VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King *SVCD* *READNFO* - TELECINE - Chakra (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=35103)

Holy SHIT! Theyd fool me if they said DVDSCR with this release...especially when put up with Ring's version, this stands out. Sound is EXCELLENT, and colors are accurate and vivid. 10/10/9

This is the keeper. The release is PRECIOUS

ONE TELECINE TO RULE THEM ALL.

__________________

9/9/7

Picture is sharper than the screener.
Audio is great.

Awesome job.

Why is it Chakra brings all the important blockbuster movies nicest?

8/8/9.

__________________
soda box

not seen the movie at all yet (sigh, i know!) but sample colours and framing look accurate enough to me. can't really judge the audio as its 6am and my speakers are down low (and im at the pc not the DTS ES sound system in the lounge) but it seems fine from what i could make out.

hoping that a dvdr print will be produced, as it *might* be anamorphic if it came from a PDVD. and thats something i'd rather like

9/x/x

__________________
563-773-1880

<Dwaggy> i caught you a delicious Bass
<The404> This is because you are an idiot

quote:

---

Originally posted by Azzkicker
Holy SHIT! Theyd fool me if they said DVDSCR with this release...especially when put up with Ring's version, this stands out. Sound is EXCELLENT, and colors are accurate and vivid. 10/10/9

This is the keeper. The release is PRECIOUS

ONE TELECINE TO RULE THEM ALL.

---

ok as to my last post, it might be russian, i really dont know the language, now that i think bout it, looks less german...anyhow, thats all.

if its russian, the Rs will be backwards not seen the beginning, only checked the sample.

__________________
563-773-1880

<Dwaggy> i caught you a delicious Bass
<The404> This is because you are an idiot

quality from sample is very nice
video looks good, kinda cropped
audio is good,very clear and up to par

heard it was nuked not sure on reason : /

8/8/9

__________________

quote:

---

Originally posted by deftones6


How are you rating the video and audio without actually having the movie????

---

From full version..
Chakra never seems to amaze me..this could pass for a dvdscreener. This release is flawless. And all 4 disc are actually in sync..unlike the cd3 and 4 of the screener. This is a 110% keeper...Thank you guys for this Chakra you rule on the best releases...

Rating this a 10/10/9...

__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...

8/7/8

ps. dvdr please.

It's made from russian TeleCine. http://sharereactor.ru/cgi-bin/mzinfo.cgi?id=1102

I have this release like from a week ago. I know Russian, so not really a problem for me.
It's a russian dubbed TeleCine with a new sound track on it.

8/10/9 (the 10 is for the dubbed in russian version. It sounds perfect in russian).

Sexy.......

easily best yet, audio is ass kickingly nice and video is also up there amongst the best TC's i seen

definately dvdr worthy so you dont have to change discs.... im just a lazy git

9/9/7 ( bleh wasnt the best of the trilogy, ill leave that for fellowship :P)

Why waste the bandwidth or the column inches anymore, lets be honest unless you are an anorak then all three films are overated and boring i don't think i've watched one yet without falling asleep which was a disapointment to me cos the books are excellent.

Nice release though judging by the sample.

From Sample

Video : Good quality, nice colors and only a small bit of pixilation, overall, very nice.

Sound : Excellent, crisp and clear.

Been waiting for a watchable release of this movie since it came out, finially Chakra belts out a nice TC. Needless to say, this is the best version so far.

Cheers Chakra, continue your good work.



Edit :: Burned all four disks and watched on my pioneer stand alone - OUTSTANDING release!!! For all of you cryng about a DVD Screener, stuff it, this baby is just as good visually and the sound is superb.

P.S.

For you lames arguing about subtitles, its only for about .28% of the movie, so stop creaming your pants its not in english.

9/9/8

__________________
Ignorance Is Bliss. An Example -

quote:

---

Originally posted by platinum_bomb
Dude, It wasn't there and still isn't... I was waiting to see what the pic looked like cuz the release was up, but there was no pic and i didn't find the sample, mo fo. Don't make me come and tie ur arms to ur chair and beat u silly with your own keyboard

lol

Will edit this after i get it.

---

It'll do nicely thanks.

Much rather have this over the SCR. Suppose i'll finally see this movie, but only if this TC is slapped on a DVDR.

No way is it the best TC though. Personally i think that award still goes to BASiC for Agent Cody Banks.

8/7

quote:

---

Originally posted by Mystic Slippers

No way is it the best TC though. Personally i think that award still goes to BASiC for Agent Cody Banks.

8/7

---

this release was relased weeks ago by a xvid group. same exact release.

__________________

great release, i'm impressed. based on sample, i'd give it 9/9/10. both video and audio are almost flawless. colors are vivid and bright. downright the best trilogy other than the godfather trilogy. good job chakra.

To mikeyrana: I have to agree that the lotr movies can make you fall azzzzzleep, happens to me every time o trie to watch one of the movies. But i dont think thats because the movie is boring or bad, you have to be prepared to see a long film like this, lots of coffee, or anything to keep your eyes open.

Besides very very good version this is, from sample it looks very good, but since its four cds and i have allready the ts, ill wait for a dvdscr or dvdretail....

quote:

---

Originally posted by FDisk80
It's made from russian TeleCine. [...]
It's a russian dubbed TeleCine with a new sound track on it.

---

from sample:

this is almost as good as a dvdscr, and is certainly better than rings release. the sound is real nice, pic is excellent, i mean its better than the matrix revolutions tc, i think i am going to encode this to dvdr and get 5 channel sound, this will hold me off till the retail for sure.

10/10/9 for a telecine one of the best ive seen.

__________________
Dust myself up
and I scream at the sky
It's been so hard
but I can't let it die
Turn my head up,
looking at the stars
So many years,
I still wonder where you are?
Dust myself up
and I scream at the sky
Every day I ask myself why?
So much pain pouring
from inside
Above me I feel the spirit fly

from sample :

looks amazing definatly the best rls out there and audio is PERFECT

but im having doubts because of the russian thing...i hope the subtitles are in english not russian because that would be gay!

__________________

not the best tc i have ever seen, but it ranks in the top 5

9/9/7

great release, amazing video and audio, maybe a dvdr release with dd5.1 is on the horizon?

9/9/10

quote:

---

Originally posted by KrackZaa
from sample:

this is almost as good as a dvdscr, and is certainly better than rings release. the sound is real nice, pic is excellent, i mean its better than the matrix revolutions tc, i think i am going to encode this to dvdr and get 5 channel sound, this will hold me off till the retail for sure.

10/10/9 for a telecine one of the best ive seen.

---

__________________

Awesome release, good job guys. Definetly better than the previous screener by RiNG, I can live until May now!

10/9/9.5

As stated before, one telecine to rule them all. One of the best, superb quality.

bah lame russian subs when people speak in elven

Well as long as the subtitles are at the bottom of the screen and not too intrusive then it shouldn't be a problem then..

Suppose if you wanted to be technical about it then you could blur out the russian subs ..

9/9/7......Didint like the third as much as two towers but they cant all be as good as one another (never are in a trilogy) Ace release but we are suffering on the qty of dvdscr as of late

Sorry for being new and stupid but who says it's subbed ? The nfo doesnt mention it, sample, what sample ? The jpg ? Yeah it looks fine but I don't see subs.

Jesus 33 posts and no one can state whether the subs only appear when someone is speaking eleven or if they are constantly there through the whole thing. Makes a bit if difference to the watchability don't you think.

Subs Only...

NO the subs only appear when talking elvish (and yes they are in russian or whatever) which is not too much at all in this movie. No subs throughout the movie like you see in japan/china releases, it is by far the best release, it is kind of weird seeing the title (Lord of the Rings then Return of the King) when it starts in russian but thats it. So the movie is in english, no subtitles throughout, only when there is elvish talk you see russian subs.

For one, the screen in the jpeg isnt at a moment when there is talking, so of course you wont see subs.

The sample looks great, id say 9's across the board.

__________________
"much to learn you still have..."

kewl rels 9/9/7

its in PAL format :/

and they mean russian subs when the elves talk in elvish

if th subs only appear when the elves talk elvish does it mean that the movie is dubbed russian?? usually russian dubs a pretty sucky considering that they on't even take away the english and some guy mumbles it in russian after tey say it in english!

__________________
---

My God, you people are lame. As stated above, the subs hardly EVER appear. If you are really anal, you can take the time and edit the release and blur out the subs. I think I can live with it until a retail rip though.

Anyways, superb release. I just threw my RiNG discs away. Video is crystal clear and sound seems flawless.

9/9/10

very nice

well what can i say- very well done chakra. the video is very good considering its a TC and encoded very nicely- none of the tremendous pixelation during battles like the vcd SCR. sound is right on, didnt hear anything upsetting (havent watched the whole thing though), and as for the movie itself, well you know the drill- either you love it or you hate it... me.... LOVE it. if you can spare the 3gigs to download, this is the best to date of this flick.

8/9/9

quote:

---

Originally posted by unique
if th subs only appear when the elves talk elvish does it mean that the movie is dubbed russian?? usually russian dubs a pretty sucky considering that they on't even take away the english and some guy mumbles it in russian after tey say it in english!

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by pbol
Sorry for being new and stupid but who says it's subbed ? The nfo doesnt mention it, sample, what sample ? The jpg ? Yeah it looks fine but I don't see subs.

---

__________________
Dark Evolution is here.....

Barely on topic question, but: Why dont they use an NTSC source for telecines? Can they not telecine straight to 24fps video?

__________________
soda box

About the subs..

The subs are useless, approx ½ of the time the actors speak, there is NO subs.. If you where not able to hear all the sound, u would miss out on ½ of the dialog in the movie.

Could have been ALOT better!

quote:

---

Originally posted by XeroFightsAlone
Barely on topic question, but: Why dont they use an NTSC source for telecines? Can they not telecine straight to 24fps video?

---

Awwww, this is nice Chakra! ;D pretty good looking shit
Wish there was a DVDscr out, but I'm not that demanding...(if you can say that o.0)

10/9/9

Wow, it was a lot better than I first thought *raising scores and going for the vote shit*

quote:

---

Originally posted by XeroFightsAlone
Barely on topic question, but: Why dont they use an NTSC source for telecines? Can they not telecine straight to 24fps video?

---

Very nice rls best out there by a long shot no other can come close, yeah its from a russian source more thumbs up to those in Chakra to take the time to match it with supberb sound. nice one lads you kept the many very happy indeed.

As for those who moan about the LOTR trilogy dont watch them if you think they are shit then we wouldnt have to put up with reading your shit, each to his own....just keep it to yourself

Wow, this rls is excellent for a telecine. It's really too bad that I've watched the screener too many times to bother with this one, but watched a friends copy. Excellent Video Quality, much sharper than the ring, Great Audio, much better bass and no sync issues on cd3 and cd4. An of course the movies awesome. This sucker clock in at over 3 gigs so be prepared to wasted some serious space, definitely worth it, best rls so far. Oh yeah and definitely read the NFO, this copy is a dupe of a Russian rls and there are some subtitles.

9/9/9

Awesome telecine, as already by far the best release yet & despite the subs still worth the 3 gigs

9/9/10 favorite of the trilogy just my 2 cents tho

props to Chakra on a great release!

Nice Pic, Decent Colours

helps if you know a lil elvish

nice work!

This is the release I've been waiting for, Logistic TS was great. Wasn't feeling the Scr from Ring, i honestly thought it sucked.

From Sample
10/10/10

Lots of a DVDRips don't even hope to compare, astounding quality.

Hi,

Just got the whole thing, it is nice, it's dark in the dark scenes, really dark. I was going to re-encode it until I had seen the Diamond release, 3cd xvid with Ac3 5.1. So I think I'm holding off right now on this one till I get all of Diamond's.

Diamond Release??

So does "Diamond" have a re-encode of this??? I have not seen that anywhere so I am curious. I agree, the dark scenes (which is a lot of the moive) are pretty dark even if you adjust on tv. So I am wondering if there is a new re-encode that is better. This version is by far incredible compared to anything else that has been released. If whoever "Ring" is they could have made it perfect being they had a VHS screener but obviously they do not know how to capture. And yes before anyone flames me I do knwo a great deal about capturing VHS tapes, that is what I do for a living at by job.