VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- I Robot *SVCD* *PROPER* - TELECINE - SKF (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=45990)

damn i understand the nuke for the amount of disks but damn those are some harsh words towards TUN in the nfo

well another new group. and they really don't like TuN. i diden't watch much of it maybe 2 min of it on my lunch break. anyway video is alot nicer the tuns and sound is good to little more sharp.
i think thats enough rls of this movie till dvdr


8/8/7

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!

Agreed. Sure this is a better release .. but i'm happy with the original TS. Nice job though

8/8/9

ya if you got the ts theres no reason to get this
8/8/7

__________________

Well said Miller, and the .nfo reasons for proper are obvious and fair.
8/9/8 (The Fresh Prince suprised me on this one)

how does this compare to centropy's?

7/7


wtf is this about "original pirated DVD" ?
lol

as far as i concern then its a reencode of a DVD TC

so why are they bitchin about a reencode of TUN?

7/8/x

I too am happy with the TS, but this is a pretty good TC.

__________________

quote:

---

Originally posted by poobread
how does this compare to centropy's?

---

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!

Another Waste of Time, Space, and Bandwidth. Compair TUN vs this Copy. Sure TUN was 3 CD's but this looks like shit. im not a huge fan of TUN but ill take TUN's copy over this anyday.

Avoid:
6/8/6

__________________
All the excitement of a trip to hell with none of the negitive side affects!

Finally. A proper that is worse than the rls its propering. God I love that. Great job SFK or SKF or whoever the hell you are. Morons.

5/5/1 - Silly movie with too much advertising.

quote:

---

Originally posted by zangano
7/7


wtf is this about "original pirated DVD" ?
lol

as far as i concern then its a reencode of a DVD TC

so why are they bitchin about a reencode of TUN?

---

__________________

The wise man does not play leap frog with unicorns...

[QUOTE]Originally posted by tr1pp1n
[B]shut the fuck up please, idiot.



ok everyone take a chill pill b4 they have to post the rules again

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!

nice release, but a little late... good movie too... at least i thought so. lol

7/8/9

waste of time..if you have the telesync or the tun re-encoded tc ( like I give a f..k it was good enough) there is no need for this until a dvdrip-dvdr.

7/8/8 not enough difference to download full release.

__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...

This is a good release, but like others have said, if you already have TuN's release, you might as well stick with that. However, METEOR has released a DVDR version of the movie with great video quality and AC3 sound, if you haven't noticed quite yet.

i agree with the above post. I really don't care if TUN's was some "russian reencoded blah blah durpa durpa". It was fine this really is just a waste of bandwidth if you already have TUN's.

Also, if this SKF group has the "true" sources then, will they step up and proper METEOR's DVD-R of I, Robot? If that, too, was also a reencoded xvid, as they seem to claim.

Still have to rate though on the release... despite it not being needed

If it is truly their source and not some clean-up of TUN's (who knows nowadays?):

8.5/9/9

Waste of bandwidth if you have TUN's/METEOR DVD-R/etc... but if it's there and you still have the Centropy TS... your choice.

Nice flaming in the nfo SKF, but encoding Meteor's TC to SVCD and releasing it like its your own? LMAO, thats just as bad.

This 'PROPER' is not needed unless you really want the TC on 2 SVCD's and not 3.

8/9/8. Nice quality, but so was the DVDR

hmm

was this movie worth it? worth all the drama?

dope flame in nfo, cause TUN is crap for what they do as of late...

whether this came from Meteor , i doubt it. prolly came from the same flea market that they got it from, thats true.

if anyone watches how things rls, one would assume TUN, Meteor and MoF all work together since they rls same thing and bout same times in order.


anyhow. shit is lame to flame, this wasnt even needed, the CTP rls was more than enough for this terrible terrible sci fi movie, if you didnt figure out it was the girl robot the first 30 mins in, i feel sorry for you.

video = 7 ....you people are just as bad as TUN, sidebars are easy
to clip if you know how to encode.

audio = 7 ...still not dts decoded, CTP TS was but this is just direct
sound...yawn.

movie = 4 ...its ok, nothing great in no way.


good for a new grp, specially being able to tackle another grp like that....nice rls, cause of the cd sizes, hope to see more earlier.

groups bashing groups whats new anyways tihs wasn't needed tun did a good job

__________________
A Movie Ain't A Movie With Out Some TITTYS
http://www.actressarchives.com/display.php?g=elisha&img=ec1542.jpg

less top and bottom cropping, but fuck it. not worth the bw wasteage. lookd the same as tuns and thats all im saying

7/9/9

Pic is still stretched a little, same with the other TC releases. I'll stick with the TS. Just say no to Bad AR.

i have metor's dvdr cos i couldnt be arsed with changing cd's for the tun release. it looks about the same, and theres no need for all the group bashing that goes on, i think people should just leave tun alone or do better themselfs, this is about the same.

7/8/8

I'd say this is an invalid proper. The only mistake TUN did, was making it 3 cd's. This XViD .ru p2p crap, well about that i couldn't care less, becasue the TUN video quality beats this crap anyday.

__________________
ProVoKaTioN

quote:

---

enough for this terrible terrible sci fi movie, if you didnt figure out it was the girl robot the first 30 mins in, i feel sorry for you

---

A nice rls, but I actually prefer the 5.1 treatment and aspect ratio of the new group METEOR DVDR rls...Very Clean pic a tad washed out and much cleaner audio..This PROPER would have been great if I hadn't already watched the CTP and METEOR rls's...Enjoy!!

quote:

---

A nice rls, but I actually prefer the 5.1 treatment and aspect ratio of the new group METEOR DVDR rls

---

8/8/8

but if u hav the videocd rls.....id stick with it until retail dvd

__________________
HOLLA AT YO BOY!

sorry i meant Centropy

__________________
HOLLA AT YO BOY!

Looks worse than the TUN release and has the exact same aspect ratio error AND the bars on the left and right. Okay release but should be nuked just for trying to call it a proper.

Video:7
Audio: 8
Movie: good enough I guess.

i dont really care for telecines anymore, but wth..

8/9/8

and pimpzta e-gangster whatever, there IS an edit button

__________________
I AM USING THE INTRANET!

first posting on vcdquality.com

awesome site btw

anyways, yeah this release wasnt needed but as it was mentioned earlier at least there is groups willing to put forth the effort to put releases out for us, so i guess its ok in the long run

as for me i have the centropy release, and it was great, watched the movie and i liked it, i didnt LOVE it but it was a good summer movie.

i give it 7/8/8

Now i am just waiting for a dvd rip or screener and lock it away in my vault of releases lately lol

This is uneeded really, i mean the the screener will probably be here soon. Stick with te TUN release.

7/7/9

quote:

---

This is uneeded really, i mean the the screener will probably be here soon. Stick with te TUN release.

---

*sample judge*
good effort, picture looks a little pinched.
late as hell, but appreciated.
for tc: 6.5/8/8

__________________
fuckinggoogleit.com
"The power of accurate observation is commonly called cynicism by those who have not got it."
-George Bernard Shaw
I like proof!

First off, Hi to everyone on the board, this is my first post.

secondly...Just near the end of getting this release now, ill edit my post shortly when i playback this on my standalone DVD player. To anyone who doesnt have any copy of the film yet i feel this might be the best SVCD copy to get, but we'll see.

EDIT:

Ok, well after watching this lastnite on the standalone, i'll comment on the quality...

Sound was fine, no problems whatsoever.

Picture was a little steched, nothng major and becomes almost unnoticable.

The colours seemed a little washed out but again, great picture Q for a telecine.

This rls includes all of the credits.

There a slight colour flicker i noticed once during the elevator scene.

overall good rls. 8/8/7

I like this movie, just a treat for the eye nothng more!

Don't think it should be nuked

This release is not useless. Ignoring the groups wars for a minute I don't think there is anything wrong with this release. Yes the quality is about the same as the TUN release but the fact is, this is a 2 cd release unlike the 2.5 cd TUN release. Whatever your opinions of TUN and SKF, if you don't have a decent I Robot, clearly the SKF is the best SVCD choice at the moment......