Show all 64 posts from this thread on one page |
VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- The Matrix: Reloaded *iNTERNAL* - TELECINE - Replica (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=22331)
wee telecine
:: ban next time -M$
great, too bad about the sync tho
7/5/9
__________________
pretty nice TC
well i usually get outta sync audio on most of the samples i get so i wont no if this is outta sync till i grab cd1 but audio is good
video is nice, a lil dark but good
8/8/9
::edit didnt read the nfo..::
__________________
quote:
Originally posted by deftones6
How are you rating the video and audio without actually having the movie????
better quality than the ctp rls... but whats the point of gettin this.. just wait for a dvdscr...
definitely looks much better than all the othe previous rls. good job on the audio too. the ctp audio was by far the most clear.
colors are pretty vibrant also
8/8 tc rating
__________________
They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."
looks good. audio is clear, but obviously desynched (as said in the nfo)
slight ghosting towards the begining of the sample towards the left though.
anyways, its nice to see this release get out, but i dunno if i can sit through a partially out-of-sync version of this shitty movie.
props to replica.
9/7/9
flipp0r I disagree I liked the APM sound better, the CTP sound was a bit hollow
__________________
?sdrawkcab ffuts gnidaer etah uoy t'noD
noone here knows if a dvd screener will even be produced for this movie.. so stop all the "wait for dvdscr" shit in every thread for this movie.. next time i see it that person gets the special fuzzy treatment
__________________
"Nothing says OBEY ME like a severed head on a fence post,"
Nice quality, for a telecine. 7/7/9, I checked the sample and the sound did not seem out of sync to me, but i will have to check the release.
quote:
Originally posted by Blackwolf
Was the audio synced with the CTP telesync release or from the dolby 5.1 soundtrack they used in the dvdr release? hopefully the 5.1 sound track
Badass Rls... I like the audio... Its pretty good IMO... Video is great for a TC... Thats after scanning through CD1
8/8/8
__________________
..::HiGHONASCii::..
The quality of the picture isn't bad. the colors seem a little too high in contrast but it is better than the ctp rls. duh, its a TC. They picked a great scene for the sample. If you have good speakers(surround/stereo) then you will appreciate the scene selected on the sample because when the guns start firing it's like an ORGY OF SOUND. You can hear where every gun is coming from. its freakin awesome!
nice video, a little bright but not too bad. as far as the audio sync issue, barely noticable...this release will do me just fine till a DVD scr/retail
did anyone else notice a slight flicker? i may be just seeing things
8/7/9
GOOD GOD NICE JOB!
AUDIO 10
VIDEO 10
MOVIE 10
Props go out to Replica for this release... by far the nicest release of Matrix Reloaded.... too bad it was a dvd screener or dvdrip. Oh well... this also nice.
Mak.
*From CD1*
Where do i start?.I have seen 6 releases of this film now before this one and until now obviously the CTP DVD-r was the best (and SVCD).I would say this release is better by only by a very small amount.The Sample was from where i would estimate to be the end of CD2 and was totally out of sync.CD1 was 100% fine at the beginning apart from the flicker when the titles were coming up,the sound goes completely out of sync towards the end of CD1 when Neo is talking to the Oracle.From this can we now expect either CD2 and CD3 to be comletely out of sync or like CD1 will they be ok at first and go towards the end of each one?.The picture is pretty dark,quite the same as CTP's version.Also when Morpheus is asking another ship to wait for a message from the oracle before the first fight scene with the agents the film freezes for a split second before resuming.
I'm going to upset the masses now and say there isn't that much difference between this and CTP's SVCD T/S!.
The picture isn't great,the sound is brilliant but when audio is out of sync it really annoys me.I don't think i'll resume cd3 if cd2 appears to be the same as CD1.
Oh and before i aam flamed to death the last time i reviewed a release of Reloaded i was inundated with PM's from newbie's asking if i could help them find where to d/l it from.If i get anymore of these PM's i will be forwarding them to administation and they can deal with them as they wish.
Thank-you
__________________
On the sample - colour is okay but the contrast and depth is a bit muggy. However, this beats the CTP version due to NO ANGLE problems (well, of course, it's a Telecine...) which is a major issue in my eyes.
Sound is clear but there are sync issues... those with Xbox's like me will have no trouble changing the sync via the Media Player as it plays to fix this
I watched the sample using winDVD and the audio sync was fine.Downloading cd 1 now.
8/8/...
video nice, audio desynced in parts as stated in nfo, overall decent release, but not needed in my opinion.
quote:
Originally posted by SycoCowz
9/7/9
flipp0r I disagree I liked the APM sound better, the CTP sound was a bit hollow
Re: *From CD1*
quote:
Originally posted by Butch
Oh and before i aam flamed to death the last time i reviewed a release of Reloaded i was inundated with PM's from newbie's asking if i could help them find where to d/l it from.If i get anymore of these PM's i will be forwarding them to administation and they can deal with them as they wish.
Thank-you
__________________
You're only in as much trouble as you think you are.
i think most people seem to not realise the 2nd centropy print was an entirely different print altogether. both video and audio were new, not just the audio, so there was no angle problem on the dvdr.
i think i'll stick to 6ch audio with no discswap personally
__________________
563-773-1880
<Dwaggy> i caught you a delicious Bass
<The404> This is because you are an idiot
Awesome release, video's colors are a bit funky, but overall great, the sound is taken from the dvdr, so it is also excellent (be aware though that it wont be 5.1 because this is an svcd). It goes slightly out of sync from time to time (judging from sample), but it doesn't bother me that much, Ill definately be picking up this release. Anyways
Vid: 8
Sound: 9(woulda been 10, if no sync issue)
Movie: 9
Sync Sound?
How do you sync sound to real time, does anybody know anygood software which can do that besides wmp for xbox?
pHo: knowing it's released by Replica, a dvdr group, it would make sense if they put out a dvdr on it.
Very good vid, colors not 100% natural but still good-looking. A bit dark in some scenes but overall alot better than earlier ones.
The few small desyncs didn't bother me much, hardly noticed actually.
9/9/8
8/10/10
Good work Replica. The colors are too saturated, but if you lower the color saturation on your TV it's fine.
quote:
Originally posted by SycoCowz
9/7/9
flipp0r I disagree I liked the APM sound better, the CTP sound was a bit hollow
quote:
pHo: knowing it's released by Replica, a dvdr group, it would make sense if they put out a dvdr on it.
__________________
563-773-1880
<Dwaggy> i caught you a delicious Bass
<The404> This is because you are an idiot
this is a nice release but i think replica should have experimented with it going on dvdr
quote:
Originally posted by pHo
not entirely sure what you mean.... is there a typo there or am i just being confused ?
gooooood shit!! 8/6/9
__________________
soda box
quote:
Originally posted by pHo
i think most people seem to not realise the 2nd centropy print was an entirely different print altogether. both video and audio were new, not just the audio, so there was no angle problem on the dvdr.
Just finished watching CD 1
Video is a little blurry. I would've liked it a little sharper.
Not enough contrast. Darks are not dark enough. Lights are not light enough.
Audio sounds very clear and good but is out of sync.
Movie. Not enough blood and bruising and too much talk. And that rave scene. ugh!
8/7/8
Ok, I thought a TC was supposed to be BETTER than a TS? lol
You know, I really can't rate this release very high.
1) There are already too many TS's of Reloaded out there that are decent quality (especially APM and Centropy).
2) Come on, guys - MONO sound? You could have done much better for a TC (and SHOULD have, for an unnecessary release like this...)
3) Picture isn't any better than Centropy's TS (and I'd go so far to say it's slightly worse...)
Again, NOT from the sample. I've watched the whole thing. I don't know how people can give the audio here a high score (unless, of course, they are only judging by the sample, freaking idiots). It's slightly out of sync (only slightly, though), not all that crisp, and is MONO... I mean, hell, they could have just put the mono audio track through both left and right when they encoded this...
6/6/8
__________________
--FunkyFlyChicken
"It's time to ruffle some feathers"
quote:
Originally posted by pHo
i think most people seem to not realise the 2nd centropy print was an entirely different print altogether. both video and audio were new, not just the audio, so there was no angle problem on the dvdr.
i think i'll stick to 6ch audio with no discswap personally
quote:
Originally posted by neoparadox
8/10/10
Good work Replica. The colors are too saturated, but if you lower the color saturation on your TV it's fine.
LOL. APM's Matrix Reloaded release was a vcd encode of Centropy's SVCD, so APM's audio is actually a downgraded version of Centropy's audio.
Stupid Question( i am new,sorry): How can i find the links for this release? On this Site? Can anyone posting the links for me? Thanks bye major
quote:
Originally posted by m3442a
Stupid Question( i am new,sorry): How can i find the links for this release? On this Site? Can anyone posting the links for me? Thanks bye major
__________________
soda box
*Judging from sample*
Nice release. Audio has no flaws exept from the mentioned SMALL desync.
Video is kind of dark, and a little blurry. But this is alot better than any telesync.
__________________
What the fuck does WTF mean?!?
quote:
Originally posted by Kn!ghTMarE
mislabeled? wat is it then? if its not dumb and dumberer, then it is...?
::LOL! -FuzZ::
Re: Ok, I thought a TC was supposed to be BETTER than a TS? lol
quote:
Originally posted by FunkyFlyChicken
2) Come on, guys - MONO sound? You could have done much better for a TC (and SHOULD have, for an unnecessary release like this...)
Again, NOT from the sample. I've watched the whole thing. I don't know how people can give the audio here a high score (unless, of course, they are only judging by the sample, freaking idiots). It's slightly out of sync (only slightly, though), not all that crisp, and is MONO... I mean, hell, they could have just put the mono audio track through both left and right when they encoded this...
6/6/8
Where the heck do i get .cue files for this thing?
__________________
What the fuck does WTF mean?!?
quote:
Originally posted by Kn!ghTMarE
mislabeled? wat is it then? if its not dumb and dumberer, then it is...?
::LOL! -FuzZ::
8/7/1
Ok, i skipped through the whole thing now, and i have to admit, that i am a little dissaponted.
Actually i am a DVDrip only-guy, and i never knew what Telecine was until now.
I think this movie alot more like a Telesync than i thought it would.
So i am still really looking forward to a DVDrip or DVDscr.
But, geez its the best so far (isnt it?)
7/9/10
__________________
What the fuck does WTF mean?!?
quote:
Originally posted by Kn!ghTMarE
mislabeled? wat is it then? if its not dumb and dumberer, then it is...?
::LOL! -FuzZ::
About the Mono sound...
In response to the question about the "mono sound", let me reiterate my earlier response.
I NEVER judge by samples. I always judge by the entire release. Now, I imagine it is possible that the version I got had been "downgraded" or something, possibly screwing the audio up - who knows. It's almost impossible to tell sometimes...
BUT -
In my copy of Replica's Matrix Reloaded TC, the sound only comes through the RIGHT CHANNEL. I am playing it on a Dolby Digital 5.1 system - as I do with all of my movies. I also plugged in the headphones to see what it sounded like (since I am a bit hard of hearing). Right channel comes through decent enough - left channel was completely silent (and I tested this during the opening sequence with Trinity blasting out of the window, firing on the Agent... Should have been a perfect point for testing...)
I HAVE the Centropy release as well, and that one sounds incredible (especially for a TS). This one doesn't sound anywhere near as good - not to mention you have the bad syncs...
ANYONE HERE have the same problem with the FULL RELEASE(Not the damn sample...)? The Mono Sound?
I watched Charlies Angels 2 TS last night, and that one was fine (audio both channels on headphones, came through all speakers also)
__________________
--FunkyFlyChicken
"It's time to ruffle some feathers"
Hmm intresting, neither me or my friend got that issue, we got perfect clear stereo. Have you tried another media player or output mode?
Great job on telecine, but the sound dub could be better
Well, I watched the first disc on my DVD player on my 36" TV with the sound being piped through my Dolby Digital/DTS receiver, and I gotta say I think it's damned nice! The sound is incredible...for a telecine with a hacked together audio track from another groups telesync. The picture is as clear as you could ask for without getting a DVD screener, reminds me of when I used to rent old VHS tapes at Blockbuster that had been watched 100 times before I got to it.
Regardless tho, this release is very nice and will likely hold me over until something ripped from a DVD or the DVD itself comes out.
8/9/10
YAY TELECINE.... quality looks great but i cant find any place to get it can somebody e-mail me on how to get this great movie
[email protected]
quote:
Originally posted by LabRat
YAY TELECINE.... quality looks great but i cant find any place to get it can somebody e-mail me on how to get this great movie
[email protected]
8 / 7 / 8
BEEN A BIT
wow been long time since i add my 2 cents but i sticking with the ctp till a dvdscr dont waste time i usuly waite till a dvd scr of a movie is realsed and download it anyway but with matrix i made an exeption.
__________________
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted BY kjeks
Where the heck do i get .cue files for this thing?
lol
Re: BEEN A BIT
quote:
Originally posted by Skippy_2002ca
wow been long time since i add my 2 cents but i sticking with the ctp till a dvdscr dont waste time i usuly waite till a dvd scr of a movie is realsed and download it anyway but with matrix i made an exeption.
Ah yes that was a noob thing to say now that i look at it.... but i cant find it on irc, bit torrent and i even lowerd myself to looking on kazaa. My friend can access ftp sites with these movies...
quote:
Originally posted by LabRat
YAY TELECINE.... quality looks great but i cant find any place to get it can somebody e-mail me on how to get this great movie
[email protected]
quote:PLEASE for your own sake, stop before you're flamed to bits and quoted in everybody's sigs If you haven't got FTP access it's going to be a day or two before it filters down onto IRC and eons before it's on Kazaa (by which point it'll be reencoded into Quicktime or something equally shite).
Originally posted by LabRat
Ah yes that was a noob thing to say now that i look at it.... but i cant find it on irc, bit torrent and i even lowerd myself to looking on kazaa. My friend can access ftp sites with these movies...
What the heck does he say at the end of CD 3.. Around the "to be concluded" message..
I think its finnish? "trachibi finale" or something.. what does it mean! Kind of ruins the release!!
__________________
What the fuck does WTF mean?!?
quote:
Originally posted by Kn!ghTMarE
mislabeled? wat is it then? if its not dumb and dumberer, then it is...?
::LOL! -FuzZ::
very nice release, a bit late though, bit better than the CTP release, sounds pretty gr8 too
8/8/7
Matrix Reloaded
Definately the best release yet, and thats a fact
Picture 8 - Nice a clear
Sound 8 - Out of sync? Wateva
Movie 9.5 (Nothing ever deserves a 10, cus Matrix 3 will kick a$$)
Much Respect to Replica, keep up the good work
Au revoir Homies
ir you mean that there is only sound coming ftom one side, call it 'single-channel sound', so as to distinguish it from 'mono' sound, whih can be dual-channel but still mono.
__________________
This perceived misuse of Internet resources caused former Dutch education minister Loek Hermans to comment: "It would be nice if the students at Twente University would use their fast connections for information and education purposes, instead of downloading huge amounts of porn."
____________________________________ knowing is the easy part _____________
.
quote:
Originally posted by Krakn3Dfx
Well, I watched the first disc on my DVD player on my 36" TV with the sound being piped through my Dolby Digital/DTS receiver, and I gotta say I think it's damned nice! The sound is incredible...for a telecine with a hacked together audio track from another groups telesync. The picture is as clear as you could ask for without getting a DVD screener, reminds me of when I used to rent old VHS tapes at Blockbuster that had been watched 100 times before I got to it.
Regardless tho, this release is very nice and will likely hold me over until something ripped from a DVD or the DVD itself comes out.
8/9/10
quote:
Originally posted by Skorpio
10? What are you high on glue? The first part of this movie sucked ass. Than when they showed Keanus ass i almost puked into my popcorn. Due to the fact that I almost fell asleep and if it wasnt for the coke i bought i would have. It kept me awake untill the second half which was by far much better. I give the the second have a B+. for and overall grade of a C+. They made this move into 3 parts because they are greedy bastards and almost ruined the movie. I hope they dont do the same in the 3rd part.
the MPAA are going to be fuckin pissed. cot damn i love this scene.
(edit: i already posted i my thoughts on this rls but just had to say it, first the Hulk pre, then this)
__________________
soda box
quote:
Originally posted by Skorpio
10? What are you high on glue? The first part of this movie
__________________
What the fuck does WTF mean?!?
quote:
Originally posted by Kn!ghTMarE
mislabeled? wat is it then? if its not dumb and dumberer, then it is...?
::LOL! -FuzZ::
i think its to be concluded but in german.
__________________
soda box
is the audio sped-up to meet the video? i keep hearing high pitched chipmunk voices.
__________________
soda box
nice release
I just finished watching this on my dvd player with my 5.1 Home Theatere system, and all i have to say is WOW!!
Sadly the movie is completly out of sync for about 5 - 8 mins i dunno... the whole scene from when the guy enters the counslers office (Around End of Disc 1) to the end of the conversation of the Oracle (Start of Dis 1), thats all i noticed, everything else was nicely synced... The audio was the best! i cant beleive this track came from a TS source... it was amazing i mean the wooshing and those other noises were very nice... I usually get some pixalted parts when ever i try svcds, vcs etc... This was different tough none of that and the colors were very good too. DVD Scr quality almost. The out of sync parts were the only bothering thing
RATING -9/8/9
Watched the whole thing.Wanted to see how the movie will fair as a second viewing at home.
video =9
audio=6
movie=still an over written ,pretentious ,boring piece of green dung. 0
called for immediate erasure.
All times are GMT. The time now is 10:33 PM. | Show all 64 posts from this thread on one page |
Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.3.0
Copyright © Jelsoft Enterprises Limited 2000 - 2002.