VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- DIVX (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=23)
-- Star Wars Episode III Revenge of the Sith *XviD* - TELECINE - MoF (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=63155)

Its cropped, with a bad aspect ratio. Picture is way too dark. Here is before/after picture when i was trying to salvage this release.

http://img222.echo.cx/my.php?image=tweak2ls.jpg

7/9/7

sample is nice, looks like a true TC..I just hope this comes out in other formats.

great job MoF

9/9/10

Judging from sample it's a kickass!

9/9/10

Yes. Definitely MoF has shown us again what they can do. And hey, it's and XviD too

9/9/?

Isnt this version the source for the TUN SVCD release?

:-)

Looks nice

v-9
a-9
m-8

very nice only thing i can say bad about it is that it's too dark

other then that great release

quote:

---

Originally posted by overstayer
Isnt this version the source for the TUN SVCD release?

:-)

---

CDRS Is a telecine, with stolen video source from TUN and a fake 5.1 soundtrack, does that sound familiar anyone?

quote:

---

-={EtHErZ}=- CDRS Is a telecine, with stolen video source from TUN and a fake 5.1 soundtrack, does that sound familiar anyone?

---

Good rip however I have noticed some syncing problems near the end of the film. The video is about 1sec behind the voice.

Overall good rip 9/7/10 (watch it at the cinemas for best experience)

from the beginning of cd2 its out of sync and its same quality as the tun rerip release only differance is tuns is in sync, this is most definatly not

vid 7
audio 5
mov 8

Impressive Quality, enjoyed every second and had no problems what so ever.

This is a sure 9/9/9

kickass MoF!

Is this release plagued by those dreaded sync problems too? It looks very nice in all other aspects.

Does this have the Russian or English crawl at the start of the movie?

I know its no big surprise what the beginning text says but it would be nice to be able to read it

Q=8
S=7 sync probs for me
M=10

Its a nice movie and a nice TC, but i would personally like the whole movie with russian subs so i could use my own subs with black bars, the text from my sub should remove the russians and when there is no sub i would get the whole pic.

Have seen it on the big screen, so I can wait for it.

Just my oppinion

quote:

---

Originally posted by johto
Its cropped, with a bad aspect ratio. Picture is way too dark. Here is before/after picture when i was trying to salvage this release.

http://img222.echo.cx/my.php?image=tweak2ls.jpg

7/9/7

---

__________________
What is love?......baby don't hurt me.....don't hurt me......no more.

hmm, first time I've commented in the divx section.

sync probs fixed with xbmc on the fly picture quality ok, not the best of telecines, relatively undefined and no-where near dvd quality. Sound has slight hiss to it but other than that it's fine. Cropping is quite noticable.

All things considered though, considering it's only been out just over a week this is a pretty top notch copy.

v7 - Gamma can be fixed, cropping can't
a5 - Clean, mostly in sync, but MONO
m8 - Still not evil enough

quote:

---

Originally posted by johto
Its cropped, with a bad aspect ratio. Picture is way too dark. Here is before/after picture when i was trying to salvage this release.

http://img222.echo.cx/my.php?image=tweak2ls.jpg

7/9/7

---

__________________
tis edimus

quote:

---

Originally posted by edimus
How infact did you tweak up the brightness?
Im abit of a noob when it comes to editing

cheers

---

No Audio :(

I'm having trouble with getting the audio to even play. I installed divx and xvid codec and windows media is giving the unable to download appropriate decompressor. Suggestions?

star wars 3

top quality Xvid seen disk 1 and 2 and look and sound superb keeep up the good work guys pic 9 sound 9 movie 9

Re: No Audio :(

quote:

---

Originally posted by FozzieWak
I'm having trouble with getting the audio to even play. I installed divx and xvid codec and windows media is giving the unable to download appropriate decompressor. Suggestions?

---

Re: No Audio :(

quote:

---

Originally posted by FozzieWak
I'm having trouble with getting the audio to even play. I installed divx and xvid codec and windows media is giving the unable to download appropriate decompressor. Suggestions?

---

__________________

quote:

---

Originally posted by neo_tokyo
i wonder who's teh retard here..

---

There is slight out of sync during the second cd, it only lasts couple minutes, then it goes back to sync.

quote:

---

Originally posted by johto
There is slight out of sync during the second cd, it only lasts couple minutes, then it goes back to sync.

---

__________________

quote:

---

Originally posted by neo_tokyo
i wonder who's teh retard here..

---

same as TUN

Same source as TUN's TC SVCD -- still red, still cropped, still russian crawl.

6/7/9

Video - 6 - i hate cropping worse than anything. redness is easily fixable with a few color correction filters, a tiny bit dark.
Audio - 7 - i had no sync issues, contrary to other people's claims here.. played fine in wmp/wmpclassic/xbmc. sound is pretty good, but I didn't notice more than one distinct channel... is it mono?
Movie - 9 - one of the best SW movies to date.

all in all a fairly good release, it's quite watchable. if you haven't already, do yourself a favor and see it in theaters first. it's worth it if you're a fan.

Please, someone with a new source?

__________________
... n1ckn4m3

How can anyone give the audio on this release anything above a 5? It baffles the mind. Are you guys deaf? Can no one hear that horrible audio hiss?

used mainconcept h.264 encoder to convert this and dvd maestro to dvd, looks and sounds stunning!

great release

9/9/9

Based on the fact that i have seen this movie on the big screen in theatres, i would definately rate this release lower than the ratings it has been given.

6.5 Video - The picture is SO dark that almost all of the background scenes are not viewable and many of the faces are just shadows. At the point where Palpatine and Anakin **SPOILER REMOVED** i could not even see Palpatine. The end scenes when Anakin becomes ****** is almost black which is a very important scene.
Its also cropped.

6 Audio - The hiss almost makes me want to kill myself.

8.6 Good movie that shouldn't be ruined watching a bad release. Go see it in theatres.

What happened to the days of early DVD SCRNRS ?

hmmm

from the sample it looks like a really good copy...im not good at re encoding no matter how many times i've tried.lol. is it same audio as workprint or the mono audio?im just asking because i dont really have a chance to download the entire thing for a long while....

quote:

---

Originally posted by johto
I'm not sure if i should bother to explain, but here it goes in short:

This whole tweaking needs re-encoding the video. Because of this, depending on the bitrate, it will always lower the picture quality some(depends what bitrate using)

Aspect ratio was corrected by lowering the resolution from 640x272 -> 640x240.

Brightnes(luma) was corrected by using Levels filters...duh.

I found that when adjusting brightnes the noise increased too. I applyed some small noise reduction too on the filter pipeline. Anyways, with these tweaks its a lot better than the origianl release.

Even though 640x272 is right aspect for this movie (2.35:1) it is fucked up because who ever encoded this, did not remember to calculate the pixel difference after cropping...thats why this release with its cropping needs to be 640x240

---

FozzieWak, change your PC monitor or Video Card settings, this looks nothing like u mentioned, all those scenes were fine for me, a little washed out looking in dark scenes, but definetly easy to see.

Audio is only Mono though, which sucks for a Star Wars film, you could edit this and the WP together, by taking the Opening titles and sound from the WP, it works fine, but is an absoulute nightmare to do and i wouldnt recommend it, the audio part i mean.

8/6/9

10/9/8

VIDEO: I've got all the various releases of ROTS and this is the best so far. It has the sharpest video of all current releases... including ViSA's WP release. It's obvious that this is NOT a re-encode of the TUN release. It is a rip direct from the original TUN source.

AUDIO: Very Good

MOVIE: Ain't Palpy the best?

GREAT JOB, MoF!

sound on cd 2 sometimes out of sync

quote:

---

Originally posted by edimus
How infact did you tweak up the brightness?
Im abit of a noob when it comes to editing

cheers

---

__________________
~Do or Do Not, There is no Try~ Yoda