VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- DVDR (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=24)
-- Star Wars EP3-Revenge Of The Sith *NTSC* - DVDRIP - XPDVD (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=66801)

IMPORTANT, PLEASE READ

1 NO REQUESTING MOVIES OR SAMPLES (THIS INCLUDES REQUESTS FOR OTHER GROUPS TO RELEASE THIS MOVIE!)

2 DO NOT DISCUSS WHERE TO DOWNLOAD MOVIES OR SAMPLES

3 NO FLAMING

4 NO "SPOILERS"

5 NO SCENE-RELATED DISCUSSION/RUMORS (ESPECIALLY REGARDING BUSTS)

6 COMMENT ON THIS RELEASE ONLY (AND ONLY IF YOU'VE SEEN AT LEAST THE SAMPLE). THIS IS THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE THREAD!

7 NO "NOOB" QUESTIONS SUCH AS "HOW DO I WATCH THIS?" ASK IN THE APPROPRIATE PART OF THE FORUM

8 NO DISCUSSING TRADING/SELLING. IF YOU SELL COPIES, GO AWAY YOU'RE NOT WELCOME HERE


*** PEOPLE IGNORING THE RULES WILL BE BANNED ***

After veiwing a few of the rars and also the sample this is a pretty much excellent release great job!!!!!!

video 9
audio 10
film 9 was good and enjoyable

Also for those of you who use vlc view the rar 2 file from this release really funny watching Yoda getting jiggy with it lol!!!!!!!

__________________
G.

Video - 8
audio - 9
movie - 2

Release is fine, movie was as lame as Ep 1 &2...

Nice enough Video though not perfect, excellent sound and i suppose the DC is a nice enough addition, but could of done without it.

I will be buying it anyway.

8/9/9

Movie was excellent, far better than Eps1 and 2, and Return Of The Jedi.

very nice thankyou allround 9's

good fast release. video could be better it drops down to 1.4 mbps in some scenes :S but its free so im not complaining. once again good release i am pleased

when its burnt how do i get to the dancing yoda

Best movie of 2005 and best Star Wars episode.
Great release and the judgement for the many earlier Telecine jokers!!

Excellent sound and video

NFO says no extras on Disc 1, any chance of releasing Disc 2 as well?

A=9
V=9
M=9

Excellent job converting this one, looked very good on my 32inch TV

Video 9 Looks good considerating length of movie
Audio 9.5 ( Only DTS gets a 10 )
Movie 9 Great Film

Excellent sound and video



9/9/7 (not a big fan)

__________________

Wow, you can really tell the difference between the TC and the DVD... MUCH crisper and more detail visible in the picture...

V: 9 - MUCH better than TC! Much more crisp and clean lookin'.
A: 9 - Certainly not DTS, but it's good...
M: 8 - One of the better Star Wars flicks...

Hopefully disc 2 is out soon...

Props for the early release though it is a shame they didn't strip 2 of the 3 menus as well as the warnings they would have had an extra 483MB to play with.

Gonna buy the boxset so this will do until then.

V=7 - More passes wouldn't have hurt.
A=9
M=9

quote:

---

Originally posted by GRAVESTORM
Also for those of you who use vlc view the rar 2 file from this release really funny watching Yoda getting jiggy with it lol!!!!!!!

---

__________________
www.dvdrfixes.com

I agree with DeVit...also would have liked DC ripped...

just a personal preference...i prefer VQ over extra's.

Still good quality. Source video must be very good.

__________________
Want to fight about it?

This rip is very very good - well worth getting. Will tide me over until the retail comes out.

Holy shit... I watched 30 mins and then turned it off... Video quality on a larger TV is crap and I'm shocked that people are all over the 9/10 wagon.

3.6gigs for the movie which has 3 sets of credits and opening (in 3 angles which contain 3 different languages), not to mention the DC and the fact that the movie is 140 mins..

The menu is a whopping 600megs also.

I would have done a few things different, but IMO the only thing that would REALLY impact this would be the rip of the menu and DC. That's upwards of 900MB (600 menu + 200 DC + 90 other), which would equal to around 25% better video quality (if it was ripped). Which would be much appreciated.

However, the scene won't let the 550MB play button be erased (rules are rules), so it looks like this is almost as good as it will get.

Video 7/10 - Wow.... It's bad IMO, but on a 27" CRT or on the computer, you'll be in heaven. Huge action sequences hitting 4.2kbit/sec, then going as low as 1.7 in dramatic sequences. But IT is a long movie, and long (action) movies need the bandwidth. Doesn't help that this is a digital transfer also, makes it hard to hide imperfections in the grain/etc...

DVD-R 9/10 - Other than the DC, which personally I don't care to hear Lucas blabber, can't do much to improve this. The menu is the real hurt here, and that has to stay by scene rules. But equally, don't scene rules say you can't brand your releases in the title (which of course is easy to fix in DVD Decrypter prior to burning).

This is definitely a "hold you over" release till the real thing comes out. Personally, I am anticipating other movies and not in any big rush to see this one. Also, if you don't care for this movie much, this release is MORE than enough.

It's funny reading people with huge TV's complaining about a free DVD-R.

If you have the home theatre, you have the money for retail.

9/9/10

I like the DC being on there. On my 27 inch TV, the video looks great.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Beelzebud
It's funny reading people with huge TV's complaining about a free DVD-R.

If you have the home theatre, you have the money for retail.

9/9/10

I like the DC being on there. On my 27 inch TV, the video looks great.

---

Strange, With Subs OFF i get a few things still pop up
at the top of the screen, whats that all about.

Apart from that, nice release.
I got a 42inch plasma and it looks OK but could be better.
then only way to get better would be to go get the one from the shops when its out.

__________________
*Meet the rest of the VCDQ Crew, HERE *

quote:

---

Originally posted by Beelzebud
It's funny reading people with huge TV's complaining about a free DVD-R.

If you have the home theatre, you have the money for retail.

9/9/10

I like the DC being on there. On my 27 inch TV, the video looks great.

---