VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Star Wars Episode III Revenge of the Sith *SVCD* *RERIP* - TELECINE - TUN (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=63121)

video no different but i guess good on the audio fix

__________________

The wise man does not play leap frog with unicorns...

Well
The audio is fixed
No sync problems found
Video is still darker than WP
Video is still red.
Overall, at least they fixed the release
Good job TUN

Video 7
Audio 8
Movie 9

Audio sync is a little better, really don't notice a difference in video but like I always say, I'm spoiled by DVDR!!

Anyway, good job by TUN getting a re-rip out there, give them alot of credit.

WORKPRINT STILL GOOD

Video still reddish

Audio fixed

V:7
A:9
M:9

__________________

IMPORTANT, PLEASE READ

1 NO REQUESTING MOVIES OR SAMPLES. THIS INCLUDES ASKING FOR OTHER GROUPS TO RELEASE THIS (or another) FILM

2 DO NOT DISCUSS WHERE TO DOWNLOAD MOVIES OR SAMPLES

3 NO FLAMING. YOU AREN’T RATING OTHER USER’S COMMENTS!

4 NO "SPOILERS"

5 COMMENT ON THIS RELEASE ONLY (AND ONLY IF YOU'VE SEEN IT)

6 NO "NOOB" QUESTIONS (such as encoding tips), ASK IN THE APPROPRIATE PART OF THE FORUM

7 NO DISCUSSING TRADING/SELLING. IF YOU SELL COPIES, GO AWAY YOU'RE NOT WELCOME HERE


*** PEOPLE IGNORING THE ABOVE RULES WILL BE BANNED ***
people bitching about moderation will also get a "RERIP".

-K

same video : 7

same audio : 6


Sync issue is fixed...

:: Stupidity removed, because I feel charitable. -K::

__________________
All my movies are burned using "PC Club" generic CD-R, and generic DVD-R disks. They are played on a AVAYON DXP1000 xvid/svcd/vcd/blah blah blah blah player...

The sync issues were hardly noticeable. Still appreciated. Thanks.

__________________
What's faith if I can't believe? It's everything, a cure, but I make it a disease. God take me because i hate me.

Is 1/8 of the movie still cropped out? Its hard to tell without screen shots of the same scene which with my meager knowledge of digital video would take me for ever to figure out.

It's still out of sync, check disc 3 at 5:55, when Obi and Yoda chat, goes out of sync to the following scene. Goes back into sync around 9:00.

You guys need to watch this before even posting 5 min after it pres

[QUOTE]Originally posted by OASVstar
[B]WORKPRINT STILL GOOD

ummmmmmmmmm

workprint was never good

:: WHAT THE HELL DO YOU PEOPLE NOT UNDERSTAND!!! -K::

__________________
Im the real Trotter

Just double checked that sync problem ur having
Im not seeing it on my DVD Player
The audio and video are matched from 5:55 to 9:00
Not sure if its your dvd player or what man

7/7/10 waits for new version but i guess i cant complain

video\sound quality is exactly the same as the initial release of this by TUN... the only thing that has changed in the *RERIP* is the audio sync issue of cd3, it has been fixed. I've had this release for a while now, burned and looks great on dvd player. Props TUN--

Revenge of the Sith RERIP

Much needed,yea its a tad dark but still
the best copy out to date enjoy!!


video 7

audio 8

movie 10

video is slightly better, believe it or not, as it doesnt skip at the cd joins as the other did, audio is in sync all the way through.
cd3 at 5.55mins is where yoda talks but because its an animated model it may seen out of stnc by 1/100th of a sec but thats all.

v8
a8
m7

just noticed some children are giving 1.1.10 for this movie, cmon neversoft do your stuff..

quote:

---

Originally posted by Lord_Nykon
Im not seeing it on my DVD Player
The audio and video are matched from 5:55 to 9:00
Not sure if its your dvd player or what man

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by ou812
I just unrared it, and extracted the mpg with vcdgear. It's clear its out of sync on this spot. Even when Obi talks on these 2 scenes its off close to a second.

---

__________________
One Day The Dead Shall Walk The Earth.

8/8/9

Gret Release from my POV, and a great movie. But youll never know what they've missed

__________________
_____________________________

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
______________________________

same picture quality as the first but with sync issue fixed.took a few days to fix but better than nothing. cheers anyway guys.

__________________
Lets praise all the groups out there who make this scene for what it's worth because if we didn't then we'd all be spending a fortune at the pics.Remember to practice SAFE SEX (as illistrated in the pic).

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by ou812
I just unrared it, and extracted the mpg with vcdgear. It's clear its out of sync on this spot. Even when Obi talks on these 2 scenes its off close to a second.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

No issues found here.

9/9/8

why rerip?
I still have an out of sync problem
Atleast you tried

7/6.5/8

quote:

---

Originally posted by Tadge
I think its amazing TUN even managed to rls this good quality at all days after its rls in cinema's.
Those who watched the news would know they were taking extra precautions to ensure this movie stayed off web for as long as poss.
Yes this might b a Telecine but these guys have to work hard to get their footage no matter how they obtain it.
These guys take serious take serious risks to share these rls's with us all and risk prison sentences obtaining the footage.
Even posting their rls's on sites can be well risky and i know a few that have been hit with mail from the FBI just for posting stuff. Its piss easy to sit and download and make comments about poor quality. Poor quality???? a Telecine days after rls? Has every 1 forgot the quality we have had the last 6 months?

I personally watched the 1st TUN rls on my dvd player and had no sync probs and found nothing to complain about in the quality either. May not have been a 10 but compared to some grps still top stuff for such a quick rls.

Those who dont like dont have to watch and can watch the big timer version or the pot.

Too many moaners who dont appreciate the hard work and risks grps put into sharing with us.

Well done TUN in the speed of ur rls's, people who knock it obviously dont appreciate the hard work. Dont see them bettering your work though!!!!

9 - All round for the speed of the rls's giving the security attempting to stop copies.

Well done TUN great stuff

---

isnt this thread supposed to be about ratings? not giving bloody backslaps or bitching or group bashing, theres another place to post them...just rate the fucking release.

8/8/9

:: IRONY! Okay people, enough with the useless comments. -K::

whats the problem ???

if you guys put as much energy into thanking the groups for there hard work and persiverance in these hard times as you do bitching about the film being out of sync maybe you would have the time to see the bigger picture...

eg;

1, its free

2, its free

3, its free

need i say more ?

well yes i do actully... if you can get a better source or can do better bring it to the players !! saosin,centrophy,tun (RESPECT)

IF YA DONT LIKE IT DONT DOWNLOAD IT....

so come on bitches what you got to show us ?????????????

thought so zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

OUT !!


::EDIT:: YOU SIR are a fucking moron! What's the point in us having release/comments threads if people don't COMMENT on the RELEASE... This site isn't called "VCDRELEASEGROUPIES.COM" you fuckin' spastic - Neversoft::

No sync Probs here, Props for the re-rip, it's not like they HAD to do it. Pretty much the same as the 1st version.

8/8/9

Pic 9
Sound 9
Film 9

Never saw much up with the first release...Superb quality considering only out last week...thumbs up again TUN.
Just hope METEOR follow with the DVDR.

Stop bitching and enjoy!!!

same release as the last one ..sync issues are fixed hoping they would fix the color 'like the redness' but cant win them all ...LOOKS GREAT ON THE TV ....thanks TUN for the rerip

8/8/10 this movie rocked best starwars ever

admins are laying down the law today..HAHA

__________________
"Imagination is more important than knowledge.
Knowledge is limited. Imagination encircles the world."
-Albert Einstein (1879-1955)

The first release was easily fixed, but this seems ok so far if you couldnt be bothered.

The video quality is obviously the same as the previous TC, which i though was really good apart from the cropping, and now the sound is fixed, also dw33p, they didnt use the WP sound, as one it would of been fiddly as hell to do, and two, the WP sound is much better than this, and is stereo for a start, and sounded pretty sweet through a Surround system, this doesn't.

8/7/9

Since Lucas dont do screeners, people should be greateful for this, as this is probably the last release till the DVD-Rip is out, which is due about Christmas, though AOTC was 3month pre.

PAL NTSC

at the dicreption page http://www.vcdreview.com/info.php/i-52361.html it says it is PAL formated does diz mean i cant watch on a NTSC DVD/TV

This is nice, i got no probs with this version, d/l today

This is the one to get

__________________
Bra!ns

Looks pretty good to me. 8/9/10

LOL You moderators RULE!

On top of that, nice work on sound re-work

V=7 (tough grader)
A=9
M=10



Be safe

GREAT JOB Lucas Arts! This movie compares to the first 3 err the last 3. 4,5, and 6


7/8/10

man come on somone release a good tc

im sorry but tun could of done much more to fix the release, example: fix redness, fix audio issues which were fixed but now other spots of synce probs now.. tun paid alot for this shit, and wont take the time to filter it. They need to get a better source. Im thinking their source was cut up already and thats why their having sync issues... redness is easily fixable and should have been fixed, aspect ratio is correct but still has some of the picture cropped.. 6/5/6
I seriously hope somone gets a different source cuz red star wars is shitty star wars..

I really want to see a different source tc......

I'll wait for the DVD-R, no thanks TUN, you see it once in the theater...thats enough!!
If visa source was original it would of kicked arse beyond anything to date!
?/?/8

__________________
AOL member since 1998

As already mentioned very dark but audio is spot on from what I've checked so far

7/8/?

__________________

I hate to rain on your parade guys but I don't have to wait for another release. I got one called Star.Wars.Episode.3.Revenge.Of.The.Sith.iNTERNAL.TC.AC3.5.1.XviD-CRDS and it looks great (NO RED), sounds GREAT, it just plain IS GREAT! As for the TUN release. It's pretty good but I like the one mentioned above better. NO RED!

TUN RERIP = 6/9/10

CRDS is the best one so far so I give the video a 9 audio 9 and movie a 10 of course.

::EDIT:: Rate THIS release and stop creating release threads or be banned! ::

__________________
People generally see what they want to see

Re: whats the problem ???

...
v8
a7 (still not wp quality)
movie 10+++++
guess i had to review it

:: Grrr. Leave the lectures to Professors. -K::

I burned this to a DVD, and play it on my TV and it looks almost like an actual DVD rip, aside for the slight darkness... Not hard to fix though, thats why TVs have settings on them.

Much appreciated work TUN..

Video: 9 (Oh-so-slightly cropped, and a tad dark)
Audio: 7 (Stereo, but doesn't sounds as good as the WorkPrint.. Nice try though.)
Movie: 9 (Go see it in theatres before you download it...)

lip sync

i read in the star on wed that it goes out of sync in the original film at this point it was in a film gaffs article so its not the realese

quote:

---

Originally posted by Firebrand
I hate to rain on your parade guys but I don't have to wait for another release. I got one called Star.Wars.Episode.3.Revenge.Of.The.Sith.iNTERNAL.TC.AC3.5.1.XviD-CRDS and it looks great (NO RED), sounds GREAT, it just plain IS GREAT! As for the TUN release. It's pretty good but I like the one mentioned above better. NO RED! CRDS is the best one so far so I give the video a 9 audio 9 and movie a 10 of course.

---

__________________

looks nice on the sample

good now i can get this again
didnt want to dl something that was out of sync

__________________
Tired of only scene rips? come join the YourRips.org community

this garbage needs to be nuked....on disc 3 during the reconstruction/death scene, there is severe distortion and pixelation. the sound is jacked and the picture skips and becomes out of sync.

why cant people do a legitimate rerip and the preview it before they post it? i just wasted my last CDRs burning this movie.

video - 9 (until the end, where it drops to a 2)

audio - 9 (until the end, where it drops to a 1)

movie - 10

__________________
BUY WIDESCREEN ONLY!!!


You paid for the whole movie, watch it that way!

Getting FS is like paying someone full price for an ice cream cone and then having 20% licked off for you!

Tut tut

Why must every1 be so dam ungreatful? i dont see you people sayin how good your attemp was?.. Oh thats coz u havin done one. I think this is a fine re-rip. things can always get better but im greatfull for this above par rls. They did bother with a Rerip.

7 / 7 / ?.

Not a fan of the films but still a rls ill watch.

PS. try Acholol 120..... or Deamon tools.. have you not heard of Drive emulation?? You can watch rls on ur Pc to see wat their like and emulate the files? Hmm obviouly not! stop postin NOOB and learn a few things b4 u hava cry!

::EDIT:: Who the fuck are you? Jerk, get the fuck off my Internet! - Neversoft::

the release is fine. I just watched it and had NO errors at the end.

8/7/10

Didnt really find the sync issue to bad on TUN'S first rip .. none the less we all knew they would put out a repack .. thanks but ill pass on this

This one would be better if it weren't so dark.

8, 8, 10

9 on the picture if it weren't so dark and 10 if it weren't so grainy.

IMO the sync issues werent bad enough to waste credits with but nonetheless cheers for the repack TUN ..

:: Get rid of that "big ass" sig. -K::

quote:

---

Originally posted by zacjedi
this garbage needs to be nuked....on disc 3 during the reconstruction/death scene, there is severe distortion and pixelation. the sound is jacked and the picture skips and becomes out of sync.

why cant people do a legitimate rerip and the preview it before they post it? i just wasted my last CDRs burning this movie.

video - 9 (until the end, where it drops to a 2)

audio - 9 (until the end, where it drops to a 1)

movie - 10

---

i know you're supposed to comment on quality so...

7/8/8. saw in theatres.

420killa, your sig is just a smidge to big.

good release, well done

Not a bad release...pictures not as good as the WP but theres no timer and its in ws..a tad dark and alot of red in certain scenes but still very watchable 7/7/8

Release worked well for me, very watchable, cant knock anything seriously about this release, nice one TUN
9/9/8

looks great, checked a few rars.

already seen the movie but will watch again tonight.

8/9/10

The quality of the repacked TC is slightly better than their previous TC. There were less artifacts and the video was slightly sharper. Very watchable. Good job TUN!

Great Movie. Mr. Lucas definately redeemed himself from the debacle of Ep 1 and slightly less disappointing Ep 2. Well, after seeing this in DLP at the theater, it's gonna be hard to rate this release, but here goes...

Based on watching first 20 minutes or so:

Video: 7 (Very red in parts and dark)
Audio: 8.5 (Not too bad but I expected better)
Movie: 10 ('Bout F'in time!!!)

__________________
"he took my stapler and he never brought it back "

Milton Waddams (Office Space)

Video - 8 - A bit red, yes, but clear, and widescreen. Well done.
Audio 7 - Mono the whole way, but very clear. I highly anticipate a stereo or a surround track.
Movie - 10 - Finally, a prequel that lives up to the hype.

__________________
This is my sig.

7.5/8/9.5

Little red for me, not really - some adjustments with brightness was needed, adjusted the color settings a little too, bit cropped for me but definetly watchable. Oh well on the foreign title/intro. Thanks TUN.

great rip more than happy with it
9/9/9

HELP...

*BORING SHIT EDITED OUT*

PS - If this is inappropriate for this thread, sorry, but I am at wits end...

::EDIT:: And we're at our wits end because people can't be bothered to post their fucking questions in the correct part of the forum. Instead, they ignore our VERY CLEAR rules and post questions in comments threads instead. WHY MOTHER? WHY? - Neversoft::