VCDQuality Forums - Kill Bill: Volume 1 *SVCD* *iNTERNAL* - WORKPRINT

Show all 64 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Kill Bill: Volume 1 *SVCD* *iNTERNAL* - WORKPRINT - VideoCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=30094)

Posted by firefighter on 10-23-2003 07:26 PM:

Kill Bill: Volume 1 *SVCD* - WORKPRINT - VideoCD

My Opinion , this copy is by far the nicest out so far. WideScreen. Sounded Excellent. Only thing that didnt make this that much nicer was the *Clear* watermark scrolling (property of). But hey i can live with it, this release will do just fine till Retail. Gj VideCD.

Love the nfo too , rofl

º Release Notes... º
º º
º What Can We Say.. We Lost.. However Its Not Easy Beating KAZAA º

7/8/8

__________________
All the excitement of a trip to hell with none of the negitive side affects!

Posted by Jdigital03 on 10-23-2003 07:56 PM:

overall ill take this over the FTM/OPIUM versions anyday of the week!

8/9/9

thanx VideoCD keep em coming

Posted by slurmman on 10-23-2003 08:42 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by lax01
yeah just got the sample...

NUKE - this is definitely screener quality

great SVCD...get this.

nuke why? it's internal and a proper.

but what I want to know is, what took them so fucking long? I woulda liked this proper last month

DEFINITELY download this copy and fuck all the rest. I saw the original shitty workprint with bad framerate, and the ONLY problem was framerate and real changes, both of which have been fixed in this release.

__________________

Posted by desertboy on 10-23-2003 08:49 PM:

No framerate issues that the first workprints had and a good picture this is the best copy so far. Worth getting if you a fan of the film or haven't seen it yet but will absolutely not pay to see it at the cinemas.

Only viewed the sample but I'm getting the rest as we speak.

for a workprint remember 9/8/8.5

PS Slurman you seem to be the first person to post who actually seen this copy otherwise why no mention of framerate (Unless you didn't cath the first WP I suppose)
Bastard beat me to it.

__________________
You're only in as much trouble as you think you are.

Posted by Chewsmoka on 10-23-2003 08:52 PM:

This release pred days ago - it just now showed up on vcdq. Easily the best quality so far, thank god, wasn't impressed with the previous efforts.

8/8/8

__________________
Ignorance Is Bliss. An Example -

quote:
Originally posted by platinum_bomb
Dude, It wasn't there and still isn't... I was waiting to see what the pic looked like cuz the release was up, but there was no pic and i didn't find the sample, mo fo. Don't make me come and tie ur arms to ur chair and beat u silly with your own keyboard

lol

Will edit this after i get it.

Posted by labrat1 on 10-23-2003 08:56 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by labrat1

.......beep.....flash(white diamond)......9,8,7,6,5,4,3,2,1,...beep..

no more of this

any way Svcd of there own rip

8/9/9 <---still the same good film :P

__________________

L A B _ R A T

Posted by VCDz on 10-23-2003 09:26 PM:

Video = 9 (Only bad thing is the Transparent 'Property Of' Water mark)

Audio = 9 (It's VHS!)

Movie = Dunno, Haven't had time to watch it yet.

Great Release VideoCD!

__________________
VCDz = Xilf .

quote:
Originally posted by viv
Hi! i´m new...aand i´ve a question:
What means a TEG-vcd
do i need a special codec to watch "teg-vcd´s"?

Posted by Stillwater on 10-23-2003 09:36 PM:

The release pre'd days ago did it Chewsmoka? Funny, because the nfo has today as a release date.

I love know-it-alls!

Quality is nice....I saw it at the theatre and the movie kicked ass. Tried to watch the previous workprint and it's nice to have if you desperately want to see it again, but music selections were so important in this movie I think it's missing something when they are not present or are different in this workprint.

Hopefully the MPAA gets their shit in order and we get some DVD screeners.....they are talking about VHS right now. ;(

Posted by kronik on 10-23-2003 09:40 PM:

9/9/9
This movie owns.

Posted by firefighter on 10-23-2003 09:50 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Stillwater
The release pre'd days ago did it Chewsmoka? Funny, because the nfo has today as a release date.

I love know-it-alls!

Yup , pre'd almost two days ago. I Still dont understand reason for internal. This copy is great and should be let out and about to all

__________________
All the excitement of a trip to hell with none of the negitive side affects!

Posted by Davy on 10-23-2003 09:51 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Stillwater
The release pre'd days ago did it Chewsmoka? Funny, because the nfo has today as a release date.

I love know-it-alls!

Yes, it did pre almost 2 days ago...

As for the sample, looks good quality - slight hiss when i turn up volume, but that could just be my TV.. I've not watched any other copies, been waiting on a better release..
Clear, Crisp Audio with a slight hiss as mentioned (only when loud though), Video is good..

8/7/?

Posted by MoViEmAn72 on 10-23-2003 09:55 PM:

1 Question??? yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy release this again and again???
The previous release was much better and very crisp and clear what the hell u guys thinking about?
How about something new already??? This one definately not a workprint someone smokin that shiznat again?
overall 7 for trying but not as good as previous

Posted by MTV on 10-23-2003 10:02 PM:

Yep its better. good quality. but hey guys pls dont slam the 1st w/p it was good & so feckin fast to get out as well .

8 / 8 / 9 <-- still like the film. : )

¯`'·.¸(¯`'·.¸©©B.M.P - M T V ©©¸.·'´¯)¸.·'´¯

Posted by ShorN on 10-23-2003 11:00 PM:

my god i was waiting for this !
after getting the opium release i watched once, but the framerate problem was really annoying, this fixes that nicely!

Video - 9 (remember its a workprint!)
Audio - 9 (very clear)
Movie - 10 (kick ass)

My greatest thanks go out to videocd for this, I make it my release of the year!

__________________
"Do You Realise What You've Done!" - Llyod Christmas, D & D

Posted by Mr_Grinch on 10-23-2003 11:36 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by acme420
whats the deal with the framerate? isnt the movies in the theater at 23/24 fps? i dont see people going to the front office demanding their money back cuz the movie was only at 24fps instead of 29.975fps.

Framerate of the original workprint that was released was hideous, looked like a very badly done pal->ntsc job! It made the fight scenes absolutely horrible. VideoCD are doing damn well of late, this is a great release, just as good audio as the prev workprint and far superior video.

Posted by lax01 on 10-24-2003 12:16 AM:

anybody notice any lip sync?

__________________

Posted by Spudkilla on 10-24-2003 12:38 AM:

Is the music in this version the same as in the movie version?

8/8/x judging from the sample.

Posted by Dr. Teeth on 10-24-2003 01:31 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by lax01
anybody notice any lip sync?

Yeah i did, sample seemed slightly out of sync to me (hope the whole copy isnt :/) but, video and audio appeared to be much better than in previous releases.

Keep up the good work VideoCD.

8/7/8

Posted by Nusphere on 10-24-2003 02:49 AM:

to be honest, i don't notice much difference in vid. quality, just the fps is better. audio sounds the same as well.
7/7/9

Posted by Mystic Slippers on 10-24-2003 03:07 AM:

The SAMPLE is interlaced, although this is deffo a different source tape. Very clean and sharp.

A VERY worthwhile release.

9/10/10

Posted by mod[e] on 10-24-2003 08:15 AM:

damn!

this is the best copy so far!....yes the workprint by opium is good but thanks to videocd for releasing their version! thank you!

this version is a keeper!

9/9/10

__________________
Dark Evolution is here.....

Posted by drboose on 10-24-2003 08:47 AM:

Great Video and audio, and no noticeable desync. Ill be getting this one for sure.

Posted by djwhiplash2001 on 10-24-2003 09:00 AM:

Ahh, finally, a decent framerate . Nice release, but I've seen the other one so I'm just gonna rate the sample :P.

9/9/10.1

Posted by chilliboy on 10-24-2003 12:45 PM:

Geez!!

I'm only writing this because I'm sick of reading other peoples posts who say things like "a bit washed out, sound hollow otherwise ok..." and I'm sure most of these people are judging on the jpeg and not a proper sample. I mean I've just saw the sample of this release and it is "slighty" better than the other wp's but not by much!! 1st post says best release yet?? Two words...Fuck off!! As cropped as tcr's is and although the audio is a bit muffled in places it's the best release imo because at least there is sync and it's not like looking at the picture with someone else's glasses on. So come on, who gives a flying fuck about who posts first. Just be honest and if not then that is very, very sad. I know I may get shit for this but at least I've seen this to comment. Phew, glad to get that off my chest.

Posted by PlanetSmasher on 10-24-2003 01:15 PM:

Video Looks Good between 7 - 8
Audio sounds Good 8
Movies over All 7

__________________

Star Wars is The Movie to watch, EPIII The Birth Of The DEATHSTAR The Planetsmasher

Posted by jfdkiller on 10-24-2003 02:48 PM:

There definately appears to be a sync problem in the sample.

Anyone with a full disc able to comment?

Posted by mod[e] on 10-24-2003 05:46 PM:

Re: Geez!!

quote:
Originally posted by chilliboy
1st post says best release yet?? Two words...Fuck off!! As cropped as tcr's

um have you watch the entire movie? or atleast cd1?...this isnt cropped as tcr's! and yes this is the best copy so far!.... if you watch the entire movie u'll notice theres no reel change and the only thing is there is the watermark either than that its perfect!.....

__________________
Dark Evolution is here.....

Posted by Bitch on 10-24-2003 06:21 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by jfdkiller
There definately appears to be a sync problem in the sample.

Anyone with a full disc able to comment?

Have same question

Sample looked pretty desynched to me

Posted by teegee420 on 10-24-2003 06:53 PM:

Thank you, VideoCD! Although the picture quality only looks marginally better than the FTV/OPIUM WP, the corrected frame rate and lack of reel changes sets this one apart from the rest. No cropping as previously stated either, though the a/v sync seems to be slightly off but nothing I can't live with. Great release, VideoCD!

Video- 8 (VHS source)
Audio- 8(slightly out of sync)
Movie- 10

Posted by Mr_Grinch on 10-24-2003 08:19 PM:

Re: Geez!!

quote:
Originally posted by chilliboy
I'm only writing this because I'm sick of reading other peoples posts who say things like "a bit washed out, sound hollow otherwise ok..." and I'm sure most of these people are judging on the jpeg and not a proper sample. I mean I've just saw the sample of this release and it is "slighty" better than the other wp's but not by much!! 1st post says best release yet?? Two words...Fuck off!! As cropped as tcr's is and although the audio is a bit muffled in places it's the best release imo because at least there is sync and it's not like looking at the picture with someone else's glasses on. So come on, who gives a flying fuck about who posts first. Just be honest and if not then that is very, very sad. I know I may get shit for this but at least I've seen this to comment. Phew, glad to get that off my chest.

Shush. TCR was a cam, you could hear people laughing. Subtitles were cropped and tilted and video was washed out. This is from a decent source tape, has a good frame rate and the lip sync is only slightly off.

In my opinion, TCR was the worse release to watch, sound put me off so much. I haven't a clue how anyone can say a cam can rival a decent, widescreen direct source.

Posted by teegee420 on 10-24-2003 08:53 PM:

Upon viewing the complete release I discovered a reel change in disc 2 just before Showdown at House of Blue Leaves. I still stand behind my ratings though.

Posted by peevuto on 10-25-2003 12:06 AM:

Any rls with the audio out of sync like this deserves a zero for audio.

Posted by allnighta on 10-25-2003 12:28 AM:

sorry but for me the orignal post by opium was the best,fair enough the framerate was iffy but the overall sample for sharpness and colour was better than this,and this one seems more pixalated
7/8/10

Posted by DrunkMonk420 on 10-25-2003 04:54 AM:

damn, are you all just rating the sample or the whole movie? i cant seem to find this rip of Kill Bill ANYWHERE (i do have the opium workprint, but this one sounds a lot better according to ya'll).. dont get me wrong, this is not a thread where i am asking where a movie is.. i actually have about 40 gigs of movies on my comp.. so i dont usually have any issues finding movies... i simply wanted to know by which means you are getting this rip.. newsgroups.. kazaa... mIRC? all i can find on IRC is the .avi rip.. i'm looking for the mpg.

but its all good.. i better not get banned for this, i just wanted to know who is having the best luck and with which source.

Posted by plonk420 on 10-25-2003 05:03 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by DrunkMonk420
i actually have about 40 gigs of movies on my comp.. so i dont usually have any issues finding movies...

ahhhahahaha 40 gigs X) i have 160 just for music vids on it's own computer ^^ ... but then again, there's a few people where i hang out that have over a TB. man, that make me feel less than a man...

Posted by Beelzebud on 10-25-2003 05:38 AM:

Well i watched the actual release instead of a sample or jpeg, and I can say this IS the best release of this flick so far. Until a DVD rip comes along, I don't see anyone outdoing this, unless someone does a TC.

8.5/8/10

Posted by Scorch on 10-25-2003 07:05 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by DrunkMonk420
damn, are you all just rating the sample or the whole movie? i cant seem to find this rip of Kill Bill ANYWHERE (i do have the opium workprint, but this one sounds a lot better according to ya'll).. dont get me wrong, this is not a thread where i am asking where a movie is.. i actually have about 40 gigs of movies on my comp.. so i dont usually have any issues finding movies... i simply wanted to know by which means you are getting this rip.. newsgroups.. kazaa... mIRC? all i can find on IRC is the .avi rip.. i'm looking for the mpg.

but its all good.. i better not get banned for this, i just wanted to know who is having the best luck and with which source.

Same here, it's almost vapor. I've seen it two places or so but the lines were full.

Posted by CyanideCordial on 10-25-2003 07:26 AM:

Ya, this release took me a while to get. Had to do some requesting to find this fucker. I guess VideoCD wanted this to be really damn internal.

Top release though, but you need a good dvd player so it decodes the interlacing properly, rather than my POS that blurs the whole image when it trys to. Runs perfect with some de-interlaced featured programs, like VLC (www.videolan.org) etc.

8 - Video
8 - Audio
10 - Movie

Posted by lax01 on 10-25-2003 07:53 AM:

I was having the same trouble...its on the newsgroups now...you know where to look.

I guess they should have marked it LIMITED

__________________

Posted by firefighter on 10-25-2003 08:10 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by lax01
I guess they should have marked it LIMITED

Limited means playing in select theaters. Internal was the proper label (means suppost to be just released in the grp), ... but wasnt that hard to get, picked it up right away and seen it around on IRC an hour after released. Search Harder

__________________
All the excitement of a trip to hell with none of the negitive side affects!

Posted by lax01 on 10-25-2003 08:46 AM:

quote:
Limited means playing in select theaters

thats what the WINK was for... I know what limited means...

__________________

Posted by Nusphere on 10-25-2003 08:57 AM:

im surprised there haven't been any better TSs or TCs. hmm..best WP for this film. id still rather have the TCR TS mostly because i hate watermarks, and the quality on that TS isnt bad at all..
for this rls:
8/6.5/9

Posted by lax01 on 10-25-2003 09:23 AM:

sure if you like watching 3/4ths of the movie and tinny audio...I think the TCR release was crap in comparison to either of the WPs...

__________________

Posted by Scorch on 10-25-2003 10:36 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by lax01
sure if you like watching 3/4ths of the movie and tinny audio...I think the TCR release was crap in comparison to either of the WPs...

Hah, yeah.. I didn't realize I was downloading the TS of it until it was like 1.14GB in.. watched it a bit.. awful audio, the screen was actually tilted, cropped to hell.. etc..

I managed to find the stripped down AVI of this, and even then, the video looks great.. if the 150-200mb AVI looks great.. wow. I'm about to download the MPEG version, but judging by the sample, I won't be disappointed.

8/8/10 (can I give it a 12?)

Posted by Logik on 10-25-2003 03:12 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Mystic Slippers
A VERY worthwhile release.

9/10/10

Posted by .Th3 on 10-25-2003 04:29 PM:

/me bows

Great job VideoCD, you're one of the best rlz groups right now !
*Where is CTP ? *

8/8/10

Posted by Dµpe on 10-25-2003 11:02 PM:

WOW, awesome! FTM release is awful in comparison.

9/9/7

Posted by th3whiterabbi7 on 10-26-2003 12:10 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by Beelzebud
Well i watched the actual release instead of a sample or jpeg, and I can say this IS the best release of this flick so far. Until a DVD rip comes along, I don't see anyone outdoing this, unless someone does a TC.

8.5/8/10

I just ordered the DVD last night, wait til it comes in and y'all have a nice DVD-R (I'll let someone else do the SVCD [of my own rip if they please], because I'm sure alot of you out there want REAL! quality)

Posted by Bazacko on 10-26-2003 04:01 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by th3whiterabbi7
I just ordered the DVD last night, wait til it comes in and y'all have a nice DVD-R (I'll let someone else do the SVCD [of my own rip if they please], because I'm sure alot of you out there want REAL! quality)

wtf

Posted by Scorch on 10-26-2003 04:27 AM:

Finally managed to get it. This rivals DVD quality. If you ignore the watermark.. it's unbelievably perfect. 8.5 (watermark!)/10/10. Definately keeping this one until retail DVD hits.

Posted by lax01 on 10-26-2003 08:19 AM:

Yeah, I just watched the first 25 minutes and only noticed slight lip-syncs during a few scenes. Nothing major though and it doesn't distract from the film at all. The only complaint I have about the audio is that the higher frequencies are some-what distorted, but this is being highly critical. Video (besides watermark) is incredible. SVCD was warranted on this movie and it shows.

__________________

Posted by psyche on 10-26-2003 12:41 PM:

Desync bothers me even if it ranges from minor to major, dialog I can kind of withstand but sound effects like a punch, kick, door slam or explosion gets on my nerves if the sound is delayed or kicks in before it's suppose to. I'll just wait for a DVD Screener or maybe even the retail, the film rocked when I saw it in the cinema. Video quality was decent but could have been better (sometimes blurrish), and VideoCD needs some work in the audio department even though they've improved on video compared to previous releases. 7/6/10

Posted by xpitxbullx on 10-26-2003 01:17 PM:

They left a reel change on CD2 in the 'Showdown at the House of Blue Leaves' segment.

Video - 8
Audio - 7
Movie - 9

Posted by scottymac on 10-26-2003 01:25 PM:

Just watched both CDs. Did not notice any De-Synch at all.

Video is very nice. I forgot about the watermark right away. The only time the watermark was an issue was at the end of the fight scene with Oren Ishii

Audio is good. A little tinny and slightly overmodulated.

Movie is wonderful.

8.5/7/9

Bring on Vol. 2 !

__________________
What stinks?

Oh, it's just JC

Posted by DrunkMonk420 on 10-26-2003 10:35 PM:

i dont even know why any channels on irc try to offer this.. every channel that does has all slots full no matter how long you try (i stayed on for an hour straight trying to just get in line for this) or any other channel lets you d/l at like 10k per sec.. this sucks.. i know once you have it, you dont care.. but i have to voice my frustration with these idiots who put this movie on bot that downloads at a max of 20k per sec.. fools.

edit:

it pays off when you know the op of a room.. i am FINALLY getting this movie at a decent speed 150k per sec.. nice

Posted by rawgwar on 10-27-2003 12:51 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by DrunkMonk420
i dont even know why any channels on irc try to offer this.. every channel that does has all slots full no matter how long you try (i stayed on for an hour straight trying to just get in line for this) or any other channel lets you d/l at like 10k per sec.. this sucks.. i know once you have it, you dont care.. but i have to voice my frustration with these idiots who put this movie on bot that downloads at a max of 20k per sec.. fools.

edit:
it pays off when you know the op of a room.. i am FINALLY getting this movie at a decent speed 150k per sec.. nice

Well you need better resources then IRC. Which can be the worse of all, but we all need to start/learn somewhere.

MOVIE
I thought it was about the same quality as OPium's release.
[7/7/7]

Posted by fuzmixman on 10-27-2003 08:16 AM:

i got this whenever it first showed up on binnews but at the time i didnt have any discs so i just decided to wait.. cuz i'll be damned if im watching a movie like this on my pc monitor.. anyways on to the review

HOY SHIT! This just oozed style. Smooth as hell. This movie was so fuckin cool..... i mean like "Straight up in your face im better then your movie so blow it out your ass Tarentino style" cool. Def matched up to the hype.. Im glad i waited for a better release to watch it too. the vid quality was top notch, other then the camera quality changing due to it being unfinished i guess..(?) Watermark was no nuissance cuz it didn't move at all. Audio went out of sync sometimes, especially at the beginning of the flick, but for the most part it was pretty good, lil distorted tho...

8/8/9.9

this is a great release all around. videocd, u made my sunday night bloody good fun. props

Posted by wfm on 10-28-2003 02:01 PM:

I watched first half on both BSPlayer and Windows Media Player and the sound is way out of sync. Can't understand why some of us have sync problems and others don't. I mounted the image with Daemon tools and played it from there. So far out of sync as to be unwatchable.

Posted by NFDfireMedic on 10-29-2003 05:10 PM:

Decent quality, very watchable on a TV, movie itself is pretty good too from what I've seen (about half)

7/7/7

Posted by Sadako on 10-30-2003 04:59 PM:

Excellent quality workprint - the transparent watermark isn't too intrusive (far better than a scroller IMO) and lip-sync is hardly noticable when played on my standalone

The movie itself is truly excellent - that girl from BATTLE ROYALE really kicks ass!

9 / 9 / 9

Posted by XeroFightsAlone on 11-02-2003 09:03 AM:

this rls owns.
9/10/10

__________________
soda box

Posted by J Fresh on 07-19-2005 04:51 AM:

bumping for no reason what so ever as no one will probably see this but

MY GIRLFRIEND JUST BOUGHT ME THE KILL BILL VOL. 2 PREMIUM BOXSET FROM JAPAN

:: I saw it. Consider yourself warned. -D

__________________

Posted by dvd r on 07-22-2005 01:01 AM:

seeing and reading.
enjoy your gift !!

Posted by K-FurY on 07-23-2005 06:32 AM:

i remember this release, it was nice

8/8/8

All times are GMT. The time now is 07:54 PM.

Show all 64 posts from this thread on one page