VCDQuality Forums - Minority Report *SuBBeD* - TELESYNC

Show all 45 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Minority Report *SuBBeD* - TELESYNC - ASZEON (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=4297)

Posted by MovieGod on 06-22-2002 07:41 AM:

Disk 1 looks solid......getting disk 2 now...

__________________
Re-incarnated as evil overlord..

Posted by QualitySlut on 06-22-2002 07:44 AM:

The whole thing looks nice too bad about the subs. Nie release

Posted by Tacreno on 06-22-2002 07:57 AM:

Great job with the release Aszeon!

good quality too...

been waiting for this one...

~Tacreno

Posted by Storm180 on 06-22-2002 08:16 AM:

nforce.nl lists this as a nuke for bad sound...What is bad about it.Sounds good on the sample and the movie.....Not sure who the hell nuked it but ears needs to be examined.

Posted by SD187_420 on 06-22-2002 08:50 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by Storm180
nforce.nl lists this as a nuke for bad sound...What is bad about it.Sounds good on the sample and the movie.....Not sure who the hell nuked it but ears needs to be examined.

Its because lots of sites nuke shit for stupid reasons or groups hates.

Posted by Profondo Rosso on 06-22-2002 09:09 AM:

not the greatest quality but ok 6/4/9

Posted by SD187_420 on 06-22-2002 10:11 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by Profondo Rosso
not the greatest quality but ok 6/4/9

Thats one hell of an OK review.

Posted by Azrael_23 on 06-22-2002 12:32 PM:

Nice release. Personally I don't mind the subs. Nice Picture (7.5/10) didn't find any audio problems. The movie is great too.

Posted by dkkev on 06-22-2002 01:57 PM:

as representative for nforce.nl

weve nuked the movie cuz weve had several reports that it had bad sound - I havent seen the movie myself (I dont like subbed)

and it was nuked on several topsites.. so it isnt us that nukes releases... sites do that..

Posted by strawhair on 06-22-2002 03:18 PM:

getting their....

not to shabby at all-of course you willget some people complaining about the subs. but thats only to be expected. but considering this is only a day old-well done to aszeon for the ok quality. 6.5/6/8.

Posted by Profondo Rosso on 06-22-2002 03:26 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by SD187_420

Thats one hell of an OK review.

well considering FTF is usally 4/2 I think this is a decent release compare to that

Posted by Rep- on 06-22-2002 03:55 PM:

What the hell is so bad about subbs? After about 2 minutes, I don't even notice them.

Posted by Storm180 on 06-22-2002 03:55 PM:

Re: as representative for nforce.nl

quote:
Originally posted by dkkev
weve nuked the movie cuz weve had several reports that it had bad sound - I havent seen the movie myself (I dont like subbed)

and it was nuked on several topsites.. so it isnt us that nukes releases... sites do that..

I realize that you dont nuke the releases you just go by what your sites you use as reference for releases and nukes and so on. We howvever know that alot of nukers are bias and obviously sometimes have real bad hearing (obviously in this case). Then it just filters down from there and everyone else nukes it. So if the nuker actually does read this forum, I would like to ask WTF and you should get those speakers on your computer fixed so you cant hear movie releases better.

Posted by toohey on 06-22-2002 05:16 PM:

maybe it was nuked cause it was missing some parts in the beginning....u don't know how much was cut off and there were people getting up during the movie.....i think i'll wait for a better version

Posted by Storm180 on 06-22-2002 05:30 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by toohey
maybe it was nuked cause it was missing some parts in the beginning....u don't know how much was cut off and there were people getting up during the movie.....i think i'll wait for a better version

The nuke reason was Bad Sound..Nothing else..

Posted by rolandtn on 06-22-2002 06:12 PM:

Welcome to the Scene

Very nice 0 day release. I gave a 7/4/9. Very nice picture quality for a TS. I can see how it may have been nuked from a few sites for sound, cause it is a little hollow, but definitely VERY watchable. Subs?? After a few minutes they are hardly noticeable. I know I could have certainly gone all day without seeing that snot come out of that guys nose in the sample

Posted by devilbeast on 06-22-2002 07:55 PM:

Decent release from CD1, i think im gonna wait for another rls and compare contrast em and then see which i want.

Posted by DeathsHead on 06-22-2002 11:13 PM:

I wasn't that impressed with this release. The sound echoed way to much for my taste, although I compensated for it. On my 20 foot crt projection system the picture looked like crap. I only watched about the first 5 minutes, but decided not to ruin the movie by watching this release of it. I'll wait for a better release. If one doesn't come out soon I will pay to see this movie in theater.

Posted by bust0ne on 06-22-2002 11:35 PM:

sound is pretty bad, and not shown in the pic is are the bars on the sides of the screen. widescreen is cool with me, but wtf is the use of these?

Posted by dcm386 on 06-23-2002 12:02 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by bust0ne
sound is pretty bad, and not shown in the pic is are the bars on the sides of the screen. widescreen is cool with me, but wtf is the use of these?

Umm.. are you using WMP to play it or something??

Posted by bust0ne on 06-23-2002 02:27 AM:

hmmm... played fucked up in wmp, but is ok in winDVD. sound still sucks, picture is watchable.

Posted by captain howdy on 06-23-2002 04:57 AM:

It just isnt watchable sound is hollow picture is grainy Ill wait for a better release

Posted by scottymac on 06-23-2002 05:49 AM:

quote:
crt projection system

Huh? How can it be a Cathode Ray Tube and a projection system?

__________________
What stinks?

Oh, it's just JC

Posted by SickMusic on 06-23-2002 04:15 PM:

Question

am i the only one who sees a P on the screen.i looked at the jpg but there wasn't a p there.so am i like the only one with it?

Posted by Naughty_Sauce on 06-23-2002 04:43 PM:

5/5/9

Great movie. This release is watchable, but I'm glad I saw it at the theater first.

The sides of the screen are cropped (which is understandable of course). Picture is grainy and dull, but not as blurry as a lot of VCD releases. Audio sounds alright. Not great, but I didn't have to strain to hear anything.

I'm just nitpicking here.

Thanks ASZEON.

Posted by Naughty_Sauce on 06-23-2002 05:54 PM:

I just wanted to add that the very beginning of the movie is missing in this release. It's not much (just some quick flashes of Howard Marks murdering his wife and her lover), but I just thought I'd point that out. I think I also noticed the movie skipping ahead a few seconds every once in a while. No biggie.

Posted by Bartolomy on 06-23-2002 09:01 PM:

picture is ok, the sound could have been better but nevertheless a great job for this fast release.
thanks

Posted by reverend on 06-24-2002 01:14 AM:

ok pic, bad sound

Well I thought the pic was certainly watchable on this one, but overall the release was let down by the sound, which was too metallic and made it difficult to enjoy the movie. Consequently I only watched as far as the end of disc 1. I hope for a better version soon.

Posted by misfits138 on 06-24-2002 02:00 AM:

i guess this is watchable if you're not too picky but be warned...the video quality is pretty grainy and the sound is a bit off.

Posted by crapper on 06-24-2002 03:19 PM:

picture ok
sound poor
movie runnin time to short
i think some cuts where made or somethin.. i seem to miss 2 to 5 minutes..

and well the damm subs..

great release thou..

but IF YUR NOT NEEDY wait for a better and complete one

Posted by captain howdy on 06-24-2002 04:17 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by crapper
picture ok
sound poor
movie runnin time to short
i think some cuts where made or somethin.. i seem to miss 2 to 5 minutes..

and well the damm subs..

great release thou..

but IF YUR NOT NEEDY wait for a better and complete one

When is centropy going to release this?

Posted by xdanny2002x on 06-24-2002 04:59 PM:

they are back to INTERNAL. so we will just have to wait and see if someone in the group leaks it. if it is released it will be hot.

Minority.Report.SVCD.TS-CENTROPY .

dont flame me for saying that. it might not happen.

Posted by bigfella35uk on 06-24-2002 05:33 PM:

Why do people even bother releasing stuff like this? I know, I shouldn't slag release groups cause afterall no-one else has released it yet, but the quality sucks bigtime. Deleted this one straight away, and I'll wait a few days longer for a better release.

Video 4/10
sound 5/10

film -/10 coz i can't pass comment yet till I can watch a watchable copy

BigFella

Posted by devilbeast on 06-24-2002 05:35 PM:

It'll be leaked soon i got a good ol curry friend thats cousins w/ a ctp guy. he always gets shit from what i heard its a nice rls but ya never really know.

Posted by Naughty_Sauce on 06-24-2002 09:26 PM:

reverend,

The sound quality is actually much better on the second disc. But yeah, sound on disc 1 is kinda distorted.

Posted by moviebootlegger on 06-24-2002 09:27 PM:

ahahhaha whoeva say this rls is watchable has shit for brains. this rls is really horrible! i think ftf does better!!! ahahaahahhaa these guys need to learn some basics b4 doin crappy crap like this! now how this movie vid quality get 6.0 id say its like 3.

Posted by brul on 06-24-2002 11:31 PM:

Video was passable but the sound was truly awful. I put up with it for about 20 minutes then had enough. Sometimes you couldn't even tell who was speaking during scenes where several people might have been talking at once or where there was a background conversation that wasn't meant to be heard.

Posted by Wiseblood on 06-25-2002 01:03 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by xdanny2002x
they are back to INTERNAL. so we will just have to wait and see if someone in the group leaks it. if it is released it will be hot.

Minority.Report.SVCD.TS-CENTROPY .

dont flame me for saying that. it might not happen.

and this is coming from where?

Posted by joekker on 06-25-2002 05:12 AM:

Sounds like the microphone was in a commode at the time of recording but the picture's reasonably ok (fucking blueish tint though) and the film makes up for it all.

Props to aszeon all things considered

Posted by da5park on 06-25-2002 05:49 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by brul
the sound was truly awful. I put up with it for about 20 minutes then had enough.

heh, I lasted 10mins more... 30mins before I gave up trying to figure out who was saying what

Posted by mOrg on 06-26-2002 01:28 AM:

sound quality

It has a great picture, but the sound was recorded WAY above acceptable decibel levels. There is major sound distortion through the entire movie. It sounds fine if you're sitting right next to the speakers at low volume, but when you turn it up, you can tell that it is very distorted. I am a freelance recording artist, so I work with audio equipment all the time. There IS a problem with the sound on this release.

Posted by nogana naishi on 06-26-2002 03:05 AM:

sound

So far I've only seen the first CD, but the sound was positively god-AWFUL. Did anyone here Schubert's 8th during the first few scenes? Neither did I. All I heard was my speakers making some absolutely hellish sounds. I deleted the thing almost instantly.

Bad bad bad bad...

Posted by brr8760 on 06-26-2002 05:23 AM:

And the wait for a decent version of this movie continues....... and continues.......

Posted by petrocs on 06-26-2002 07:51 PM:

Re: sound quality

quote:
Originally posted by mOrg
It has a great picture, but the sound was recorded WAY above acceptable decibel levels. There is major sound distortion through the entire movie. It sounds fine if you're sitting right next to the speakers at low volume, but when you turn it up, you can tell that it is very distorted. I am a freelance recording artist, so I work with audio equipment all the time. There IS a problem with the sound on this release.

Gee thanks genious..none of us could've guessed that the sound has a problem...maybe if we stick our head in the toilet and flush and then watch it with our left ear to the ground and our right on the left speaker tuned to 1.2345 volume we could hear it perfectly

Posted by ThEgAmE on 06-29-2002 01:07 AM:

Minority Report

This is a very bad picture and sound, but i still watched it because its free and im in the u.k and it is not even out YET!!!!!!!!!!!
Gotta see it in the cinema, wicked moviieeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!

All times are GMT. The time now is 08:22 AM.

Show all 45 posts from this thread on one page