VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Doom *SVCD* - TELECINE - PRODiGY (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=66964)

IMPORTANT, PLEASE READ

1 NO REQUESTING MOVIES OR SAMPLES (THIS INCLUDES REQUESTS FOR OTHER GROUPS TO RELEASE THIS MOVIE!)

2 DO NOT DISCUSS WHERE TO DOWNLOAD MOVIES OR SAMPLES

3 NO FLAMING

4 NO "SPOILERS"

5 NO SCENE-RELATED DISCUSSION/RUMORS (ESPECIALLY REGARDING BUSTS)

6 COMMENT ON THIS RELEASE ONLY (AND ONLY IF YOU'VE SEEN AT LEAST THE SAMPLE). THIS IS THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE THREAD!

7 NO "NOOB" QUESTIONS SUCH AS "HOW DO I WATCH THIS?" ASK IN THE APPROPRIATE PART OF THE FORUM

8 NO DISCUSSING TRADING/SELLING. IF YOU SELL COPIES, GO AWAY YOU'RE NOT WELCOME HERE


*** PEOPLE IGNORING THE RULES WILL BE BANNED ***

Good Quality Release
Prodigy, you guys ROCK!

Audio is clear and crisp
Video is just right
Not to dark like the other rls's.

Video: 8.0
Audio: 8.0
Movie: Havent watched it yet, in the process

Sample looked damn impressive.

very good for a TC.

8/9/??

As dark as the movie is, i cant really tell if this is dark, but the colors seem vibrant even considering.

Good audio, couple spots it seemed out of sync so far, around the 15 min mark, any one else notice that?

hopefully this is somewhat good. love the games, and dig the rock.

__________________
"much to learn you still have..."

9/8/6
Real good telecine. Nice enough sound.
Movie was.. well.. can´t expect a lovely masterpiece based on a fps game, but it´s a nice way to spend a few hours.
The fps scenes are real fun and kinda inspires me to play the game again.

Very nice. FPS scenes that were terrible on the cams look nice and are the only part of the flick worthwhile. The constantly shooting dead bodies is funny too.
8/8/2

cd 1 goes out of sync around 15:00 but fixes itself...

now it would HELP if it was a TC which it isnt anyhow decent rls nuttin spectacular and yea look b4 u speak as this AINT A tc

Judgeing from the sample...

V: 8.5 - Oh so slightly grainy, but very good none the less..

A: 8 - Direct, and sounds stereo...

M: n/a - Will download full version when an xvid or DVDR is released...

Nice job Prodigy!

Good release but its not a TC.

Why do groups lie these days? Just be honest and take a nuke, cause your going to get nuked anyways.

__________________
Coming soon....

Well as for what it is... a TS


v- 8 Colors are right on! But the camera is out of focus and blurry throughout the whole movie, i like my copies a little crisiper and sharper!


s- 9 A+++++ good work!



m - 2


I would rather play the doom95 on a p1 with 32mb of ram then watch this one again!!!

__________________


:::FOR RENT:::

quote:

---

Originally posted by MyNameIsAnakin
Good release but its not a TC.

Why do groups lie these days? Just be honest and take a nuke, cause your going to get nuked anyways.

---

__________________
HOLLA AT YO BOY!

Well i DOnt Know If I Would Call This A TC But Works For Me And Fast Too
From Sample:

Video=8

Audio=8

Movie=Not Seen

__________________
GGG-UnOt

THUGLIFE

MaKaVeLi All DaY

8
8
possible the worst movie ever made?

__________________
I Just Want to Be like Radiohead, And do something ingenious.

quote:

---

possible the worst movie ever made?

---

__________________
"Signatures Suck"

it IS out of sync -_- confirmed by a few people

watched the whole thing, just got done.

there are about 4-5 spots where there are maybe 15-30 second moments where its out of sync. nothing major, still quite watchable.

__________________
"much to learn you still have..."

based on sample:

v: 8
s: 9
m: ehhh..

this is a telesync rather than a TC all the way. TC's have that movie theater look to the film. now compared to other TS's, this one is awesome.

Good release you don't really notice the out sync it sorts it's self out quickly good work.

8/7/6

__________________
Shit Happens..............

EDIT: Ask where to get movies again and you're banned .P

Sync issues

Quiet a few times it goes out of sync real nasty, then comes back to normal. Kind of annoying but watchable. First disk about 16 min in goes out of sync then comes back at 18:30 or so, then 29:20 again, then at the end of disk too. CD2 begins all the way out of sync. If you don't pay much attention then it's not big deal since every thing else is good. It reminds me "40 Year Old Virgin" - it had same problem.

Video - 8.5 / Audio - 8.5 (with out sync issues) 6.5 (with sync issues) movie - will watch..

well i hope its a tc coz i don't bother wastein my bandwith on any thing less............... review to cum soon...

Nice ts its never tc

8/8/probably shite

looks good on a tele.... maybe not a tc but good enough for now

sync issues are annoying.... should check these things before release !!!!


for tc (doubtful)


video- 7
audio-6 (would be 8.5 if not for the sync problems)
movie-6

nfo is a piece of shit, prodigy aka ex saosin member ( not the good ones) trying to rebuild the old name with some piece of shit comming from russian news group, crap.

http://img473.imageshack.us/img473/4543/saw2tsxvidmaven2az.jpg

at least, maVen taging right ...

aaaand the reason youre posting jpg's of SAW 2 in the DOOM review thread is ??????????????

to show a ts what should be, and a tc should be better then this, you don't have to look at what movie it is, but mainly at what the sharpness and colors are ( for this type of movie ) as for a TC even if the movie is *fucking dark* you don't mind , because the print is made like this, so the movie is like this, if they do a TC with a 24p camera on a smaller screen ( what russian does ) then its normal that on this type of movie, you will clearly see this is not a tc, wich mean, this group is full of shit.

i would be interested to see what a good ts could be compared to this. This is my point .

Video - 8
Sound - 8
Movie - 4 (What a peice of shit this movie was, why cant they make a movie about a videogame as good as DUNE2 anymore?? Both the movie and the game where sweeeet)

Video is nice. Its a dark movie, and thats to be expected. I'm not saying that its not a TC, but with all the previous releases, the dark scenes were pretty much unwatchable. At least in this version you can see whats going on. I'm not seeing any signs that this is a mislabeled Telesync. So judging as a Telecine:

8- as good as we're gonna get until a screener. Dark, but nice.

7- The sound is nice and direct, but has multiple sync problems throughout.

7- Definitely entertaining, but not oscar worthy. :-)

CATBOX

nice release, but imo not a tc

v 8.5 (a little blurry, but decent qualty and more watchable than the others)

a 9 (very clear audio)

m ?

__________________

quote:

---

Originally posted by pHo
the difference between compression and encoding is:

compression software works the same way as trying to get The 404, who is 350lbs, through a normal door. its method is to basically keep kicking The 404 until he gets thru the door. This works quickly, but leaves a nasty mess.

encoding software is the equivalent of The 404 going on a diet and walking thru the door. takes longer and sometimes more skill, but ultimately worth it.

---

The best release of this movie so far, i give them that much but that's where it ends.
I refuse to Rate a movie that's mislabeled,
they are ether too thick to know the difference between a TS and a TC
or they just take us all for Mugs.

__________________
*Meet the rest of the VCDQ Crew, HERE *

quote:

---

Originally posted by katalist
Video - 8
Sound - 8
Movie - 4 (What a peice of shit this movie was, why cant they make a movie about a videogame as good as DUNE2 anymore?? Both the movie and the game where sweeeet)

---

unfortunately many sites are nuking for being a TS lol

also with the tc.xvid-asteriods version as well

quote:

---

unfortunately many sites are nuking for being a TS lol

---

Watched both parts, and found that the audio is out of sync in some parts on both CD images.

I have been waiting for a good copy to surface of this movie

V-8
A-6 (out of sync really annoys me)
M-? Will Post After Finishing Movie

as a tc..... piss poor
as a ts which i think it is..... not bad

overall not sharp enuff, and colors are over bright at times

8/8

thats being generous

__________________
One Day The Dead Shall Walk The Earth.

Video - a really good TS

Audio - hangs a bit on my PC (like you plug and unplug the line - connector) but only the Movie, Sample is OK!!???

Movie - haven't seen it yet



Cu




Penecho

tc or ts?

my opinon is who cares! its as good as most tc's these days. what is important here is, that people are getting you these releases. nice to hear of audio out of sync issues, but no need to bash the video saying ts no tc. its free

v=8 abit grainy
a=7 some sync issues
m=3 if you like the game you may enjoy the movie

__________________
bleh!

watchable

Much better copy! Colors look vivid and sound is stable.. 8/9/5.

--- VCDQuality is the Best ---

much better

Looks good.. Much better than the cams, first posted. 8/8/5..

it's a TC it has credits at the end when has a tS ever had credits

__________________
hi

quote:

---

Originally posted by hutt
Does anyone really give a fuck when something is nuked?
I have watched plenty of 'nuked' movies and there were perfectly fine.
What's the point?

---

Best svcd out so far of this movie. 8/7/7

can sum1 pls for and for all tell me da diff between a TS and a TC......!!!!
pls.....!

Well, I think this was mislabeled as a TC because this is looking like (from sample) a REALLY GOOD TS, which we haven't seen much of lately. Will post my ratings when I'm done seeing the movie.

Syncing ?

you guys have been talking bout syncing does it happends like 5 times thhrought the movie or constantlyso far this looks liek the best quality jsut want to be sure about the syncing Before i do anything else

Nice release overall.

8/7/6


Movie really isn't as bad as all that. Depends if you like no-brainer movies with lots of guns. If you do then you can take it for what it is.

Sorry but this is not a Telecine, if it was then why is it so cropped, also the overall video quality is not that great and the Audio has random sync issues, I have better quality VHS movies.


6/7/7

quote:

---

Originally posted by Schmiggy JK23
Good audio, couple spots it seemed out of sync so far, around the 15 min mark, any one else notice that?

---

__________________
"Allen is having a small problem and needs help adjusting his additude" - Flutterby
"K meet of a the have we come in" - fisher @ SummaDayze '04, wtf?

6/5/4

quote:

---

Originally posted by kidrock
can sum1 pls for and for all tell me da diff between a TS and a TC......!!!!
pls.....!

---

NOT a TC. It's a TS. Clearly given away by the dodgy audio and the wonky end credits.

Nice quality TS tho.

FFS enough with the current trend of mislabeled TC's though.

As for this movie. Fuck watching it, no thanks.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Captnhook

CAM - basically just a guy who uses either regular or professional camcorder to shoot the movie either from TV or actually inside a movie theatre (in most copies you can actually see and hear the audience as well).

Telesync - a copy which was shot in an empty cinema or from the projection booth with a professional camera, directly connected to the sound source, these are generally very good quality.

---

Doom

I just finished watching this version and the dialogue was out of sync. Did this happen to anyone else?

Couple of things.
Now I'm no hardcore scener or anything (I'm not some lamer bittorrent kid but I have absolutely nothing FTP-wise, which is what counts) but I do know a bit about the state of the scene today and about video in general, and last I heard DTS-2 hadn't been cracked yet. So the poster above who said Prodigy used the same DTS source as some other group was wrong... it's probably line source from a deaf-people jack in the theater.
Remember the "concession stand" bit in the ORC release? From the line-in.
Also, there's no rule about TSs or TCs and credits... if they're not there, they probably chopped them off to fit on 2 CDs.

I'll repeat what everyone has been saying about this release: It's a mislabeled telesync. Nuked pretty much all over. Not that nuking makes a release invalid (remember that group TheFly with the EXCELLENT DVDSCRs that got nuked for a bitrate header problem?) but hey, rules are rules.

Damnit, I rambled again.

In conclusion, this went wide in Russia on the 27th so maybe we'll have a real TC soon.

watched this on the tv tonight...

very good quality overall, especially for such a dark movie.

video is excellent, audio is clear (few sync problems, nothing thats a big deal as they clear up quickly).

movie.. good for what it was.

v:8.5
a: 8
m: 6.5

lipsync miles out please nuke

nuke this release the lipsync is miles out

Nice release...v - 9; a - 8.5 ; m - 7

quote:

---

Originally posted by dragon25
NOT really, but to be honest i would rather respect a group for being honest and stop l;ieying for fuck sake.

why have there been so many bloody grouops claimed tc when their ts or even a bloody cam?

hell if you lot that dont give a shit and have bandwith to waste and time to burn then fine, but i prefer to know what im getting when downloading and not finding the quality of the film is a cam when i was expecting a tc .

the tc (ts) xvid by asteriods is better though in my opion

---

WHY ISN'T THIS NUKED?!?!?!

Yeah I found this release to be out of sync lots. It does correct itself, but still not proper.

V - 8.4 (Dark a but but still pretty good!)

A - 4.4 (Sorry, OOS issues drop it 5 points!)

M - 4.2 (Total Crap! A half decent director wouldn't have fucked this movie up!)

Anyways, not sure why this hasn't been nuked, It looks like everyone else had Sync issues. You put the 2nd CD in & right away the audio is out, that and it looks like it's missing a few seconds between the 1st & 2nd parts. Thanks though, just wish audio & video could be more in sync. Too many releases are like this now, and it's a shame they're not being nuked for it!

Thanks again...

GOOD QUALITY AND VIDEO AND SOUND EXCELLENT

I only noticed just one sync issue at the beginning of CD2. I thought the picture was very clear and may yet be a TC, but is has this shiny thing in bright spots which makes me think it's a TS.
But hey, the quality is great and it's free.

V: 9
A: 8
M: 7

YAH!

Finally justice prevails! It's now Nuked! Thanks for the release guys, hopefully we get a proper now!