VCDQuality Forums - The Recruit *Proper* - DVDRIP

Show all 14 posts from this thread on one page

VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- SVCD (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=20)
-- The Recruit *Proper* - DVDRIP - T4L (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=18576)

Posted by reelnewbie on 05-02-2003 11:44 PM:

wow, what is there to say except "128 audio"? try again.

visual quality was decent, but this entire release stinks of stupid.

Posted by |sw1tch| on 05-02-2003 11:47 PM:

STUPID, YOU SO STUPID. 128 audio. lol. ill stick with my 3 cd release. thank you

Posted by pHo on 05-03-2003 12:41 AM:

see, usually i'd add some condescending remark as to how the group suck, and how their attempts are laughable.

in this case, i dont need to, as their work speaks for itself. i wouldn't make my worst enemies sit thru a 128kbit soundtrack. yeesh. kazaa ready?

__________________
563-773-1880

<Dwaggy> i caught you a delicious Bass
<The404> This is because you are an idiot

Posted by Yobanok on 05-03-2003 02:07 AM:

oh my gosh
what r u folks thinkin about dudes
128 audio?
nice attempt......
not good enuf

Posted by Kleenx on 05-03-2003 03:16 AM:

simply pathetic

Posted by G-Unit on 05-03-2003 06:36 AM:

damn release group trying to do us a favor and save 25 cents for not burning a 3rd disc...

__________________

" Politics is war without bloodshed, while war is politics with bloodshed. "

Posted by horizonstar on 05-03-2003 08:13 AM:

Ok, since I seem to be the only person who actually downloaded this and watched a fair bit of it, I must say that it looks fine next to DCi's, and really ... I can't hear any difference in audio quality. But whatever ... it got nuked, so that's that.

Feel free to download before commenting instead of jumping on bandwagons. Cuz otherwise what's the point of this forum?

G-Unit ... you pay $0.25 per disc? Damn. I thought my $0.14 was bad.

Posted by Orky on 05-03-2003 08:33 AM:

³ AUDIO: ³
³ - Minimum 224kbit @ 44.1khz (regardless of source) ³

³ VIDEO: ³
³ - CCE: 4 pass minimum ³

From The SVCD Releasing Standards 2002...

Both 128kbit audio and only 3-Pass VBR in CCE.
Great proper

__________________
,,|,, ^_^ ,,|,,
DISCLAIMER:
When I write "Havn't seen it yet" in a moviereview about a new release I mean that I havn't seen the whole movie, only the sample.
"Written to avoid accusations of only judging by jpg"

Posted by ou812 on 05-03-2003 10:46 AM:

Those standards are never used, TCF and CTP only does 3-pass (even seen 2). But yea I wouldnt use 128 audio even for myself, maybe 192 and chop off credits maybe.

*Sruggs*

Posted by Prosk8r on 05-03-2003 03:53 PM:

This release is the joke of the month. 128kbit audio muhahaha.

Posted by backoff on 05-04-2003 01:46 AM:

:: Stop flaming. -K::

Posted by bryehn on 05-04-2003 01:53 AM:

i also have this copy, and there's nothing wrong with it, imo...i noticed the audio compression maybe twice out of the whole movie. movie wasn't good enough to me to warrant 3 discs...

8/7/6

Posted by backoff on 05-04-2003 04:41 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by bryehn
i also have this copy, and there's nothing wrong with it, imo...i noticed the audio compression maybe twice out of the whole movie. movie wasn't good enough to me to warrant 3 discs...

8/7/6

I disagree. EVEN GLITTER WOULD WARRENT 3 CDS FOR OVER 128 SOUND FOR A SVCD (well maybe not glitter, but ANYTHING ELSE). 224 is the quality for SVCD and it is needed. You cant just go and do 128 unless it is internal or it will be NUKED!

Posted by horizonstar on 05-04-2003 10:52 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by backoff
224 is the quality for SVCD and it is needed. You cant just go and do 128 unless it is internal or it will be NUKED!

lol.

so let me make sure I understand you fully. in a discussion about the audio quality of a release, your argument is that it sucks because it was nuked. rofl. and, what's more, that anything less than 224kbps audio is automatically poor quality simply because the "scene rules" say so. hehehe

I went and looked at t4l's other two releases. I was only able to find the Sample for the Internal "The Last Dragon". It was SVCD 192kbps audio and, surprise surprise, sounded fine. And remember, I watch in an auditorium with enormous, not-very-high-quality speakers. For "Jailhouse Rock", I got the whole XviD at 96kbps audio and, amazing, it sounded crystal. Probably because the movie was filmed in 1957 and a higher bitrate would have been pointless.

So far I have yet to *hear* any problems with these releases, despite the lower file sizes, though I can't be certain about that Last Dragon. /me waits and sees ...

All times are GMT. The time now is 07:12 AM.

Show all 14 posts from this thread on one page