VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- VCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=19)
-- Troy *PROPER* *READ NFO* *SVCD* - TELECINE - WESTSIDE (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=46033)

NUKED
REASON-reason invalid.proper.TUNs.rls.was.fine.on.standalones

Kinda late, plus i don't think TUN got nuked.

__________________
ProVoKaTioN

Nice, but useless in my opinion... should mos def be internal, because its very late and retail date is only two to three weeks away. I could not find a date for America strangely on www.amazon.com, but according to the german release date (17th of september) it should be also out here very soon.

Slightly better than TUN

8 (for TC) / 8 / 6

Ok for starters if they knew any rules what so ever, you cant proper on quality so this was nuked before it was even released. Only checked the sample *curious*, was that brad pitt or someone else. Couldnt see this was so frigin dark.

Picture , extremly dark, tad overcropped , clear otherwise. Sound is pretty good.

Overall. Retail in 1 month 1/2. Avoid this release, save your time, bandwidth , hd space. Unneeded ....


6/8/7

__________________
All the excitement of a trip to hell with none of the negitive side affects!

has westside released anything but nukes? 6/7/x

There nfo was whiny baby crap. Boo Hoo. NEXT.

7/7/7

These Westside guys seem pretty lame. I saw the sample (sucked), and then read the info. Are these guys trying to pretend they are gang bangers? I live in L.A. and from what I can see, real gang members aren't spending their time releasing films to the internet for little or no profit.

That life is about getting paid. In addition, I suspect that though many of them never finish high school, they can at least write complete sentences or spell at a third grade level. I mean, what kind of computer nerd is a functioning illiterate?

It must be hard to be a 'gangsta' when you still live with your parents. Sad

The normal sample was dark, the bright sample looked good. I'll just wait for the DVD.

7/8/8

pointless rls. video is dark, and little over croped but other then that its good. audio is really nice. no reason for proper and as firefighter has said you can't proper for quality. anyway retail will be out soon so sample was enough of this rls.


7/9/8 TC rating

__________________
Straight out of karate Lessions, to register these hands as wepons!

YES! another shitty release group we prolly wont need... dont think this release was warrented as a screener or something better should be out very very soon... didnt think the vcd scene could get much lower than this, but i guess a mix of peer 2 peer and xdcc chans, has gotten a whole lot of jackasses to join up in atleast this past year (if not the past 2)

video : six audio: eight movie: five

__________________

The wise man does not play leap frog with unicorns...

i'll stick with my ts

7/7/9

The quality is OK on this, the thing i didn't like about this is i dont remember the aspect ratio being as wide as that, when i saw it at the theatre, maybe it was, but ive just never saw as wide a screen as that.

Looks a good release to me, but ive only saw the TS and screener of this.
7/8/8

i do find this to be an unneeded release, persay, but due to nukes... arent u supposed to be able to proper nukes? guess not, no need for proper is what i hear... altho the original got nuked, no proper on quality... how about theft of a source? ok fair enuff, but dont nuke on pixelated and blocky if u cant proper with the same excuse, thats lame.... with this rls, agian uneeded, but better a lil blurrier than tun, and darker as said... 7/9/6 not my movie anyway, but excuses excuses, on all ends, a rls is a rls, if is late its still a scr or ts or tc or wtf it is, rate it as what it is, critisize on what it should be, but that shouldnt effect the rating, good day...

For those of you who doesnt know already, Troy DVD is not coming out until january 2005. So retail is still a long way of.

I don't know what DVD's you buy. German Edition will be out in two and a half weeks, look at www.amazon.de for TROJA, 17th of September 2004 is the release date. so US edition can't be that far away. Otherwise someone will surely ac3dub the german dvd for you english guys ;-)

Region 2 is due out on Octoberf 25th 2004

I agree with the NUKE..I'm not a huge fan of TUN telecines, but this one was NICE on my 64inch..TUN doesn't always get a fair shake from the NUKERS out there but this one was justified...Thanx, but NO thanx...WESTSIDE....Keep on trying!!!

why is this nuked as not needed yet the other TC is nuked, the only one not nuked is the dvdr, so i think this WAS needed.

am i missing something?