecially for 4 CDs) so I say the release is welcome.

And that's all I gotta say about that.

Posted by NeoCverA on 01-22-2002 02:22 PM:

uhh testing

just trying to see what people are saying of the DUPE

Posted by justinmaurer on 01-23-2002 07:32 AM:

lol...

These boys just want attention thats all...

Man if i wanted attention too I would reencode a LOTR...haha

waste of time for them if ya ask me...but if your too lazy to download the svcd and reecode your own I guess its a good bet.

This group only did two things right. Reencode the file, and distribute it to lazy ppl.
Therefore I rate this a 2 since tcf did all the work.

Posted by bret on 01-23-2002 09:11 AM:

and still no one has said how to reencode the flick, all you've done is either bitch that it was reencoded and released, or called the folks who don't know how to reencode it stupid. I guess that how you all became "1337"?

Posted by xpitxbullx on 01-23-2002 09:22 AM:

I made it a 3 CD VCD by taking running vcdgear v3 and and choosing mpeg>mpeg (I copied it from the cd's I burned of the SVCD) then I used TMPEGEnc and ran the mpeg tools. De-multiplixed (extracted just the audio). Then Changed the settings to Video CD NTSC. Loaded the mpeg for the video. Loaded the mp2 for the audio and re-encoded.

It may have been the long way but the job got done and I was left with a damnn good VCD Screener rip from the SVCD.

Posted by dumwaldo on 01-23-2002 09:23 AM:

i guess you missed this...

quote:
Originally posted by dumwaldo
anybody with a half of a brain has the ability to find www.vcdhelp.com and convert the SVCD themself.

if you want to live to be 1337 years old the first thing you need to do is read before you speak. if thats not enough help perhaps you should just go download the WVF copy.

__________________
what the hell do i know, i watch my movies on a 2.2" screen.

"pho est wonderful!" "pho est wonderful!" really, he is

Posted by bret on 01-23-2002 09:56 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by xpitxbullx
I made it a 3 CD VCD by taking running vcdgear v3 and and choosing mpeg>mpeg (I copied it from the cd's I burned of the SVCD) then I used TMPEGEnc and ran the mpeg tools. De-multiplixed (extracted just the audio). Then Changed the settings to Video CD NTSC. Loaded the mpeg for the video. Loaded the mp2 for the audio and re-encoded.

It may have been the long way but the job got done and I was left with a damnn good VCD Screener rip from the SVCD.

THANK YOU! Sincerely, from the bottom of every n00b's heart. This is a fantastic start, at the very least. You'll get a la-z-boy in the afterlife for this . . .

Posted by bret on 01-23-2002 10:04 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by dumwaldo
i guess you missed this...
if you want to live to be 1337 years old the first thing you need to do is read before you speak. if thats not enough help perhaps you should just go download the WVF copy.

I did. vcdhelp is a great source of information. My complaint is that people are bashing this so much without offering up direct solutions, aside from ambiguous links to websites.
Example: vcdhelp.com versus http://www.vcdhelp.com/tmpgenc.htm,. That doesn't make any sense to me. At least xpitxbullx was willing to shed some info on what he did to convert it.

I don't want to sound like an idiot or an asshole with this, really. I would have liked to see someone say "Hey, this release is lame, all you need to do if you stand alone won't play svcd is get x program and do this."

I don't think it would have violated any rules regarding the forum, and it probably would have cut the amount of posts in half. Also, it could have shown people how to play around with various encoding programs. For example, TMPEGenc. "Hey, I converted LotR to vcd using this, maybe I can convert a DivX flick with this. . .
It would have just been a better way, I think. . .I could be wrong of course. . .

Posted by justinmaurer on 01-24-2002 01:20 AM:

jeez...

If you are that clueless on making vcds you should be posting in a forum at say maybe??? vcdhelp.com?

If you are really that lazy and not able to search and look it up for yourself on how to do it thats just pathetic..

This is just the place for comments about the movie not about how to reecode the movie.

Read at the top where it says VCD Comments

Posted by tOny_bOgs on 01-24-2002 08:17 AM:

CD1!?!?!?!?!!?!?!!?!?!?!

can ne1 get cd1 to extract???? all the others r fine but cd1 wont extract in winRAR..ne help would be appreciated..
bOgs_Out

All times are GMT. The time now is 10:13 PM.

Show all 35 posts from this thread on one page