Mag i agree with you, even though i am prone to the odd outburst myself.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, and that should be respected, but i think there should be no numbers, because its too easy for members of a group to go on and say 9/9/9 for their shitty TS, or a rival group memeber to give a perfect DVD rip a 5/5/5.

If you give a rating of 9/5/6, tell us why its a 5, it'll more easily point out the bull shiters and ass kissers.

Im not against CharlyTuna or his ratings, even though he's been way off on a few occasions, its his attitude i dont like.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

quote:

---

Originally posted by Redemption
Mag i agree with you, even though i am prone to the odd outburst myself.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, and that should be respected, but i think there should be no numbers, because its too easy for members of a group to go on and say 9/9/9 for their shitty TS, or a rival group memeber to give a perfect DVD rip a 5/5/5.

If you give a rating of 9/5/6, tell us why its a 5, it'll more easily point out the bull shiters and ass kissers.

Im not against CharlyTuna or his ratings, even though he's been way off on a few occasions, its his attitude i dont like.

---

how would you know im way off? did god appoint you the earths new rating judge? do you got a college diploma on rating?

as much as you think im off, i think as much you are off


p.s. look at the whole ENTIRE 1ST page of vcdquality, out of the past 40-50 releases, this is the highest rated , 8.8 in video, i gave it a 9

way offf you say? bah

Last edited by on 09-26-2002 at 05:18 AM

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Kill The RATTT!!!!

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Its the newest thing on here, it always starts high, it will drop down over the next few days, and most of those ratings are jpg based.

And i never said you were off on this release, i said you were off on a few, not all, like the Undisputed SVCD which you said was nuked for a bad bin 3:12 seconds overburn isnt worth a nuke, and saying the TC of Minority Report was better than the SVCD screener, when the TC was worse than the WP, 4/4/2 if i remember.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

quote:

---

Originally posted by CharlyTuna


randomly hehe.(i rate after i view)

dont you people relize, there are people who arnt as lame or new to the scene, you should be thanking me, without some of us being on top sites and spreading the shit everywhere, your KAZZA connection in getting stuff would be empty, and those lame home ftp's that you run on mIRC, so next time when you are downloading somehting, thank the people who fxp everywhere for the newbies, thank them in your mind, cuz if it wasnt for us, you would get dick. remember the release groups dont spread or share the releases, the fxp groups do.

thank you

p.s. i still see your shy of this release
it will hit kazza soon and mirc fservers, wait inline for thise files hehe

---

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

quote:

---

Originally posted by CharlyTuna


how would you know im way off? did god appoint you the earths new rating judge? do you got a college diploma on rating?

as much as you think im off, i think as much you are off


p.s. look at the whole ENTIRE 1ST page of vcdquality, out of the past 40-50 releases, this is the highest rated , 8.8 in video, i gave it a 9

way offf you say? bah

---

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

quote:

---

Originally posted by a1catraz


you callin everybody a n00b, but ur self.. again.. i ask.. whta is a rated topsite.. u seem to get everything way before hand, a few days maybe?? maybe you cud tell us the name of ur site, or maybe, what kind of a connection its on? cable? dsl?

---

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

quote:

---

Originally posted by Redemption
Its the newest thing on here, it always starts high, it will drop down over the next few days, and most of those ratings are jpg based.

And i never said you were off on this release, i said you were off on a few, not all, like the Undisputed SVCD which you said was nuked for a bad bin 3:12 seconds overburn isnt worth a nuke, and saying the TC of Minority Report was better than the SVCD screener, when the TC was worse than the WP, 4/4/2 if i remember.

---

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

CharlyTuna you really need to s.t.f.u
Get a fucken life, and stop dissing the noobs.
Everybody is a noob once, you think people just get added to topsites out of the blue?

You might be fucken l33t on the internet, but in real life you are nothing but a loner.
Stop taking your frustration out on newbies, dissing them won't help turn your shitty life around.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Someone here need memory skills then,

http://www.vcdquality.com/forum/sho...=&threadid=8732
(your link goes to the main page)

I know it is a DVD-Rip, it isnt exactly hard to tell, and it deserves a lot more than a 4 for pic/sound, and i find no post where you review this version anyway, the official SVCD post has no posts in it.

I never said i or you judged a TC against a SVCD, you said the TC was better than the SVHS screener, the TC is a bad TC, the SVHS screener is an average screener, and when you compare them side by side, scores dont matter, one is better than the other, and in my opinion its the SVHS easily, but you opinion differs.

A few days ago i wrote a post stating people should rate by format and not put all releases into one catergory, so how don't i know how to rate, when as far as i know im using the same system as you are.

Last edited by Redemption on 09-26-2002 at 10:32 AM

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

9/9/4

Better than any previous releases and definetly worth it. TCF You are the gods of the screener scene at this moment, take note all other groups that feel 20 propers of one film is the appropriate way to go.


Now if only they got better films, not XXX though as that's the biggest pile of crap I've ever seen.

Is it just me or does Vin Diesel look like that guy from Right Said Fred, my mate reckons they're the same person.



PS. Charley you really shouldn't post quite so much it makes you look sad.

__________________
You're only in as much trouble as you think you are.

Last edited by desertboy on 09-26-2002 at 11:05 AM

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

damn man ,there are just 2 many n00bs here, just 2 damn many.

look at the 3 posts above me lol

1 saying he cant find undisputed on the 1st page, and how his words are wrong about the bad bin.

1 saying i shouldnt post so much that i look sad, yet he posted the same rating as me,lmfao.

1 saying im so 1337, yet he thinks my real life is shit without even knowing me, hehehe ,love that jealousy..

whats wrong with you people?

remember ,i only post my opinion, and as the mods can see, im not the one throing flames, everyone is flaming me cause i speak the truth.. relax

please when you are upto PAR in the scene, then come speak to me, please, we still love you n00bs

Last edited by on 09-26-2002 at 12:18 PM

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

quote:

---

Originally posted by Redemption
Someone here need memory skills then,

http://www.vcdquality.com/forum/sho...=&threadid=8732
(your link goes to the main page)

I know it is a DVD-Rip, it isnt exactly hard to tell, and it deserves a lot more than a 4 for pic/sound, and i find no post where you review this version anyway, the official SVCD post has no posts in it.

I never said i or you judged a TC against a SVCD, you said the TC was better than the SVHS screener, the TC is a bad TC, the SVHS screener is an average screener, and when you compare them side by side, scores dont matter, one is better than the other, and in my opinion its the SVHS easily, but you opinion differs.

A few days ago i wrote a post stating people should rate by format and not put all releases into one catergory, so how don't i know how to rate, when as far as i know im using the same system as you are.

---

__________________
RoLL That Shit
Smoke That Shit
Pass That Shit

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

man c'mon why u flame CharleyTuna again ?
this time even without reason , he just gave his opinion ,
9/10/1 and u flame becuz of the 1 . i mean , this movie really sux.
me would give a 1-2 too.

__________________
no idea

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Stop bitching at Charley, stop bitching amongst each other, stop bitching about whose the best group, stop voting 10/10/10 or 1/1/1 all the fucking time as that's the lamest thing people do on this site. Stop reviewing movies you haven't even seen, stop using jpeg to judge a film.


All I care about is how good these releases are and while at first it was amusing to read some of these posts it's starting to wear thin.

Remember VCDQuality<>One of my younger sisters slumber parties

Take it elsewhere Ladies



PS I didn't actually rate the film the same as you Charley, you are always saying people should read your posts maybe you should extend others the same curtesy. I believe you gave it 9/10/1 similar but not the same.

PPS Charley and a few others are actually the only other people I see on here who actually post ratings about films so before you post here watch the film and post a score not a grudge.

__________________
You're only in as much trouble as you think you are.

Last edited by desertboy on 09-26-2002 at 04:39 PM

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

quote:

---

Your must be kidding me right? U SOLD A FEW COPIES! WTF R U SOME FUCKING STUPID ASS COCKLICKER? U DOWNLOAD THE FUCKING SHIT FOR FREE OFF UR LIL FSERVERS AND SELL THEM! YOU KNOW ITS PEOPLE LIKE YOU THAT SHOULD DIE CAUSE YOUR JUST A WASTE OF BREATH YOU MOTHERFUCKING Ball lickeR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I mean what kid in there right mind sells this shit? Its free and you sell it? OMG gimmie a break you should kill yourself cause your just fillin the world with unwanted carbon dioxide, so stfu kthx cuz ur lamer ass shouldnt be on this board.

---

LOL havn't had a laugh like that in ages, whats with all the gay stuff, you a fag or something.

People ask me a film, do u expect me to give them it for free, sorry not me, and since they are friends, im not gonna say no and i dont really charge them much anyway, its not like i make a business of it, wouldn't take the risk ive a family to support.

Wake up Rappa, there are markets that sell this stuff, and they make a shit load of money out of it.

What kid sells them hang on a minute not everyone on here is 16, and by your comments you dont sound very grown up, and are probably nearer my Daughters in laws age then mine.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

quote:

---

Originally posted by [RaZoR]
man c'mon why u flame CharleyTuna again ?
this time even without reason , he just gave his opinion ,
9/10/1 and u flame becuz of the 1 . i mean , this movie really sux.
me would give a 1-2 too.

---

razor im like rodney dangerfield i get no respect

people actualy think i give fake ratings, how can someones opinion be fake, makes no sense lol
you take away a mans opinion, then what does he have? just a cock n balls.



to the non believers: i VIEW every flick that gets release, as i have access to everyone, im not bragging, but you didnt think everyone uses mirc or kazza did you? lol
anyway, all my ratings are after i view it, thats my story and im sticking to it

love all knowers
hate all the haters

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

First Time Posing...

quote:

---

Originally posted by CharlyTuna


randomly hehe.(i rate after i view)

dont you people relize, there are people who arnt as lame or new to the scene, you should be thanking me, without some of us being on top sites and spreading the shit everywhere, your KAZZA connection in getting stuff would be empty, and those lame home ftp's that you run on mIRC, so next time when you are downloading somehting, thank the people who fxp everywhere for the newbies, thank them in your mind, cuz if it wasnt for us, you would get dick. remember the release groups dont spread or share the releases, the fxp groups do.

thank you

p.s. i still see your shy of this release
it will hit kazza soon and mirc fservers, wait inline for thise files hehe

---

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

quote:

---

Originally posted by CharlyTuna


razor im like rodney dangerfield i get no respect

people actualy think i give fake ratings, how can someones opinion be fake, makes no sense lol
you take away a mans opinion, then what does he have? just a cock n balls.



to the non believers: i VIEW every flick that gets release, as i have access to everyone, im not bragging, but you didnt think everyone uses mirc or kazza did you? lol
anyway, all my ratings are after i view it, thats my story and im sticking to it

love all knowers
hate all the haters

---

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

quote:

---

Originally posted by a1catraz


cuz joo deserve NO respect...

stop with ur fawking quotes.. they make almost no sense. and they make you look fruity damn it..

---

__________________

..::HiGHONASCii::..

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged