VCDQuality Forums - The Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy *PROPER* *XviD*

Show all 14 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- DIVX (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=23)
-- The Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy *PROPER* *XviD* - DVDRIP - (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=65992)

Posted by X69 on 09-02-2005 08:30 PM:

IMPORTANT, PLEASE READ

1 NO REQUESTING MOVIES OR SAMPLES (THIS INCLUDES REQUESTS FOR OTHER GROUPS TO RELEASE THIS FILM!)

2 DO NOT DISCUSS WHERE TO DOWNLOAD MOVIES OR SAMPLES

3 NO FLAMING

4 NO "SPOILERS"

5 COMMENT ON THIS RELEASE ONLY (AND ONLY IF YOU'VE SEEN IT). THIS IS THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE THREAD!

6 NO "NOOB" QUESTIONS SUCH AS "HOW DO I WATCH THIS?" ASK IN THE APPROPRIATE PART OF THE FORUM

7 NO DISCUSSING TRADING/SELLING. IF YOU SELL COPIES, GO AWAY YOU'RE NOT WELCOME HERE

*** PEOPLE IGNORING THE RULES WILL BE BANNED ***

Posted by chiv on 09-02-2005 08:31 PM:

nice release, glad it was propered with the ac3 audio... synched up nicely, video was great, gotta admit im surprised given the amount of crap being released by groups lately. good one.

Posted by mos_def_au on 09-03-2005 03:46 AM:

Nice RLS.

8/8/9.5

__________________
Cheers!

Posted by playon1 on 09-03-2005 04:00 AM:

almost got the last one good stuff on the proper

Posted by Mongoloid on 09-03-2005 04:11 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by chiv
nice release, glad it was propered with the ac3 audio... synched up nicely, video was great, gotta admit im surprised given the amount of crap being released by groups lately. good one.

a) it's no valid proper
b) that u personally like the ac3 sound and it being 2disc doesnt make it a valid proper
c) it's reencoded from a, yet untouched, still stolen source... it's still regarded pretty much lame to do that
d) synched up nicely ? its a freaking retail rip... groups who fuck up synching sound on retails shouldnt be shown the light of day anyway. period.
e) no e).. i'm out.. instead of getting pissed off at ignorance, i'll be the bigger man and only whine just today.. good day.

Posted by chiv on 09-03-2005 08:01 AM:

i never said it was a legit - i even concidered stating that it isn't a legit proper - but decided against it because its irrelivant.

i simply stated i was glad that it was 'propered'...

as for your other statements:

a: covered above
b: again, i never said it was a legit proper.
c: again, its irrelivant, because im discussing the quality of the rip
d: not all retail rips are synched well, especially given how many new noob groups their are now
e: nice of you to drop in, talk some absolute bullsh*t, not even comment on the quality of the rip, then run off like a little girl so you dont have to face a response.

perhaps stop being such a loser and rate the quality next time, rather than whining about how its not a legitimate proper.

Posted by thepacifist on 09-03-2005 01:33 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Mongoloid
a) it's no valid proper
b) that u personally like the ac3 sound and it being 2disc doesnt make it a valid proper
c) it's reencoded from a, yet untouched, still stolen source... it's still regarded pretty much lame to do that
d) synched up nicely ? its a freaking retail rip... groups who fuck up synching sound on retails shouldnt be shown the light of day anyway. period.
e) no e).. i'm out.. instead of getting pissed off at ignorance, i'll be the bigger man and only whine just today.. good day.

yet another noob speaks named chiv

This source is stolen, re-encoded and should be nuked for invalid proper.

Now i agree with mong because hes right

IF YOU CANT SYNC A RETAIL DVDRIP UR A FUCKING MORON, plain and simple. Now people who really arent involved in what we do should really but out and stfu, its getting quite annoying

Posted by mattmatt02 on 09-03-2005 01:40 PM:

i will prob download this version over the 1cd copy coz i convert all xvids to dvd anyway (connection = too slow for dvdr - 30hrs dl time!)

v 10 - perfect quality

a 10 - well its 5.1 so how can it be less than a 10?

m 5 - i watched 40 min then turned it off, im just gettin this to replace centropy's copy, just fot the hell of it!

nice rip overall

Posted by chiv on 09-03-2005 08:34 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by thepacifist
This source is stolen, re-encoded and should be nuked for invalid proper.

.... there really should be an age restriction on this forum or something...

anyway,l you go ahead and whine all you want about your precious rules - id rather have decent quality, over some shitty single cd rip with mp3 audio.

and for the other tosser to be right, he'd have to actually have to have contradicted something id said... which he hadn't. ill try using smaller words, because you didn't seem to get it last time i said it. i said i was GLAD that it was 'propered', NOT that it was a legitimte proper, yank.

i never said jack shit about the source, so its got nothing to do with anything, and i dont think anyone gives a shit about it either.

try to stick to commenting on quality next time, if you can...

Posted by Mongoloid on 09-04-2005 05:06 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by chiv
.... there really should be an age restriction on this forum or something...

anyway,l you go ahead and whine all you want about your precious rules - id rather have decent quality, over some shitty single cd rip with mp3 audio.

and for the other tosser to be right, he'd have to actually have to have contradicted something id said... which he hadn't.

1) This tosser didn't thought it was necessary to call people, with a different point of view, names. Makes u kinda think about your remark about age-restriction doesnt it ?
2) This tosser was plain and 100% right. No matter if u like the 2cd rip and all.. this site wouldnt exist if there wasnt a scene.. so discussing nukes according to scene-rules is pretty much valid. Stating that u dont give a fuck about rules... well.. that kinda directly states the level of involvement of yourself and most of all the extreme level of ignorance u portray at the same time.
3) If there weren't rules, there wouldn't be scene (how much that's left of it nowadays.. its still a scene), thus u wouldn't be able to leech it. Weird huh ?
4) Stick to p2p networks coz that's where u belong. Nothing wrong with that.. but dont try to act like you're something you are clearly not.
5) Besides being a fucking noob, you are also an extreme prick. Oops.. i just went against what I said under 1).. sorry for that.

quote:
ill try using smaller words, because you didn't seem to get it last time i said it. i said i was GLAD that it was 'propered', NOT that it was a legitimte proper, yank.

i never said jack shit about the source, so its got nothing to do with anything, and i dont think anyone gives a shit about it either.

try to stick to commenting on quality next time, if you can...

I'll try to say it in smaller words too since u seem to prefer those :

Makey the rip from stolen sourcey, isse part of being quality. Ify you dont carey.. go p2py.. shut upy.. and dont carey abouty giving teh pointsy.

Posted by JonBlaze87 on 09-04-2005 05:14 PM:

why does this only have a 6 for video.
The video quality is awsome. It's a 10 by far. Audio is deadly too. Movie was weird but funny and entertaining.

10
10
7

edit - I've said it be4. ppl on this site bitch about stupid shit. The qulaity on both rips are good. Just because one release is nuked wont stop thousands of ppl downloading both versions. WHO FUCKING CARES!!!!! ENJOY THE QUALITY and dont get ur panties in a bunch. Oh ya and if a source is stolen, why does that matter? THE MOVIE IS"NT THEIR PROPERTY IN THE FIRST FUCKING PLACE. god damn pirates eat where they shit....

Posted by D-503 on 09-06-2005 04:43 PM:

This is an awesome movie. I've watched it a few times. 9/9/9.

::EDIT:: 99% of post removed... You typed all that for fuck all fella, read the rules! - Neversoft::

Posted by brandedbt on 09-09-2005 01:54 PM:

This is not a retail rip.
Its just a very good quality rip from another source.
The picture looks too cropped above and below and just because the sound is quite clear, its not perfect. I can tell the sound has been hooked in with leads and recorded on the fly.
However, its the closest thing to the upcoming retail release.
I cant believe I am the only one who can see this. I guess I have an eye for detail.

Video = 8.5 (Remember, 10 is as perfect as you can get for an DivX/XviD conversion)
Audio = 8.5 (An untouched AC3 stream should be considered perfect, this has been recorded in real-time from a digital source, through cables/sound card etc.)
Movie = Haven't seen it yet (lol, my expectations are high, but I couldn't wait to post my thoughts on the quality, because again, nobody seems to pick up that its not a proper DVD rip)

Otherwise, while I'm very fussy about video/audio quality rips for my collection, this will pass as a keeper!
Thanks to the releasers for this beauty I've been waiting so long for!

Posted by mattmatt02 on 09-09-2005 07:01 PM:

it IS a retail rip, honestly some n00bs just dont know shit! theres something about that autogk proggy they use, it crops a minor amount of the picture to make bitrate higher or something. it is a retail rip. its not a dvdscr as it has no markings, its not an unmastered retail or scr as it has no ciggy burns, it cant be a tc or lower because its too high of a quality. and dts discs havent been cracked yet so where did they obtain the 5.1?

simple answer - IT IS A RETAIL DVD RIP!!!

some people just have to learn these things i guess...

sorry to snap at you like im your mom or something, but i see posts like this so often and nobody seems to learn...

All times are GMT. The time now is 03:22 PM.

Show all 14 posts from this thread on one page