VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- SVCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=20)
-- Raising Helen *WS* *PROPER* - DVDRIP - XPD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=47114)

This release is better than the Chakra one for sure, not by much but it is. I'm hearing this is nuked because it wasn't a valid proper..which sounds like b/s, but anyways, picture isn't nearly as blury as the other release. Sound is just as good. Get the other if you don't want to mess with 3 cds, not that big of a difference.

9/9/8

3 CD releases are for the birds..Might as well get the DVDR. Very few releases warrant a 3 CD. It is an improvement on the Chakra, which is definitely the first time they've had a bad one that i can remember in quite sometime..Its better than Chakra, but if u can, go for the DVDR Replica..Enjoy!!!


NUKED:Raising.Helen.WS.2004.DVDRip.SVCD.PROPER-XPD=Reason: can.not.proper.based.on.bitrate.alone

9/9/7.5

!!NUKED-Raising.Helen.DVDRip.SVCD-Chakra
NUKED 1x by XXXXXX - bitrate.is.too.low.1750kbit.minimum

Nukes mean nothing, but I totally agree, ya need standards on SVCDs. U can fit this on 1CD or 6CDs if ya want, but the question is 'When Do You Use It.'

Based on most releases Action or Not, 119 falls on 3CDs and 2CD XviD. Just look at past releases.

As for myself, I'll get the SVCD, cause this movie isnt worth a DVD.

Yes this is a bit better, but on anything but a big TV, i cant see a lot of people telling the difference.

Im sure XPD are telling porkies about this being 2350 4 pass, as a 119min film on 3CD's is an average bitrate of about 2500, so its a waste of time to do a VBR on this release.

Gah, nuke for this, nuke for that, why dont these ppl nuke themselves. Its obvious they cant tell the difference between a motion picture film and a freakin TV clip, Stupid igits.

I have Chakras and its totally fine.
Absolutely no need for a 3rd cd. Unless of course, your a brainded nuker.