VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- DIVX (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=23)
-- Transformers (2007) *XviD* - DVDRIP - FLAiTE (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=78531)

IMPORTANT, PLEASE READ

1 NO REQUESTING MOVIES OR SAMPLES (THIS INCLUDES REQUESTS FOR OTHER GROUPS TO RELEASE THIS MOVIE!)

2 DO NOT DISCUSS WHERE TO DOWNLOAD MOVIES OR SAMPLES

3 DO NOT ASK FOR "RAR PASSWORDS" COS WE DON'T KNOW THEM. CHECK WITH YOUR SOURCE

4 NO FLAMING

5 NO "SPOILERS"

6 NO SCENE-RELATED DISCUSSION/RUMORS (ESPECIALLY REGARDING BUSTS)

7 COMMENT ON THIS RELEASE ONLY (AND ONLY IF YOU'VE SEEN AT LEAST THE SAMPLE). THIS IS THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE THREAD!

8 NO "NOOB" QUESTIONS SUCH AS "HOW DO I WATCH THIS?" ASK IN THE APPROPRIATE PART OF THE FORUM

9 NO DISCUSSING TRADING/SELLING. IF YOU SELL COPIES, GO AWAY YOU'RE NOT WELCOME HERE

* Newbie questions? Want some weird term clarifying? Read our FAQ

* General questions unrelated to this release? Internet LOL's? Right here dudes

* Haven't read the forum rules? Want to play Russian roulette with your forum account?
READ THIS TO AVOID BEING BANNED


*** PEOPLE IGNORING THE RULES WILL BE BANNED ***

From just a quick skip through the 1st part ...

V: 8.5
A: 9.5
M: N/A

Busy getting the 2nd part as I type this ... and can't wait to watch the bad lad, as I've been waiting for a good release ...

__________________

Video is nice, but I wonder if it might be too thin, maybe it's just me. The TS was so good, I'm amazed at how much in this I really didn't miss.

V-9
A-9
M-8.5

V. 10
A. 09
M. 10000000000000000000000

The best movie.

ace copy watched this this afternoon

V 9.5
A 9.5
M 9.5
can not give it a 10 as i may find something i like more

looks good

9/9/9

quote:

---

Originally posted by Mailman
it might be too thin

---

Not the best video quality i've ever seen for a 2 cd rip but not bad. Will do nicely.

V=8
A=9.5 (sweet 5.1)
M=?? Have not watched yet, but will soon as i get this to dvd.

This may not be a Dvdrip.. If it is, they messed up encoding the video. There is several glitches in the video. Blurry pixels, and a weird motion blurr. DvdSCR??

Audio is great. Nice AC3. Perfect for a 6.1 system.

Rated as a dvdrip

V - 7
A - 9
M - 10 awesome movie

Sweet

V - 9
A - 10
M - 10

Nice job

Nice Release.

8/8/9

v:9
a:9
m:10

i always get suspicious when groups release xvid way before retail and no dvdr follows it.

as it goes, there is a dvdshrinked dvdr doing the rounds and i suspect they encoded it from that... might be wrong.

either way

video - 8 - pretty good... something about it i cant place my finger on though, just looks a bit flaky in parts

audio - 9 - fine

movie - 5 - pretty shit

V: 8
A: 10
M: 5 (I prefer the animated series)

Burnt it on dvd to check it out, seems the motion sequences are a little pixelated.

quote:

---

Originally posted by wanksock
i always get suspicious when groups release xvid way before retail and no dvdr follows it.

as it goes, there is a dvdshrinked dvdr doing the rounds and i suspect they encoded it from that... might be wrong.

either way

video - 8 - pretty good... something about it i cant place my finger on though, just looks a bit flaky in parts

audio - 9 - fine

movie - 5 - pretty shit

---

are you guys kidding me, i dont think this is a dvdrip ... i think this is a mislabled r5 because of how thin the video looks but still is pretty good for an r5

7/8/9

v-7.
Despite being 2 CD, it still looks a bit blocky in places & not up to usual high FLAiTE standards.

a-9.
Sounds good to me.

m-7.
Not bad, quite entertaining i thought.

went though this and was reviewing it, really bad blurry pixels, its boxy too.. it got motion blures as well.. So im guessing this is not a dvdrip!

m7
a8
m10

just put this to a dvd after recoding it to dvd.. watching it now.. and a total difference on my dvd player, not as much as bad blurry pixels, boxy too.. or motion blures. way better on with the dvd...

after set to dvd

8.5/9/10

i think it dope enough
u all being way picky
video - 8
audio-9
movie-9

nothing but love

__________________
Nothing but love and positive vibes !!

v 8

a 7.5

m 7

Bit rate: 1286 kbit/s

Video: mpeg4, yuv420p, 640x272
Audio: ac3, 48000 Hz, 5:1, 448 kb/s

Nice. Not quite full dvd quality but good enough until the hd-dvd version comes out.

8/8/10

holding out for a BluRay version 1.5 years from now -_- damn toshiba DIE ALREADY

hey superdong wrong place to post i think.(i came here b/c i love the strict policy of finding out my quality)
M strong 7
V 9
A 8
i agree there could be a bit better rip. but there is nothing wrong with this one. job well done

once again i must say the audio is great thru surround sound with my stand alone divx player

__________________
Nothing but love and positive vibes !!

According to the r5 realese dates list, it's not supposed to be out till November...
So its a genuine DVDRip (I suspected its a cropped DVDScr, byt the ar and res looks real to me).

8/9/9

A bit blocky during actions scenes when viewed on a bigger screen. But still, this is not bad.

v-8
a-9
movie-9 Loved it!

video: 8.5
audio: 10 (perfect)
movie: 9

as previously mentioned; blocky / pixelated at times, watched on a 19" Widescreen LCD

audio is simply amazing on my 5.1 system and in sync

what more can i say, the fact that this came out early makes up for the slight blockiness...
def. gonna pick up the dvdr though

V 8
A 10
M 10

excellent movie - great brainless candy film, after all why watch transformers if you're expecting oscar material.

only a lower pic score cos I feel at 144mins it should be a 3cd release, or at the very least a few more passes at the encoding

__________________
Don't Eat The Yellow Snow

quote:

---

Originally posted by _jadakiss
all they did was one pass when encoding so that they can rush out to you kids!!!!

---

Good rip apart from the mentioned blocky/pixelated parts that briefly appear but doesnt spoil the viewing of it at all imo

V:8
A:9.5
M:9

absolutely UNACCEPTABLE video.
especially for 2 cd's.

pixelation everywhere in motion sequences.

v = 5.
a = 7. sounds low.

After the credits there are 1-frame stills of dubbed credits (names of french and spanish dubbing speakers) which I suppose were in the same VOB they extracted to encode the video. For me that's a clear indication that the source is some sort of retail dvd. However, the encoding is horrible...

V = 5
A = 9
M = 8

quote:

---

Originally posted by deathr0w_
stop ya complaining it's free and quality is nice audio couldn't be better.

---

this release is awesome...I suggest
some of you get a real dvd player and
sound system...the 5.1 audio on this
is great and the picture is flawless!!!!!

but ,what do I know??I'm not a little
piss pants teeniebopper like most of you in here!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

V-9
A-9
M-9

Hmmm doubting this is a dvdrip.....and if it really is then it was poorly done
Rated as dvdrip
V-7 very poor even as 2 cd's its a mess
A-8.5 very decent
M-10 excellent movie
Flaite should have done a re rip to get this flik right for quality

DVD-R by mVs folks go get it as vcdquality won't nuke this shit xvid.......or wait for a superb proper that gets nuked lmao

V 9.0
A 8.5
M 9.5

Video - Very nice
Audio - Could have been recorded at higher dB
Movie - The most entertaining movie of the summer

don't know why they rush? They should do 2pass. Transformers to be Released on DVD / HD-DVD October 16th in USA

it's real DVD9 or great R5/TC?

Shit, 1pass, i will use postprocesing

V - 8(becouse 1pass)
A - 10
M - 10(I Love Transformers)

Greatings


/Edit:

I think they must do repack and make it on 3cd and use a little sharpen because it sometimes little blurry

v:7 (I was actually tempted to give it a six - its either a bad coversion or not a full commercial dvd source. I live in Russia - some of the releases here are not bad... R5 is no excuse. There's some blur and boxing, especially in some action scenes).
a:8 solid.
m:8 liked it. now I'm sorry I didn't see it in the cinema but I hate the dubbed versions they have here.

Deleted a shitload of posts

Stick to rating and discussing quality of release or don't bother posting.

I registered just to comment on this release.

V: 9
A: 8
M: 8

Watched this on a media pc connected to a standard definition CRT TV (29 inch) using only stereo channels (no 5.1 or anything). I feel this might be relevant - were I to watch this on a HD theatre setup I don't think I'd expect the same quality - but this isn't a HD rip, nor a full DVDR. Those with standard def setups should be happy to download this, those with HD setups might want another release.

The video was near seamless the only blurring I was conscious of was during 1 sequence early on, and to be honest it looked pretty close to an intentional motion blur effect applied during rendering - could be wrong as I never saw this movie at the cinemas. It seemed a little dark, but again could have been the production not the rip and simply adjusting the tv picture corrected it.

And on a 2-channel stereo setup the audio was quiet and the mid-tones were a bit lost, but once more a couple of tweaks to the tv and all was good.

It may be a 1-pass, I don't have the "skillz" to detect that - but it's (on my SD setup anyway) as good or better than any other DVD rip I've snatched.

Maybe someone watching on a HD setup could offer a more detailed opinion on quality.

::ModEdit: Consider this your first official warning, since I already posted to stick to reviewing and rating the release only. No flamming is permitted!!!:: ~LOLobo

quote:

---

Originally posted by Cr-critic
alrighty grasshopper lmao so u like that pixel stuff huh that floaty / mirage like shit.......flawless lmao yer an idiot

---

v=8
a=8
m=2

This movie sucks.
The last 20 minutes lift it to a 2 before that it's a 1.
Pure sheit.

V : 9
A :10
M : 8

Great release. Surround sound is great, pic looks ok to me too.

compare this with Live free or die hard,

and you'll see how horrible the encoding is on this.

Live Free action sequences don't have big ass boxy pixellation.

quote:

---

Originally posted by shadowsniper
v-7.
Despite being 2 CD, it still looks a bit blocky in places & not up to usual high FLAiTE standards.

a-9.
Sounds good to me.

m-7.
Not bad, quite entertaining i thought.

---

Video: 7 (pixelization and a bit blurry)
Audio: 7 (very low sound but high music and special effects. I guess thats what 5.1 is )
Movie: ?

V: 9
A: 9
M: 9

excellent release watched it last night on my 42inch telly with my mpeg4 dvd player no problems what so ever really enjoyed the movie effects were unreal.cheers flaite

V:9
A:9
M:9

__________________
d.willis

great movie great quality nice post