VCDQuality Forums
Show all 88 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Thunderbirds - CAM - FTF (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=44808)


Posted by KillMePlz on 07-22-2004 01:38 AM:

This is the greatest release!

I can't remember seeing another release up to this caliber.
50 first dates, spiderman 1, anything does not compare to this!

pic 10
sound 9
movie 9

pic is clear and full of color not like the other releases.

Pot thied twice with out success. Fra was alright, but sound was deafing.


Posted by dirtydan on 07-22-2004 01:38 AM:

hmm props for being first to release, seems very grainy but its not the best cam iv seen.

Audio is pretty good isnt holo nor hissy.

6/7/ havent watched yet goin cinema to see.

__________________
UK DAN


Posted by wizwoz on 07-22-2004 01:39 AM:

thunderbirds ftf

very poor picture but good sound and it go burrly where thehood is the sub


Posted by SSR_2K4 on 07-22-2004 01:59 AM:

I Love It

Great Quality And Sound Is Much Better...Im Certanly Watching This Movie 2nite!!!
8/9/8


Posted by KiLLeRSpaM on 07-22-2004 02:02 AM:

Nice

Watched parts of CD 2 earlier. A bit bright in some places, but overall, the video quality is very good. I'll probably play with the gamma before re-encoding. The JPG doesn't do the picture justice.

Audio was v-nice, no hiss or muffling.

Will watch the whole thing later.

9/9/?


Posted by Mezt^Up on 07-22-2004 02:10 AM:

cool pre! film comes out in theatres july 30th, bot my kind of movie but what the heck, i'll watch it anyway, as for quality:

V: 7 (pretty good not too washed)
A: 6 Average for cam
M: ? havent watched it fully

__________________


Posted by UltrA1 on 07-22-2004 02:17 AM:

dont know why the posting is for thunderbirds not I, robot CTP
must be merged somehow....
ctp copy I, Robot is good took a while. 8/8/8
thunderbirds pict is fuzzy.. 6/6/4
well later...

__________________
Anyone with any complaints, contact:
[email protected]

Movie From Maven Priceless!!

*Broadband internet not included...


Posted by deano21 on 07-22-2004 02:22 AM:

yay finally cant wait to see this i loved thundewrbirds wen i was a kid 8/8/?


Posted by EViL-EWoK on 07-22-2004 02:28 AM:

fuckme this is ftf?
god damn nice work
reminds of me of UTi's old cam's
8/8/X?

the director of this should be shot. please dont ruin a good old tv show

__________________
I Just Want to Be like Radiohead, And do something ingenious.


Posted by deano21 on 07-22-2004 02:30 AM:

quote:
the director of this should be shot. please dont ruin a good old tv show



Is it that bad then


Posted by KiLLeRSpaM on 07-22-2004 02:40 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by UltrA1
dont know the posting is for thunderbirds not I, robot CTP
well later...



For some reason the posts for thunderbirtd and iRobot CPT are both coming to this thread... hence my 9/9 review (wrong film)


Posted by Debo on 07-22-2004 03:29 AM:

this might be the best that ftf put out
8/8
got no interest in the movie

__________________


Posted by dc_man on 07-22-2004 03:40 AM:

8/7

and ya this movie is homo. 0% interest.


Posted by GRAVESTORM on 07-22-2004 03:47 AM:

WTF!!!!
Picture looks like a bloody puzzle and aweful and the sound damn is echoey as hell (a yoddler yoddling in cave would sound hell of alot better)

Video : 2
Audio : 2
Film : i'll wait on a better copy because i ain't watching this shit

__________________
G.


Posted by vip3r on 07-22-2004 04:25 AM:

2/2? You're out of yer mind. Just because you don't like FTF doesn't mean you need to post b/s ratings...

6/6.5/3 - movie sucked ass

::edit:: after watching cd1, i had to change my ratings, qual. wasnt nearly as good as the sample


Posted by Dayzt on 07-22-2004 05:06 AM:

Don't be fooled by the NTSC labeling here... just tested it and it's definitely PAL.


Posted by pHizZ on 07-22-2004 05:10 AM:

Thunderbirds.CAM-FTF

This does suck. FTF is just another shitty silver group. Video is steady, at least, but it has washed out colors, and it's cropped to shit. The audio is hollow, typical cam. I don't hear any external noise, but I wouldn't watch this. I rated as a cam. Doesn't hold up to UTi's standards.

5/6/x


Posted by Bassboy on 07-22-2004 05:47 AM:

Props to FTF for the great pre,
Video is a little grainy, yet clear and vivid.
Sound is a little hollow, but not too bad.

Overall 7/6/? (Havent watched it yet)

Anyone who says its not vivid, has bad sound etc. Must be watching a different sample than the rest of us

Watched the begining of Cd1, Decided that the sample seems better than the actual cd therefore I changed what I rated it.


Posted by Chino XL on 07-22-2004 06:08 AM:

i see people saying 9, 8 and 7's the video is grainer then then a beach and the audio is crap id give it a 4/3.. ppl voting off jpg should be banned, i think its un-watchable and i thought ftf was dead now they seem to have a uk source.. movie seems to be crap too.. FTF should spend more time encoding and acctualy output a watchable video. thats just my opion


Posted by cowdog on 07-22-2004 07:31 AM:

7/8/7
Its alright for a cam.
sound is good.
my son seems to like the movie.


Posted by Miller on 07-22-2004 07:34 AM:

nice color for a cam, but grainy. sound is a little hollow as well. good for a first rls and deffently for a pre. this movie is crap though.
7/7/4

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!


Posted by -Jenix- on 07-22-2004 07:39 AM:

wont waste my time on thunderbirds but since this is also i, robot its 100x better than the fra cam i watched, I actually get to see faces!
9/8.5/8 second time through


Posted by corvex on 07-22-2004 07:54 AM:

welcome back FTF :P havent seen you in a while, anyways for a pre rls it aint that bad...watchable but not worth burning 2 cds

Cam rating : 6/6/?

__________________
eat, live , breathe : VCD


Posted by DigitalMonkey on 07-22-2004 08:01 AM:

from the sample. looks very fuzzy and grainy, excellant colors though, sound is ok for a CAM,

5/6

move looks really gay


Posted by MTV on 07-22-2004 08:01 AM:

looks good for a cam. pic a bit faded but nice . sound is v clear but a bit hollow,but good for a cam, no crackling or back ground noise.as some1 said ,this is very much like the uTi cams. props on the rls speed & the quality.this is better than the 1st two rls of i robot with out question,so lets see how it gets marked .

7 / 8 / 4 <--- marked as cAm.


Posted by kezm on 07-22-2004 08:01 AM:

watchable thats all for me 7/7/3 movie sucks


Posted by DigitalMonkey on 07-22-2004 08:08 AM:

quote:
TEHVODKA 10 10 6


how the hell can u give this a ten, its a decent cam, but a 10, come on thats a perfect cam, now this is def not a perfect cam


Posted by manofice on 07-22-2004 08:44 AM:

ok, This is CTP rlsing a good vcd quality but come on people


VCD/I.Robot.TS.SVCD-Centropy was nuked 1x by ********* - reason: .R.Interlaced

don't judge by the group, judge by whats really right here. I saw couple people calling it a cam, its a nuke right there if its a CAM.


Posted by frak on 07-22-2004 08:54 AM:

uhhh.. the database might be a little pooched.. i clicked on
the ctp-i robot and landed in whatever the fvck thunderbirds is.


Posted by Debo on 07-22-2004 08:59 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by manofice
ok, This is CTP rlsing a good vcd quality but come on people


VCD/I.Robot.TS.SVCD-Centropy was nuked 1x by ********* - reason: .R.Interlaced

don't judge by the group, judge by whats really right here. I saw couple people calling it a cam, its a nuke right there if its a CAM.


if u look at the thread title it clearly sais thunderbirds
ur both in the wrong place
the mods probably had enough bullshit from people flaming shit in the ctp thread and removed it

__________________


Posted by gurry on 07-22-2004 09:02 AM:

database is defo screwed. This thread is rating Thunderbirds cam and not the I Robot SVCD (but if you click the add comment tab for I robot you come here) go into the main forum list for VCD and there is no thread for the I robot SVCD.

I RObot SVCD very good work perhaps a little too bright in some places but like the nfo says better too bright than too dark
Audio seems like DTS to me movie....not seen it all will have a proper squizz tonight. This was nuked as interlaced but had no problems myself with this.

Thunderbirds

Movie version of the Jerry Anderson puppet show from the UK
It is a cam.....havent seen it so cant rate it.

Id say til the database is fixed if the rater says cam then its thunderbirds......if they give it a 10 for sound or picture then its I Robot.


Posted by stezo2k on 07-22-2004 09:04 AM:

Good cam, one of the best i've seen, will get this later

video is one of the better cams i've seen 7.5/10

sound is a little echoed (can be expected on a cam) 7/10

not interested in the movie, will grab this for my brother though


Posted by HoldDaSalad on 07-22-2004 09:35 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by dc_man
8/7

and ya this movie is homo. 0% interest.



for a rls 6/7 for ftf 10/10, lol.

this should be up your alley then since it's homo? lol

__________________

Hold Da Motha Fuckin Salad.


Posted by Hairyhamster on 07-22-2004 10:14 AM:

Unhappy

one word....... shite
5/5/?

__________________
One Day The Dead Shall Walk The Earth.


Posted by diekund on 07-22-2004 12:11 PM:

well the thunderbirds cam looks like a pofs. colours are horrible. its VERY grainy, the colours suck and the audio is so hollow

im not an FTF basher, but this sucks

also it was quite hard to find since every1 has banned ftf

4/4/?


Posted by Hairyhamster on 07-22-2004 12:23 PM:

just updating having now viewed the whole movie...
8/9/9
great movie (although lacking a spielberg input)
audio great
video good for a cam, but why do dumbfucks still insist on walking into view???? cant they tell a valued member of the scene is recording.... jeez....


Posted by IcEmAn on 07-22-2004 02:57 PM:

Centropy y bother

Da, whats the dfference between pots vers and centropys, nada, only a clearer picture of peoples heads wandering around a picture theatre!

Get it right guys or dont do it at all.....your wasting our valuable downloads on a lot of amature rubbish, dont waste your time if your going to let god knows how many pple waste thiers downloading a lot of rubbish, i cant beleive centropy who were the best in the business release a vers not better than that group of buffoons called pot, time to wake up, your have made your name centropy because u released the best, what were u thinking when u released KING ARTHUR and I ROBOT, if we want to see a bunch of heads moving around a picture theatre we'll go to the theatre and watch it, pull ya socks up guys as ya name is slowly going down the sink.....IcEmAn...

edit:I'm leaving this in so you guys can roast this idiot .P


Posted by warhead1999 on 07-22-2004 05:44 PM:

this is the same source of the poor quality dvd that has been knocking about , on the dvd cam picture was on the piss a little , looks like ftf recoded it and taking credit for it, this is why picture is very blockly and grainy where they have cropped picture.


for who ever got this release out thumbs up !

as for ftf nice try but some seen dvd first !


Posted by Tyranthaxis on 07-22-2004 05:46 PM:

Thumbs up :P

Í Róbôt

Video = 7.5

Audio = 8.5

Movie = 8



http://d21c.com/AnnesPlace/Hal/Demon.gif

quote:
You know I dont like queers, whimpy assed kids, or frigging retards..... -Dwight Yoakam 'SLINGBLADE'

__________________
THERE IS NO SCENE ONLY ZHUUL!


Posted by KrackZaa on 07-22-2004 06:37 PM:

yeah i mean theres some bitch now in the camera every two seconds, and in the beginning on the right side of the screen theres some weird yellowish line that moves up the screen, kinda pissed me off but once that was gone, the release was excellent. as they said in the nfo, rather a lil brighter than a not being able to see in the dark scenes. no green tint like pots internal, sound was excellent, nice work boys fuck the haters this is the good shit right here.

9/9/9 loved the movie, nice special effects, decent plot.

__________________
Dust myself up
and I scream at the sky
It's been so hard
but I can't let it die
Turn my head up,
looking at the stars
So many years,
I still wonder where you are?
Dust myself up
and I scream at the sky
Every day I ask myself why?
So much pain pouring
from inside
Above me I feel the spirit fly


Posted by cddvdheaven on 07-22-2004 06:38 PM:

Just finished downloading this FTF cam and i must say i have seen a lot lot better cams then this by a long way.
Picture is so bad and sound as if in a train tunnel.
Heads in the veiw and cropped on the right side and the cam is angled up on the left side.
The only way you would want to watch this copy is in a very small window on your computer.
Dont even think that it's worth encoding or burning to cdr or dvd What a wast that would be .
well impressed that you got this out so early as UK had the first release date..? for a change. but as always no good UK cam have to wait for the french or the guy's in the old USA.

Hope to see a better version soon to encode to DVD.
and watch on the big screen.


Posted by BLUE-NEO on 07-22-2004 07:28 PM:

Looks ok. The video is average for a cam a little choppy at times. The audio even though you can hear it. Really sounds like a cam. Its very hollow. Lately most of the cams have had good audio. This doesnt. Overall wait for a telesync or maybe in a week or two a svcd telesync will arise with better audio and video. This is one cam not worth getting. Not even to watch.
yeah its free blah, blah, blah. But its still bad.

Nice First Outting FTF, but no Thanks!

6/5/?

__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...


Posted by desertboy on 07-22-2004 09:04 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by BLUE-NEO
Looks ok. The video is average for a cam a little choppy at times. The audio even though you can hear it. Really sounds like a cam. Its very hollow. Lately most of the cams have had good audio. This doesnt. Overall wait for a telesync or maybe in a week or two a svcd telesync will arise with better audio and video. This is one cam not worth getting. Not even to watch.
yeah its free blah, blah, blah. But its still bad.

Nice First Outting FTF, but no Thanks!

6/5/?



The sample is very very good especially for a cam and especially for ftf. The full release is no where as good. I've only bothered grabbing cd1 as I doubt this will be my sort of film but I thought I'd have to check ftf out (Obviously a silver though as that's all ftf does).

Sound isn't bad for a cam really heard a lot worse.

6/7/?

Don't bother waiting for a better copy, just don't bother.

__________________
You're only in as much trouble as you think you are.


Posted by hellraiseruk on 07-22-2004 09:30 PM:

Nice 1st rls FTF..think this will be a big hit with all the kids as there on there 6 weeks holiday but i still dl and take a watch of this one, keep up the good work "FTF" u guyz should show ur faces more often hehe


Posted by deano21 on 07-22-2004 10:50 PM:

i dont kno how all you can complain the picture is really good nothin bad about it just sit bak wen watching giv em credit for first release.

7/7/?


Posted by Mr_Grinch on 07-22-2004 11:48 PM:

Re: Centropy y bother

quote:
Originally posted by IcEmAn
Da, whats the dfference between pots vers and centropys, nada, only a clearer picture of peoples heads wandering around a picture theatre!

Get it right guys or dont do it at all.....your wasting our valuable downloads on a lot of amature rubbish, dont waste your time if your going to let god knows how many pple waste thiers downloading a lot of rubbish, i cant beleive centropy who were the best in the business release a vers not better than that group of buffoons called pot, time to wake up, your have made your name centropy because u released the best, what were u thinking when u released KING ARTHUR and I ROBOT, if we want to see a bunch of heads moving around a picture theatre we'll go to the theatre and watch it, pull ya socks up guys as ya name is slowly going down the sink.....IcEmAn...

edit:I'm leaving this in so you guys can roast this idiot .P



Quite clearly you're an idiot. The I, Robot ts was one of the best i've seen in a good long time.

Oh and so i'm not too far off, thunderbirds was ok, watchable for kids (Kids seem to be able to put up with anything quality-wise).


Posted by diekund on 07-23-2004 12:43 AM:

Re: Centropy y bother

quote:
Originally posted by IcEmAn
Da, whats the dfference between pots vers and centropys, nada, only a clearer picture of peoples heads wandering around a picture theatre!

Get it right guys or dont do it at all.....your wasting our valuable downloads on a lot of amature rubbish, dont waste your time if your going to let god knows how many pple waste thiers downloading a lot of rubbish, i cant beleive centropy who were the best in the business release a vers not better than that group of buffoons called pot, time to wake up, your have made your name centropy because u released the best, what were u thinking when u released KING ARTHUR and I ROBOT, if we want to see a bunch of heads moving around a picture theatre we'll go to the theatre and watch it, pull ya socks up guys as ya name is slowly going down the sink.....IcEmAn...

edit:I'm leaving this in so you guys can roast this idiot .P



you are a complete and utter idiot. the quality of i, robot is far superior to POT's and it is a very good release. are you fucking watching this shit on a fricking 20 year old monitor, all burnt out and shit? you are a complete fool. also, what do u want them to do about peoples heads? say before:
"now every1, just to say, im filming this movie from the back of the cinema here to release on the internet. i would appreciate it if you all stayed in your seats for the duration of the film so i dont get your heads in the way. thanx for your co-opperation." not very likely. if u dont like it, dont download it. clearly thousands of people do, myself being one of them, and so just stfu. and also, if you dont like the rls of king arthur, why dont u go out and cam a version yourself? lets see your effort. king arthur was a silver and not recorded by them so dont go talking shit again. also dont go bashing POT for their efforts, people like them, and they deserve respect. so go to fuck thank you and please, do come again


Posted by deano21 on 07-23-2004 12:58 AM:

quote:
you are a complete and utter idiot. the quality of i, robot is far superior to POT's and it is a very good release. are you fucking watching this shit on a fricking 20 year old monitor, all burnt out and shit? you are a complete fool. also, what do u want them to do about peoples heads? say before:
"now every1, just to say, im filming this movie from the back of the cinema here to release on the internet. i would appreciate it if you all stayed in your seats for the duration of the film so i dont get your heads in the way. thanx for your co-opperation." not very likely. if u dont like it, dont download it. clearly thousands of people do, myself being one of them, and so just stfu. and also, if you dont like the rls of king arthur, why dont u go out and cam a version yourself? lets see your effort. king arthur was a silver and not recorded by them so dont go talking shit again. also dont go bashing POT for their efforts, people like them, and they deserve respect. so go to fuck thank you and please, do come again




good fucking point m8


Posted by henriklarson on 07-23-2004 03:19 AM:

why is the peeps saying welldone one the first release,, ftf hav been on the scene for years ,, they always done a shitty job b4 abut his one is pretty good for ftf

6/6/0.1 movies sucks ass if ur not 10 years old

__________________
lala


Posted by Miller on 07-23-2004 03:40 AM:

Re: Centropy y bother

[QUOTE]Originally posted by IcEmAn
[B]Da, whats the dfference between pots vers and centropys, nada, only a clearer picture of peoples heads wandering around a picture theatre!

Get it right guys or dont do it at all.....your wasting our valuable downloads on a lot of amature rubbish, dont waste your time if your going to let god knows how many pple waste thiers downloading a lot of rubbish, i cant beleive centropy who were the best in the business release a vers not better than that group of buffoons called pot, time to wake up, your have made your name centropy because u released the best, what were u thinking when u released KING ARTHUR and I ROBOT, if we want to see a bunch of heads moving around a picture theatre we'll go to the theatre and watch it, pull ya socks up guys as ya name is slowly going down the sink.....IcEmAn...

slowly going down the sink.... that was you common sence. their is no way in hell even the best groups can stop people from leaving their seats.

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!


Posted by lorddusty on 07-23-2004 04:27 AM:

Re: Re: Centropy y bother

quote:
Originally posted by Miller
that was you common sence. their is no way in hell even the best groups can stop people from leaving their seats. [/B]


(cough)find sources with booth access (/cough)... my comments on this rls were deleted earlier, and Im too drunk to post again.. yawn


Posted by RUiNU on 07-23-2004 04:43 AM:

I robot ctp

I have to say that this realese is slightly better then pot's. Pic is bight as fu6k, but the audio is louder. But in no way is this any were near what everyone is rateing it. I think I rated pot's a 7 and this would have to rate a 7.75-8 at the most.


Posted by Da Postman on 07-23-2004 05:07 AM:

I downloaded it today and converted it already to DVD. This is a great copy and I will watch it more than once. Clean sound, but not loud to hear.

V 8.5
A 7.5
M 7.0


Posted by WOW! on 07-23-2004 06:27 AM:

Re: Centropy y bother

quote:
Originally posted by IcEmAn
Da, whats the dfference between pots vers and centropys, nada, only a clearer picture of peoples heads wandering around a picture theatre!

Get it right guys or dont do it at all.....your wasting our valuable downloads on a lot of amature rubbish, dont waste your time if your going to let god knows how many pple waste thiers downloading a lot of rubbish, i cant beleive centropy who were the best in the business release a vers not better than that group of buffoons called pot, time to wake up, your have made your name centropy because u released the best, what were u thinking when u released KING ARTHUR and I ROBOT, if we want to see a bunch of heads moving around a picture theatre we'll go to the theatre and watch it, pull ya socks up guys as ya name is slowly going down the sink.....IcEmAn...

edit:I'm leaving this in so you guys can roast this idiot .P



You should go kill yourself right now!.......NOW!@

I've been around this forum for quite a while now. Never registered because i didnt have a real reason to, until that post above which i quoted. So i decided to register to tell him what hes worth......................NOTHING!

As for the quality:
8/8/9


Posted by frak on 07-23-2004 08:59 AM:

watched the centropy version on the TV tonight.

video was excellent, one of the better TS I've seen. Audio
was excellent as well. Movie was... ok.

video:8.5
audio: 8
movie: 7


Posted by 104 on 07-23-2004 11:42 AM:

FTF Thunderbirds

over cropped shit film but respect for the pre

CTP I Robot

very nice best so far


Posted by fuzzywuzzy1 on 07-23-2004 04:10 PM:

i robot
watched full movie last night on standalone dvd player, not bad release, pity about couple of people walking in front of cam, overall quality watchable


Posted by spdabbs on 07-23-2004 04:13 PM:

Having just flicked through both CD's I can say it looks watchable, though the pic is extremely grainy. Audio seems to be your average cam quality. Can't comment on the movie as a whole because I haven't watched it all the way through yet. Has to be said though, major props to FTF for an early rls - I was expecting to have to wait until the US rls date before this one was available.

5/6/?

Tnx FTF


Posted by punzada on 07-23-2004 06:33 PM:


8/7/6 - watchable movie in terms of entertainment, product placement annoyed me.

:: Don't flame. -K::


Posted by dvdhouse111 on 07-23-2004 11:57 PM:

i got the 2nd pot release first and as usual I was to quick on the draw. Centropy was a good effort and I was late for work as I got really into the flik. anyway I rate 8/10/9- 9 for flik is based on first disc im off to watch it all now but thinking will stick to my 9

best film ive seen in a while this I enjoyed


Posted by Miller on 07-24-2004 01:00 AM:

[QUOTE]Originally posted by punzada
twice, for like, 3 seconds, get over yourself with every other lil cunt bitching about it, quality otherwise is fine for a TS, good job to centropy.

have to agree with you their , 3 seconds of a movie nothing to complain about!. some people just need somthing to bitch about!!!

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!


Posted by Redemption1980 on 07-24-2004 02:21 AM:

At what point to the people stand up, ive not been able to find it, and i dont wanna spoil any of the movie.

A time would be nice.

Cheers


Posted by diekund on 07-24-2004 02:32 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by Redemption1980
At what point to the people stand up, ive not been able to find it, and i dont wanna spoil any of the movie.

A time would be nice.

Cheers



in i, robot i noticed in the intro bit and thats all so far like when it says I, Robot i see 1 guy sitting down


Posted by fluffykiwi on 07-24-2004 03:06 AM:

I Robot comments since this thread is messed up big time.

Picture has the usual Centropy problem where the glare from anything white renders any bright scenes almost unwatchable. I actually found the POT CAM more watchable with about the same number of people moving in front of the Camcorder, though the slight blur and cam shake with POT is a pain.
The picture quality and sound quality here is higher, by a good bit, but I'd rather see the details hidden in the bright glare.

7/8/8

The best available just now but it can be improved a LOT.

*edit* for info
There is a guy who sits down at the beginning and a woman? who moves around twice and a head that appears a couple of times.
This doesnt bother me in the slightest but the point of this forum i thought is to give feedback on the quality of the releases, to let people know what to expect. The groups have made it clear they dont care whatever we think.
It all good as far as I'm concerned.


Posted by ErrorS on 07-24-2004 11:28 AM:

I, Robot IMHO is the best release yet. nothing like the recent VideoCD releases.

but ignoring videocd's releases (Spiderman2 and whatever else) I give this a 9. 7 if you count videoCD's releases. still a shitload better then any other group's release

still worthy download. I doubt i'll bother with anything else until a dvd copy is released.

dunno about thunderbirds..

i have a question though (at least im asking?). but why do people comment that video for a cam is good? i thought TS and Cams video was the same.. TS patched into the theatre's audio directly and a cam just used the camera's microphone. TC does the same as a TS except it does it for video also..

can someone tell me if im wrong and why i'm wrong?


Posted by shark on 07-24-2004 03:24 PM:

I, Robot-CTP

Agreed with comments on the white-balance of the video, audio good though seems to be v. quiet in quiet segments and overloud in action sequences. Movie: enjoyable, but some of Smith's lines are weak... 7/7/6

__________________
Google owns...


Posted by wideboywells on 07-24-2004 10:34 PM:

Angry Thunderthighs !!!!!!!



This film should be called thunderthighs - because like a girl with them , it should be avoided by all costs !!!!

The release itself is aload of c*$p - how it manages to get above a 4 in the video rating is above me - i think people must be judging off jpegs or the sample which is surprisingly the best quality in the whole film .

No disrespect to ftf because it is a pre release copy and i admire their work but i'm sure they can do better than this !!!!


Posted by Mr E on 07-24-2004 11:48 PM:

Just watched the full movie, for those who need to know.......

Someone walks in front of the camera and sits down close to the start.

Someone else gets up in the middle some where, twice.

Nothing major, Quality is well watchable but the first post rating it as a 10 is way off the mark!!

Bright in places, similar to the same thing in Troy. But doesn't waste the movie.

Some strange horizontal lines appear and go, they can be seen on the right at the start of the film and then on the left during the film in some places (hairline, nothing to worry about)

Full film, right to the credits. Worth getting a hold of, no need for a proper.

Video:7.5
Audio:8
Movie: 9 (I thought it was a great flick)

...This is for I Robot, not Thunderbirds which seems to be in the same thread!

__________________
"The lesson here is you can't expect users to learn. There's too much fun going on out there on the Internet."


Posted by tyson24 on 07-25-2004 12:40 AM:

i robot

people need to start giving better info quality is good apart from the 5 or 6 bed wetters who walk past the screen in the first 45 minites


Posted by Mr E on 07-25-2004 01:23 AM:

Re: i robot

quote:
Originally posted by tyson24
people need to start giving better info quality is good apart from the 5 or 6 bed wetters who walk past the screen in the first 45 minites


I dont know what you were watching but there were 3 people for a few seconds!

And if thats your idea of better quality info, maybe you should forget about posting!!!

Was my post not detailed enough for you????

__________________
"The lesson here is you can't expect users to learn. There's too much fun going on out there on the Internet."


Posted by peevuto on 07-25-2004 03:16 AM:

The white balance everyone is bashing is NOTHING compared to that of TROY, which made that film totally unwatchable! So don't compare this to TROY, you meathead!!


Posted by Bravo on 07-25-2004 03:41 AM:

You want an honest and accurate opinion. Here ya go.
Picture was very good with a slight line(hairlinethin) that seemed to roll up the picture a few time. It didn't really affect the movie. There were three "heads" that i saw in the picture that didn't really affect it either(one may have stood out a little though). The picture was bright, but it was not at the "Troy" level(couldn't enjoy that movie). Also this movie didn't have the usual centropy overcrop.

The sound was very clean, but a little too dynamic in that the dialog would be at a very low volume then the action would seem to be ten times louder(was a little irritating). All in all a good release. This is the one to get.


Posted by babelfish on 07-25-2004 10:42 AM:

<< I Robot >>

I watched the full movie last night...

I rate the release:

7.5 / 9.0 / 9.0

As discussed, the white balance was the biggest problem for me... the interior scenes are fine, but when the action moves outside, things get a little washed out. The movie does suffer from a blur within fast paced scenes... which seems the norm for a cam release... use a fast shutter speed on camcorder..??

Sound was fine, it was clear on a standard Dolby surround setup.

As for the movie, I really enjoyed it. I'm not a fan of Will Smith though... his dialogue in the movie is poor. The star of the show is predictably the robot
I thought the 30 year look into the future was very well done... no flying cars or spaceships.. check out the Audi car.

Overall the best release so far... yes there are 3 times the screen is obstructed by some gimp "dropping the kids off @ the pool", yes the cap has an intermittent green hairline on vertically scrolling parts... who cares.. I enjoyed the movie, and I will pay good money to see it properly in the cinema, based on this "preview".

Thanks for your efforts Centropy.


Posted by 404notfound on 07-25-2004 04:14 PM:

Ok. I've had enough of this. Lets set some rules.

1 NO REQUESTING (This is obvious. Ask and get banned)

2 NO SLAGGING OFF OTHER USERS. I am fucking sick to death of people slagging each other off. Stick to rating the quality and note any problems you feel with the release. SLAG OFF OTHER USERS AND I WILL BAN YOU!

3 I do not want to hear any shit about "Ooooh. Where's Centropy/Video CD" or "I'll wait for Centropy/VIDEO CD"

4 If you cant abide by the above rules. GET THE FUCK OUT. Nobody wants you here!

__________________


Posted by Redemption1980 on 07-25-2004 04:29 PM:

quote:
Ok. I've had enough of this. Lets set some rules.


About time, though 404 will the US users know what Slagging off each other means?


Posted by Stuart49 on 07-25-2004 06:45 PM:

Thunderbirds - CAM - FTF

Video is very pixelated at times throughout the movie,so bad sometimes could not make out what was on screen,at other times pic is watchable but not the best cam I have seen

Audio sound like someone is speaking into a tin bucket

Video 4
Audio 4
Movie ?


Posted by weedchemist on 07-25-2004 08:40 PM:

bad movie

i will have to say that the movie SLEEPOVER was easily a more entertaining movie, i never saw this as i heard that it has been done before, a tv series or sumthing, but this is the worst movie ive ween in months upon months, the quality umm ehhh no, but it is pre, and it was watchable the audio isnt that incredibly bad, the new catowoman is worse, no audience noise, slightly muffled/hollow, shoulda been svcd, but oh well... 4/7/3


Posted by qubit on 07-26-2004 04:50 AM:

regarding I, Robot

Haven't watched the whole thing yet, but so far it looks damn good to me. Will Smith in the shower....mmm...mmm....mmm!

I haven't read all the posts since it's so mixed up with Thunderbirds, but I saw some complaining about I, Robot. What is there to complain about? I can never figure out why some of you people whine and pout, use fowl language (no doubt due to a limited vocabulary and limited intelligence), rant and rage over FREEBIES!!!! Catch a clue, people. As they say, "You get what you pay for." If you're paying nothing and you get crap, so what? At worst, maybe you have a couple of coasters. But this release is great, especially compared to nothing, which is what you would get at the theater if you didn't pay them. Have a little appreciation for these groups. If you think it can be done better, then you go out and do it yourself. I doubt there will be very many takers on that challenge.

__________________


Posted by Hairyhamster on 07-26-2004 04:40 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Redemption1980
At what point to the people stand up, ive not been able to find it, and i dont wanna spoil any of the movie.

A time would be nice.

Cheers



i counted twice thoughout the movie..... a person walks across screen from right to left then later from left to right

__________________
One Day The Dead Shall Walk The Earth.


Posted by bcm2001 on 07-27-2004 08:10 PM:

thunderbirds

All I Can Say Is Wait 6/10 very poor


Posted by qubit on 07-27-2004 10:19 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Redemption1980
About time, though 404 will the US users know what Slagging off each other means?




I googled British slang and found out what it means:


slag someone off: to say unpleasant things about someone to other people.

__________________


Posted by Malarky05 on 07-28-2004 03:23 AM:

anyone have any trouble with the files being corrupt while they are being extracted?


Posted by fizzz on 07-28-2004 04:11 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by Malarky05
anyone have any trouble with the files being corrupt while they are being extracted?


Didn't happen to me. All extracted fine.

Movie was suprisingly watchable actually and this was too bad for a cam, just blurry as anything. Sound was quite good if not a tad too quite.

6/5/7


Posted by homershaggy on 07-28-2004 07:39 AM:

i,robot

i dont know if this has been addressed but
why the same page for i,robot centropy and
thunderbirds ftf ?????????

i,robot 8.5/6.5/10

the audio even though clear was very low volume and some hissing (or is it my speaker!)
the colors were a bit off and the brightness too much sometimes
other than that great release

yeah i loved the movie so much i watched it twice and wil go to the theater when it comes out on 6th august here !

__________________
Will Kill For Movies


Posted by deano21 on 07-29-2004 06:01 PM:

IRobot is the best movie ive seen in a long time even better than spiderman 2!! any way the picture was great sound even better.

pic 8
sound 9
movie 10


Posted by deano21 on 07-30-2004 01:47 AM:

Thunderbirds
Ok well i aint watched it on a tv or pc but i watched it on my mobile.The picture is reall gd just zoomed still watchable the sound is just brilliant noraml for cam.This movie i thought was brilliant but then again i am a thunderbird fan This is a really good film i cant see how no 1 can slate it.Action from the beginning cant wait for thunderbirds 2


pic 7
aud 8
vid 9


Posted by TrueDevil on 08-01-2004 09:00 PM:

Talking

Top Top film 10 out of 10


Posted by djj on 08-03-2004 09:23 AM:

Ok, it seems this page is kind of screwed up but here comes ratings for both I, Robot by CTP and Thunderbirds - FTF.

I, Robot:

Quite nice release. Video is good and audio is rather great. Movie is ok.

8/9/7

Thunderbirds:

Meh. Yes, I understand it was a pre but still... well, anyhow, there's a better release of this movie so get that one if you _really_ want to see this movie, what a lousy movie this is.

6/7/4

__________________


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:00 AM.
Show all 88 posts from this thread on one page

Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.3.0
Copyright © Jelsoft Enterprises Limited 2000 - 2002.