VCDQuality Forums - Cars - DVDRIP

Pages (2): [1] 2 »
Show all 33 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- DVDR (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=24)
-- Cars - DVDRIP - Replica (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=72739)

Posted by X69 on 10-20-2006 06:29 PM:

IMPORTANT, PLEASE READ

1 NO REQUESTING MOVIES OR SAMPLES (THIS INCLUDES REQUESTS FOR OTHER GROUPS TO RELEASE THIS MOVIE!)

2 DO NOT DISCUSS WHERE TO DOWNLOAD MOVIES OR SAMPLES

3 DO NOT ASK FOR "RAR PASSWORDS" COS WE DON'T KNOW THEM. CHECK WITH YOUR SOURCE

4 NO FLAMING

5 NO "SPOILERS"

6 NO SCENE-RELATED DISCUSSION/RUMORS (ESPECIALLY REGARDING BUSTS)

7 COMMENT ON THIS RELEASE ONLY (AND ONLY IF YOU'VE SEEN AT LEAST THE SAMPLE). THIS IS THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE THREAD!

8 NO "NOOB" QUESTIONS SUCH AS "HOW DO I WATCH THIS?" ASK IN THE APPROPRIATE PART OF THE FORUM

9 NO DISCUSSING TRADING/SELLING. IF YOU SELL COPIES, GO AWAY YOU'RE NOT WELCOME HERE

* Newbie questions? Want some weird term clarifying? Read our FAQ

* General questions unrelated to this release? Internet LOL's? Right here dudes

*** PEOPLE IGNORING THE RULES WILL BE BANNED ***

Posted by porco556 on 10-20-2006 06:33 PM:

Dammit... They cut out the short. I missed the short in theaters and hoped I'd catch it here Kept stupid deleted scenes instead. I guess I am a firm believer of "they were cut for a reason".

Good release overall. Going to get the full DVD later anyways. Similar caliber of Over the Hedge for video. 9/10 video I guess, didn't see anything too wrong with it, but I didn't really look too hard for problems, but nothing jumped out.

Untouched would look better though (duh!), especially on movies like this... But we'll just have to wait for that when it comes out most likely.

Posted by chaotic646 on 10-20-2006 07:10 PM:

The short wasn't as good as some. Just two "one-man bands" competing for a tip from a little girl.

Anyways judging by the sample the video is pretty good but I bet it could have been better if they would have removed the deleted scenes. I havent finished downloading the release yet but knowing Replica I would be willing to bet they didnt remove the unused buttons.

Video - 8
Audio - ?
Movie - My opinion 4
My Kids' opinion 8

Posted by ukiron on 10-20-2006 07:50 PM:

the short was lame and is not missed. just started to watch on standalone and have had no problems at all. looks aok to me.
v10
a10
m8

Posted by Enzomatrx on 10-20-2006 07:56 PM:

If you want the short, get the maVen TS, which has it included just fine.

As a DVDR, this is a good one. Up to the norm with Replica.

Only viewed sample, so can't comment on if a PPF will be needed for this.

Posted by MrF'nMovie on 10-20-2006 11:33 PM:

Decent enough release but this one really needs a DVD9 as there is obvious compression noise . They should have left out the deleted scenes , menu and the THX calibration patterns so improve bitrate . Will grab the retail on Nov. 7th .

Vidie = 8
Audio = 10 (DD EX)
Movie = 8

__________________
BMOC

Posted by Dirty on 10-20-2006 11:48 PM:

quote:
I would be willing to bet they didnt remove the unused buttons.

unused buttons were removed.

anyway, this plays flawlessly on my dvd player. video and audio quality could have been better though. good enough rip.

8/8/X (will see later tonight)

Posted by SgtBigNuts on 10-21-2006 12:00 AM:

Hey , its free and is quite a good movie for the kiddies, and me lol. The short was pretty naff anyway.

Posted by punchinello on 10-21-2006 12:05 AM:

I think the release is pritty good.

video: 9
audio: 9
movie: 7

Its more one for the younger ones.

__________________
If you're not down with that
then I got two words for ya.
SUCK IT!

Posted by Triffid on 10-21-2006 12:24 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by chaotic646 knowing Replica I would be willing to bet they didnt remove the unused buttons

Knowing Replica????? I have viewed at least 20 Replica releases. The unused buttoms have always been removed.

To the point: This is another fine piece of work from Replica. Quality is plenty good.

v = 9
a = 9
m = 7

Posted by STB on 10-21-2006 03:17 AM:

Usual quality from Replica....nice release guys.

V - 9
A - 9
M - 9

Posted by iLLmATiK on 10-21-2006 08:19 AM:

Replica does it again...

v-10
a-10
m-9

great release thats why the best i get there shit right away other groups i hesitate on cause i know theres going to be a patch or something for it or propers.. but replica always good..

Posted by chaotic646 on 10-21-2006 03:44 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Triffid
Knowing Replica????? I have viewed at least 20 Replica releases. The unused buttoms have always been removed.

To the point: This is another fine piece of work from Replica. Quality is plenty good.

v = 9
a = 9
m = 7

Wrong, Replica has left unused buttons many times. In fact their last release "Over The Hedge" had several unused buttons left. There have been plenty more but I'm too lazy to argue about it and look them all up. Don't get me wrong, Replica is a trustworthy group as far as the dvd's being authored properly, they just get lazy sometimes with unused buttons and they seem to be infatuated with deleted scenes even though removing them would mean better quality.

Posted by Redemption198 on 10-21-2006 04:51 PM:

Very Decent rip, although Video quality could be better, but i dont think thats Replica's fault, some Pixar DVD's havent looked as good as you would of liked, with the exception of Monsters Inc, which is stunning looking.

Audio is a great 5.1 EX track, which as usual by Pixar sounds great.

Not keen on Pixar deleted scenes as, well they arent that pretty to look at. so that always puts me off watching them, but have to disagree on removing them making a difference to the video quality, the deleted scenes are only 119mb in size, meaning they only have a video bitrate of about 13-1400k, so by removing the deleted scenes, the movie would of had an extra 140k of bitrate, no-one, no matter how fussy or how big their TV is gonna see the difference.

Only quibble i have is, they also left the THX Optimiser and the 43mb sample file, which prob wasnt needed, and the advanced button on the THX Optimiser doesnt go anywhere, and crashes one of my DVD Players, but apart from that, this is as good as your gonna get on a DVD5.

9/10/7

Posted by Bird of Prey on 10-22-2006 02:45 AM:

just finished watching sound and video is fine it would be perfect if they had not have to chop out some of the extra features of the dvd,but you do not look a gift horse in the mouth.5 weeks before uk retail..sweet enough for me..

v.9
a9
m. 9.5

Posted by cw_uk on 10-22-2006 08:03 AM:

Nice release as usual from Replica.

Only minor problems like the forementioned THX Optimiser and layer breaks left in which i found strange since it was encoded video.

V= 8
A= 9
M= 7

__________________
cw_uk

Posted by Triffid on 10-22-2006 04:12 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by chaotic646
Wrong, Replica has left unused buttons many times. In fact their last release "Over The Hedge" had several unused buttons left. There have been plenty more but I'm too lazy to argue about it and look them all up. Don't get me wrong, Replica is a trustworthy group as far as the dvd's being authored properly, they just get lazy sometimes with unused buttons and they seem to be infatuated with deleted scenes even though removing them would mean better quality.

Wrong? I said, "I have viewed at least 20 Replica releases. The unused buttoms have always been removed." Can you tell me what is wrong in this statement? Sadly, reading is a lost art.

I took a closer look at this release in DVD ReMake. It's nice to see all the warning/rating/studio screens removed, but it would be even better if the dvd player can go straight to the menu instead of seeking thru multiple blanked pgc's. The same goes for when selecting the play button. Also, as someone else commented, the layer break was not removed. There's over 100Mb that could have been trimmed by removing the 43Mb clip and blanking the unused menu pgc's, although perhaps scene rules don't allow for editing menu pgc's.
Still, I take this release with gratitude. It took a small effort to tailor this release to my preferences.

Posted by Girlsare3vil on 10-22-2006 10:40 PM:

hmm

Well noone seems to have a problem playing this in a standalone except for me? It will load the disk and displays the title, but when you hit play it reads error no disk. wtf?

Posted by Girlsare3vil on 10-22-2006 10:44 PM:

hmm is noone having any trouble playing this in a stand alone?It will load the disk and read the title but the second you hit play it goes to error no disk?

Posted by B1NG0 on 10-23-2006 12:56 PM:

I see this has turned into the usual 'brawl' about who said what etc, lol

My thoughts on the menu size are always the same, so Im always supprised when the groups release stuff with 200mb+ size menus. (218mb on this release)
The menu could've been shrunk (using menuShrink & keeping the audio AND the main transistional screens) to save at least 200mb - which would've left room for the animated short.

This reminds me of the Madagascar rip where the Penguin animation short was removed - pointless.

Lets face it, do we really need large menus when we are trying to achieve the highest bitrate possible?.
Its ok if the video is untouched, obviously, but not if it means sacrificing picture quality & the desired extras.

All in all, a decent rip/release, but we all know it could've been better!

V 8
A 9
M 8
Rip 7

All times are GMT. The time now is 03:14 PM.

Pages (2): [1] 2 »
Show all 33 posts from this thread on one page