VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Pirates Of The Caribbean - TELESYNC - TGF (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=23411)

Video : Blurry and they need to learn how to crop.

Audio : good not great but good.

Movie : this movie sucked.

wait for a better release if you're going to waist time and bandwidth..

Sound seems decent....video is a regular TS these days...

5/7/8

__________________
Drinking Vodka with Vovka!

Watchable. Good First release of this movie. Keep working TGF

5/7/?

hmm, lets see.

angle(but then again, most ts have that these days, only other groups crop them, so it isnt as obious as here)
video is a bit blurry
audio is ok, but not good.

5/4/?

nuked almost everywhere i presume?

nice and fast but sound and vidoe is not so nice... ill pass on this one. but props on being first...
4/4/?

good rls, too many damn sheep nukers out there, but it looks good.. pretty watchable.

7/5/9

only checked sample no angle as far as i could tell
they look to have sorted the sound
picture is blury and seems to jump a bit
the sample suffers from heavy picture break up at 1 point
but i think they will get there in the end
nice work tgf and why its been nuked i dont know no where else has nuked it yet

props for getting this out before anyone else picture quality needs some work but much better than some groups weve seen in past years so cheers

TGF impressing me a lot lately Legaly blond had OK VCD TS picture and crappy sound but this one is nice pic again and good sound.

YES YES i know it aint a SVCD TS and a lot of u will have critic on this release but as far as original VCD TS goes this one is very acceptable.

Keep uhm commin like this. Im sure it made a lot of people happy already.

7/8/?

I like this release. Most of the users who post here are spoilt by CTP, TCF etc releases. Well, come back down to earth for a second and stop putting all the pressure on relying on those groups to come up with the goods.

Anyway, nice release. Clean, colourful pic (besides the VERY slight tilt), good audio. Nice overall.

7/8/X

glad to see you released it despite the fact that flaming nukers still nuke it, it being a first release also, you'd think ppl wouldn't be such flamers specially since this movie came out 2 days ago... Methinks, less releases than usual because they are all nuked anyway! cept the select few of course....

very nice first release
come on ppl this is fast and clear
sure has its probs ,but its a new style of release
needs time to grow ,lets throw some possitive critcism at this and not negative
tell what needs improving not what they shouldnt bother doing
that way we can all contribute to further relases
if we throw alot of negative crap at these, we just end up with worse results
i dont say this often but a new group with a new source
very promising they got my backing

Not bad, looks ok sound is good , 6/6/6

....

Picture is real blocky, blurry and you have to really tilt your head because of the angle on it
sound is a lot better than their last rls
movie?

3/6/?

:: Don't flame people, then report a post when they flame you for it. -K::

LOOKS like a dope first release

yah tru dat, ppl are to dependent on ctp or tcf, this looks like a swell release and good qulaity for first release too... So many ppl are just so god damn picky and complain about everything... keep up the good work TGF...

now back to watching my movie ripp haha its so much fun lol

Great Job on this VCD. Much better than LGB2
Video was a little bit Dark. Nothin the brightness knob couldnt fix.
Sound was a little low as well. Great rls for someone who cant handle SVCD on their DVD player
7/6/x

__________________
They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."

picture is ok, sound is also not too bad. Movie upbruptly ends (no fade/credits..)


b

....

6/7/?

:: Nothing makes you look worse than flaming with the use of "n00b". -K::

For a first release, this is great. I had to tweak the cue file a little bit to "git 'er goin", but it all worked out well in the end. There's a bit of a problem on the right, as noted in the nfo, the picture is almost clear as day for a TS.. these guys are really blowing me away. The audio is almost perfect, only very very slightly muffled.. all of this judging is based on CD1.

7/7/?

You know.. i'm going to get a large amount of flaming for this, but if these guys hammer out the video problem, and slightly fix the audio.. centropy has a rival.

Not a bad rls at all, Pretty decent if you ask me, Good choice on keeping it vcd.

7/7/? Enjoyable rls, Will have to check it out. Thanks TGF, Keep em coming. Thanks.

does the video jump on this one?

No, it doesn't jump.. it sorta.. i dunno gets scrambled every now and then for less than half a second.. extremely tolerable unless you're just an anal grognard about it.. this'll hold me over until the dvd

Nice for a earily rls..

Just seen the sample........alittle blurry but good sound.....nice job of getting it out before anyone else....

nice rls TGF

video is a lil blurry yeah but very watchable
audio is bleh ok ts

7/7/?

__________________

quote:

---

Originally posted by deftones6


How are you rating the video and audio without actually having the movie????

---

Very nice for a first rls.
Once again TGF is showing their stuff. And they are getting better at it !

Pic just a bit blurry, and audio is very exceptable for a TS.

7/7/6

hmm people are being harsh on this release because of the slight tilt but the sound is very good and the pic seems a little dark from sample but colorful. vcd is a good decision on this so i can get the mov quick

-bizz|e

__________________
Dust myself up
and I scream at the sky
It's been so hard
but I can't let it die
Turn my head up,
looking at the stars
So many years,
I still wonder where you are?
Dust myself up
and I scream at the sky
Every day I ask myself why?
So much pain pouring
from inside
Above me I feel the spirit fly

well...judging at the sample of this...5/6/10

This is just a plain good release. It's not amazing, and it's not horrible. It's a plain old watchable, decent looking VCD telesync. It's nice to see some people still have the sense not to make everything an SVCD wether the quality is good enough or not. Decent quality, Nice and speedy. Hope to see more from TGF.
7/7/x-Want to watch the film...

wooot nice great pic kinda blury but i still like it ok sound
9/8/6

hum....

I think ms is 100% right, people are getting spoiled by these svcd ts', and its getting 2 be quite annoying cause ppl are saying "i'm waiting for the ctp"....ok... maby ur waiting for it, but do u think they are gonna make a speacial trip 2 thier theater just for you? yeah theres a high likly hood that a svcd ts/cam will be rlsed, but were not jugeing the svcd *ThAT DONT EXIST YET*, so lets not compare this to the "centropy" or previoius ctp realeses because there is not one. having said that, my un bias opinion on the quality of this film is:

7/6

(high ratings becuase its a vcd not svcd)

I heard the movie was good... Good first release...good job TGF!!!!!! haha

what an amazing thread. No one babbling on about shit, no one severly flaming! (aside from a post or two i noticed were edited)
i have to agree with many posts made in this thread. This group is doing a damn fine job. very good releases.
i also agree that lots of people are spoiled by CTP and TCF.
this group IMHO is fine. Theres a few things that they could improve a little bit. theres also a few things that ALL release groups could improve on. TGF's first 2 releases are pretty darned good.
7/6/6
keep up the good work, TGF!

__________________

...

Nice audio. No popping, cracking or anything bad. Some audio sync issues come & go about 1/2 way through the movie. Overall, very nice audio.

Video is average at best, but it contains about 3 TS's worth of flaws. It's too dark, and it's not very sharp. Glitches abound, and not just on the far right of the screen. About 30 minutes in, the camera goes black for a minute, and then the screen zooms in & out a few times, finally settling on full screen (yecch). Parts of the movie are missing, nothing major. On CD2, the picture seems to switch between having weak colors and a bright picture, to having lots of colors and a dark picture.

Compared to their first release, this is a nice step forward, and I hope they keep improving. THANKS.

:: This isn't a CTP thread. -K::

Im impressed.. for a new group they are doing well. I sampled rar 6 - 9 cd1. apart from the problem on right as noted the sound was good and video perfectly watchable. there was the odd break in video but good enough.


6/7/6

not bad for second release. def watchable but they do need to make a few adjustments to they way they're doing their films.
Promps for speed.

__________________
your never alone with Schizophrenia

Nice release, audio is an improvement over the audio on their Legally Blonde, video has enough colors to satisfy me...7/7/8

Pirates.Of.The.Caribbean.TS-TGF

Pretty Good Quality Have The Full Thing And And CD1 At The Starting Is Widescreen And Then It Goes Full Screen Cropping Alittle And Fuzzy Stuff On The Right Corner

7/7/9

Grant187

Not too shabby

6/7/8

The glitches and pixelation gets annoying on the right side and the 30 second or so stretch when it goes black is odd but other than that it is decent. Good movie to boot.

Yarg!!

i watched about 45 min and decided to wait for a better release to continue

video: great colours, camera moves a lot, pixelation on the right side often, dark ... 5

audio: good, volume goes up and down a bit, weird noises every once and a while ... 7

we're all used to CTP/TCF bringin the goods.

TGF look like they hav a lot of potential to meet the standards we've come to expect from a TS these days. Getting there, anyway

good rls, quickly impressing and beating the big groups to the rls!!

7/7/X

__________________
I Have This Thing, Advanced Dillusionary Schizofrenia with Involuntary Narcissistic Rage. It's No Big Deal.

7/7/9

Good Release.

video is VERY skechy at times but the sound is alright. burnt this copy and hour to soon which pissed me off cause the SVCD.TS came out. oh well, nice try on this release but needs some imporvements as always

__________________
������������������
blazin.

nice

props on keeping the flow. pic was nice and colorful sound needs a bit of work, but good job on dropping it first.

__________________
Bangin your mom since '98

ok im used to rating ctp and tcf's and figure nobody needs to hear what i have to say, but these guys are new and at least deserve a comment so i'll give one.

the video and audio are almost perfect 95% of the time, its just got a ton of really little glitches... if they didnt have the damm glitches here and there during scenes i would say it would have easily been the 8/8 range for TS's that CTP usually gets, because of the frequent glitches though you have to really knock a few points off...

I gave it a 6/8/6, but remember i feel that rating needs to be explained because 95% of the time its 8/8/6 really, with the other 5% just totally messing a beautifaul rls up.

these guys are definitely a group to watch, they are very close to being a quality rls grp, and this is just based on their first 2 near gems, lil fine tuning and they could be a crowd pleaser

I kinda wanna know, was it just me or was everyone else missing a little something at the end of this rls also. Anyways 6/6/?, I have yet to completely watch it.

__________________
Want Some Candy?

This is ok

This rip isnt that bad... Im going to see it on my dvd player. Thanks TGF.

This version is crap 0/0/?0 the video when from widescreen to full screen and back to widescreen a shit load of times. The color kept shifting and half way through the first disc the screen when black then a few seconds later the sound went out for about 5 minutes. The sound good when it's synced or not crackling. I don't recomend this version. All the fuckups keep you from getting into the movie.

Audio is pretty good for a ts, video sux, nearly cam, esp. the prob. with the video at the right side of the screen gets on one's nerves. and the fact that they admitted it themselves in the nfo doesn't make it look any better. It's like Oscar Wilde said: "If you don't want other people to bitch about you, do it yourself first." Well, he put it a little differently, of course, but you get the point...

Missing ending?

d/l and looked at it on my PC. Is it me or this movies missed the ending? I didn't see the whole movies just FF to the end and there was no credit. It looked like it cut off when Johnny Deep is about to say something...

6/6/?