VCDQuality Forums - King Arthur *SVCD* - TELECINE

Pages (3): [1] 2 3 »
Show all 47 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- King Arthur *SVCD* - TELECINE - TUN (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=45816)

Posted by vip3r on 08-23-2004 07:52 AM:

Video is ok - kinda shitty though, the audio is nice.

Nuked: gay.sidebars.overcropped.missing.heads

And yes .. it's definately overcropped, and the fkking sidebars are annoying as hell!

6.5/8.5/9

::edit:: Well in VideoLAN it had sidebars, but others told me while viewing it in PowerDVD it did not. Either way, the heads are cut off like hell in some parts of the sample, and the video is crappy for a TC. So i'll pass on this one.

Posted by CrashRoX on 08-23-2004 08:19 AM:

Audio is really nice, video is decent. I didnt really hear anything good about the actual movie... NUKED, still watchable if your desperate... If you waited this long.. hold out for another.

6/8.5/?

__________________
Kazaa has good zero day

joey_75051- "WHAT DO YOU MEAN kazaa HADS GOOD ZERO DAY"

Posted by dark101 on 08-23-2004 08:19 AM:

If this is a TC im going blind.

__________________
__________________________

Fuk off biatch this is my turf!
__________________________

Posted by lorddusty on 08-23-2004 08:24 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by vip3r

And yes .. it's definately overcropped, and the fkking sidebars are annoying as hell!

6.5/8.5/9

nuked on only a few sites i see *cough*sheep nuking?*.. ps the sidebars go away when you watch on tv... and wtf is a missing head?
/edit nm think i see what you mean, kinda cropped on the top.. stil a decent TC though

Posted by Ibegoat on 08-23-2004 08:46 AM:

quote:
RELEASE NOTES: Another nice telecine from your friends in TUN. =)

I think by nice they mean NUKED! lol.... and TUN thinks they deserve respect. This should have been released *INTERNAL* if at all. Video is washed out, pixelated not to mention cropped like a bitch! Audio seems damn crisp though. Keep up the work, just try and make it better. As for the movie not a bad flick, not as good as gladiator or braveheart, but not bad either

5/8/7

__________________
Banned for repeatedly advertising pyramid schemes in signature.

Posted by HELLiON on 08-23-2004 09:01 AM:

5/7/6

wish TUN would get some good encoders since they obviously have an ok source just rips kinda suck

Posted by MoegHoeg on 08-23-2004 11:04 AM:

Am I the only one who watch my movies on a TV? The black bars on the sides will not be visible on a TV since they disapear in the overscan. Also colors tend to look more "right" on a TV. Why not just quit bashing the poor guys in TUN? I'm glad someone takes their time to release these movies, saves me ticket money :P

Posted by commiewhore on 08-23-2004 11:46 AM:

video = 7

audio = 7

movie = 5

movie was ok, nothing too special. pissed me off, thought it was going to be good, not so rushed. sample for this is misleading, video isnt that bad, if they cut off the sidebars, would be smarter, the cropped isnt that bad on top and bottom , bout the same as the LOTR ROTK telecine Chakra did, just no russian. all and all not bad, but this doesnt have same dts audio as CTP Rls, at least their rip doesnt have the same quality sound i expected it to have. other than that, pretty decent.

Posted by tr1pp1n on 08-23-2004 12:26 PM:

maybe the rumours are true, any how this is definitly a reincoded source...

quote:
Originally posted by diekund
do you have a clue? the last TUN rls u said the same thing, and you were wrong. dont post if you dont have anything to say about the quality. theres no need to slam a rls group. even if they do mess up, there still doing more than 99% of us.

video is cropped, not enough to complain about. its washed. dark and grainy. i dont think it is a TC, def not worth a 3cd dl. the ts wasnt good, and neither is this.

audio: theres a hiss, its def not DTS

movie: i dont want to see this :|

6.5/6.5/?

i dont see how i am wrong here, these people are buying silvers on the streets, and shitty pdvds and saying they are telecines fuck you, my personal belief is this is a fuckoff group much like UGG in the mp3 scene, so shut the fuck up if u have no basis to flame me besides the fact that you like TUN. You can tell me im wrong once this group stops getting nuked, and site banned... k thx

__________________

The wise man does not play leap frog with unicorns...

Posted by yyiryyib on 08-23-2004 01:15 PM:

lol, the video is ok but its anything but a re-encode, its a tc alright, looking at the colour, the screen size and quality.

the cropping im not a fan of, i dont see why they crop things, i dont get why xvid groups do as well, i can remmeber my killbill dvd rip (the diamond one) where at the end u cant see where o ren ishi's skull has been removed at the top, its doesnt make any sense to me

Posted by commiewhore on 08-23-2004 01:32 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by tr1pp1n
maybe the rumours are true, any how this is definitly a reincoded source...

if the source was re-encoded from CTP's source, then we would see french subs when the pagans speak in multiple scenes in cd1, or you would see it cropped high enough to cover those subs, which it isnt, and replaced with hardcoded english subs.

check source though before making rumor claims and preaching them...if this was a re-encode of that source then its damn good hiding. heh. but interested in seeing what source it could be from other than pdvd.

or comment and score the movie pls.

7/7/5 ...just like my previous score , broke forrum rule for comments but wanted to see someone prove their remarks rather than spread more rumors.

Posted by Froggi on 08-23-2004 02:13 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by commiewhore
if the source was re-encoded from CTP's source, then we would see french subs when the pagans speak in multiple scenes in cd1, or you would see it cropped high enough to cover those subs, which it isnt, and replaced with hardcoded english subs.

check source though before making rumor claims and preaching them...if this was a re-encode of that source then its damn good hiding. heh. but interested in seeing what source it could be from other than pdvd.

or comment and score the movie pls.

7/7/5 ...just like my previous score , broke forrum rule for comments but wanted to see someone prove their remarks rather than spread more rumors.

Maybe a reencode from the rus. avi's?

Posted by loxs on 08-23-2004 02:15 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by commiewhore
if the source was re-encoded from CTP's source, then we would see french subs when the pagans speak in multiple scenes in cd1, or you would see it cropped high enough to cover those subs, which it isnt, and replaced with hardcoded english subs.

check source though before making rumor claims and preaching them...if this was a re-encode of that source then its damn good hiding. heh. but interested in seeing what source it could be from other than pdvd.

or comment and score the movie pls.

7/7/5 ...just like my previous score , broke forrum rule for comments but wanted to see someone prove their remarks rather than spread more rumors.

Where in gods name did he say it was a reincode of CTP's he just said a reincode eg. they picked up a copy of it on the streets and "reincoded" it . scene rls's arent the only versions of movies going round you know look at the wider picture

__________________

Posted by manofice on 08-23-2004 02:17 PM:

NUKED-REASON-gay.sidebars.overcropped.missing.heads.surprise.a.tun.nuke

Posted by Bazacko on 08-23-2004 02:56 PM:

yeah, the cropping is pretty yucky on this one.
6/7

__________________

Posted by Debo on 08-23-2004 03:09 PM:

shitty and i still havent seent he movie
6/7

__________________

Posted by Miller on 08-23-2004 04:02 PM:

over cropped and such. video is not bad but its cropped to death. audio is not bad as well. but still i have ctp version and i'll stick with that untill a dvdr . movie sucked

5/8/6

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!

Posted by diekund on 08-23-2004 04:13 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by tr1pp1n
maybe the rumours are true, any how this is definitly a reincoded source...

do you have a clue? the last TUN rls u said the same thing, and you were wrong. dont post if you dont have anything to say about the quality. theres no need to slam a rls group. even if they do mess up, there still doing more than 99% of us.

video is cropped, not enough to complain about. its washed. dark and grainy. i dont think it is a TC, def not worth a 3cd dl. the ts wasnt good, and neither is this.

audio: theres a hiss, its def not DTS

movie: i dont want to see this :|

6.5/6.5/?

Posted by paleh0rse on 08-23-2004 06:53 PM:

bottom line: is this better than CTP's TS, yes or no?

__________________
-paleh0rse-

Posted by mooseman2070 on 08-23-2004 07:29 PM:

6/8/8

sidebars are annoying as fuck, good sound, movie was great

if you got the ctp ts, id keep it

__________________
I AM USING THE INTRANET!

All times are GMT. The time now is 05:40 PM.

Pages (3): [1] 2 3 »
Show all 47 posts from this thread on one page