VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Minority Report - TELECINE - TCF (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=7472)

Kick ass Quality

TCF u guys have a KICK ass supplier,,. even though this aint a scr itz still good

*uck yeah!!! the scr was ok, but this *ucking rocks!

Not SVCD

I find this and other TCF releases great, however there's one problem I find. I believe that since the source of this release is of a very high quality, a telecine to be correct, it should in fact be encoded to 3-SVCDS as it would be much better quality or resolution for those people who wish to watch on large RPTVs of plasmas.

TCF usually encodes their stuff into VCD, and it degrades from the usually high source. I think they believe that more people prefer downloading less than downloading more at a higher quality.

Someone needs to remind them that quality is always more important, of course, that's in my opinion.

Best film of the year. I dont care how many releases of this movie there are as long as they improve. Picture's better than the WP, seems a little jerky (assuming that's why they labelled it a telecine), but that doesn't bother me. Sound is similar to WP, but with no glitches and no 30 second gap

Nice one TCF 8/8/9.

-- but once again we get an upgrade of a movie that...didn't need the upgrade!

Who is the we you arte referring to? Me personally I thought the previous versions sucked ass enought that I wanted a better release, and I am cpompletely excited that this fine group has done another great release in keeping with their previous work.

I guess you will be here bitching when the dvdrip comes out too ?
Not all of us convert these to divx and watch them on our gameboy.

nice telecine Ive been waiting to see a killer release of this movie anyway...

Since, TCF is ruling the scene right now, I wonder if they will rls a better version of ¤[The Bourne Identity]¤

9/9/9

Popcorn Playa™ - «Urkman»

Why

Am i the only one here that gets fed up when so many differant versions of the same movie are released, its true this copy seems to be the best so far but judging from the last so called screener which in my opinion was very good why rls this one? there really does not seem to be much in it except for the clock,and i must also add that its old and will probably be available in Blockbuster soon n e way. Sorry to go on with this being my first post an all but it just annoys me.

Fuck yes good job on this one, this is the only rls ive gotten of this movie and im guessing its the best cause its damn nice

Sound

the sound is just a little fucked.. its like TS quality sound sounds hollow or something it aint right

Wow! I just finished watching this and it was very nice. I have to agree with the previous sentiment that this was one of the best movies of the year and to keep good releases like this coming! This one is very nice and I wouldn't even be disappointed if there wasn't a screener after a nice release like this (but would be very happy if there was, of course...). =)

I'd rate this one a 9/9/10.

Thanks again TCF!

I already got the workprint and thought that was exceptional. Should I get this? Is it any better?

Re: Why

quote:

---

Originally posted by Puffs
Am i the only one here that gets fed up when so many differant versions of the same movie are released, its true this copy seems to be the best so far but judging from the last so called screener which in my opinion was very good why rls this one? there really does not seem to be much in it except for the clock,and i must also add that its old and will probably be available in Blockbuster soon n e way. Sorry to go on with this being my first post an all but it just annoys me.

---

Whats funny is this

If you look at this release and you look at the TC of Stuart Little 2, they are almost identical, and in some cases the SL2 even seems better, though granted MR is a much better movie, I have to ask myself if any of the people who vote on this site actually vote based upon the quality of the movie or simply by the group name next to it? Jesus people.

quote:

---

Originally posted by rvwinkle
-- but once again we get an upgrade of a movie that...didn't need the upgrade!

Who is the we you arte referring to? Me personally I thought the previous versions sucked ass enought that I wanted a better release, and I am cpompletely excited that this fine group has done another great release in keeping with their previous work.

I guess you will be here bitching when the dvdrip comes out too ?
Not all of us convert these to divx and watch them on our gameboy.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Urkman
nice telecine Ive been waiting to see a killer release of this movie anyway...

Since, TCF is ruling the scene right now, I wonder if they will rls a better version of ¤[The Bourne Identity]¤

9/9/9

Popcorn Playa™ - «Urkman»

---

Re: Not SVCD

quote:

---

Originally posted by viper505
I find this and other TCF releases great, however there's one problem I find. I believe that since the source of this release is of a very high quality, a telecine to be correct, it should in fact be encoded to 3-SVCDS as it would be much better quality or resolution for those people who wish to watch on large RPTVs of plasmas.

TCF usually encodes their stuff into VCD, and it degrades from the usually high source. I think they believe that more people prefer downloading less than downloading more at a higher quality.

Someone needs to remind them that quality is always more important, of course, that's in my opinion.

---

Re: Why

quote:

---

Originally posted by Puffs
Am i the only one here that gets fed up when so many differant versions of the same movie are released, its true this copy seems to be the best so far but judging from the last so called screener which in my opinion was very good why rls this one? there really does not seem to be much in it except for the clock,and i must also add that its old and will probably be available in Blockbuster soon n e way. Sorry to go on with this being my first post an all but it just annoys me.

---

Good Realease For A Very Shity Movie

__________________

FUck this movie. they need to release good copies of NEW movies. stop wastein there time on old ass movies and release something new like Feat Dot Com

__________________
How bout a choclate coverd pretzel

wes... that was the n00best thing you've ever said. Period. Zip your lip child before you put the "bob" at the end of our name to shame! Some peopel like good quality older movies, I for one, will download this movie. And you do relieze when Fear Dot Com comes out, it will be a shitty ass quality silver.... so please... let the "bob" addon not be looked at in shame!

__________________
One time, my cousin Walter got this cat stuck in his ass. True story. He bought it at our local mall so the whole fiasco wound up on the news, it was embarrassing for my relatives and all, but the next week he did it again, different cat, same results, complete with another trip to the emergency room! So I run into him a week later in the mall and he�s buying another cat and I says to �em "Jesus Walt, what are you doing? You know your just gonna get this cat stuck up your ass too, why don�t you knock it off?" And he says to me "Brodie, how the hell else am I supposed to get the gerbil out?" My cousin was a weird guy....

-

Great release TCF keep it up.
wesb0b is right in a way i wish first run movies had this quality and would love to see fear dot com released like this.

Ew, Fear Dot Com. That movie looks as fucking corny as Michael Jackson. I would probably dl it but it looks stupid as hell.

great release but i hate it when groups use hjsplit or what ever app gives *.001 files. please just use winrar like the rest

Come On Kids Grow Up.

Why the hell are all the kids in here bitching @ me for my fair comments in my earlier post, the only reason they like having a go @ ppl with something to say is that as small children they dont have any brain and lack having a life other than that of being an incredibly brain dead rich kid with no life, And whos parents are obviously Brother & Sister!!!

All i was trying to say was why keep releasing older movies all the time when there are very good versions around already although we do appreciate them it does get a little annoying to see so many versions of the same movie around.
It was not my intention to slag off this or any other group, far from it, its just my observation and opinion..Get It..

Come on this quote was written by a small child with no brain!

"dickhead do u think they released it just for u? go back to that rock you have been under..."

Grow Up Kids and except other peoples comments rather than slagging them off...

Fuck you and fuck this movie it sucks balls any way

__________________
How bout a choclate coverd pretzel

Im sorry wesly, are you on your period..... awww hes getting older every day... this movie owns you FATASS, and get a goddamn life

__________________
One time, my cousin Walter got this cat stuck in his ass. True story. He bought it at our local mall so the whole fiasco wound up on the news, it was embarrassing for my relatives and all, but the next week he did it again, different cat, same results, complete with another trip to the emergency room! So I run into him a week later in the mall and he�s buying another cat and I says to �em "Jesus Walt, what are you doing? You know your just gonna get this cat stuck up your ass too, why don�t you knock it off?" And he says to me "Brodie, how the hell else am I supposed to get the gerbil out?" My cousin was a weird guy....

-

quote:

---

Originally posted by svenbob
Im sorry wesly, are you on your period.....

---

oh geez ,another minority report

yawn

i sorry kalavitis... but my bitch needs to know when the keep her.. i mean, his mouth shut

__________________
One time, my cousin Walter got this cat stuck in his ass. True story. He bought it at our local mall so the whole fiasco wound up on the news, it was embarrassing for my relatives and all, but the next week he did it again, different cat, same results, complete with another trip to the emergency room! So I run into him a week later in the mall and he�s buying another cat and I says to �em "Jesus Walt, what are you doing? You know your just gonna get this cat stuck up your ass too, why don�t you knock it off?" And he says to me "Brodie, how the hell else am I supposed to get the gerbil out?" My cousin was a weird guy....

-

i won't be picking this up because the screener was also very good but still this release is kick ass .

keep up all the good work TCF

the quality of the picture and sound is fantastic on this rip, except the frame rate is extremely poor and it stutters along. 6/8/9.5

The frame rate drops the first score down.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Cory
Ew, Fear Dot Com. That movie looks as fucking corny as Michael Jackson. I would probably dl it but it looks stupid as hell.

---

WHY?

it really doesnt bother me how many rls they do of a film as long as its better why bitch on how many rls if it takes a hundred to get a good version why not?

why they dont release this as svcd ... why ...

__________________
no idea

i have all rather buy this dvd in thailand its pretty good
Minority Report (Telecine Vesrion)9.8/9.0 its dvd format nstc
i had buy 100 dvds all rather sold out if dont't belive me
check out the web site { removed }

as long as they include a sample, noone "pays for more than they get" ?

If you look for perfect quality, I recommend the movie theater

Hiya folks,

I just downloaded this movie and was somewhat dissapointed with the quality... the video is a bit choppy and the audio is kinda hollow... you may have a headache after watching it... but, it's still the best rls of this movie to date... how long till the dvd?

quote:

---

Originally posted by Corrado
the quality of the picture and sound is fantastic on this rip, except the frame rate is extremely poor and it stutters along. 6/8/9.5

The frame rate drops the first score down.

---

__________________
no idea

Frame rate is the only problem with this release. Wish it could have been better cuz when people move they look like they're going in slow motion or some shit. Still a nice release... keep 'em coming TCF.

Are all you people who are saying fantastic quality judging by the jpegs because, this is a perfect example of, only judge it by the sample or the whole release.

On anything slow, it looks great, but as soon as it moves its horrible, looks like when i encode a 15fps quicktime trailer to mpeg, the sound is very muffled and sound like mono, plus the aspect ratio is anamorphic, instead of letterbox, not a bad thing if you have a widescreen tv, but still not to everyones taste.

I agree it should be nuked, i got the 2nd CD, im not getting the first, the last one was better, true it looked like a TS in some bits, and had a few audio glitches (I never had a 30sec gap)but the sound was Dolby Surround, but it was very watchable, this hurts your eyes and your ears, the people leave trails behind, if anyone wants to know what this looks like, find a low framerate avi or quicktime file and use tmpeg to encode it to 29fps and you'll see what i mean.

Im dissapointed TCF, its the first time you've wasted my bandwith.

__________________
Don't knock it if its free, if you could do better why are you downloading it

quote:

---

Originally posted by Schock


For someone with a scanners avatar you seem like you are a person with some taste in horror, but i guess you are from the scream generation and only chose that avatar because you think its "cool". I bet michael jackson's thriller video scares the shit out of you. LMAO!!!!!!!!!

---

I thought this release was pretty decent, but yeah, the frame rate problem did show a bit. Anyway, definitely the best release so far so take it if you haven't seen it... December should be the month for this on DVD though...

I'd give this release a 8/8/10.

Thanks TCF.

hmm well i have the workprint, i was dissapointed with that, but if i do get another version of this movie then i will just wait for the dvd

Audio is terrible....

You can not even watch this movie the audio is so bad. Video is pretty good but the screener already released by TCF is much better. Why even try to beat a vhs-screener. Especially if you are TCF who has the best rls with vhs-screener. Loved the screener and hated this.....

quote:

---

Originally posted by Cory
Ew, Fear Dot Com. That movie looks as fucking corny as Michael Jackson. I would probably dl it but it looks stupid as hell.

---

Frame rate, frame rate, frame rate.

The frame rate was a bit choppy but not bad enough to spoil the movie, picture quality was fine otherwise, and i had no problems with the sound either.
not perfect but still definitely worth a look.
I enjoyed the film.

[QUOTE]Originally posted by Cory


Eh, Scanners is a great movie and as for taste in horror I don't think a good horror flick would be "Fear Dot Com". The plot sounds childish and stupid but thats just my opinion and others may think different. And as for the "LMAO!!!!!" I seriously hope you weren't laughing your ass off because I don't think anyone on this board even chuckled at your post. Thank you, come again. [/QUOTE

I'm laughing my ass off at your dumbass

I agree the frame rate makes it drag a bit, Ill stick to the screener till the dvdrip.

TCF does it again

Once again another awesome release from 1 of the best groups in the biz. U guys are always rockin us with great quality. keep up the good werk. This kills the workprint which was borderline crap but watchable if u want to see it one time and toss the disk away.

Having watched the film, I can say the sound is poor, nothing a good amp with noise reduction can't help, but I've already posted about the frame rate, but having watchewd the whole thing I can say that the "Workprint" is better even if the picture quality isn't a patch on this one and it is missing 30 secs.
PS. I was going to drink 24/7's beer but I found out it was actually Kaliber

My advice stick with the "Workprint" or even better go to the cinema and watch it as god intended

quote:

---

Originally posted by desertboy
Having watched the film, I can say the sound is poor, nothing a good amp with noise reduction can't help, but I've already posted about the frame rate, but having watchewd the whole thing I can say that the "Workprint" is better even if the picture quality isn't a patch on this one and it is missing 30 secs.
PS. I was going to drink 24/7's beer but I found out it was actually Kaliber

My advice stick with the "Workprint" or even better go to the cinema and watch it as god intended

---

1 - Frame Rate. If you have to convert it to 23 or 29fps in order for it to comply with VCD standards, why the hell dont you shoot it in that framerate in the first place? Maybe TCF was using a slower shutterspeed to achieve the brilliant colors that were achieved in this Telecine, however what is the point when the framerate conversion ruins the watchability of the VCD?

2 - Audio Quality. Crappy encoder? Crappy technique? The audio just plain sucks.

I cant believe anybody would consider releasing this after viewing the final disc.

not bad

picture quality is great, but strangly jerky.. sound could be much better considering it's a telecine.. 'sounds like you're listening to it inside a barrel or something.. vid = 7 : aud = 6

I agree with the others. The framerate is noticeably low, and the audio is difficult to hear. Stick with the Workprint release for now.

Are we all watching the same VCD? I must say this is very disapointing from what the pics made me think. They should not have released it. First the frame rate is really messed up, isn't that apparent on a computer but sucks on a DVD player. Second the aspect ratio isn't even close. And third the audio is bad to the point where it is painful to watch. I never had the workprint but it had to be better.

quote:

---

Originally posted by xer0mark
1 - Frame Rate. If you have to convert it to 23 or 29fps in order for it to comply with VCD standards, why the hell dont you shoot it in that framerate in the first place? Maybe TCF was using a slower shutterspeed to achieve the brilliant colors that were achieved in this Telecine, however what is the point when the framerate conversion ruins the watchability of the VCD?

2 - Audio Quality. Crappy encoder? Crappy technique? The audio just plain sucks.

I cant believe anybody would consider releasing this after viewing the final disc.

---

__________________

This perceived misuse of Internet resources caused former Dutch education minister Loek Hermans to comment: "It would be nice if the students at Twente University would use their fast connections for information and education purposes, instead of downloading huge amounts of porn."


____________________________________ knowing is the easy part _____________


.