Show all 94 posts from this thread on one page
|
Show all 94 posts from this thread on one page |
VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- VCD (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- I Robot *INTERNAL* *SVCD* - TELESYNC - POT (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=44676)
I Robot *INTERNAL* *SVCD* - TELESYNC - POT
Very nice rls POT!
Still a little blurry, but looks much better than the VCD rls.
Perfect DTS audio too. Anyone rating this less than a 10 has issues. How can it BE any less perfect? (Unless it was out of synch or something).
Think i'll settle for this rls and watch this and get the movie out of the way once and for all. 
8/10
WOW great job pot.your becoming great at releases not that u aint.The pic is nice a tad blurry but if u sit away its perfect.Great sound as well nothing wrong.
well done pot will get this
8/10/?
brilliant release, especially the sound, managed to get the sample
video 8 pretty good telesync, well watchable
sound 10 couldn't be any better
havent watched the movie yet
going to be a pain in the arse to find this release though, with the other release having a similar file name, oh well
/me takes the crack pipe of ms and co
have u actually checked the colours on this rls ?
not good enough quality to worthy svcd either
4\9\8
__________________
SeeDee MKII
quote:
/me takes the crack pipe of ms and co
have u actually checked the colours on this rls ?
not good enough quality to worthy svcd either
4\9\8
Crazy
You guys are rating this way too high. Yeah, its a lot better compared to their other releases, but this release is in no way an 8 for video. Blurry, heck yeah its blurry.
5/9/?
quote:
Originally posted by SeeDee_MKII
/me takes the crack pipe of ms and co
have u actually checked the colours on this rls ?
not good enough quality to worthy svcd either
4\9\8
a decent release of this long awaited movie. a little better than the last. this is the one to watch so grab it while you can
__________________
your never alone with Schizophrenia
the sample i saw did not look that good. Audio was Great but video from the sample looked ok. i get the 1st cd and see if its better. Saw the movie last night in theater... it was Great!
7/10/9 (from sample)
__________________
Elisha Cuthbert is sooooooooooooo hot!!!!
just watched the sample . pot cleaned this up alot. as the nfo said its brighter, sharper, and a little more color.its still a littel blurry. id settle for this rls. and of course audio is perfect.
7/10/8
__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!
this is a true ts, you cant get much better then this, DTS sound, good not so croped picture, decent quality, the only thing that could be better is if the video had better / more viberant colors, but im sure as hell not complaining good job guys good to see your takeing up group up more steps
VIDEO - 8
SOUND - 10
MOVIE - Going to theaters to see it, will smith is just tooo good lol
just watched the sample....
wow this rls isn't as dark or fuzzy but it's way too bright and everything has a sea-green tint to it.
original TS by POT:
7/9
THIS rls by POT:
7.5/10
picture was a little better but i already watched the other release that was enough for me...shitty attempt at matrix effects or something,movie bites.
__________________
pha~Q
Very nicely done POT! Quick Quality & DTS oh my! You'd NEED to be smoking crack to think that these A/V sources didnt warrent SVCD... just look at the difference ;Þ
Movie wasnt as quality, good idea... poorly executed :T
8/10/6 (Whole Movie)
i dont know if we got the same sample
but this looks like shit
picture is fucking horrible
its green
audio isnt bad but it isnt the best i seen
4/8
__________________
Video still looks like crap for me, the audio is the only thing that great.
Thats Better No guy with a HAT!!.. needing the toilet every 5 mins
V:8 ..far better picture then the other rls (bit of a green tint 2 it though)
S:10.. The Sound is Fab
M:8 Enjoy'd it (not better then spiderguy2 though)lol
Very nice copy 7/10/8
hey Mystic, where in the NFO does it say the source audio is from the DTS disc?
x/x/x
rating it soon
__________________
quote:cos he's in bed with the other guys *wink* SEEdee
Originally posted by deano21
OMG this is a good release the picture is good how can u give it a 4?????????
but this IS however a decent release, not the best but not the worse... 7/9/7
quote:
Originally posted by lax01
hey Mystic, where in the NFO does it say the source audio is from the DTS disc?
x/x/x
rating it soon
Green tint traded for the blur.
Mystic Slippers: both releases are from the DTS so how do you rate one an 8 and this one a 10? I just listened to the same scene in the internal sample as in the first telesync. They sounded identical went I viewed the scenes back to back. Audio still seems too low.
LOL i think the DTS bit is a little missleading casue there is no way none of these carry dts track
1) if it was in dts most people wouldnt be able to play it on there pc/stand alone as it wouldnt revert back to 2 channel stereo.
2)The amount of cds per film to carry 2 sound tracks would have to increase and i cant switch audio when its playing so i guess there is only one audio track on the disk
DTS as you all keep refering to is the fact its a direct plugin to the theater sound system not a proper DTS sound track as in 5.1/6.1 etc
The movie still looks blurry but like its been said the sound is good.
8/10/3
very nice release, crappy movie, nfo has the word shit in it.
zad:
the DTS thing means they got the audio for their camera in the theater from a DTS *SOURCE* meaning they got DTS disc(s) from the movie that are sent along to a theater and used them though didn't encode them in DTS. rofl, a DTS track wouldn't even FIT on a single CD-R let alone with any video on it at all.
omg this shit is terrible....again pot wins with sound, still alittle low..but the video is f..king horrible. What the f..k is up with the green tint. The contrast is f..king high, and the picture is blurry and pixelates during movement. Man stick with FRA cam. Pot is still losing points for even trying to pass this re-encode off as a svcd telesync. Horrible release again.
4/7/9 movie was good. Too bad most of these releases aren't.
-Videocd is gone as far a telesync's
-Centropy is back but releases are to the shits.
-Will TCR or Fujitive make a guess appearance.
-or will TUN return with another fake Telecine....
__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...
ok;..shall i now give my opinion so at last u will read the comment of a dude that knows what he's talking about and is very objective:
video:. If you tune ure tv with a bit more color etc then it's watchable. It's not bad but definately not the quality that gives me a boner. It's watchable and nothing more.
audio: yes;..this is good. Dont think it's DTS but ok. It's still easy on the ears and therefor a job well done
movie: yes it is an american blockbuster so you can expect the same idiology as in other flics like this;.. A.I etc. But this movie has had so much bad critics and that is not right.
Overall rates:..well i personally find the video more important then the audio. So:
6/9/6.5
No WAY...
wish I know how to fix the video like re encode for a better looking video personaly.....
everything is starting to look green.......... picture is to much, looks better the the rest.
wow !!!! svcd internal ok.. anyhow I hear a hiss in audio but it's clear driect dts cool.
a-7.8
v-6.2 my min requirments
due to no ctp or vcd grp rels maybe, I'll keep this copy..
movie 8.0
__________________
Anyone with any complaints, contact:
[email protected]
Movie From Maven Priceless!!
*Broadband internet not included...
this isnt any better then the other one, its still shit, now there is a green tint to it , the sound is good, still a little low but i can deal with it,
5/9
pic
ill take blurry over green tint
FAO Ms
The reason i only voted the sound 9 was although the sound was DTS source the level quality playback on my TV was too low.
Just because they say its DTS, dont make it an actual 10 does it now.
here endeth lesson
__________________
SeeDee MKII
well best out there sofar..
so get it if you like will smith
or get it if you like to support POT...
get this if you can adjust your tv's green tint..
NEW NEWS'
jjo a radio station here has a 1st anual dodgeball contest want in??
weard.
looks like people are lowering there raitings for TS vcd or svcd's man wish there was a way to get direct video .....
__________________
Anyone with any complaints, contact:
[email protected]
Movie From Maven Priceless!!
*Broadband internet not included...
quote:
Originally posted by SeeDee_MKII
FAO Ms
The reason i only voted the sound 9 was although the sound was DTS source the level quality playback on my TV was too low.
Just because they say its DTS, dont make it an actual 10 does it now.
here endeth lesson
quote:
Originally posted by ShinBone
Green tint traded for the blur.
Mystic Slippers: both releases are from the DTS so how do you rate one an 8 and this one a 10? I just listened to the same scene in the internal sample as in the first telesync. They sounded identical went I viewed the scenes back to back. Audio still seems too low.
Unless they have a new way to do DTS sound there is no way to put this on a svcd. The sound file would be too big. This is a direct source converted to mp2 sound. Please stop saying dts and just say direct sound. Put on a factory disc and you will hear the difference of what true DTS sounds is.
8/10/8
Superb Audio. Video not discernably different from the VCD
version. Oh well , not much new out atm anyway if you want
to DL it.
__________________
Heph (Hephaestus)
The only real complaint I had before was that the pic was a little dark. I never thought it was blurry. But if they brightened it up, ah reckon it's worth a peek.
POT-- your rep is growing.
__________________
November 2, 2004. America shoots itself in foot, re-elects Bush. Recovery to take decades. Stay tuned.
quote:
Originally posted by Mystic Slippers
Audio seemed low to me on the first VCD.
Maybe they used a different level for this one? Maybe i was drunk? Maybe Miami will win the world series?
Who cares.
It sounded different.
The end.
6/10/? from sample
the tint is really annoying. unless i can adjust it with wmp or something i'd rather settle for blurry. sound is nice though.
Alls I can say is if you want to see this movie don't watch the sample. Ruins the whole flick. GJ, POT
__________________
My sig worked, It's back.
good job guys thank you
my score 8/9/10
thats 8 for the picture
9 sound
10 good movie
would have been 10 for the picture but it is blurred and that guy gets in the way three times but all in all great job
thank you
quote:
Originally posted by Bravo
Unless they have a new way to do DTS sound there is no way to put this on a svcd. The sound file would be too big. This is a direct source converted to mp2 sound. Please stop saying dts and just say direct sound. Put on a factory disc and you will hear the difference of what true DTS sounds is.
__________________
563-773-1880
<Dwaggy> i caught you a delicious Bass
<The404> This is because you are an idiot
What sample have I been watching?
What sample have I been watching? I dunno, but the sample is kinda green and blurry. What's up with everyone giving the video an 8??? Should some of the better VideoCd and Centropy releases get a freaking 15 then? On a scale of 10, no way this is an 8. You guys must have real low expectations
quote:
Originally posted by pHo
sigh, please read before typing. i think everyone here except you and zad, knows the difference between a DTS track on a dvd and a DTS source from a theater. direct sound could mean a jack in a seat used, and that's hardly the same as using a DTS disc and muxing is it?
quote:
Originally posted by Jazzmo
Thats Better No guy with a HAT!!.. needing the toilet every 5 mins
__________________
zooted adj : 1. under influence of drugs: relaxed, excited, or euphoric from taking illegal drugs, especially marijuana ( slang ) 2. intoxicated: very intoxicated ( informal )
looter n. : someone who takes spoils or plunder (as in war) [syn: plunderer, pillager, spoiler, despoiler, raider, freebooter]
way too green to me and why is there 2 mpg in disc2 with different lba
audio 8
video 5
film 6
__________________
quote:
Originally posted by XboxFreak
Miami doesn't have a baseball, and if you mean Florida Marlins yes they already won the world series, twice!
quote:
Originally posted by maccydad
and why is there 2 mpg in disc2 with different lba
audio 8
video 5
film 6
fras rls is still superior;]
quote:
Originally posted by dc_man
Alls I can say is if you want to see this movie don't watch the sample. Ruins the whole flick.
Damn stupid sample, did they mean that.
I think this is OK, the pic is blurry and strange looking, but watchable enough, not really an improvement from the VCD version though.
Sound is overrated, if this is from a DTS disc then, then they've messed up the encode to mp2 as this isn't as good as the sound on VideoCD's Spiderman2, which is the best TS audio yet.
6/7/8
Good release .. not much more to say that hasn't been said already.
7/9/8
k
i guesse by now everyone that wants the know bout it knows
but this isnt an amazing release
its fast.
its watchable
but its not amazing
its not a dv cam job
the sound is good
the picture is cropped and well washed out. and grainy. so not that good
if i'd give ctp an 8 i'd give this one an 5.5
cuase its watchable .. but i dont wanna see this movie this way.
so right now goto the cinema's
and see it there
sound great
vision not so great
its interesting that in the full release the audio seems much better then the sample
but the pic is much shittier
__________________
....
video 5
audio 7
movie - waiting for a watchable release
yes i know its fre etc etc
:: Just shut up with the comedy and rate the friggin release. -K::
quality sux a lot dont kno what yall r thinkin =\ 4/5/8
I'm not stevie wonder but I can rate this above a 5. I would think stevie would rate it a 0 for being to dark. <<<---Joke!! Pic was fine but too green (washed out). I didnt notice it being blurry,just grainy. Sound was good, sounded like it was direct. Movie was cool, not great but entertaining.
7/9/7.5
BTW All the peeps that gave the video below a 5 are just peeps that like to stur up crap. Please rate this, dont bash it.
Man this shit is worse than the proper. Green tint all the way through. And what is with everyone saying the sound is better. It isn't that much better. Played on stand alone dvd player (yes I wasted 2 cd's). Stick with the proper or FRA if you have it. This is not that much better. However, it is still watchable if you must have.
Peace
Video: Green vs Blurr u decide = 6
Audio: Great for a TS = 10
Movie: Not bad for Will Smith = 7.5
shitty picture, green tint? blurry?
no way its any higher than a 5, audio is great, i watched the other pot release, was fine enough to watch
5/9/7
why did i waste my time with this rls???
i'm sorry but the sound wasn't altogether there, the pic...well let me not go any further on that and i cant comment on the movie cos the picture was so bad i couldn't watch it
2/4/???
quote:
Originally posted by Bravo
True, now it makes sense. If i take a plain audio tape and copy a 5.1 digital disc audio track i will have 5.1 digital on the tape. It will play back as 5.1 too on my stereo system. Makes perfect sense to me now, thanks.
6/8/7
Video is not too bad for a TS release, audio is good but not great. The movie, egh, well its a sci-fi independence day..
-------------------------------------------
I don't give a fuck what you think.
Watched this last night. I expected it to be shit but was pleasantly suprised. Not an awesome movie, but good enough to keep you interested. This release is let down by fairly crappy video, it's washed out, blurry and (as mentioned earlier) there's the bloke with the baseball cap and some slut with an afro gettin' in the way.
The audio also loses sync for 10mins on CD1, but otherwise the sound is perfect, although quiet.
Overall: 5/9/8
__________________
Statistically... 9 out of 10 people actually enjoy gang rape.
pretty good release by pot
excellent sound, this is probably the best that pot has released.
I give it a 7/9/?
quote:
Originally posted by garvey100
A fairly retarded comment. Clearly you can't understand that the audio source is from a DTS DISC, and therefore should be labelled as such, whether it's 5.1, 6.1 or simply encoded to 2 channel sound. It is from a different source to the jack in the seat, for example. Also despite your attempt at irony/sarcasm, you clearly also have difficulty understanding the difference between analogue and digital.
was a very nice rls 6/7/7 I would have given you guys a better score if the jerk in front of you didn't get up 4 times while your cam man was filming it!
eh missing ending of the movie
__________________
quote:
Originally posted by deftones6
How are you rating the video and audio without actually having the movie????
quote:
Originally posted by your name here
eh missing ending of the movie
__________________
All the excitement of a trip to hell with none of the negitive side affects!
quote:
Originally posted by your name here
eh missing ending of the movie
seriously m$, how are you rating the video so high ?? its cropeed quite a bit, green to fuck and generally pretty shit for a silver, SVCD, TS.
I personally still think that the FRA repack was far superior in quality, and if like me you rip the audio from the pot rls and mux with the FRA video, you have a half decent rls.
I`d also like to say Hi to my mum, and suck my balls to the 99% of the twats on here.
__________________
SeeDee MKII
Mystic, why is it that all the nay-sayers are newbies? Anyone who rates this rls lower than a 7/10/x is a fucking groupie. Go suck on your favorite groups nuts some more, POT did an excellent job with this one.
Anyway, this rls is great. The sound is perfect, colors are just fine, only thing that keeps it from being perfect is the very very slight flicker in brightness, but it's hardly noticable, blurry, but what do you expect? A Screener or DVD-rip?
All in all 9/10/8.5
Movie wasnt bad at all, but had a few shortcomings. Great flick though.
quote:
Originally posted by Bravo
Thank you for clearing that up for me as it was obvious i didn't understand. Thanks again, you are noble. So tell me, is the sound still DTS or is it MP2 stereo once it's converted?
but only stereo on my amp weird
DAMN fine job on the rls
7/9/9
Grainy with green tint and slight blur. This release was BAD.
Video 3.5
Audio 7
Movie 8.5
__________________
It is purpose that created us
Purpose that connects us
Purpose that pulls us
that guides us,
that DRIVES us,
It is purpose that defines
PURPOSE........that BINDS us
"Agent Smith" (and cloned virii cohorts)
"The Matrix Reloaded"
this looks much better than the proper ts but still has ways to go before being as good as videocd. I mean I really miss those guys. SO far their garfield, the terminal, dodgeball and white chicks have been their best ts's and right now pot does not stand a chance but they are getting better. Keep improving, hopefully you can then be the solution to videocd
__________________
hello
hey bravo,
did you know (s)\vcd's can totally be authored with DTS audio? you blithering idiot. obviousely it is encoded to mp2. nevertheless, it will be infinitely better than another means of direct audio, i.e. the aforementioned headphone jack.
and on another note, pot rules because they are NTSC god damnit!! and i dont have to re-enc to author DVDR.
8/9/9
awesome release
Video - green,grainy,god-awful
Rate it a 4(and I'm being generous)
Audio - superb
Rate it a 10(don't see how the sound can get any better)
Movie - a joke....hasn't "The Matrix" been re-hashed enough already.Hollywood needs some new script writers....BADLY.
Rate it a 2(please get some ideas for films)
Considering I, Robot was written about 900 zillion years BEFORE The Matrix, someone needs to get their bold statements right.
Originally posted by bee_nutz
hey bravo,
did you know (s)\vcd's can totally be authored with DTS audio?you blithering idiot.
Bravo-OK i'm an idiot, SO! And can you post a link to back up your statement?
bee_nutz-obviousely it is encoded to mp2.
Bravo-And what was the argument again?
CASE CLOSED!!!!
video is total sh!t....worst than the first release as said many times alrdy. also, it would be nice to see a release by this grp without heads poppin up in front of the camera....repositioning the camera might eliminate this...but what do i know
4/9/x
still waiting for a better release..even if i have to wait for the dvdrip
bravo,
read pot nfo for king arthur & the proper ts of i robot
quote:
Originally posted by Bravo
Originally posted by bee_nutz
hey bravo,
did you know (s)\vcd's can totally be authored with DTS audio?you blithering idiot.
Bravo-OK i'm an idiot, SO!
bee_nutz-obviousely it is encoded to mp2.
Bravo-And what was the argument again?
CASE CLOSED!!!!
quote:
Originally posted by garvey100
Obviously you don't feel the need to know where the audio is sourced from. I personally think that knowing where audio is from gives us a better opportunity to discuss the release. Still you can't get it through your thick skull that it has to mentioned that its from DTS, as this is different to other forms of direct sound. MP2 encodes from different sources are obviously gonna sound different. We ALL know that it is MP2 sound, the group don't insult our ignorance by stating the blatantly obvious, and mention therefore where it is sourced from. You are sounding more ignorant in every post bravo, so now's the time to stop.
. True i don't care where the source is from. As long as it is clean. And i can see where knowing what the source is may mean alot to some of you. But calling the audio on the svcd DTS is still wrong. If you call it audio from a DTS source that is different and correct. There are alot of noobs who won't understand your lingo and think they have DTS on a disc.
This is the worst release i have ever gotten. I see ppls heads leaving to go to the bathroom n then i see them come back. Colors are horrible, screen is blury, it freezes after cd1 n cd2 and i cant even watch the ending.
I give it a 3 or video and a 7 on audio
did i grab the wrong rel? audio is awesome. video is all green toned. it was labled the internal svcd rel
?/9/6
quote:
Originally posted by Bravo
Gotta love the insults, always leads to a more honest and constructive conversation
And don't say it won't happen cause i have seen people who think mono in two speakers is stereo. Let's just call it what it is and nothing more. It is great sound. Probably one of the best released on svcd, but it is not DTS. It's mp2 audio from a dts source.
It's weird to see 2 releases that needed each other so bad. The FRA cam had a pretty nice pic and bad audio. And this is exactly the opposite. I don't see how anyone can say this video is good. It's green, blurry and washed out. The audio is pretty nice except too quiet. So you take this audio and turn it up and take FRA cam you have a nice release. That's what I did. I've only watched half so far but the movie seems ok to me.
4/8/?
__________________
"with great power comes great responsibility."
Wow you guys didnt remind me to bring the underwater diving googles so everything else in the room would look as green as the video... Video also a little bit grainy, but not cropped too bad.
And unless I am losing my mind the sync is off a little bit in the first cd (round 15 mins in).
6/8/6
quote:
Originally posted by Mystic Slippers
Considering I, Robot was written about 900 zillion years BEFORE The Matrix, someone needs to get their bold statements right.
6/8/4
Decent release, Not worth a blank CD imo. Not because of the quality, but because I thought the movie was trash.
__________________
After watching the full vcd, i have to say nuke this one. it is not a ts, people are walking though the screen as it plays, and the picture is shaky/blurred. I do have to agree the audio is excellent
This one should be nuked for the fact that there's a chunk of film missing in between cd1 and cd2.
:: I have watched this release. There is NOTHING missing. Whatever problems you are having are yours and yours alone. - 404notfound
[IMG]http://storeage.s5.com/store/q.gif[/IMG]
Film was worth a watch
Quality was average, Shame about the couple of heads when people were going to the restroom.
Sound was a bit low, but the quality was not 2 bad once the volume was cranked up.
http://storeage.s5.com/store/qbanner.gif
| All times are GMT. The time now is 01:28 PM. | Show all 94 posts from this thread on one page |
Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.3.0
Copyright © Jelsoft Enterprises Limited 2000 - 2002.