Well BHP, to be honest, the R3 was plenty for this garbage. It had english menus (which looked to be R1), nice 5.1DD english surround sound, english subs, etc..the whole works. I'm sticking with that release, i'm sure others will too. But, if you have yet to download it, this would definately be the release to get.

10/10/4 - I liked this movie more the first time i watched it, but now that i have watched it agian, i think it sucked ass.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

I thought I was going to be the only one posting on this "fine" film

But I agree, the R3 looks pretty much the exact same (even down to the extras). I also think all the encoding of the R3 is the same as the R1s (like I Robot was).

Either release is more than enough for this film.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Ya just different audio and subs. R3 had asian languages and subs, this has the R1 french audio/subs.

(R3 chapter points are messed up in the extras - not a big deal, but still worth mentioning)

Some sites dont take R3 dvds anymore, so it's just what u prefer. R1>R3

I've personally gone back and re-downloaded all R1 discs like Replica's Day After Tomorrow and Mast3rs Dawn of the Dead. My collection is all R1 now

I figure I don't buy R3 or rental discs, so why should I download them to see if it's worth the purchase.

Last edited by JoshNya on 12-22-2004 at 05:40 PM

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

The DVDR scene is getting ridiculous with all these dupes.. Another unecessary waste of time and space.. Thanx but NO thanx. Region dupes are just another way to get more DVDR on the scene..R1, R3 who cares if the pic is nice and untouched:P


9/9/5

Wait for it Alien Vs. Predator R1 retail very soon!!!

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

quote:

---

Originally posted by bcool2k
The DVDR scene is getting ridiculous with all these dupes.. Another unecessary waste of time and space.. Thanx but NO thanx. Region dupes are just another way to get more DVDR on the scene..R1, R3 who cares if the pic is nice and untouched:P


9/9/5

Wait for it Alien Vs. Predator R1 retail very soon!!!

---

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

If it was up to bcool2k the whole scene would be R3 dvds and crappy TS. Forget that crap. He can download what he wants, I dont care.... I'll take R1 anyday. Screw the nukers, there just idiot teens who look for false reasons to keep a quota.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Hehe...

R3 movie only is in MANY cases AS good (or equal) to R1 movie only. So keep the R3's coming, as they keep us entertained until the R1!!

But NOT all R3s are as good as R1 (ie: Hero, House of Flying Daggers... The video there was crappy).

So, there's no telling how good or bad R3 vs. R1 will be.

But, for a movie this "good", it is a waste

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged