VCDQuality Forums (http://forum.vcdq.com/index.php)
- DVDR (http://forum.vcdq.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=24)
-- World Trade Center *NTSC* - DVDRIP - Replica (http://forum.vcdq.com/showthread.php?threadid=73286)

IMPORTANT, PLEASE READ

1 NO REQUESTING MOVIES OR SAMPLES (THIS INCLUDES REQUESTS FOR OTHER GROUPS TO RELEASE THIS MOVIE!)

2 DO NOT DISCUSS WHERE TO DOWNLOAD MOVIES OR SAMPLES

3 DO NOT ASK FOR "RAR PASSWORDS" COS WE DON'T KNOW THEM. CHECK WITH YOUR SOURCE

4 NO FLAMING

5 NO "SPOILERS"

6 NO SCENE-RELATED DISCUSSION/RUMORS (ESPECIALLY REGARDING BUSTS)

7 COMMENT ON THIS RELEASE ONLY (AND ONLY IF YOU'VE SEEN AT LEAST THE SAMPLE). THIS IS THE SOLE PURPOSE OF THE THREAD!

8 NO "NOOB" QUESTIONS SUCH AS "HOW DO I WATCH THIS?" ASK IN THE APPROPRIATE PART OF THE FORUM

9 NO DISCUSSING TRADING/SELLING. IF YOU SELL COPIES, GO AWAY YOU'RE NOT WELCOME HERE

* Newbie questions? Want some weird term clarifying? Read our FAQ

* General questions unrelated to this release? Internet LOL's? Right here dudes


*** PEOPLE IGNORING THE RULES WILL BE BANNED ***

The best group in the scene has been having a great week...6 rls's since sunday night... Replica is once again doing there thing!...

V-9
A-9
m-8

Replica keep it up

Perfect release

9/9/7

Replica is busy this week.
9/9/8

__________________
Op

xtras and everything
9+
9+
8


cramp

so perhaps the idiots above could enlighten me as to why a perfectly intact and untouched dolby digital soundtrack would warrant anything less than a 10? Rating scale of "1-10", 1 being shitty and 10 being DVD quality, how can a original DD5.1 track warrant a 9 rating? use your fucking heads eh?

Ever consider the above people may not have 5.1 setups? Try not to be so abusive. Also why make any comment if you're not rating the flick? Personally I'd ban your ass for flaming. Anyways....

V9 I don't own a 1080p set so so can't say if it's utterly perfect
A9 I don't own a 5.1 sound setup, so can't give it a 10
M9 One of the best films of 2006 (and I hate those USA! WOO!! YEAH!! type fims)

quote:

---

Originally posted by override2k3
so perhaps the idiots above could enlighten me as to why a perfectly intact and untouched dolby digital soundtrack would warrant anything less than a 10? Rating scale of "1-10", 1 being shitty and 10 being DVD quality, how can a original DD5.1 track warrant a 9 rating? use your fucking heads eh?

---

5.1 and DTS both get a 10
if it sounds like a AM radio then it gets a 1

well its quite obvious that ol_perfesser is one of many that doesnt know how to rate..and or hasnt seen a clip of the rip ,and or hasnt read the NFO 9/9/8 even if its untouched video

9.5
10
8

No, the guy bitching about the lack of 10s is absolutely correct. The ratings aren't here to judge the studios on their sound mixing abiltities, when its a DVDR its a comparison between the release and the real thing. Now obviously its not possible for most people to do this but it is possible to use common sense. If there's a low bitrate video stream and there's artifacts because of it, the score gets lowered etc.

The only time an audio track can be scrutinized really is when there's an option of DTS on the original disc and this hasn't been included... in essence thats a fair reason for someone to lower the audio rating, but usually the video bitrate is the factor that stops these. If the original is DD5.1 and thats whats on the rip (as in most cases) as long as nothing has screwed up then the audio should be defaulted to 10 really.

__________________
563-773-1880

<Dwaggy> i caught you a delicious Bass
<The404> This is because you are an idiot

quote:

---

Originally posted by llewhtork
Ever consider the above people may not have 5.1 setups? Try not to be so abusive. Also why make any comment if you're not rating the flick? Personally I'd ban your ass for flaming. Anyways....

V9 I don't own a 1080p set so so can't say if it's utterly perfect
A9 I don't own a 5.1 sound setup, so can't give it a 10
M9 One of the best films of 2006 (and I hate those USA! WOO!! YEAH!! type fims)

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by override2k3
right, so you tell me why, because you do not have technology good enough to view the release at its full potential, you give the release a rating based on the b grade playing capabilities of the technology you do own even though theres no way you'd know its full potential? they could make the best dvdr rip ever made in the history of the scene...but because one fag only has a B&W tv and £3.99 dvdplayer you grade them down? my fair rating (because i do have the technology to view this release at its FULL potential) is 9/10/8 (9 being because the video is not untouched, but perfectly mastered)

---

This sound thing needs some sort of a rating guide. People simply get their audio in too many different ways.