Puma
Nov 2004
Junior Member
|
quote:
Originally posted by Fire_Sokar
go read your rules before posting anywhere. if your that stupid to ask why its a dupe go fuck yourself and read up on some scene standards.
SAOSIN release was fine. it was sheep nuked. Corba - They didnt label proper. so its a dupe. if they attempted to proper, they would of been a laughing stock. Proper thats shit = not smart. This group shoulda just kept the shit to themselves. as you should your comments.
okay.... first thing first.... there is no stupid question.... this is not a scene forum, otherwise one would have to prove thier axx (above that, the site would have to be much more secure than it is now) to be able to apply for membership..... maybe the bloke doesn't have axx to the scene rules and was just askin a question, therefore it shoulda been answered with "well Delgarth scene rules state that a subbed release dupes (and therefore is reason for a nuke) an unsubbed release, the reason for that is 99% of the world would rather an unsubbed rls over a subbed rls (just like most would rather a nice svcd ts over a vcd ts, and vcd ts' dupe svcd ts')....
don't get me wrong on some of your points either Fire_Sokar, personally, i don't think SAOSiN's rls was sheep nuked, it was quite cropped... however, you are quite correct in the sense that Cobra didn't lable their rls proper (which makes all the difference in the scene)... if they had labeled proper they would have made fools of themselves (from time to time everyone makes mistakes... I don't see how 16:9 can be mistaken for 4:3, but it happens)... they really should have labeled it .internal. imo.... that would have kept the people that wanted to get thes subd rls happy, and kept thes scene happy...... but, its all in words these days.... as for you telling someone else they should keep their comments to themselves... well, shite, imo your one to talk..... do you not even have a rating on the release????
from sample (aside from the 16:9 which is one of reasons for nuke
Video is getting better, a little grainy... not as much of angle as SAOSiN's (imo). and audio is spot on.... movie is a pile of junk that shouldn't be looked twice at
8/9/4
__________________
nothing dulls glitter like vomit
Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged
|
02-20-2005 12:50 AM
DUPE...you guys on DOPE!!
