VCDQuality Forums - Ladder 49 *NTSC* - DVDRIP

Show all 7 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- DVDR (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=24)
-- Ladder 49 *NTSC* - DVDRIP - Replica (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=55595)

Posted by coldconfessio on 02-20-2005 08:21 PM:

10/10/9 . i thought it was a great movie. havent seen it yet until now. but i did have a glitch dont know if thats part of release or burn.

Posted by porco556 on 02-20-2005 11:09 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by coldconfession1
10/10/9 . i thought it was a great movie. havent seen it yet. but i did have a glitch dont know if thats part of release or burn.

Glitch? Where did you see it?

I am personally happy with this release. Untouched video (at the cost of 2 mins of credits) is fine with me. Personally, I wish a re-authored menu would have been done instead of stipping credits. But c'est la vie.

Movie wise, it's nice to see a firefighter movie, it's been a LONG time since Backdraft

Jaqouin Phoenix, yay! Travolta, boo!

Great release. Anyone see a glitch? If so, where? I didn't catch one myself.

Posted by Carlitosbaby on 02-22-2005 08:57 PM:

I watched it fully and tested everything and no glitches whatsoever. I like the fact that replica thinks outside the box. How many people actually watch credits (NONE) unless its animated credits like some movies. Menu could have been redone but so many people complain when a group does that if I had to i'd done the same as they did and just killed last 2 minutes of credits for untocuhed picture.

10/10/8

Posted by TerminatR on 02-23-2005 07:48 PM:

Personally, I'm suprised that this release wasn't nuked. Sure no one watches the end credits, but its still part of the movie.

I'm not saying I wouldnt have done the same thing personally, but there were other options available to cut the size (reauthor the menu)

A precedent will be set here. If this release doesnt get nuked, it will be a signal to other groups and the scene in general that this is acceptable protocol.

P.S. I'm not dissing Replica, just making sure that scene standards are observed. It's probably in vein anyway, given the other releases by various groups with blatent disregard for upholding these standards....

Anyhow {flame retardant suit on}...

quote:
I like the fact that replica thinks outside the box.

Posted by porco556 on 02-24-2005 04:44 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by TerminatR
Personally, I'm suprised that this release wasn't nuked. Sure no one watches the end credits, but its still part of the movie.

I'm not saying I wouldnt have done the same thing personally, but there were other options available to cut the size (reauthor the menu)

A precedent will be set here. If this release doesnt get nuked, it will be a signal to other groups and the scene in general that this is acceptable protocol.

P.S. I'm not dissing Replica, just making sure that scene standards are observed. It's probably in vein anyway, given the other releases by various groups with blatent disregard for upholding these standards....

Anyhow {flame retardant suit on}...

Personally I also agree that other options are possible, but at the same time, I find that the nukers are out on lunch lately or too busy nuking all the telesyncs (there are 16 nukes on the VCDQuality home page at this moment

).

Recently, I've kept maybe 3 of the past 10 DVD-R releases. I miss Corrupt (where'd they go?) and the other "video quality/movie only" groups. I can't believe also that ThP releases (except for Zelary which was a 1:1 DVD-5) wheren't called on their blantant lies (Motocycle Diaries claimed 5390kbit/sec on the 128min movie, but the actual bit rate was approximately 3550kbit/sec). I even remember people yelling nuke when the NFO just had the wrong movie title, but the DVD-R itself was just fine (Human Stain was the movie I believe).

So, I guess the nukers are out smoking up somewhere as I too am surprised a "nuke whistle" wasn't blown on this release, but at the same time, I'm personally really happy with untouched video.

Closing comment though, every release that was "nuked", I still managed to get almost as easily as a non-nuked release (unless it's a re-pack). Nobody really likes or listens to the sheep nukers anyways.

Posted by MiSSiONDVD on 02-26-2005 03:50 PM:

really enjoyed this film,,i dont mind the end of the credit being cut.dont really watch them anyway.I dont remeber seeing any glitch?anyway thanks Replica

Posted by jlrm365 on 03-22-2005 09:27 PM:

Nonsense!

"it will be a signal to other groups and the scene in general that this is acceptable protocol"

Nonsense!

The average person doesn't watch credits or doesn't watch most of them.

As long as the picture is good and the movie itself is whole, then the release is good.

When last I checked, the credits were not included as part of the script!

Credits are not scenes and it will send no such signal!

All times are GMT. The time now is 09:12 PM.

Show all 7 posts from this thread on one page