Definitely not a re-encode totally difference source and the best copy out clear and picture is actually nice just dark..overall lovely release SG18 you guys are getting better.
8/9/?
__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...
An excellent ts, good job sg18, the watermark at the beginning are kind of annoying, but easy enough to get rid of. The quality is great, best release yet, at times slightly washed out, and dark, but you get what you pay for.
very good copy video is good audio is good (goes slightly out of sync for me on cd2 but probably my media/copy) definately NOT a recode of the other versions pots is crap compared to this their picture is cropped and a lot less quality but their effort is appreciated
7/9/7 kids thought it was ok
Last edited by scousethief on 12-21-2004 at 07:48 PM
This is the same source as VCD's release with Pot's audio, they cut out part of the opening titles to put their little intro clip in, you can hear the "pop" where they replaced the adudio right at the moment that Pot's release starts.
I wouldn't say it was a re-encode of VCD's but it is the same silver source and perhaps encoded it striaght to SVCD...unfortunately the source doesn't justify it to be SVCD resolution, it came out very soft and and the colors are a little washed out. The softness of it tends to make me think that they may have re-encoded VCD's and just added a temporal smoothe filter.
I took VCD's release and added Pot's audio to it and it is much sharper and better color than this release.
i couldnt see any out of sync probs all way through the movie. this isnt much better than pots release. stick to that if youve already got it.
__________________
Lets praise all the groups out there who make this scene for what it's worth because if we didn't then we'd all be spending a fortune at the pics.Remember to practice SAFE SEX (as illistrated in the pic).
Hey "brut7" the rules say no spoilers u selfish prick, some people aint seen the film yet and just want to know a rating as thats what this site is about, that goes to all the other losers with opinions about the film, just rate it ffs.
Video and comment
Audio and comment
Movie and NO COMMENT as thats a spoiler.
Nothing worse than some wanker who's seen it wanting to
spoil it for others.
Sorry but I came to look on whats best one to see and some losers gone put crap assuming everyone who reads it will have
seen it, well give that guy dumbo of the year prize somebody!
[EDIT:: Seems a bit harsh it was a very small spoiler - Neversoft]
Last edited by Neversoft on 12-22-2004 at 09:10 AM
now this is getting annoying
1 this release has a better picture better audio and all the subtitile
2 pots release is cropped doesnt have all the subtitles and in my opinion a worse picture
think some of you need to check your release names cos mines very good and has none of the problems apart from being slightly out of sync on cd2 for about 5 minutes ( downloaded cd2 3 times from different sources 1xftp and 2x irc also asked friend to download and he got same sync issue)
quote:Originally posted by Tadge Cant see much wrong with this rls - cant see any probs with sync at all. Video is pretty good stuff and sound equally. Only comment i would make is that there is a little too much brightness in the faces. But nothing to complain about - best release of this movie so far in my opinion. I know sg18 take a hammering for their sources but as long as credit is given where credit is due in nfo and they can improve on previous attempts, the more groups the better is what i say. worth the downloading and very watchable
VIDEO 8 / 8 / 6
Well done sg18 much better than previous attempts
Nuked for being stolen source, not yet confirmed. Another nuke for SG18, would NOT suprise me in the least however. Try doing something orginal for a change. LMFAO!!
This version is nice and I liked it, until I saw the VCD version, I did make this one into a DVD. The brightness isn't a problem when compared to darker versions of any movie. When compared it is cleaner then all previous versions.
12-21-2004 08:23 AM
it was a very small spoiler - Neversoft]
