VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Harry Potter And The Prisoner Of Azkaban *PROPER* *SVCD* - TELESYNC - VideoCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=41539)

VideoCD... usual work.... little grainy... good ass sound.... should do ya'll that can't wait for the DVDr of this money hog....

from sample:
8/9/? (don't care)

__________________

as the man said usual videocd quality the usual glare bit grainy perfect sound. Lets hope we see no more of these now unless we get a decent TC etc until dvd

7 (gotta sort that bright glare guys) / 9 / 8 (it was ok movie i liked the last one more)

damn. very nice this early.

8/9/? (from sample. watching at the theater tomorrow)

__________________

IRCSpy Forums
-Administrator

Good aspect ratio...too bad it's not as clear as uti's release..

7/10

quote:

---

Originally posted by }{KeYmAkEr*}{
Good aspect ratio...too bad it's not as clear as uti's release..

7/10

---

Damn, i justed finished downloading UTI's version. Anyways, judging from the sample this looks like a typical VideoCD release. Alot more clear and crisp colors and yes, a better AR.

8/9/8 -- as a CAM

Movie was pretty good, but not as good when compared to the last two.

__________________
"Unfortunately, no one can be told what The Matrix is. You have to see it for yourself."

looks good
tho i wont be watching the movie
8/8

__________________

money hog? funny how newbies have to repeat a catch phrase in hopes of getting some credit. fyi, every movie ever made is a money hog... that's the freakin reason people make movies (except for spike lee )


as far as this release.. good work again videocd.

while this is a better release I don't see it being THAT much better so if you've already downloaded UTI's then stick with it for now. if you haven't then of course get this one.

haven't watched the entire movie yet... not really into this francise.

7/8/?

It's a pretty good release.

7/8/?

__________________

Good release...Good Audio and Video Worthy of the name Proper.
I know alot of people are talking about AR and all that ..but it looks really good on the television and its complete til the end. And not cut short.

8/9/7

__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...

this is the release ive been waiting for 8/9/ tell you when ive seen it all

Looks good...

8/8/5

Picture & Video aren't up to the normal VideoCD 'TS Standards,' but definately the best and final TS (lets hope) .. Movie wasn't that great compared to the other two imo. some loved it, some hated it.

pz

looks good. best version available

8/8/8

to all the "stick with the uti release" guys:

the uti release has not only a bad ar, there are a few minutes missing (around 5:18)

btw. the uti version has the "complete" right side of the picture - the videocd version hasn´t - but it has the left side

uti was faster with a watchable version - but videocd has the better release

VideoCD... little grainy perfect sound
aspect ratio ok
if u have uti copy stick with it
let hope we can get a decent copy soon

__________________

lol the UTi version is only missing about 10 seconds or 20 the UTi version pic is still the best but AR VideoCD version very good with sound pic grainy wud most probly stay wid videocd

vid 7
sound 8
film 9

these guys kick ass once again

8/8/8

this is not to the right and not to the left its in the center just a bit of a angle

nice work keep em comming so far so good will post the rest when im done watching it colours are great, sound can't say sh*t about it always Fngreat:P

__________________
why bitch about the cost just switch to dvd-r "dam-it"

quote:

---

Originally posted by rastag33k
money hog? funny how newbies have to repeat a catch phrase in hopes of getting some credit. fyi, every movie ever made is a money hog... that's the freakin reason people make movies (except for spike lee )


as far as this release.. good work again videocd.

while this is a better release I don't see it being THAT much better so if you've already downloaded UTI's then stick with it for now. if you haven't then of course get this one.

haven't watched the entire movie yet... not really into this francise.

7/8/?

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by neatz
this is not to the right and not to the left its in the center just a bit of a angle

---

Not bad at all, not watched it yet so not sure about missing scenes but skipping through disc 1 it's a hell of a lot better than any other release at the mo.

I grabbed UTI's release at it was rough far to pixellated and almost pitch black at points. Saw the sample of Tun's release which was grabage with good sound. Grabbed the dvdcam which wasn't a hell of a lot better than UTI's (Was better though) this. Thewre was a release by cerebus (An IRC group) which was somewhere between UTI's & dvdcam.

I'd give this release 7.5/8/?

Looks better than the first 2 movies but I suspect it'll be a pile of shite really.


On an unrleated note it's been a while since I was grabbing films I just used a popular BT site but I've wanted a few films quick recently and was happy to find queues on xdcc bots have all but disapeered.

__________________
You're only in as much trouble as you think you are.

I love videocd's sound....every release sounds great on the surround sound. Keep up the good work videocd. And its nice to see them listed at vcdquality.

UTi's rls has now been binned

good work again videocd

8/9/6

quote:

---

Originally posted by vinnyv07
I love videocd's sound....every release sounds great on the surround sound. Keep up the good work videocd. And its nice to see them listed at vcdquality.

---

__________________
You're only in as much trouble as you think you are.

Hmmm i'm not THAT happy with this rls.

Offcourse it's better then UTI (wich i'm suprised on how many ppl reply here without seeing it;..yes it misses 7 mins, yes de guy coughs etc etc) but i was hoping for better video.

It's obvious that thye picked this sample cause off the color. Even UTI had some color here. But when you watch further in the movie then you see that it's pretty colorless

Yes the audio is good but maybe i'm spoiled by there last rlseses and expected a bit more. Or maybe this is the same qual as last rlses but is the flic hard to cam cause it's almost entirly night during the film

7/8/7

Colors a little washed out but alot brighter then UTi's

For the guys fighting over the cam been to the left, center or right - watch it from the begining of CD1 and you will see from the movie title where on the screen the CAM is set (its bang in the middle with a slight angle, as said above)

7.7.7

__________________
Ding Dong

Why does every thread for a popular movie degenerate into a bitch-fight between two (or more ) loosers just because their opinion differs? Some of you really need to get out more.

Harry Potter? Well, I can't comment on the other releases because this is the only sample I've grabbed but the quality is fine. I won't give you the usual "grainy this" "angled that" speech either, despite it's faults, this release is a damned good TS.

7/8/PJEER!


:: Edit - Just seen it, it's not that great a movie. I know it's not aimed at 30-year-old retarded perverts, but it just didn't seem to go anywhere... Then it finished. 7/8/6

Glare?

Does this movie have the same glare that the VideoCD Troy release had?

__________________
I cut the pockets out of all my pants

lol i like this copy but i really like UTIs the pic is good n clear if u sit away. they made a mistake in the file harrys scar is on the right sidein 1 bit then on the left all the time lol

From what people were saying about the UTI version, it seems as though were watching a different film to me. It was horribly washed out, flicker and very murk (even for a dark film). The picture is a million times better on this VideoCD version. The DVD Cam by theBrain was better than the UTI version, if you could get hold of it.

Where is the DVDCam? It's not posted anywhere.

__________________
"Unfortunately, no one can be told what The Matrix is. You have to see it for yourself."

The DVDcam is the UTI version in iso format, same coughing etc, unless they were sat at the side of UTI

This version is awesome, Thanks videocd also for Raising Helen that was almost perfect, more screener quality telesyncs from you! I have to say after removing those trailors and changing the format of the DVDcams to 16:9 I have been very happy with that version as well I think the picture is about the same but you have to change the format to really enjoy DVDcams or you have a funny looking picture.

Harry Potter Videocd 7/9/6
Harry Potter DVDcam 7/7/6
Raising Helen Videocd 9/9/7

quote:

---

Originally posted by deano21
they made a mistake in the file harrys scar is on the right sidein 1 bit then on the left all the time lol

---

I saw the DVD cam release on xdccspy.com (search for harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban) or maybe it was on suprnova.org . think it was xdccspy.

__________________

quote:

---

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by SycoCowz
now this is a bitch!

I just spend 26 hours encoding the XVID to dvd-mpeg2 and now theres a probably better quality one available for download! grrrr....
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Originally posted by Dummie
Down loading a film isnt that illegal !.
i cant imagine such a thing.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by PLUGTOP
The DVDcam is the UTI version in iso format, same coughing etc, unless they were sat at the side of UTI

---

sound on hp3 video-cd??

is it my copy i have downloaded or what ????

cd2 sound goes about half second out ????

checked the svcd's and same there only noticed after i converted to dvd grrrrrr

wish i had checked first...
other then that spot on..

quote:

---

Originally posted by revolution-x
1. - I think he means money hog as in selling pirate coppies to make money for himself u thick twat

2. - 12 posts kinda makes you a n00b too so stfu ass (he has 17 posts btw)

3. - Im a bit perplexed as to why in hell you would reccomend people stick with UTi release ,uti version was colorless ugly and missing a bit of footage

did you actually get samples/releases for either of these movies or are u trying to show off what you havnt got infront of the big boys?

as for this release is excellent ,usual videocd stuff 8/8/5

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by muhali3
Where is the DVDCam? It's not posted anywhere.

---

Agreed snozzler, nothing special really. Still a helluva lot better than UTI's though. (theBrain Internal DVDCam)

yer ur right snozzler u always get the chinese ppl selling em on dvd at boot sales in uk £5 each time lol

man i dont know about you guys, but the ratings for this movie is like 8.3 for video? Are you guys blind? I seen dvdrips that were rated almost at that rating whereas their video was practically dvdrip crisp. This video should get anything less than 8, but not higher than 8....

Video is rated as a telesync/cam... not to be compared with dvdrips which are undoubtly clearer. The vid for this compared to the best ever ts is definately worthy of around a 8

pretty nice, 7.5/8/9

__________________

quote:

---

Originally posted by mafioso
Why is this nuked? I pay for my downloads and I don't like to waste.

---

7/8/7

movie is cropped isnt good AR as some are stating yes right side is missing movie AR is 2:35:1.

Non The less a better release just not up to par on other stuff they have done in the past.

quote:

---

Originally posted by RaZmAn
man i dont know about you guys, but the ratings for this movie is like 8.3 for video? Are you guys blind? I seen dvdrips that were rated almost at that rating whereas their video was practically dvdrip crisp. This video should get anything less than 8, but not higher than 8....

---

I just finally picked this one up. I watched about 10 mins into cd1 and I must say this is very nice. I also have the Uti cam and this is a gigantic improvement over that. Anyone who says keep the Uti cam is an idiot! This is the best version out right now. Period. Forget any AR issues or angles or even if it's a fix from the Uti source. I don't care. I'm going by picture clarity and clean audio... this is very clear and the audio is near perfect, as usual.

I came down hard on videocd for their debauchery of the Kill BiLL 2 TC (rightfully so), but when it comes to doing a great TS they have taken over the reigns from Ctp and TCR....

I just hope this rls doesn't chop off the ending of the movie like The Day After Tomorrow, Shrek 2, Kill BILL vol2 TC, etc. I'd actually like to see an explanation WHY they can't/couldn't put together an entire film from beginning to end. Before I sound too negative, I'd love to add that this rls DOES start with a black screen and shows the small light in the distance flickering on and off to reveal the WB logo! Yes! Great! I'm so glad this was left into this TS! I loved the new, inventive, way that they started this movie off.... TY to videocd for keeping that "intro" into this copy.

I know this film ends with Harry flying into the sky on his new broom... I hope it's there.

from cd1...
8/8/9 - saw the full film in the theater

ENDING SPOILER (not a plot point)




The film ends with Harry getting a package in the "cafeteria" and then taking it outside to fly his broom off into the clouds. He flies up towards "camera/US" on the upper left... the shot closes on his face and then goes into the credits.

If this copy doesn't even have him getting onto the broom or flying on it at all in the end I don't see how the fuck they (videocd) can even call this rls a proper. This rls is not their best quality, as they stated, but it's enough to satisfy me... IF the ending is there!

I'll see....

(I couldn't wait to burn it all before posting --- pardon mwua)

__________________
My YMDB page
http://www.ymdb.com/user_top20_view.asp?usersid=18281

empress, when you say : " I just hope this rls doesn't chop off the ending of the movie like The Day After Tomorrow, Shrek 2, Kill BILL vol2 TC, etc "


shrek 2 had ending, finished on credit,
kb2 had enciding.

The day after tomorow didn't have.

i'm agree they cut credit very fast, but whats the point to keep the credit ?
anyay, this release finish at the end when credit start, harry fly up to the sky, say something i don't remember and its become black, than a map apear and its writen harry potter bla bla bla

Shrek 2 didn't have the ending, yes, it started the credits, but there's another 3-4 minute scene that I won't ruin for people that happens during the credits. Only know this because I've taken my kids to see it in the theater 2 times.

Ahh well, such is life and free bootleg video.

8/8/8 (redundtant isn't it)

Sure .. just after working with the UTi this comes out

Thanks VCD .. and thankfully there are DVD rewritables
too

It's fun to play with the early releases though...hehe

Now to go mess with the garfield internal pre

__________________
Heph (Hephaestus)

VideoCd seem mad at us

i saw the Uti Cam version and give that 6/6/8 only seen sample of this one and i think it much better video and audio and will give it 7/8/8... i seems that VCD might me mad at nukers for nuking there Troy on some sites, as it was White Bright, but i think that was the only decent version released. they seem to be cutting off the endings on purpose just to show their power over the sceen and how good there quality is and to tease the nukers and us to get us to d/l a crap version to see the ending... donno but i think Video cd are being crap about all this and sould just release full movies will endings as people might just not d/l from them in da future if they keep being directors and cuting the movies endings..

anyone got any other expliantion of this odd behaviour from Video CD???

I just got this rls myself, Had it waiting for me when I got home, Nice treat. Sound is flawless, video is good as hell but not GREAT.

The picture, clarity is great, sound is good, but a tad zoomed it seems, So I give it a 8, and the sound is flawless, I give that a 10

So I give this rls a 8/10/9

as for this being better than the uti rls. I say MUCH MUCH MUCH MUCH better, I did watch the uti rls, But man this is sooooo much better.

Re: VideoCd seem mad at us

quote:

---

Originally posted by gunituk
anyone got any other expliantion of this odd behaviour from Video CD???

---

Harry.Potter.And.The.Prisoner.Of.Azkaban.PROPER.SVCD.TELESYNC-VideoCD (CD3)

Hey if not sure if its just me or not, but i cant seem to unpack CD3 for harry potter, its 718MB - am i doing something wrong?

__________________
DEE JAY NICK JAY

Re: VideoCd seem mad at us

quote:

---

Originally posted by gunituk
i saw the Uti Cam version and give that 6/6/8 only seen sample of this one and i think it much better video and audio and will give it 7/8/8... i seems that VCD might me mad at nukers for nuking there Troy on some sites, as it was White Bright, but i think that was the only decent version released. they seem to be cutting off the endings on purpose just to show their power over the sceen and how good there quality is and to tease the nukers and us to get us to d/l a crap version to see the ending... donno but i think Video cd are being crap about all this and sould just release full movies will endings as people might just not d/l from them in da future if they keep being directors and cuting the movies endings..

anyone got any other expliantion of this odd behaviour from Video CD???

---

great release
8/8/7
watched it on my 27" last night
clear pic, good sound

not typical VideoCD rls as far as video quality goes. i've seen much better from them. almost feels like they were rushed on this one to rls it. great audio though.

7/8/8

Re: Harry.Potter.And.The.Prisoner.Of.Azkaban.PROPER.SVCD.TELESYNC-VideoCD (CD3)

quote:

---

Originally posted by x-vision
Hey if not sure if its just me or not, but i cant seem to unpack CD3 for harry potter, its 718MB - am i doing something wrong?

---

This should be nuked as it is missing 12 rar files from cd3

the #incomplete channels are overloaded with requests for the missing rars

plz nuke it and call for a repack

Re: Re: Harry.Potter.And.The.Prisoner.Of.Azkaban.PROPER.SVCD.TELESYNC-VideoCD (CD3)

quote:

---

Originally posted by SToNERUK
Im havin a prob with cd3 too..plays fine on p.c. but when i demultiplex it to convert the audio, it seems to lose the last 13 or so minutes of video.???
Anyone else havin trouble tryin to stick it onto svcd-dvd?

Its exactly at 30:07 on cd3 (499.5mb) that something happens..i hear a high pitch click on it while i watch it on my p.c., and thats where it seems to knock off while demultiplexin, its got me well and truly stuck!
Anyone any suggestions?

---

CD3

no probs here, just binned uti's rls and got videoCD rls, cd3 fine
718mb, 2 incomplete RAR files but soon fixed with PAR.

8/10/8

quality.

Video has a 'fuzz' over it kind of like when you crank the color up to much on a TV ..also the contrast blooms in bright scenes (typical telesync stuff), Audio is very nice tho. Saw this one in the theater yesterday its a good movie, liked it better than the first two.


7/8.5/8.5

quote:

---

Originally posted by delphin460
This should be nuked as it is missing 12 rar files from cd3

the #incomplete channels are overloaded with requests for the missing rars

plz nuke it and call for a repack

---

Very watchable. Sound & Video Great! Keep it up!

quote:

---

Originally posted by delphin460
This should be nuked as it is missing 12 rar files from cd3

the #incomplete channels are overloaded with requests for the missing rars

plz nuke it and call for a repack

---

__________________
Dark Evolution is here.....

The sides of the video are cut off pretty noticably(AR issue?),at least on the left side (especially being i just saw it in the theater),for example when watching the first scene with harry practicing a spell in bed, whenever he'd lay down to act like he was sleeping you should be able to see his head, but its cut off. Also in the scene when the maid knocks on the door and says "Housekeeping!" ,you should see a 'magic' broom thats sweeping by itself behind her but its cut off as well.

just watched this on the TV.

Video: 8
Audio: 8.5
Movie: 7

videoCD is the best group out there right now. keep up the
good work guys.

snozzler 29.... of course you could also crop the overlapping video so's not to have repeating when you join cd1,2,3. A bit pedantic but it annoys me when I see 3 cd's merged without cropping.

Wow is VideoCD the only group that can do a quality SVCD TS... this is a WORTHY proper of this Box office Hit.. Pic is a lil Dark, but hey so is the movie.. The sound is Waay better than previous rls's. Props to VideoCD for continuing to put out the very best in SVCD TS



7.5/8/8

best release ive seen of this yet worth the download, put to dvdr and played on stanalone no problem

Much better than UTI's release. Alot more color and sharpness, and lacks dct blocks. Only downside is the green noise/graininess, but that can be fixed with TMPGenc or Avisynth. I'm gonna hold on to this until a DVDScreener is released.

Oh yeah, does anyone elses CD3 of this release end with Harry and a bunch of other people in the courtyard, because he's supposed to be flying on his new broomstick?

9/10/8 -- As a telesync

__________________
"Unfortunately, no one can be told what The Matrix is. You have to see it for yourself."

ending

mine ends with harry flying off on broom stick, then flash of credits b4 it stops

Re: ending

quote:

---

Originally posted by cfUK
mine ends with harry flying off on broom stick, then flash of credits b4 it stops

---

__________________
Just as long as it is free

OK, from sample 8/8/?

I only say from sample because everytime I dl this, from any channel, It says I got the whole 2.16 GB of it. Then I open in Winrar and I get corrupted file errors, then only CD1 is accessable dispite the two gigs of info in the file, plus, I can't even get cd1 full files to extract. What the hell is going on. I've gotten the same file from many channels, is the 1.5 GB version I've been seeing labeled as a VideoCD the one I need. Please Help.

__________________
What is love?......baby don't hurt me.....don't hurt me......no more.

i also noticed AR, more pronounced on ALBA Dvd player (£30) than my meridian 800.3 (£5000+) weird!!

yeah credits wud b nice, and def not up to VideoCD usual standards, nut at least it the most watchable out of the rls's

watched this today finally, video is abit grainy and dark, and also cropped quite some. some scenes people would be talking to one another and all you could see was the tip of their noses. video was overall good though. sound, nothing needs to be said, perfect as usual. ending is partly cut off as usual, what the fuck is so hard about letting the camera role another 10 seconds and letting people have the satisfaction of knowing the movie is done, and not worrying about if the ending is missing??? everytime i watch a videocd release, i have to come here and make sure i just saw the whole movie, annoying as hell.

7/10/5

all depends on where cam was done, in some cinema the house light come up as credits start therefore, you certainly aint gonna hang around! but, yes, credits would be good, if possible!esp on something like HP2 i think where there is more movie after the creds.

Good video (no flicker, a little glair), excellent audio (no hiss or buzz, very clear sound), not a huge fan of the films, but it was the best of the three.

great release.

7/9/7

looks good, decent release, though chakra just released one that is on a higher rating there copy looks a lot more blocky if you ask me, iim still sticking to videoCD.

Luv videocd, but this ain't up to snuff.

6/7/5

quote:

---

Originally posted by delphin460
This should be nuked as it is missing 12 rar files from cd3

the #incomplete channels are overloaded with requests for the missing rars

plz nuke it and call for a repack

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by mikeb
how can u call for it 2 b nuked when u have a crap newsgroup?
grow up & get a decent newsgroup server like most folk here

---

good video a little cropped, sound is really low on my tv, when i run it through the stereo its good and clear crisp. i still have 20 min left in the movie to watch but so far its a pretty decent movie, i dont like how they leave 90% of the plot to the last 30 minutes though thats kinda lame.

8/8/?

__________________
eat me balls!!

quote:

---

how can u call for it 2 b nuked when u have a crap newsgroup?
grow up & get a decent newsgroup server like most folk here

---

Release looks good to me, not the best by VideoCD but they did say that in the NFO.

Good enough for me not to bother with the Telecine though, I'll stick with this one.

Centred or not??? Who cares!!

7/7/8

Nice release, good quality. I liked the previous harry pooter better. Still worth a watch.

7/7/7

videocd at their average here, worth it over the other releases.
audio - 8
video - 7
movie - 8